Theoretical Modelling of Ingress in Gas Turbine Rim Seals.

Lead Research Organisation: University of Bath
Department Name: Mechanical Engineering

Abstract

Engineers aim to improve the efficiency of gas turbines without sacrificing the life of materials. Ingress is the phenomenon where hot gas from the mainstream flow is ingested into the wheel-space between the stationary casing and the adjacent rotating disc. To prevent or reduce ingress, rim seals are fitted at the periphery of the discs and sealing air, which is directly bled from the compressor, pressurises the internal cavity. However, using too much sealing air reduces the efficiency, while too little can damage the materials due to high temperatures. Siemens currently use the University of Bath Orifice Model to design rim seals for their engines. Here, only the inertial effects are taken into account, while discharge coefficients are used to account for the viscous effects and other related losses. These coefficients cannot be determined theoretically and they are treated as empirical constants for each seal. The Orifice Model is used to predict ingress, and although it is in good agreement with concentration based experimental results, problems with pressure difference predictions arise for different rim seals geometries (i.e., axial and radial rim seals). Recently, Savov and Atkins proposed an alternative approach, where turbulent diffusion is used to model ingress as a viscous problem while ignoring the inertial effects.
This project aims to develop a new Control Volume Model for the prediction of ingress by uniting the Orifice Model and the viscous terms of turbulent diffusion model which are currently ignored by the Bath approach. The new model is expected to solve the problem of the pressure difference prediction while maintaining good agreement with concentration based effectiveness measurements. The student will combine the experimental and theoretical parts for a better understanding and interpretation of the results. Furthermore, it is desirable to involve CFD for validation purposes, however, at this stage, it is undecided to what extent.
At the start of the project the student will cover the available literature around ingress, while conducting experiments in the 1.5-stage turbine rig with the supervision of an experienced operator; later the student will be the main operator of the rig. The second phase includes the collection of pressure distribution and concentration effectiveness data which will inform the modelling. A parametric study of Siemens specific rim seal design will then be conducted. Finally, during the third phase, which overlaps with the second, the student and the supervisor will incorporate the experimental test results into the new theoretical model for validation.
Throughout the project, it is expected that colleagues from the Turbomachinery Research Centre (TRC) will be involved for the validation and verification of the model by comparing their results and improving their models and codes. This will constitute a 3.5 - year PhD programme and by 2022 a new Control Volume Model will be established.

Publications

10 25 50

Studentship Projects

Project Reference Relationship Related To Start End Student Name
EP/R513155/1 01/10/2018 30/09/2023
2127975 Studentship EP/R513155/1 05/11/2018 04/05/2022 Dimitrios GRAIKOS
 
Description High-efficiency operation of industrial gas turbines and aircraft engines are critical in the required reduction of carbon dioxide emissions to mitigate the change in global climate. The most advanced combined cycle plants (known as H class) reach efficiencies in excess of 60%. Here the turbine entry temperature exceeds the melting point of metal components. To maintain integrity, high-pressure air is extracted from the compressor and distributed throughout the engine through the secondary air system for cooling and sealing purposes. Superfluous use of secondary air reduces engine efficiency and performance, while insufficient use can be detrimental to the life of vulnerable components operating at the extreme limits of thermal and mechanical stress.
A typical turbine stage consists of stationary and rotating discs called stators and rotors. The space formed between the two discs is called the "wheel-space" or "cavity" of the stage. Hot gases from the annulus are free to enter the wheel-space and in order to minimise the ingestion, complex geometries which are called "seals" are fitted at the periphery of the discs. The secondary air system provides cool and high-pressure air which prevents any hot gas ingestion from the annulus.
This is an experimental project which is oriented towards the investigation and understanding of the mechanisms which drives hot gas ingestion. Although the used rig is using cold flow, there is an analogy between heat and mass transfer which allows the measured mass concentration flux to be equivalent to an enthalpy flux. For that reason, a trace gas is used to seed the secondary or purge air which is used to seal the wheel-space.
The most important achievements from this award include:
• The student gets the opportunity to work in a highly controllable environment using state of the art equipment and the valuable expertise of professors and technical staff.
• Access to all the required tools depending on the application.
• Technical support from technicians which are ready to tackle the most challenging practical problems.
Many research questions were raised:
• How does the level of ingestion in the wheel-space change when the flow coefficient is different than that of the design condition?
• How does the level of ingestion in the wheel-space change when the flow coefficient is different than that of the design condition?
• How does the level of ingestion in the wheel-space change when the flow coefficient is different than that of the design condition?
• How does the level of ingestion in the wheel-space change when the flow coefficient is different than that of the design condition?
• How does the level of ingestion in the wheel-space change when the flow coefficient is different than that of the design condition?
All the above were realised by a series of objectives:
• In order to study ingress in the cavity, a series of experimental procedures will be followed, these include:

1)Concentration measurements: A tracer gas i.e. CO2 will be used to quantify the amount the ingested air into the wheel-space.
2)Pressure measurements: By measuring the pressure inside the wheel-space the structure of the flow can be determined. Pressure measurements will also be taken in the annulus. Additionally, static and total pressure measurements can be used to quantify the swirl ratio in the wheel-space, which is linked to ingress and is highly valuable information for the engine designers.
3)Unsteady Pressure measurements: By measuring the instantaneous pressure fluctuations inside the upstream and downstream wheel-spaces and rim seal gaps, valuable insight into large-scale structures (LSS) will be obtained. These structures rotate at a fraction of the rotor speed and have been shown computationally to be linked to the causes of ingress.
4)The effect of the flow coefficient and the sealing flow rate will be investigated in a series of experiments in order to quantify ingress under off- design conditions. To achieve this, the rotational speed of the rotor disc will be kept constant and the mainstream annulus and sealing mass flow rates will be varied.".

• A series of improved, engine-representative seals designed by Siemens were tested and provided valuable information of how the geometry of the seal influences the hot gas ingestion.

• Rotationally induced ingress (absence of vanes and blades) experiments will be conducted in order to validate the new theoretical model.

• A new mechanism which drives ingress is currently under investigation. This can be proven to be a revolutionary method of quantifying ingress which can couple ingestion to pressure. This is of prime interest for the engine manufacturers.

Considering the Covid-19 pandemic, the student was able to use CFD techniques although this was not originally a major aim. However, up to the date, some of the most accurate CFD results have been produced.

The student believes that thus far the main aims and objectives have been met.
Exploitation Route The student believes that the new method which was developed for assessing the vane / blade effect can be further investigated by other students or groups.

Secondly, a new theory is under development which if proven right can lead other students to further investigate the phenomena
Sectors Aerospace, Defence and Marine

 
Description The Gas turbine research department of Siemens has provided geometries which were tested by the student. The results which were produced and returned to Siemens will help the engine designers to better understand and optimise their design tools. Further information cannot be given as it is restricted. From the academic point of view a new method of experiments was developed which is new to the field. People from the academia can/should take ingestion into account when the isentropic blade profiles are produced. A new theory is under development at the moment which could/might correlate pressure to ingestion which is of prime importance to both the academia and engine designers. At the moment we are at an early stage and more discussion should be made before anything tangible can be shown.
First Year Of Impact 2018
Sector Aerospace, Defence and Marine
Impact Types Economic

 
Description Hot gas ingestion (Advanced seals) 
Organisation Siemens AG
Country Germany 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution Part of this project is to collaborate with Siemens (Germany) and to provide them with data that affect hot gas ingestion. Bi-weekly meetings are held to keep both sides updated regarding the progress and outcomes of the research. Siemens has developed and provided advanced engine seals which were manufactured and tested from the PhD student. (No further information can be given, as the work is restricted)
Collaborator Contribution Siemens have provided funds to support the project and the student throughout the length of this collaboration. Siemens aims to improve the efficiency and life of their aero engines and valuable information is provided from them towards the investigators. Research is elevated from academic interest to practical applications as its findings can potentially have huge impact in industry.
Impact The outcomes which have resulted from this collaboration are that engine representative seals have been tested experimentally from the University's facility. Valuable information has been provided to the engine designer on how to improve their prediction methods and optimisation techniques.
Start Year 2018