PhD - 2 Curious: More Than Words

Lead Research Organisation: Manchester Metropolitan University
Department Name: Faculty of Education

Abstract

New Government funding offers places to 'disadvantaged' two-year-olds in nursery classes, responding to the widening achievement gap for children from low-income families at the start of formal schooling, and increasing anxiety related to language and literacy acquisition (Save the Children, 2016, Ofsted 2012, Bercow, 2008). Assessment, planning, and data is becoming central for early years practitioners whose performance is judged in relation to progress children make in what is seen as a critical year for successful school life. This has lead to a proliferation of deficit-oriented interventions that are either aimed at changing parent-child interaction (by increasing spoken interaction and vocabulary), or classroom intervention strategies. However, there is little research to provide evidence about what a rich foundation for language skills might look like for two-year olds in classes (Georgeson, J et al, 2014). A growing body of scholarship emphasises young children's literacy practices as entangled meaning-making with and through place, their bodies, and the objects they encounter (Pahl, 2002, Wolhwend, 2009, Hackett, 2014, Somerville, 2015). This emphasis on the moving body and materiality contrasts with word-deficit approaches.

Visual and non-linguistic research methods, including collaboration with artists (Barone and Eisner, 2011), have played a central role in developing understandings of the non-representational within aspects of children's learning and experience (Huuki and Renold, 2016; Olsson, 2013; Otterstad and Waterhouse, 2016). Dance practices have also been used to theorise how movement constitutes the world, drawing on Deleuze and Guattaris' notion of absolute movement (Lenz Taguchi et al, 2016; Manning,2013; Olsson, 2009). However, whilst there is some work looking at performance to support children with autism (Shaughnessy and Trimingham, 2016), and approaches such as Write Dance to facilitate mark making (Oussoren, 2010), the potential for performance arts coupled with young children's literacy and language practices remains strikingly under explored.

Research questions:
How might movement-based arts practice (dance, theatre, puppets, music) contribute to pedagogic practice with two year olds in ways that support language, literacies and communication?
What is the potential of non-representational, embodied and material performance practices as emergent forms of knowledge for 2 year olds?

This doctorate addresses the intersection between performance arts practice and literacy pedagogies for two year olds in early years classrooms. The collaboration between the doctoral student, Curious Minds (Bridge Organisation to enable creative collaboration between the cultural and education sectors, and to create access to the arts and culture for all children and young people), Manchester Metropolitan University, and creative practitioners, brings together theory with early years literacy research and performance practice to address the sticky problem of the early years language gap (Avineri et al, 2015) in a novel way. Central to the collaboration is the aim of bringing together complementary lenses or 'ways of knowing' related to emergent literacies, the body and two year olds. The intention is that by using an innovative methodological approach, academic and linguistic ways of knowing will be decentred in favour community knowledge (Campbell and Lassiter, 2015) and practice-based knowledge (Nelson, 2013). Thus, the collaboration aims to create an experimental and immersive space that flattens expert and professional knowledge in favour of more local ways of knowing.

Publications

10 25 50

Studentship Projects

Project Reference Relationship Related To Start End Student Name
ES/P000746/1 01/10/2017 30/09/2027
1947155 Studentship ES/P000746/1 01/10/2017 30/09/2021 Charlotte Arculus
 
Title 360° film making movement and relation tangible 
Description The use of the Gopro Fusion 360° camera technology is uniquely placed to go beyond human framing offering potential to know with multiple movements in a single space. 360° is able to 'heighten attention to the human-nonhuman interactions taking place and help articulate the affective moments of intra-action that bring about the condition of possibility and change'. (Vackova 2018). The frameless Fusion technology allows a complete sphere of view around its single point. This can be manipulated so that everything can be seen on a flat plain (figs. 5&6). This 'tiny world' can be rolled around so that different parts of the spherical field of vision are foregrounded. Every frame has almost infinite potential. 
Type Of Art Film/Video/Animation 
Year Produced 2019 
Impact I am currently processing the 360° data. I have been notably impacted by the rich complexity of a few seconds of time. 
URL https://charlottearculus.wixsite.com/morethanwords/post/360-an-unframed-adventure-in-perception-move...
 
Title Arts project and Installation 
Description My fieldwork project involved a residential project in a nursery setting for two weeks working with a dance artists and using temporal arts as communication methods. An installation was created for children and practitioners. this was a space where adults were asked to minimise talk and instead communicate through gesture, movement and sound. 
Type Of Art Performance (Music, Dance, Drama, etc) 
Year Produced 2019 
Impact The impacts are currently still being processed. Anticipated presentations in the form of spoken, film and portfolio to take place as part of a network partnership with scholarship partners Curious Minds. 
URL https://charlottearculus.wixsite.com/morethanwords/post/my-more-than-words-immersive-installation
 
Title Illuminating Arts Practices in Early Childhood with More-Than-Human Technologies 
Description This image was shortlisted for the MMU competition Images of Research 2020: Flair, Ambition and Enthusiasm Shortlist The image is from an immersive environment for two-year-olds. This was part of my doctoral project, More Than Words, which aims to reconceptualise understandings of young children's communication through improvisational arts practices. Using music and dance with materials such as silk, string, and light, children, parents, artists and educators adopted a practice of stripping back talk in order to tune into the multiplicitous encounters and communications that are going on between children and the world. My immersive environments offer multiple, varied and open-ended ways to engage. Many things are happening simultaneously yet related through the affects, textures, sonics, bodies and movements of the space. I used a 360° video camera to create audio/visual data. This more-than-human technology observes in ways radically different to 'framed' video. It makes tangible young children's entangled knowledge through relation and movement in ways that are not perceptible to the adult gaze or traditional video technology. 
Type Of Art Image 
Year Produced 2020 
Impact Many people have seen and voted for it from my FB and Twitter page. This was both surprising and touching as my network is mostly non-acadmic 
URL https://www2.mmu.ac.uk/research/research-study/events/images/
 
Title TCam : a wireless live camera for making research datawith two-year-olds 
Description In order to achieve the research aims of: a) foregrounding and reconceptualizing children's knowledges, b) exploring the pedagogical affordances of arts practices and, c) using video as a generative form of research-creation, I developed a cctv based wireless camera - Tcam Tcam is a toddler-driven, freely, rolling, position-able, child's height, video camera which is designed to be an 'embodied camera drawn into the world' (Grimshaw & Ravetz 2015, pg.271). I hope that children will freely use tCam and explore its potential. It's built-in CCTV camera can live feed to an iPad, projector or nursery monitor offering potential for augmentation (e.g making small things big or close up) making special or giving focus to 'things that would be overlooked from an 'adult-centric view'. (Caton 2019: 112). Prototype Tcam footage was used for a paper presentation at the DigiLit conference in March (MacRae & Arculus 2019). The clip was produced during an early years arts project "Near and Far" (Magic Acorns 2018). A prototype tCam was piloted during this arts project. The qualities of the tCam footage made tangible the complex multiplicity of a small event. The research involved Deep-hanging-out with Tcam and two-year-olds in a nursery setting over a two-week period. Deep hanging out is an attempt to 'produce a rich, polyvocal, evocative and complex account of cultural value by co-investigating arts engagement with audience participants' (Warmsley 2018:272). I hoped that during this time the children will get a sense of Tcam through playing with the technology. 
Type Of Art Film/Video/Animation 
Year Produced 2019 
Impact I am currently processing the multiple impacts that Team had on the research and young children's engagements 
URL https://charlottearculus.wixsite.com/morethanwords/post/tcam-development
 
Description Actually the keyfindings are still in process. I just didn't want to say No
Exploitation Route I need to continue and finish the work
Sectors Creative Economy,Education,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections

 
Description This research is still underway and findings are not complete. However the research fieldwork projects generated independent case studies by nursery practitioners and findings are due to be presented at informal arts-educator network meetings over the next year.
First Year Of Impact 2020
Sector Education
Impact Types Cultural,Societal

 
Description Early years working group. Arts council Durham Commission
Geographic Reach National 
Policy Influence Type Participation in a guidance/advisory committee
Impact The commission advises that (and this has the impact of making early childhood more visible) The purpose and place of creativity and teaching for creativity should be recognised and encouraged in the early years (0-4). To achieve this: The DfE should integrate creativity into the Early Learning Goals within the Early Years Foundation Stage, to be operational from 2021. The DfE should establish and fund effective training and CPD for the pre-school workforce, reviewing current Continuing Professional Development opportunities, qualifications and entry routes to the sector by 2021. The BBC, other media and broadcasting organisations and the DfE, should further develop quality early years content that encourages young children's creativity alongside literacy and language development.
URL https://www.dur.ac.uk/resources/creativitycommission/DurhamReport.pdf
 
Description Research practitioner network for arts-education in the NW 
Organisation Curious Minds
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution This research is contributing a specific focus on arts education with-year-old children. The research feeds into the overall work with of Curious Minds and their focus on early years. This includes The SLiCE fellowship ( senior Leaders in Cultural Education) which has had a 2 year focus on early years .
Collaborator Contribution Curious minds is the arts council Bridge for the NW England. They have contributed to the research through funding the artist and the arts residency in the nursery. They are the partner in a series of workshops seminars that will both disseminate findings and generate new perspective on the research.
Impact Duvet Dancing is a piece of Theatre for under 3s by Anna Daly which I directed and which came out of the SLiCE fellowship project. This work was also entangled with my fieldwork project as I worked with Anna and the Duvets.
Start Year 2007
 
Description Early Years Culture and Heritage Stakeholder Event at the Royal College of Music 4th July 2019 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact I was asked to speak at this event, unusually not about the knowledge of children, but of the knowledge of the artists who work with them. This is a transcript of my 10 minute talk. The talk I gave was later published in Arts professional.
https://www.artsprofessional.co.uk/magazine/327/feature/giving-artists-seat-table?fbclid=IwAR20t0GNalU8o-nyhbvDorOQYBcpY8HsfAHzLRFXCJAnuBOCxp_3TAfiw1o
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL https://charlottearculus.wixsite.com/morethanwords/post/early-years-culture-and-heritage-stakeholder...
 
Description Early Years and Wellbeing creative thinktank 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact The creative thinktank was hosted by Katherine Zesserson , Professor Graham Welsh & Professor Margaret Barrett. I attended with Dr Jessica Pitt, Dr Christina Macrae, Dr Julian Knight and a cohort of strategists in early childhood music, music psychology and early childhood education.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL https://snapemaltings.co.uk/project/music-and-wellbeing-in-early-childhood/
 
Description The improvisation experts 
Form Of Engagement Activity A magazine, newsletter or online publication
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Article on young children's knowledges
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
URL https://www.artsprofessional.co.uk/magazine/320/feature/improvisation-experts
 
Description Working with Eastern Music Hubs towards early childhood music Padagogy 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact It is interesting that early years settings does not appear on research fish drop downs. This is exactly the problem. This is not Schools nor is it scaled down work for bigger children. Perennially low status and invisible. So my engagement work is concerned with making young children, their concerns and their world visible. Research fish I suggest that if you want people like me to take this silly web portal seriously. Make the people I work with visible. EARLY YEARS IS NOT SCHOOLS!!!!
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL https://charlottearculus.wixsite.com/morethanwords/post/introduction-to-early-years-for-music-servic...