Romania's Camin Cultural: between political programme and cultural appropriation from 1955 to the present day

Lead Research Organisation: Goldsmiths University of London
Department Name: Art

Abstract

Introduction: Throughout a 50-year period, prior to December 1989, almost every city, town and village in Romania was furnished with a cultural centre, called Camin Cultural or Casa de Cultura. These terms can be translated as homely places for culture or houses for culture. The construction of thousands of such institutions materialized the utopian dream of communism to create a communal place where everyone could be both engaged and surveyed.
This practice-based research proposal has two complementary elements: an historical and anthropological comparative analysis of Romanian Camin Cultural, carried out for the dissertation element of the proposal, and an experimental documentary film for the practice component developed through a process of collaboration and reenactment with past and present-day Camin Cultural users.
Research background and questions: My goal is to identify and present the diverse, conflicting, ways in which these centres currently operate; focusing on internal micro-processes and community usage. A comparative perspective will analyse the transformation of similar institutions within the former Eastern Bloc and wider European context. My research questions are:
- How did everyday social and cultural practices in Casa de Cultura differ from, and politically challenge, a centralised policy agenda during the communist era?
- How were these places appropriated in the social context of different multi-ethnic communities?
- In the context of a growing interest in socially engaged art in contemporary Romania do state owned Casa de Cultura represent a distinctly different model of participation in cultural activities than that provided by increasingly privatized contemporary art and cultural institutions throughout Europe?
- Within the framework of an experimental film, how do strategies of reenactment and performative interviews enable us to make sense of shifting cultural strategies and the value placed upon diverse cultural expressions?
This research proposal looks at how Houses of Culture were not only destinations for disseminating official culture, most often in bluntly ideological and propagandistic ways, but also places where the population was 'activated' creatively through encouraging contact and participation in activities such as theatre, visual arts, music and crafts.
Research methodologies: For the past 20 years I have been active in various contexts, including academic institutions, alternative galleries, museums, art biennials, film festivals, hospitals and multipurpose community centres. This proposal extends and develops my methodological and artistic focus on the de-centralisation of cultural discourse and the sustainability of creative diversity within a system of established values.

The ethnographic, historical, and artistic research methodology will combine quantitative, qualitative and immersive anthropological-artistic strategies including: focused archival research, visual and textual analysis, extensive field work, placing a high emphasis upon documented interviews in Romania (I speak fluent Romanian) with former/present participants in Caminul Cultural to identify how local residents actually remember and perceive the history and function of their local House of Culture.

The filmmaking process will combine reenactment, simulated auditions and elements of cinéma vérité.
The filmic strategy challenges a documentarist tradition that heavily served propagandistic functions under 'Soviet Colonisation' through introducing performativity and individual agency. Participants will reenact personal stories; recite from official documents, press articles and statements from official archives. My intention is to create a stage/forum of negotiation wherein participants are interpreting source materials; selecting what is useful and relevant whilst deciphering the rhetoric of propaganda.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Title Film produced: The Building will have a Future She Said 
Description The building will have a future, she said 14:20 minutes Produced in collaboration with Jon Dean Video HD 2017 Throughout the history of the Socialist Republic of Romania (1947-1989), almost every city, town and village in Romania had a cultural center. Known as a House of Culture, these centers materialized the utopian dream to create a communal place where everyone could be engaged in the collective production of culture. In the small town of Campina, Romania, the Youth Cultural House opened in 1982. Today, a variety of resources can be found there, including free amateur theatre shows, sports clubs, dance groups and a library. In front of the camera, workers and visitors share poems and stories of the house. Most of them also participated in the building of the house itself, demonstrating that this historic model has a present and a future. 
Type Of Art Film/Video/Animation 
Year Produced 2017 
Impact The film allowed me to analyse one of the institutional models that I am researching Casa Tineretului/ A Cultural House for the Youth. 
 
Title Film produced: Un Camin Cultural/ A Cultural Hearth 
Description Throughout the 50 year period prior to 1989, almost every city, town and village in Romania had a cultural center. Known as a House of Culture or Cultural Hearth, these centers materialised the utopian dream to create a communal place where everyone could be engaged in the collective production of culture. "Un Camin Cultural" investigates both the history and present usage of the Cultural Hearth in Slon through local inhabitants' personal experiences, as well as attempts to ask the question: how can we imagine such places in the future? 
Type Of Art Film/Video/Animation 
Year Produced 2018 
Impact A structural film that analysis a particular institution A Cultural Hearth from Slon village, Romania. The film has just been submitted to film festivals, and will be show at the Art Biennial Art Encounters, Timisoara/ Romania in 2019 
 
Title Orpheo 
Description Extending my research into Cultural Houses in Eastern Europe, the film delves into the Orfeo group, an artist collective that was interested in producing a critique of the Hungarian system from within during the late 1960s and 70s; their work was initially created within Cultural Houses before then being banned by the regime. "The Orfeo group was considered by the cultural authorities as the new generation of socialist artists until the smear campaign launched against them in 1972. The members of the group could occasionally access parts of the public education infrastructure, such as houses of culture, community centers and clubs, despite their continuous political and artistic radicalism." 
Type Of Art Film/Video/Animation 
Year Produced 2019 
Impact The film was presented in the exhibition Left Turn, Right Turn, curators Kristóf Nagy and Márton Szarvasat, at OSA Archívum, CEU UNiversity, Budapest Hungary 
URL https://www.osaarchivum.org/events/left-turn-right-turn-0
 
Title Retrospective exhibition, The National Museum of Contemporary Art (MNAC): Apostrophe. Everything started with the keeper's hesitation 
Description IRINA BOTEA BUCAN Apostrophe. Everything started with the keeper's hesitation Chapter VI of The White Dot and The Black Cube, an exhibition project in six parts 19 January - 14 May 2017 An exhibition conceived and curated by Anca Verona Mihulet Curatorial input: Diana Marincu Irina Botea Bucan's personal exhibition is the final chapter of the six-part curatorial project The White Dot and The Black Cube developed between November 2015 and March 2017. The exhibition was constructed in several stages, starting in 2014, and came to revolve around three nuclei - a series of six films featuring secondary, suspended histories mostly unknown to the general public; a selection of films focusing on gestures and behavioral fragments; and a third direction, presenting two personal stories marked by the antagonism of private vs public and shown at the Dalles Hall in such a way as to make them visible from the street. The 16 mm tape, the attention devoted to sound, the historical references to the films of Jean Painlevé or Jean-Luc Godard induce a profoundness of communication between the artist, the individuals she films, and the subject matters she follows, captured at the borderline between vulnerability and initiative or passivity and reaction. The process of identification between the viewer and the observed subject is not being imposed, but rather carefully modulated by the loops of the narrative thread, while the choice that the public has to make oscillates, in its turn, between empathy and distance, between transfer and exclusion. As a punctuation mark, the apostrophe always signals a reversion, a turning from direct address toward a third entity, absent, but essential, that is being necessarily invoked in the dual relationship between the reader and the listener. The title acts as an exemplary cut-out, as a unique moment extracted from the logic of the narrative and the sequential construction of cognition, conferring an acceptable, fluid and open form to the subject-object relationship. In Art Historians (2014), Irina Botea Bucan invited two art historians from the Brukenthal Museum in Sibiu to talk about the way in which they work with the collection, about their favourite works, their vision and their relationship with the museum. The emphasis is on the characters' gestures, on their emotion and the type of discourse. In Impersonations (2014), the artist follows the preparations for the reenactment of the Lincoln assassination, filming the discussions between the actors, the rehearsals, the dilemmatic or humorous instances, while at the same time keeping her presence behind the camera unnoticeable. Irina Botea Bucan's most recent films, Ferenc Bar (2016) and Rock. Paper. Skin (2017) were produced in collaboration with Jon Dean and filmed in 2016 in Budapest. The son of the famous Hungarian soccer player Ferenc Deák had opened a bar dedicated to the memory of his father, but the dialogue with the owner and the regular customers shows that the place represented much more than that. In the video Rock. Paper. Skin, two young curators interested in the experimental unearth several parallel stories from the storage of the Hungarian Museum of Natural History and read, interpret and analyse them using the instruments of the collective imaginary. Behind the scenes of this presentation, questions are raised about the integration of reality into art and the way in which the central characters of a video, recorded in their natural surroundings, cope with their filmic existence. Where lie the boundaries in revealing an identity, and what is the filmmaker's responsibility toward the subject of the gaze? In the past 20 years, Irina Botea Bucan has been using multiple media to inspect topical socio-political dominants and centralise the agency of the human factor. Irina Botea Bucan's artistic methodology combines reenactment strategies with simulated auditions and elements borrowed from of direct cinema and cinéma vérité. She develops her projects by drawing on her collaboration with the performers, who become an integral part of the entire process of preparation; at the same time, as a filmmaker, her role is in a continuous flux, as she transitions from the position of the observer to that of a reflexive, participative and performative module. 
Type Of Art Artistic/Creative Exhibition 
Year Produced 2017 
Impact A mid career retrospective, the exhibition allowed me to re-contextualise and re-think my artistic practice and methodology. It was challenging to create a site-specific response to the location of the exhibition while also doing justice to the work itself. MNAC (The National Museum of Contemporary Art) is located in the famous"Casa Poporului" or The House of Parliament, a building of colossal proportions, with a contested history, being ordered by the former dictator of Romania, Nicolae Ceausescu. The exhibition ignited a lot of interest from various groups of visitors and it was reviewed by a number of articles including: Everything started with the keeper's hesitation by By Valentina Iancu http://revistaarta.ro/en/everything-started-with-the-keepers-hesitation/ Apostrof. Totul a început cu o ezitare a portarului. Comentariu [Un experiment de critica confesionala] / Apostrophe. Everything started with the Keeper's Hesitation. Comment [an experiment in confessional critical writing]', exhibition review, Revista Arta, edited by UAP (Visual Arts Union Romania), vol. 28-29/2017. "Totul a început cu o ezitare a portarului", la MNAC,by Doinel Tronaru, Adevarul newspaper https://adevarul.ro/cultura/arte/totul-inceput-ezitare-portarului-mnac-1_587f96c95ab6550cb88d15c8/index.html Un labirint de filmari: "Apostrof. Totul a început cu o ezitare a portarului" by Razvan Tupa https://www.newmoney.ro/un-labirint-de-filmari-apostrof-totul-inceput-cu-o-ezitare-portarului/ Irina Botea / Rolul major al micilor neplaceri / MNAC by Ionut Cioana https://www.scena9.ro/article/irina-botea-rolul-major-al-micilor-neplaceri-mnac Irina Botea ?i arta ei de la Chicago la Londra, prin Bucure?ti by Cosmin Tupa https://www.cotidianul.ro/irina-botea-si-arta-ei-de-la-chicago-la-londra-prin-bucuresti/ Cum folosim istoria? Ce facem cu ea? Obiectul istoriei e unul fragil - interviu cu Irina BOTEA BUCAN by Daria GHIU/ How do we use Hostory? What do we do with it? The object of history is fragile by Daria Ghiu https://www.dilemaveche.ro/sectiune/la-zi-in-cultura/articol/cum-folosim-istoria-ce-facem-cu-ea-obiectul-istoriei-e-unul-fragil-interviu-cu-irina-botea-bucan 
 
Title Solo Show,The Phillips Museum of Art: In the zone of transition, the building will have a future, she said 
Description Irina Botea Bucan uses various media in her videos and films to question current socio-political dynamics and the possibility of their transformation. In the zone of transition, the building will have a future, she said. is comprised of nine works made over the last 10 years and revolve around three ideas of recording: suspended histories mostly unknown to the general public; gestures and behavioral fragments; and stories marked by the antagonism of the private vs. the public. Opening reception and Artist in Conversation with Professor Mirela Tanta, Milliken University, Art History Department: Sept. 7, 5 p.m., Dana Gallery Performance of Mad Forest by Caryl Churchill, excerpted and directed by Jesse Murphy '18: Nov. 30 and Dec. 1, 6 p.m., Dana Gallery 
Type Of Art Artistic/Creative Exhibition 
Year Produced 2017 
Impact The show allowed me to broaden the discussion on post-comunism and the period of transition, especially with Mirela Tanta as well as the public in US. 
URL https://www.fandm.edu/events-calendar/irina-botea-bucan-in-the-zone-of-transition-the-building-will-...
 
Title Workers Club Victoria collaboration with Jon Dean 
Description We went to Victoria in order to understand the particular intimacies of the former 'city of youth'. While the focus was mainly on the Cultural House, it soon became very obvious that there was a strong and complex connection between the Combinat (chemical plant), Cultural House and formal educational institutions (primary and secondary school, industrial high school). This project continues an ongoing research into the history, planning and everyday usage (collective and individual) of such institutions. The methodology is based upon slowly developing a dialogue with past and present actors, participants, in Cultural Houses, and therefore the city itself became a significant actor. 
Type Of Art Film/Video/Animation 
Year Produced 2019 
Impact -a publication was made, in which both I and my collaborator submitted a contribution, Utopian Cities, Programmed Society Journal -the film was presented at Simultan Festival in 2020, Timisoara, Romania -the film was presented in the exhibition: Utopian Cities. Programmed Society in Cluj Paintbrush Factory, Romania, https://fabricadepensule.ro/events/orase-utopice-societati-programate/ 
URL http://programmed-societies.info/artworks/victoria-an-excerpt-from-a-filmmaking-methodology/
 
Description I have developed two films that analyse through a filmmaking methodology the model of cultural houses.
Exploitation Route I have already screening/ exhibited the two films in various locations and held artist talks in connection to them.
The films will continue to be disseminated in film festivals and Art Biennials.
(see more details in the portfolio)
Sectors Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections

 
Description I have produced two films that have been disseminate din both solo shows/ presentations as well as group exhibitions and screenings.
First Year Of Impact 2017
Sector Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Cultural,Societal

 
Description Modelsof Organization. Image as a Comrade Single Screen, NTU CCA Singapore 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Artist talk, film screening
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL https://vimeo.com/439136149
 
Description Participative Artistic Methodologies, Cetate Arts Danube, Cetate, România 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact An artist talk/ workshop exploring participative methods of art making for the artists in residency at Cetate, Romania
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
 
Description Victoria-Cultural House, Utopian Cities.Programmed Societies, "Double Breath" 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact Artist presentation, screening excerpts from films
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
 
Description WET Film, Rotterdam, "Stereotypical Conversations" 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Media (as a channel to the public)
Results and Impact film screening
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
URL http://wetfilm.org/2020/02/22/wet-lounge-5-at-tent-rotterdam/