Computer Art and Technocultures (CAT): evaluating the Patric Prince Collection in the Digital Age

Lead Research Organisation: Birkbeck, University of London
Department Name: History of Art

Abstract

The Patric Prince Collection is a unique record of crucial developments in the digital arts from its origins to the 1990s. The bulk of the collection dates from the 1970s to the early 1990s, a period that saw the introduction of the desktop PC and all current computer graphics systems, as well as the consolidation of computer imagery and special effects across a wide range of graphic industries. The compiler, Patric Prince, is a California-based art historian who quickly realised the value of collecting and documenting the work of emerging computer artists. In addition, her husband was head of computer imaging at the Jet Propulsion Lab. As a SIGGRAPH Art Show organiser from 1982 onwards, she established the contacts that enabled her to compile an extensive personal archive of actual art works, plus documentation, correspondence and taped interviews with computer artists and graphics pioneers. Since its inception, SIGGRAPH has been the international focal point for emerging digital visual technologies.

The results of Patric's industrious work filled 50 boxes when the entire collection was brought to the V&A during 2005-6, as the result of an agreement assisted by the CACHe Project (Computer Arts Contexts Histories etc). CACHe covered early computer art in the period 1960-1980, mainly from a British perspective. The PP Collection dovetails chronologically and enlarges its horizons to include material from North America, Europe, Japan and elsewhere. It contains line plotter drawings, screen prints, inkjet prints, posters, photographs, books, manuscripts and a wide range of ephemera. These are mainly works on paper, with examples in other media, including 3D images and computer files. Themes already explored by CACHe, including the emergence of recognisable computer styles and the close linkage of graphics technology and computer art, are expanded in the Collection.
The Project intends to make this invaluable archive widely available online for scholars of art and technology, and also to the increasing number of digital artists and graphics professionals who need a basic grounding in the evolution of their field. This will include ca. 250 artworks, highlights from the 4,000 documents in searchable formats, and the taped interviews as digital files. These will be freely accessible through a database hosted by the AHDS and at the V&A itself, which will also have high-resolution digital surrogates of the collection.
The project is envisaged in six-month segments, beginning with a pilot period that will take a representative cross-section of all material and digitise it to establish our modus operandi. During this pilot period we will carry out a general survey of the material in order to prioritise the most significant and historically important items. This will also enable the team members to adapt to their roles and establish our reporting structure. Initially we will have fortnightly meetings, to be followed by monthly meetings.
As the Collection is digitised and catalogued at the V&A, its contents will be researched at Birkbeck to investigate the relation of specific artworks and artists to theories of technocultures, hypermedia and transmediation. The works will also be fitted into a detailed chronology to establish a comparative history of the parallel forms of computer art from different countries.
A number of public outcomes are anticipated in addition to the online database. The major outcome will be a display that incorporates highlights from the Patric Prince material, to be held at the V&A in 2010-11. This will give an authoritative historical background to digital art. It is anticipated that some or all of the exhibited material will then travel in the UK and/or North America.
A detailed catalogue will be produced with a dozen essays by the project contributors and invited scholars. Journal papers will also be produced. We will also hold an historical panel session at SIGGRAPH 2010.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Title Digital Pioneers 
Description Digital Pioneers was the display organised by Douglas Dodds and Honor Beddard, associated with the book "Digital Pioneers" (see Publications) and the CAT Project, It was held from 7 December 2009 to 23 May 2010. The display was also linked to the significant contemporary exhibition entitled "Decode: Digital Design Sensations", that ran from 8 December 2009 - 11 April 2010. For more details, see the Museum's press release, which includes the following description of the Digital Pioneers display: "Digital Pioneers will showcase some of the earliest computer-generated art and design drawn from the V&A's recently acquired computer art collections and will include works by Frieder Nake, Georg Nees, Roman Verostko, and British artists Paul Brown and Harold Cohen. The display will explore the arrival of the computer in art and design practices across the globe and its impact on subsequent generations. It will include plotter drawings, screen prints, digital inkjet prints, photographs and early algorithmic works, as well as important documentary material from the time. The display will be open from 7 December 2009... Admission will be free." 
Type Of Art Artistic/Creative Exhibition 
Year Produced 2009 
Impact It was extensively visited and well received, including a write-up in the New York Times review of the Decode exhibition as a whole: 
URL http://www.nytimes.com/2009/12/14/arts/design/14iht-design14.html?pagewanted=all&_r=0
 
Description The partners examined the development of computer-based art from the late 1970s to the 1990s. The basis of our research was the collection of artworks, publications and ephemera assembled by Patric Prince, an American art historian who comprehensively chronicled the nascent Computer Art scene. Project staff documented and evaluated the Patric Prince Collection's contents, using it to establish a framework for understanding the medium in its art historical, cultural and technological context. We also considered these historic developments in relation to areas of contemporary practice in the digital arts. Outcomes included: the photographing of artworks and associated artefacts, and their entry into the publicly accessible database Search The Collections at the V&A; the one-day conference Ideas Before Their Time, about computer art in the period 1960-2000, and the collection of papers published by the British Computer Society; the display "Digital Pioneers" at the V&A in 2009-10 and the publication associated with this collection; several papers and journal articles in 'Leonardo' and 'Digital Creativity'; ongoing lectures with the Computer Arts Society; and indirect outcomes such as the exhibition 'Intuition and Ingenuity', for the Alan Turing centenary in 2012, that drew on aspects of research from the CAT Project.
Exploitation Route Within the V&A, there has been an expansion of interest in digital art and design that certainly owes much to the initial CACHe Project and CAT, as its successor. The ICA too has rediscovered its early Cybernetic Serendipity show, whilst initiatives by the ZKM around Bit International, the Kunstmuseum of Bremen, which bought the digital art archive of Herbert Franke, the Database of Digital Art (at the University of Bremen) and the Database of Virtual Art at Humboldt University utilise data or discoveries from CAT in various ways.

The expanding work by Middlesex University on the Lansdown Archive, left by Computer Arts Society founder John Lansdown, and the Science Museum's interest in the early history of electronic music (especially their acquisition of the files of another CAS founder, Alan Sutcliffe, relating to his pioneering work with electronic music) demonstrate increasing engagement with the history of this area.

In terms of teaching, the MFA and MA courses in Computational Studio Arts at Goldsmiths, several modules on the BA and MA courses in History of Art at Birkbeck, and various other institutions have benefitted from material uncovered during the research for this project.

Furthermore, an ongoing programme of public engagement through lectures and exhibitions mounted by the Computer Arts Society; its sister organisation EVA London (Electronic Imagery and the Visual Arts) with its annual conference every July that brings together professionals from arts, the graphics industry and heritage organisations; and partnerships with the Royal College of Art, Central St Martins, Ravensbourne College, Plymouth University, De Montfort Leicester, etc have brought useful public exposure for our work.
Sectors Creative Economy,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections

URL http://www.technocultures.org.uk/index.html
 
Description Within the V&A, there has been an expansion of interest in digital art and design that certainly owes much to the initial CACHe Project and CAT, as its successor. The ICA too has rediscovered its early Cybernetic Serendipity show, whilst initiatives by the ZKM in Karlsruhe around Bit International, the Kunstmuseum of Bremen (which bought the digital art archive of Herbert Franke), the Database of Digital Art (at the University of Bremen) and the Database of Virtual Art at Humboldt University utilise data or discoveries from CAT in various ways. The expanding work by Middlesex University on the Lansdown Archive, left by Computer Arts Society founder John Lansdown, and the Science Museum's interest in the early history of electronic music (especially their acquisition of the files of another CAS founder, Alan Sutcliffe, relating to his pioneering work with electronic music) demonstrate increasing engagement with the history of this area. In terms of teaching, the MFA and MA courses in Computational Studio Arts at Goldsmiths, several modules on the BA and MA courses in History of Art at Birkbeck, and various other institutions have benefitted from material uncovered during the research for this project. Furthermore, an ongoing programme of public engagement through lectures and exhibitions mounted by the Computer Arts Society; its sister organisation EVA London (Electronic Imagery and the Visual Arts) with its annual conference every July that brings together professionals from arts, the graphics industry and heritage organisations; and partnerships with the Royal College of Art, Central St Martins, Ravensbourne College, Plymouth University, De Montfort Leicester, etc have brought useful public exposure for our work.
First Year Of Impact 2009
Sector Creative Economy,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Cultural

 
Title Main database on the V&A's Collections Information System 
Description The data collected from the various artefacts of the Patric Prince Collection and the Computer Arts Society collection is used on the internal MUSIMS database, and its successor the Collections Information System, developed by the V&A 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact It facilitates internal searches for material on the V&A collections database, and also informs the metadata used in the publicly accessible Search the Collections database. 
 
Title Main metadata source for the V&A's computer art collections, including the Patric Prince archive and Computer Arts Society collection 
Description The V&A has been collecting computer-generated art and design since the 1960s, and has also acquired two significant collections: The Computer Arts Society Collection and The Patric Prince archive. Together these form the basis of the UK's emerging national collection of computer art. The V&A's holdings range from early experiments with analogue computers and mechanical devices, to examples of contemporary software-based practices that produce digital prints and computer-generated drawings. Images of artefacts from these collections were digitised by the V&A over the course of the CAT Project and the accumulated metadata added to Search The Collections, as part of the overall V&A database update. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact Apart from being integrated into Search the Collections and thus becoming a major resource for researchers using the Internet to find digital artworks and collections, the digital data from the several computer art collections also informs the development of the new Digital Art & Design section at the V&A. This has been developed under Douglas Dodds' remit as Head of Digital Collections and Services. 
URL http://www.vam.ac.uk/page/d/digital-art-and-design/
 
Description Collaboration with Computer Arts Society 
Organisation British Computer Society (BCS)
Department Computer Arts Society (CAS)
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution The Computer Arts Society was reformed as a result of the previous CACHe (Computer Arts Histories Etc) Project (2002-6) and helped facilitate the transfer of CAS's archives and Patric Prince's archives to the V&A.
Collaborator Contribution Throughout the period 2007-10 and ongoing today, CAS has hosted lectures given by members of the project team (Lambert, Dodds, Beddard, Franco and Gardiner) and continues to provide a focal point for digital art community involvement and discussion. It has also facilitated the recovery of several more archives, notably additional parts of the John Lansdown archive to Middlesex University, and recently deceased CAS founder Alan Sutcliffe's archive of electronic music files to the Science Museum. Through the BCS, CAS also hosted and published the proceedings of the symposium "Ideas Before Their Time" and also runs the annual EVA Conference, on electronic visualistion in the arts.
Impact EVA Conferences since 2007 "Ideas Before Their Time" symposium held at the British Computer Society London Office on 3rd February 2010. CAS Lecture: "Parallel Evolution: the Patric Prince Collection and the emergence of SIGGRAPH as a North American computer arts venue". about the core research of the project on May 6 2008, by the project team gave a presentation to members of the Computer Arts Society: Lectures by the following computer art pioneers and historians: * "Going With the Flow", Thu, 24 Oct 2013 6:00pm, James Faure Walker * "When Technology met Art: An introduction to 1960's British Computer Art Pioneer, Desmond Paul Henry (1921-2004)" Tue, 21 May 2013, Elaine O'Hanrahan * "The delegation of aesthetic decision making to machines", Thu, 14 Feb 2013 6:00pm, Peter Beyls * "From Programmed Art to Visual Research with Computers: The New Tendencies (1961-1973)" Tue, 23 Oct 2012 6:00pm, Dr Armin Medosch * "Waldemar Cordeiro: An Overview of His Pioneering Digital Art", Tue, 24 Jan 2012, Eduardo Kac * 3 February - "Ideas Before Their Time" - 9-6pm at BCS London HQ followed by a CAS talk by Brian Reffin Smith at 7:00 * 4-5 February - Decoding the Digital - a 2 day conference at the V&A * "The Origin of Ideas & Analogue Programmer T4 with Digital Overtones", Wed, 07 Sep 2011, Dr Jack Tait * "Writing the Score for Drawing", Wed, 14 Oct 2009, Roman Verostko * Barbara Nessim, Wed, 02 Sep 2009 * "1970 - The First Computer Art Show at the Venice Biennale: An Experiment or Product of the Bourgeois Culture?" Wed, 04 Mar 2009, Francesca Franco * CAS stand at the Kinetica Art Fair, 28th Feb 2009 * Lansdown Symposium: "Completing the Circle: Incorporating Evaluation in Creative Work" Mon, 19 Jan 2009 * "Ranulph Glanville: No Longer a Shrinking Violet?", Tue, 02 Dec 2008, Ranulph Glanville * "Parallel Evolution: the Patric Prince Collection and the emergence of SIGGRAPH as a North American computer arts venue", Tuesday 6th May 2008, CAT Project team members
 
Description Collaboration wth GV Gallery 
Organisation GV Art Gallery
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution Robert Devic, owner of GV Gallery, and Professor Ernest Edmonds suggested a joint symposium to mark the opening of the exhibition "Automatic Art: human and machine processes that make art" at GV Art gallery, London. This built on research and partnerships established by the CAT Project with the artists and institutions including De Montfort University, Leicester. Speakers discussed the development of UK Systems Art form the 1950s onwards, including: Sean Clarke, Ernest Edmonds, Sue Gollifer, Terry Pope, Stephen Scrivener, Steve Sproates and Susan Tebby.
Collaborator Contribution GV Gallery ran the exhibition "Automatic Art" that provided the context for this event. The Computer Arts Society gave funding towards travel and speaker expenses. Birkbeck provided the venue.
Impact The symposium Automatic Art, on Wednesday 2 July 2014, 6:30pm at Birkbeck
Start Year 2010
 
Description Middlesex University 
Organisation Middlesex University
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution The Lansdown Centre, formerly at Cat Hill and now on the main campus at Hendon, houses the John Lansdown Archive, comprising the papers and other material of one of the founders of the Computer Arts Society. Working with Dr Stephen Boyd Davies, the team utilised materials held here and also talked to researchers and students at the Centre, e.g. when Nick Lambert delivered the Lansdown Memorial Lecture in 2009.
Collaborator Contribution The materials held by the Centre provided useful identification for materials held in the Patric Prince Collection, and also informed other aspects of our research
Impact Lectures and input to published materials
Start Year 2007
 
Description Decoding the Digital Conference 
Form Of Engagement Activity Scientific meeting (conference/symposium etc.)
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Type Of Presentation paper presentation
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Decoding the Digital was a 2 day conference on 4-5 February 2010 consisting of presentations and dialogues between contemporary digital practitioners and historians within the world of digital and computer-generated art and design. Speakers included artist Frieder Nake and writer Edward Shanken, with theorists Charlie Gere and Beryl Graham. There was a in-conversation between Paul Brown and his son Daniel Brown. Other contributors included the collector Michael Spalter, the writer and artist Anne Morgan Spalter, plus Louise Shannon (V&A) and Shane Walter (Director, on edotzero), co-curators of the V&A exhibition Decode: Digital Design Sensations, and Douglas Dodds, one of the curators of the V&A display Digital Pioneers: Computer-Generated Art and Design from the V&A's Collections. It brought in an audience of at least 70 people and was extensively discussed afterwards.

Apart from the dialogue between pioneers and practitioners, the conference also resulted in articles in the press, e.g. http://www.eyemagazine.com/blog/post/the-wm-morris-code
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2010
URL http://www.vam.ac.uk/whatson/event/485/decoding-the-digital-1048/
 
Description ISEA Ruhr 2010 panel: Codifying history: the CAT Project examines the international trajectory of computer art 1975-2000. 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact The project partners - Lambert, Dodds, Beddard and Franco - gave a series of presentations at ISEA Ruhr, marking the completion of the project. The panel session on 27 August was entitled Codifying history: the CAT Project examines the international trajectory of computer art 1975-2000. The talks are listed in the Publications section.

We engaged with an audience and digital art specialists and other from allied fields, e.g. museology etc, who asked numerous questions about the CAT Project and its results.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2010
URL http://www.isea2010ruhr.org/conference
 
Description Ideas Before Their Time 
Form Of Engagement Activity Scientific meeting (conference/symposium etc.)
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Type Of Presentation paper presentation
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other academic audiences (collaborators, peers etc.)
Results and Impact The symposium was put together by Lambert, Gardiner and Franco, and had 20 speakers with around 90 attendees, including participants from the USA and Germany. All talks were published in a collected volume. Each one sparked healthy debate and developed thematic ideas around specific areas covered by the CAT Project.

Apart form the book, the talk resulted in further discussions, further work with Prof Frieder Nake at Bremen, and informal collaborations with Ernest Edmonds and others .
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2010
URL http://www.technocultures.org.uk/symposium.html
 
Description Technocultures: The History of Digital Art - A Conversation 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact The MFA Computer Art Department at the School of Visual Arts (SVA) in New York presented Nick Lambert and Jeremy Gardiner along with four of the most influential pioneers of digital art: Kenneth Knowlton, Margot Lovejoy, Kenneth Snelson and Lillian Schwartz. It was chaired by Department Chair Bruce Wands will moderate. Video of the panel sessions can be found here: http://www.nydigitalsalon.org/techno_1.php

This prompted much interest amongst the audience in New York, with subsidiary discussions and further contacts with American artists, and links made to British and other European institutions.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2009
URL http://www.nydigitalsalon.org/Technocultures%20e-release.pdf