📣 Help Shape the Future of UKRI's Gateway to Research (GtR)

We're improving UKRI's Gateway to Research and are seeking your input! If you would be interested in being interviewed about the improvements we're making and to have your say about how we can make GtR more user-friendly, impactful, and effective for the Research and Innovation community, please email gateway@ukri.org.

Deciphering the origin and geometry of freshwater tufa barrages. From process understanding to sustainable management

Lead Research Organisation: University of Lincoln
Department Name: School of Geography

Abstract

Not all rocks originate from volcanoes (igneous, like granite), deposition (sedimentary, like sandstone) or transformation of these two types (metamorphic, like marble). Some rocks like travertine originated from the progressive deposition of concrete-like carbonate minerals near hot springs. One more peculiar type of travertine is called tufa, and it's created in freshwater environments such as springs, wetlands, and streams. Modern tufa is a porous rock that's freshy deposited over existent pebbles, vegetation and logs, and its precipitation is facilitated by biological elements such as algae and moss. In limestone and chalk streams in Britain, tufa can create series of barrages that resembles reefs, and these environments provide habitats for a variety of plants, macroinvertebrates and fish. Unfortunately, tufa barrages are not well known nor well protected, and some ill-informed river management practices or changes in water quality can affect them negatively.
This project focuses on sequences of tufa barrages in streams of Lincolnshire. We will survey the geometry of tufa barrages, and determine their shape, growth and age in natural environments, as well as identify if these barrages have withstood past floods. We will then focus on a specific reach of the Dunston Beck, a stream near Lincoln with abundant tufa barrages. Here we will install slabs of different materials in different parts of the stream, and we will monitor the growth of freshwater tufa in order to determine what are the best conditions for tufa to deposit. Results obtained from these field surveys will give us the information needed to design leaky barrages (made up of brushwood and fascines/faggots) that will facilitate the deposition of tufa. Leaky barrages of these kind are often used in river restoration and natural flood management projects, as they improve the river ecology, slow down the water and help prevent flooding downstream. However, their persistence and stability could improve dramatically if tufa could grow on them given that the conditions for its deposition are provided. Also, building these leaky barrages in places where tufa could be potentially present (given the good water quality and presence of moss) may facilitate its deposition.
Our field surveys will guide us in designing and planning the right shape for these barrages, and we will install a pilot trial in the Dunston Beck. Tufa barrages are a hidden and undervalued treasure of many streams in Britain, and their presence needs recognition and protection. This project will gain further understanding on how and where tufa grows the most, and will go beyond by mimicking real tufa barrages in river restoration projects. In this project, basic Earth Science and Biology knowledge will inform Engineering solutions for the benefits of the environment and communities, as improved ecosystem services support healthier societies.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description We installed limestone and wood slabs in different morphological units of the Dunston Beck stream and monitored the accumulation of tufa deposits over time. Tufa accumulation was quantified using structure-from-motion and laser scanner techniques and was as high as 1 mm per year. Tufa accumulated more on slabs located at the edge of barrages where the flow was faster and shallower if compared to slabs positioned in pools and other morphological units with deeper and slower flows. The accumulation rate of tufa is relatively high and allows for the development of morphological structures such as barrages. The geometry of barrages is comparable to what reported for step-pool features in high-gradient streams. Although the location of tufa barrages seems to be determined by the presence of larger sediment fractions, bedrock or large wood (i.e., supporting the jammed state hypothesis), the spacing between them appears to follow the antidune mechanism geometry. In terms of the age (persistence) of tufa barrages, our findings indicate that the barrages in the study site are relatively fresh (<80 years), which is compatible with the occurrence of high-magnitude events in the site that could have dislodged them, but also supports the finding that tufa barrages are stable under formative floods. This reinforces the idea that leaky dams and other geomorphological features used in river restoration (e.g., beaver dams analogs) in streams with the potential of tufa deposition (i.e., high calcium carbonate saturation index) could be designed using step-pool dimensionless hydraulic control variables to favour the deposition of tufa, to stabilize the structures and enrich the environment with tufa features.
Exploitation Route We are in the process of preparing two publications with the tufa deposition rates as a function of the hydraulic characteristics of the sites and the geometry and persistency of tufa barrages. One is nearly ready to be submitted (target journal: Earth Surface Processes and Landforms) and the second one will likely be submitted in early summer (target: Geomorphology).
Sectors Environment

 
Description Collaboration Agreement
Amount £6,000 (GBP)
Funding ID IES\R3\223130 
Organisation The Royal Society 
Sector Charity/Non Profit
Country United Kingdom
Start 03/2023 
End 03/2025
 
Description Collaboration agreement
Amount £22,000 (GBP)
Organisation Environment Agency 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 04/2022 
End 06/2023
 
Description Freshwater Tufa Barrages, University of Calabria 
Organisation University of Calabria
Country Italy 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Bilateral agreement with the group lead by Prof. Edoardo Perri at the University of Calabria in Italy. We applied and obtained a Royal Society fund for a bilateral collaboration on the geomorphological features of rivers with tufa deposition (The Royal Society IES\R3\223130). The project is ongoing and for the time being allowed Dr. Mario Borrelli from the University of Calabria to visit the University of Lincoln in May 2023 and spend 3 days in the field in the Dunston Beck. The visit was reciprocated in October 2023 and allowed to spend a few days in the field in the Cornino stream, where similar measurements were taken, in order to obtain comparable results that will become a publication in due time. A further visit is planned for June 2024, when Prof. Edoardo Perri will visit Lincoln. We planned a day-long seminar on tufa, with a master class, field visit to the Dunston Beck and meetings with the local Environment Agency and the Lincolnshire Chalk Stream Project (Lincolnshire County Council) who are interested in designing ways of restoring streams with tufa features.
Collaborator Contribution Expertise in the use of Electronic Microscope to identify and classify tufa deposits, use of eDNA on tufa deposits
Impact for the time being, reciprocal visits to each other field sites to conduct collaborative campaign and field surveys that will lead to publications
Start Year 2023