High intensity focussed ultrasound (HIFU) treatment planning with geometrical optics acoustics

Lead Research Organisation: University College London
Department Name: Computer Science

Abstract

Focussed ultrasound is increasingly being exploited in therapeutic applications, for example for thermal ablation of tumours and lithotriptic destruction of urological stones. Accurate planning of the treatment requires acoustic modelling to predict where the ultrasound waves will focus. In the high acoustic pressure regimes required for these treatments, the acoustic waves propagate nonlinearly - in other words they steepen and push energy into higher harmonics, sometimes as much as an order of magnitude higher than the fundamental frequency. This can significantly alter the rate of heat deposition, or the shape of the acoustic wave, and thereby have an effect on the treatment. It is therefore necessary to model the nonlinearity accurately. The leading numerical models of acoustic propagation are grid or mesh-based, and require nodes spaced closer than half-the-highest-wavelength (in practice quite a bit closer) and so the generation of harmonics leads to a requirement for very large grids, and the computations become impractically large.


HIFU simulations (forward problem) therefore call for a different approach. As for most of these applications, the propagation is linear until close to the focus, and so the focal position does not change from the linear regime, just the amplitude of the field. Based on this observation we propose to devise a method that calculates the ray trajectories using fast linear geometric optics, and then computes the acoustic pressure amplitude along these rays by solving nonlinear acoustic equations, eg. Burgers equation or Westervelt equation, or a derivative from them, along the rays. This method can then be used as a forward solver in the optimisation of the treatment plan (inverse problem).

Publications

10 25 50

Studentship Projects

Project Reference Relationship Related To Start End Student Name
EP/R513143/1 01/10/2018 30/09/2023
2425111 Studentship EP/R513143/1 01/10/2020 30/09/2024 Matthew Foster
EP/T517793/1 01/10/2020 30/09/2025
2425111 Studentship EP/T517793/1 01/10/2020 30/09/2024 Matthew Foster
 
Description Two ray-based approaches to modelling nonlinear waves in acoustics:
- Uses a simple asymptotic expansion to simplify the general governing equations for acoustic waves. This produces rays, which move perpendicular to the wavefronts, that are the same as ones found for linear wave equation. The amplitude of the wave along each ray was found by solving nonlinear equation in one dimension. This model does not include diffraction thus an artificial sound speed is created to mimic diffraction using refraction of the rays. This model does not model the asymmetric behaviour of nonlinear focused waves such as in HIFU.
- Second method used a more complicated asymptotic expansion with more flexibility on the small parameter. This produced new nonlinear rays which depend upon the amplitude of the wave meaning waves will bend away from high pressure areas as desired. This model does not require any artificial sound speed however the strength of bending is not enough since again there is a lack of diffraction included in the model.
Both these methods have issues and inaccuracies but they both run quicker than other full wave solvers for linear and nonlinear waves.
Exploitation Route The funding is still active, so the work is being directly progressed to produce a model which incorporates the diffraction effects of waves and thus accurately model the acoustic wave from HIFU.
HIFU simulations take a long time to run, the current findings are quick to run but will be progressed to better model HIFU while keeping the speed increase.
Sectors Healthcare