NSFGEO-NERC Collaborative Research: Effects of a changing climate on the habitat utilization, foraging ecology and distribution of crabeater seals
Lead Research Organisation:
British Antarctic Survey
Department Name: Environment and Information Division
Abstract
We propose to investigate the differences in the trophic ecology, distribution and foraging success of crabeater seals across a latitudinal gradient along the western Antarctica Peninsula (wAP). As a consequence of global climate change and local environmental processes, the atmosphere and oceans along the wAP are rapidly changing. Our study will enhance our ability to understand how the entire krill-dependent community of large predators will respond to the projected environmental changes. Furthermore, we have ecological baseline data from 20 years ago on movement patterns, diving behavior, feeding behavior, distribution and abundance for the species, as well as historical data and samples from the mid-1990s, providing us with a unique opportunity and advantageous position to detect changes in the ecology of this conspicuous Antarctic mesopredator and the extended predator community.
The crabeater seal (Lobodon carcinophaga) is the most important predator of Antarctic krill Euphausia superba in Antarctic waters. This is due to its high degree of ecological specialization, large abundance and biomass, and high metabolic demand. Its high dependence on a single prey resource, combined with being an obligate inhabitant of the pack ice, makes the crabeater seal an excellent species to examine changes in krill distribution as well as potential changes in the structure of the entire ecosystem: the horizontal distribution of the seal is determined by the distribution of krill, and similarly the seals diving behavior provides insights into the vertical distribution of this euphausiid in the water column.
Given the dichotomy in the daily habitat requirements of the crabeater seal, we aim to evaluate whether these previously-overlapping habitats are now separating in time and space along the western Antarctic Peninsula. Given the latitudinal differences in sea ice timing and extent. As well as the extreme dependence of crabeater seals on krill, we expect that individuals in the northern wAP have modified their foraging behavior and incur in elevated energetic costs as opposed to animals in the southern wAP. Alternatively, crabeater seals could have modified their habitat usage patterns and/or their diet in response to the changing climate along the wAP.
We will use traditional aerial surveys combined with new technologies (UAS and satellite imagery) to census the population of seals in the wAP through a collaboration with BAS. The aerial surveys will provide a benchmark against which we can validate the new data obtained from these platforms, which are logistically easier and more cost-effective. The tracking studies will also provide concurrent data on haulout patterns of crabeater seals that will be used to correct the survey data for the proportion of individuals at sea1. The survey and tracking data will be utilized to first determine if the crabeater seal population has declined and or moved south in response to declining sea ice. Second, develop habitat models of the species distribution to define the variables that influence where the animals are eating versus where they are hauling out, determine how these habitats differ and predict the spatio-temporal co-occurrence of these environmental conditions.
The crabeater seal (Lobodon carcinophaga) is the most important predator of Antarctic krill Euphausia superba in Antarctic waters. This is due to its high degree of ecological specialization, large abundance and biomass, and high metabolic demand. Its high dependence on a single prey resource, combined with being an obligate inhabitant of the pack ice, makes the crabeater seal an excellent species to examine changes in krill distribution as well as potential changes in the structure of the entire ecosystem: the horizontal distribution of the seal is determined by the distribution of krill, and similarly the seals diving behavior provides insights into the vertical distribution of this euphausiid in the water column.
Given the dichotomy in the daily habitat requirements of the crabeater seal, we aim to evaluate whether these previously-overlapping habitats are now separating in time and space along the western Antarctic Peninsula. Given the latitudinal differences in sea ice timing and extent. As well as the extreme dependence of crabeater seals on krill, we expect that individuals in the northern wAP have modified their foraging behavior and incur in elevated energetic costs as opposed to animals in the southern wAP. Alternatively, crabeater seals could have modified their habitat usage patterns and/or their diet in response to the changing climate along the wAP.
We will use traditional aerial surveys combined with new technologies (UAS and satellite imagery) to census the population of seals in the wAP through a collaboration with BAS. The aerial surveys will provide a benchmark against which we can validate the new data obtained from these platforms, which are logistically easier and more cost-effective. The tracking studies will also provide concurrent data on haulout patterns of crabeater seals that will be used to correct the survey data for the proportion of individuals at sea1. The survey and tracking data will be utilized to first determine if the crabeater seal population has declined and or moved south in response to declining sea ice. Second, develop habitat models of the species distribution to define the variables that influence where the animals are eating versus where they are hauling out, determine how these habitats differ and predict the spatio-temporal co-occurrence of these environmental conditions.
| Description | Main findings The findings from this award are still being assessed, but a scientific paper that highlights the main findings is about to be submitted over the coming days. Our project has been successful in collecting remotely sensed data from aerial survey, UAV and satellite data over two areas in the West Antarctic Peninsula. This was the main task of this joint NSF/NERC project. The second NERC part of the project was to assess the imagery to count seals and calculate abundance. These aims were to be completed by developing an automated counting method and by using statistical demographic procedures to turn the raw counts into a population estimate. The data collection phase has been successful, with two seasons of fieldwork, collecting both UAV and aerial imagery. This was supported by the collection of extensive amounts of satellite imagery by our partners at the NSF. Due to the extremely low sea ice in the years of fieldwork, the UAV imagery could not be used to assess abundance (as most of the sea ice had moved away from the field location), so the main initial findings concentrate on the aerial survey results. The data that was able to be collected from the UAV survey has been provided to our NSF colleagues to be used to assess the body condition of seals which will help the NSF side of the project. The main findings from the NERC side of the project are highly impactful. They show that crabeater seal densities on the West Antarctic Peninsula have decreased dramatically over the last 25 years. The region, which was notable for having the highest global densities of this species, has seen dramatic ice loss over the last few decades and we can now record and quantify, for the first time, the repercussions on ice seal numbers. The presented density estimates derived from this semi-automated approach are significantly lower than those previously published for ice seals on the WAP. These observed decreases pose sizeable questions regarding the status of ice seal populations in light of the dramatic changes that have impacted this region because of climate change. The article also presents a new, semi-automated methodology which greatly improves the efficiency of the population assessment. It uses a rule-based classification to filter the vast amount of aerial data, producing a far small and more manageable dataset, which is then manually reviewed. It is highly accurate and dramatically speeds up the assessment of the thousands of aerial images taken over the region. Ongoing work The project has amassed a large archive of satellite imagery specifically for the analysis and counting of ice seals on the West Antarctic Peninsula. At present these have not yet been fully analysed. Our initial work shows that whilst satellite imagery can cover great areas and reach regions not typically feasible by aerial survey, the accuracy of the satellite counts, either manually or automatically counted is significantly lower than by aerial survey. However, this resource of satellite imagery is still extremely important to assess the wider distribution and impacts from changing sea ice conditions. Our project's main aim was to measure abundance of ice seals on the West Antarctic Peninsula and assess any latitudinal difference. We have successfully completed the key points of assessing abundance, but the latitudinal differences have been negated by environmental events. Record breaking low sea ice in the two fieldwork years of the project enabled the team to assess seal abundance in low sea ice years. This, combined with historical data that had not previously been analysed has enabled us to not only assess ice seal numbers, but to track their decline over several time periods, including low sea ice and high sea ice years. It will be crucially important in the future to re-survey the area to assess whether ice seal (including crabeaters) numbers recover, or if the extremely low numbers seen in this study are a permanent shift towards a new environmental state. How will the information be used? The species which this project concentrates on, the crabeater seal, is thought to be the most abundant wild mammal on earth. Its diet is almost exclusively krill and current estimates suggest that consumption of krill by crab-eater seals is higher than all other air-breathing predators combined. Therefore, changes in its number will have profound implications for krill fisheries, managed by CCMALR. This is especially relevant, as the West Antarctic Peninsula is one of the two main krill fishing areas, and it is believed that with on-going climate change, the fishery is likely to move southwards and concentrate more heavily in this area. We have presented the findings at the recent SCAR Open Science Conference in Chile and we in in discussion with the FCDO to present the findings as a working paper at the Antarctic Treaty Meeting in 2026. |
| Exploitation Route | The findings of this award will critially change our understanding of crabeater seal population and have implications for Antarctic governance, especailly through CCAMLR (The Commission for the Conservation of Antarctic Marine Living Resources). It delivers an urgent need to further study this important Antarctic predator, which can be used as a bellweather of the cryptic sea ice ecosystem. We will instigate collaborative funindg bids with other International Antarctic partners to facilitate follow up research. The publication of the paper mentioned in the previous section will instigate media and public awarness campaignes that will highlight the ecological impact of rapid climate change on the Antarctic Peninsula. |
| Sectors | Environment |
| Description | Co Pi on joint project |
| Organisation | University of Exeter |
| Country | United Kingdom |
| Sector | Academic/University |
| PI Contribution | This is a joint project with NSF. The NSF lead has now moved to Exeter |
| Collaborator Contribution | Please see project proposal. |
| Impact | The project is only 6 months old, so no outcomes as yet except planning meetings and joint field plans. |
| Start Year | 2022 |
| Description | Oral presentation "CRABEATER SEALS POST SEA-ICE MAXIMUM ON THE WESTERN ANTARCTIC PENINSULA" at the SCAR Open Science Conference in Pucon Chile, August 2024. |
| Form Of Engagement Activity | A talk or presentation |
| Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
| Geographic Reach | International |
| Primary Audience | Professional Practitioners |
| Results and Impact | Invited Oral presentation (503) to the Scientific Committe on Antarctic Research Open Science Symposuim. The talk was to international scientists, students (mostly postgrad level), NGOs, and policymakers. Audience of 50-100. The talk led on to conversation and input to the general discussion about climated change in Antarctica. |
| Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2024 |
| URL | https://www.scar2024.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/08/SCAR2024-Full-programme-20-8.pdf |