NSFPLR-NERC: THwaites Offshore Research (THOR)

Lead Research Organisation: UNIVERSITY OF EXETER
Department Name: Geography

Abstract

There is a consensus that incursion of warm water across the continental shelf is the main driver of
contemporary retreat of Thwaites Glacier, which presents the greatest risk of future rapid global sea-level
rise. Uncertainty in model projections of the future of Thwaites Glacier can be significantly reduced by a
range of investigations seaward of the current grounding line, including extracting a record of decadal to
millennial variations in warm water incursion and the history of pre-satellite era grounding line
migration, and constraining the bathymetric pathways that control the flow of warm water to the
grounding line. Sedimentary records and glacial landforms preserved on the seafloor will allow
reconstruction of changes in drivers and the glacier's response to them over a range of timescales, thus
providing reference data that can be used to initiate and evaluate the reliability of models. Such data will
also provide insights on the influence of poorly understood processes on marine ice sheet dynamics.
The proposed project includes an integrated suite of marine and sub-ice shelf research activities aimed at
establishing boundary conditions seaward of the Thwaites Glacier grounding line, obtaining records of
the external drivers of change, improving knowledge of processes leading to collapse of Thwaites
Glacier, and determining the history of past change in grounding line migration and conditions at the
glacier base. These objectives will be achieved through high-resolution geophysical surveys of the
seafloor and analysis of sediments collected in sediment cores from the inner shelf seaward of
the Thwaites Glacier grounding line using ship-based equipment, and also from beneath the
ice shelf using a corer deployed through the ice shelf via hot water drill holes.

This project will use a suite of marine geological and geophysical data from seaward of the modern
grounding line, to derive records of drivers and pre-satellite era retreat history, and determine key
boundary conditions that control Thwaites Glacier retreat. The data will be used to address three pairs of
hypotheses about the behavior of Thwaites Glacier. The first pair of hypotheses address the impact of
warm-water incursions on glacial stability, both the modern pathways for such incursions and the 20th
century history of warm-water initiated retreats. The second pair of hypotheses address the role of
subglacial meltwater on Thwaites Glacier stability, using a comparison of modern sediment flux rates to
those recorded in cores to test the episodic nature of subglacial meltwater output, and of its influence on
glacial stability. Finally, the third pair of hypotheses address the role the nature and topography of the
bed and ice shelf pinning points have on stabilizing the grounding line.

Planned Impact

We will apply for a PolarTrek teacher to participate on cruise 1 (2018/19), who
will link up with several schools in the UK and the US and the general public using blogs, e-mail question
and answer sessions, curriculum development, and other activities before, during, and after the cruise.
Several of our team members have successfully hosted such teachers in the past. Additional K-12
outreach will include visits to schools by individual PIs and an Earth2class (https://earth2class.org)
teacher training workshop at LDEO-Columbia University with Co-PI Nitsche's involvement, where K-12
science teachers will be updated on project results and develop curriculum materials. Co-PI Minzoni will
build static displays on Antarctic climate change for the Alabama Museum of Natural History, and
participate in the "Natural Science with an Expert" program, which reaches hundreds of K-12 students
from local schools each semester. UK Co-PIs Hogan and Smith and the BAS post-doc will work with the
BAS Comms team to promote the shipborne research and outcomes, as part of their educational strategy,
with local schools and national schools through BAS's digital channels. Examples would include blogs,
images of 'science in action', video clips and on the BAS website (on average 65,000 unique visitors per
month) and social media via Facebook (16,000 followers) and Twitter (19,000 followers).

The UK (Exeter) component of the project will fund development of "Ice Flows," a computer game about ice
flow in Antarctica underpinned by real data and ice-sheet physics (http://www.iceflowsgame.com).
Together with Dr. A. Le Brocq, and in collaboration with professional game developers (Inhouse
Visuals), we will build upon a successful existing app (>10,000 individual players in 2016) to construct
new gaming elements related to our proposal's science objectives. Specifically, players will learn,
through play, about the techniques of under-ice survey in Antarctica, and the forcing that leads to TG
change. Linked online content and further development of a teacher mode will allow the app to be used as
an educational aid in classrooms at a variety of educational levels.

Public Engagement with Science: Field activities are rich opportunities to engage, excite and educate the
public about real-time science discoveries. In support of advancing understanding of Thwaites Glacier
through field activities, we will provide a variety of real-time outreach communications to inform and
directly engage stakeholders, educators, media, and the general public about Thwaites Glacier change,
specifically how the paleo-record helps us understand the future of Thwaites Glacier. Rice University
science writer L. Welzenbach will participate onboard cruise 2 to provide direct public
outreach throughout the project timeline. As part of cruise 2, the science writer will, for example, write a
daily blog, broadcast video of field and laboratory research if sufficient internet bandwidth is available,
and conduct media interviews with the scientists. These blogs and videos will be re-packaged by BAS for
posting simultaneously on UK digital channels (BAS website, Facebook, Twitter and YouTube). Videos
could also be shared with trusted journalists like BBC Online who frequently package up Antarctic
footage into digital stories, reaching millions of viewers. Post-field deployment activities will utilize
undergraduate students from local institutions (Rice U. and the U. Houston) associated with the grant to
work with PIs and the science writer in developing content captured from field activities that can be used
for a variety of education and outreach products, for example, museum special exhibit programs,
documentary films, and science briefs to help students develop skills in science communication. PI
Wellner will continue to give talks to local societies and organizations as well as continue her new
column at Forbes.com about energy use and the envir
 
Description This award covered a 9-month period of time before the PI moved from the UK to the US. The award was subsequently transferred to a sub-contract to the PI administered by the British Antarctic Survey.

This award found, through new cutting-edge fieldwork in the Antarctic, that Thwaites Glacier suffered a period of very fast retreat, doubling its current rate of retreat at some point during the past couple hundred years. These findings were based on newly acquired high-resolution geophysical imagery of the sea bed off the front of Thwaites, made using a state-of-the-art autonomous submersible. That pulses of retreat might occur at the grounding line of Thwaites is a new outcome of this work, and has implications for the pace at which Thwaites may retreat in the future. Moreover, we have shown that tides and the geometry of the sea bed are important in modulating the pace of retreat, which we suspect is enhanced by ocean melting in the cavity of the grounding zone.

A number of other important findings and outcomes include:
- observations of the pathways and modification of warm water at and under the floating ice shelf at Thwaites Glacier, which has characterised the dynamics of the ocean that melts the ice in this environment, for the first time.
- successful modelling of tidal ribs and their formation at the grounding line of ice streams, showing that these features are linked to the tides and form via a mechanism of sediment extrusion
- analysis of sediment cores at Thwaites which shows that the glacier has a shared history and forcing to its neighbour, Pine Island Glacier, and that major changes were underway in the system during the mid-20th Century, likely controlled by external climatic factors.
Exploitation Route Our work has implications for sea level predictions from the Antarctic ice sheet. Specifically, ice sheet modellers may use the findings to benchmark future forecasts, to refine models of the grounding zone and its behaviour. More widely, insurers and policy makers will be interested in the rates at which ice loss may proceed at Thwaites in coming centuries, which will determine the ongoing resilience of global coastlines, steer infrastructure and coastal management decisions, and dictate sea-level mitigation strategies.
Sectors Environment

URL https://communities.springernature.com/posts/orange-submarine-ran-explores-the-sea-floor-in-front-of-antarctica-s-thwaites-glacier
 
Description - major popular media and news coverage of 2022 paper, including TV and radio interviews (CNN), editorials and science write-ups in global coverage newspapers (Washington Times, New York Times, Eos). Huge social and public attention of the science and implications for local communities, in Florida, and elsewhere around the world. - interest from Morgan-Chase in the findings of our work - participation in Antarctica Week 2023, connecting Antarctic fieldwork experiences and science investigation to school children.
First Year Of Impact 2022
Sector Environment
Impact Types Societal

 
Title Gridded multibeam bathymetry data from 'The Bump' at Thwaites Glacier, collected by 'Ran' Kongsberg Hugin AUV (Kongsberg EM2040), on the RV Nathaniel B. Palmer during cruise NBP19-02 (2019) 
Description EM2040 multibeam swath bathymetry data collected by the Autonomous Underwater Vehicle 'Ran' (University of Gothenburg), deployed at Thwaites Glacier ice front in 2019 during cruise NBP19-02 of the R/V Nathaniel B. Palmer. The dataset here comprises AUV Mission 009, and was gridded using a Gaussian weighted mean algorithm in the mbgrid program, adopting a spline interpolation to fill grid cells not filled by swath data for gaps up to 6 grid cells in size. The data have a square grid cell size of 1.5 m and are projected in UTM Zone 13S, datum WGS84. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2022 
Provided To Others? Yes  
URL https://figshare.com/articles/dataset/Gridded_multibeam_bathymetry_data_from_The_Bump_at_Thwaites_Gl...
 
Title Research data supporting Towards modelling of corrugation ridges at ice-sheet grounding lines 
Description Code for generating simulations of glacial ribs as described in the associated manuscript and in the README file. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2023 
Provided To Others? Yes  
URL https://www.repository.cam.ac.uk/handle/1810/349691
 
Description Collaboration with Anna Wahlin/University of Gothenburg 
Organisation University of Gothenburg
Country Sweden 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution New productive collaboration initiated through the award - shared fieldwork, post-fieldwork discussions/workshops, and academic papers. AG made contributions through aiding mission planning, data analysis and interpretation, paper writing, figure production, and co-authored publication.
Collaborator Contribution AW and Gothenburg made contributions through aiding mission planning, data analysis and interpretation, paper writing, figure production, and co-authored publication.
Impact Wåhlin, A. K., Graham, A., Hogan, K. A., Queste, B. Y., Boehme, L., Larter, R., Pettit, E., Wellner, J., & Heywood, K. J. (2021). Pathways and modification of warm water flowing beneath Thwaites Ice Shelf, West Antarctica. Science Advances, 7(15), Article eabd7254. https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.abd7254
Start Year 2018