Uncovering the primate clitoris

Lead Research Organisation: Manchester Metropolitan University
Department Name: Ecology and Environment Research Centre

Abstract

All female mammals have a clitoris. The clitoris plays a vital role in arousal, sexual pleasure, and orgasm. Yet we know very little about this structure and how it has evolved. The 'pea-sized' external part of the human clitoris is just the tip of the iceberg: 90% of the structure lies hidden under the skin. Such details of the human clitoris were only revealed in the last two decades, following the use of medical imaging technology, such as MRI and X-ray CT. Even less is known about the clitoris of our closest kin, the primates. Whilst distinctive skin swellings around the genitals have been documented in females of many species, we know almost nothing of the internal anatomy of the clitoris. How many nerve endings are present? Where is the clitoris most 'sensitive'? How might tissues change shape during arousal? Without this information from other primate species, it is impossible to understand the evolutionary forces that have shaped the form and function of the human clitoris, nor human sexual behaviour.

The lack of understanding does not extend to male reproductive organs. The equivalent structure in males, the penis, is comparatively well-studied. This may reflect a societal bias, where female genitalia were historically thought to be less variable than male counterparts and therefore overlooked. This one-sidedness may also relate to technical challenges associated with studying the clitoris. Compared to male genitals, female tissues are often small, delicate, and hidden from view. Recent advances in biological imaging, however, ensure these hurdles can now be overcome.

In this project, we will develop new methods for studying the primate clitoris. They will allow us, for the first time, to understand the structure of the clitoris, from gross anatomy to microscopic features, across the family tree of primates. Cadavers will come from the National Museum of Scotland, which is the main repository for deceased UK zoo animals. Sampled females will include lemurs, loris, marmosets, macaques, gibbons, and apes. Meticulous dissection of the perineal region will be required, to both describe the clitoral anatomy and to extract the tissues without damage for further analysis. An anatomical guide exists only for human cadavers, and dissections will therefore be extremely novel and exploratory.

Once dissected out, the clitoral tissue will be sliced very thinly, stained with dyes and viewed under a microscope, a process referred to as histology. These 'thin sections' will be used to document the number of nerve endings and their distribution across several areas of the clitoris. To better understand the 3D shape of the primate clitoris, the pelvic regions from additional cadavers will be x-ray microCT scanned. This will allow for a non-destructive 'virtual dissection' of the whole clitoris (including the hidden tissue), allowing us to better understand its shape and function by ensuring clitoris remain undisturbed within the animal's pelvic region. The resulting models will be the first ever glimpse into 3D structure and shape of the primate clitoris, beyond our currently limited understanding of human females.

Having established the feasibly of extracting such valuable information from highly prized museum specimens, the proposed project will open several avenues for further research. In mammals, reproduction ultimately requires the direct interaction of male and female genitals. The idea that female and male reproductive structures should evolve together is generally accepted and yet, remarkably, has never been tested in our closest relatives, the primates. Using the techniques developed in this project, future research will explore the size and shape of primate genitals, as well as interactions between male and female anatomy during sex. These advances will revolutionise the study of sexual selection in this group and transform our understanding of the natural history of human genitalia and human sexuality.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description In the 12 months since this award began, we have generated an unprecedented anatomical dataset of the pelvic region of female primates, comprising 23 species of primate (far exceeding our target for the grant). In total, we accessed 41 individual cadavers. 23 cadavers (1 per species) were physically dissected and tissue histology was subsequently conducted. 18 cadavers were bisected at the pelvis, and the pelvic girdle either MRI scanned, or microCT scanned following iodine staining.

Thus far, tissue segmentation and 3D model generation has been conducted on 8 species of primate. The major take-home findings so far include:
- Unsurprisingly, the previously documented diversity in external genitalia in female primates is dwarfed by the diversity in clitoral morphology we have documented subsurface
- We also uncover previously unknown instances of clitoral hypertrophy, suggesting the pendulous spider monkey clitoris is not a 'one-off', but rather an extreme example of hypertrophy that is commonplace in the group. We find previously undocumented hypertrophy in Galago, and whilst the pygmy slow loris is not externally hypertrophic, the body is found to be extensive.
- Previous data on vestibular bulbs in non-human primates has been almost non-existent, with the exception of the ring-tailed lemur in which they were claimed to be absent. In contrast, we find very clear presence of the bulbs in the microCT data of lemurids, alongside other primate taxa. Our preliminary findings hint at very considerable interspecific differences in the extent of the bulb spongiosus tissue.
- We find a clear phylogenetic trend in crura:body lengths, in which prosimians (esp. lemurids) are confirmed as having relatively long clitoral body and Old World monkeys and apes possess the shortest clitoral bodies. This may be related to lemurids lemurids being socially female-dominant and/or the use of the genitalia in scent-marking
- As a by-product, we have generated new imaging protocols for the pelvic girdle of cadaveric primates, refining the settings required for clinical MRI and determining the appropriate iodine staining protocol for this particular tissue type.
Exploitation Route The outcomes of this funding will be primarily of interest to anatomists and primatologists with research interests in the fields of genital anatomy, and sexual behaviour and functioning. More broadly, our results can be placed into the context of the evolution of primate mating and social systems, and may therefore be taken forward and put to use by evolutionary biologists interested in the evolution of social systems.

Our MRI and CT data is the first medical imaging conducted on the primate clitoris outside of existing clinical data on humans. Here we also develop and refine a clinical MRI protocol to optimise clitoral soft tissue contrast specifically on cadaveric material. Achieving high-quality MRI scans on cadaveric material is notoriously challenging, and our MRI protocol will therefore be of interest to other academics and clinicians interested in applying MRI to the pelvic region of cadaveric humans.

Our research will also be valuable to those operating within the museums and collections sector, as a case study for the value of actively collecting new zoological cadaveric material, in addition to working on the conservation of existing historical collections. Our project highlights the importance of maintaining national archives of whole body soft tissue cadaveric material, in addition to more standard osteological and skin collections.
Sectors Healthcare

Culture

Heritage

Museums and Collections

Other

 
Description Mount Holyoke collaboration 
Organisation Mount Holyoke College
Country United States 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Intellectual input; sending an MMU PhD student to Mount Holyoke via the Turing Exchange Scheme to assist with USA-based dissection and scanning
Collaborator Contribution Access to cadaveric primate specimens already held within the research collection of Prof Patricia Brennan (Mount Holyoke College)
Impact Collaborative visit and shared data collection to commence Aug 2024.
Start Year 2024
 
Description National Museum of Scotland collaboration 
Organisation National Museums Scotland
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution Intellectual input; expertise in dissection; offsite digitisation of specimens via microCT and MRI
Collaborator Contribution Access to large sample size of frozen primate cadavers, originating from zoos and accessioned into the museum collection; physical bench space for animal dissections
Impact Large dataset of microCT, MRI and histology images of tissues sourced from the NMS collection
Start Year 2023
 
Description University of Liverpool collaboration 
Organisation University of Liverpool
Department Institute of Ageing and Chronic Disease
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution UoL funded PhD student (2023-2026) Betzy Manners (lead supervisor Dr Alana Sharp) to be using a portion of our collected MRI and microCT data within her UoL doctorate on the human and non-human female perineum.
Collaborator Contribution Betzy will be augmenting our primate dataset with her dissections on human female cadaveric material, available to her via association with UoL's Human Anatomy Research Centre (HARC)
Impact Studentship commenced Sept 2023 so no discernable outputs thus far
Start Year 2023
 
Description Popular science journalism article 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Interview and subsequent online article for IFL Science
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
URL https://www.iflscience.com/primate-clitorises-come-in-more-shapes-and-sizes-than-we-ever-imagined-69...
 
Description Public lecture (Liverpool Victoria Gallery & Museum) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact An evening series of talks by 4 comparative anatomists, organised as the public-facing component of the Progressive Palaeontology postgraduate student conference
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
URL https://allevents.in/liverpool/progressive-palaeontology-presents-an-evening-with-palaeontologists/1...