Series as multipart pieces with regulated changes

Lead Research Organisation: Bath Spa University
Department Name: College of Liberal Arts

Abstract

The research aims to establish a set of principles which govern the structure and application of multipart series in music and visual art. The idea of a series in this context is best defined by Sol LeWitt, who states 'Serial compositions are multipart pieces with regulated changes. The differences between the parts are the subject of the composition. If some parts remain constant it is to punctuate the changes ...The autonomous parts are units, rows, sets, or any logical division that would be read as a complete thought. The series would be read by the viewer in a linear or narrative manner even though in its final form many of these sets would be operating simultaneously, making comprehension difficult.' This approach has become central to various bodies of visual art since the 1960s, particularly monochrome and colour-field painting, some conceptual art, and minimalism in its various forms. Within music, it is most evident in the work of the central European and American Wandelweiser group of composers.Founded by Antoine Beuger and Burkhard Schlothauer in 1992, Wandelweiser have defined a clear aesthetic whose resonance has been critical to a continued exploration of new compositional ground internationally over the past decade. Their work is distinctive and makes few compromises: it deals with extremes and archetypes. Schlothauer summarises the characteristics of the Wandelweiser composers' work succinctly in his essay Etwas über Wandelweiser , saying that their music is generally very quiet and that silence has a large share of the often extended performance durations. Generally there is little conventional drama and the presentation of sound material is very clear: harmony, rhythm and melody play either a subordinate role or none at all. These composers also make frequent reference to the work of visual artists. In Beuger's work for example, the series [first - fourth] music for marcia hafif (1994-2002) draws on the serial structure of Hafif's monochromes. Most of Hafif's work is in series, some complete and some ongoing. For example, her Extended Gray Scale (1972-3) comprised 105 ordered grey paintings and was complete when she felt she was unable to distinguish a new shade of grey. Other artists whose work underpins this study include Sol LeWitt, whose series of wall drawings have informed my own compositional approach to interlinked pieces, and Carl Andre, whose floor sculptures represent, alongside Dan Flavin's neon light work, perhaps the most consistent extended application of modularity.
Through examining the work of these composers and artists, the aim of the project is to establish a set of principles that are common to their serial work. These will be articulated through a journal article and edited volume of Contemporary Music Review, focusing on the Wandelweiser composers (the first major study in English), and a series of composition projects resulting in pieces for Basel Sinfonietta, [rout], and Apartment House. These compositions will focus on the further expansion of my existing series, and the development of new ones, both of which will be informed by the parallel musicological research. Specifically, the criteria determined by the analysis of other work will shape some of my decision-making when planning new multipart work: it is the nature of this mode of working that decisions made at the macro-level have major ramifications for later development of sub-pieces. The two ensemble pieces will be related as part of a new series that emerges from the principles determined through the contextual research, and which is informed by my current series and earlier modular piece #[unassigned]. The research will therefore benefit practitioners, musicologists and art theorists with an interest in serial and modular structures, and audiences seeking to engage with these concepts and work. The two parts of the project are intrinsically linked, with my practice-led and musicological research being interdependent.

Planned Impact

In addition to the academic beneficiaries, there are three target groups who will benefit from the research and its outputs: composers/artists, performers/programmers/curators, and audiences.

Composers and artists working experimentally, or with multipart series, will find the principles formulated by the research a useful point of reference for their own creative practice. This will be communicated through the journal article, compositions and associated writing, and informal networking. Through the work they produce, the research will be disseminated to a wider public audience, embodied in the creative work itself and through discussion in accessible texts, such as programme or exhibition notes, and more extended technical writing. Traces of this work, such as recordings and texts, or exhibition catalogues citing the research, will ensure its continuing relevance as a resource. It will also be of benefit to performers, concert programmers and curators seeking to present work structured as multipart series in an appropriate context. The question of the status of sub-pieces within a series and the necessity of presenting more than one piece during a performance, or not breaking a series of artworks, is a recurring problem in particular, and the ideas developed during the research will help provide a framework for its consideration.

The journal article already has a publication schedule, and my track record as a composer is evidenced by the list of publications and plans for performances, including those outside the UK, so there are established channels for the dissemination of the research. In writing about my work in concert programme notes and via my website, the theoretical and conceptual basis of my compositional practice will be made available to a wider audience than that of the academic journal. The stated performances will involve in some cases also giving a pre-concert talk, radio interview, or undertaking work in an educational context (seminar, workshop). This provides a more informal way to discuss aspects of the research in relation to my music. It should be noted that this will encompass work well beyond the duration of the fellowship. Working in series and modularity has been central to my practice for over ten years, and the ideas developed during the research will provide many new directions for future investigation.

Publications

10 25 50
publication icon
Melia N (2011) Introduction: What is Wandelweiser? in Contemporary Music Review

 
Title any one part can replace any other part 
Description any one part can replace any other part (2010) is scored for violin, cup on brick, and bowed metal. Each player performs a repeated single action resulting in a series of unstable held sounds. The title is taken from Carl Andre's statement Anaxial Symmetry (1970). The piece is part of the series divisions that could be autonomous but that comprise the whole (2009- ) and was written for Angharad Davies and Parkinson Saunders. 
Type Of Art Composition/Score 
 
Title certain elements within that situation remained constant 
Description certain elements within that situation remained constant (2011) is scored for guitar, melodica, bass clarinet and double bass. A constant drone is offset by unstable tones played at regularly repeating intervals. The title is taken from Bridget Riley's Untitled Statement (c.1968). The piece is part of the series divisions that could be autonomous but that comprise the whole (2009- ) and was written for Travis Just. 
Type Of Art Composition/Score 
 
Title certain elements within that situation remained constant 
Description certain elements within that situation remained constant (2011) is scored for guitar, melodica, bass clarinet and double bass. A constant drone is offset by unstable tones played at regularly repeating intervals. The title is taken from Bridget Riley's Untitled Statement (c.1968). The piece is part of the series divisions that could be autonomous but that comprise the whole (2009- ) and was written for Travis Just. 
Type Of Art Performance (Music, Dance, Drama, etc) 
 
Title distribution study [#1-12] 
Description distribution study is a series of distributed sound compositions by James Saunders. Taking the model of a decentralised and self-organising network, as utilised by large dissipated groups of people when attempting to mobilise en masse for the purpose of demonstrating, distribution study operates as a composition made for personal, distributed performance. Realisations of the piece performed at the Pinakothek der Moderne in Munich during 2011 catalyse an emergent score-distribution network. Copies of the scores are made available to visitors, who facilitate their dissemination through self-determining channels. These exchanges are mapped via this website, showing the way in which inter-personal communication networks can shape the dissemination of information. Each month a new score will be distributed in the museum by the singers from Neue Vocalsolisten Stuttgart. They will give performances of each piece, and pass the scores to visitors, who may then take the scores with them to perform and pass on to others as determined by the particular instructions. The piece also examines the way in which people give and receive objects, communicate and make contact with each other away from social networking sites. It is about direct contact between people as a means of distributing information, which in this case is a sound structure performed in an unobtrusive and quiet manner. It has its roots in leafleting as a method of disseminating information. For me this direct contact is important in the age where everyone is our friend online, and where it is easy to convey one's point of view in a blog which nobody reads. 
Type Of Art Composition/Score 
 
Title distribution study [#1-12] 
Description distribution study is a series of distributed sound compositions by James Saunders. Taking the model of a decentralised and self-organising network, as utilised by large dissipated groups of people when attempting to mobilise en masse for the purpose of demonstrating, distribution study operates as a composition made for personal, distributed performance. Realisations of the piece performed at the Pinakothek der Moderne in Munich during 2011 catalyse an emergent score-distribution network. Copies of the scores are made available to visitors, who facilitate their dissemination through self-determining channels. These exchanges are mapped via this website, showing the way in which inter-personal communication networks can shape the dissemination of information. Each month a new score will be distributed in the museum by the singers from Neue Vocalsolisten Stuttgart. They will give performances of each piece, and pass the scores to visitors, who may then take the scores with them to perform and pass on to others as determined by the particular instructions. The piece also examines the way in which people give and receive objects, communicate and make contact with each other away from social networking sites. It is about direct contact between people as a means of distributing information, which in this case is a sound structure performed in an unobtrusive and quiet manner. It has its roots in leafleting as a method of disseminating information. For me this direct contact is important in the age where everyone is our friend online, and where it is easy to convey one's point of view in a blog which nobody reads. 
Type Of Art Performance (Music, Dance, Drama, etc) 
 
Title divisions that could be autonomous but that comprise the whole 
Description Audio CD containing compositions from the series 'divisions that could be autonomous but that comprise the whole'. edges ensemble/Stephen Chase/Angharad Davies/Tim Parkinson/James Saunders/Philip Thomas, Label: another timbre, at44 (2011). 
Type Of Art Performance (Music, Dance, Drama, etc) 
 
Title materials vary greatly and are simply materials 
Description harp, objects, 4'00" Written for Rhodri Davies, and first performed by him in Portmeirion, 22 October 2010. materials vary greatly and are simply materials (2010) uses ten different materials placed in a harp, and then bowed. The materials are drawn from the list of traditional gifts given for the first ten wedding anniversaries. The title is taken from Donald Judd's essay Specific Objects (1964). The piece is part of the series divisions that could be autonomous but that comprise the whole (2009- ) and was written for Rhodri Davies. It is dedicated to Tim Parkinson and Angharad Davies, and first performed at their wedding. 
Type Of Art Composition/Score 
 
Title materials vary greatly and are simply materials 
Description harp, objects, 4'00" Written for Rhodri Davies, and first performed by him in Portmeirion, 22 October 2010. materials vary greatly and are simply materials (2010) uses ten different materials placed in a harp, and then bowed. The materials are drawn from the list of traditional gifts given for the first ten wedding anniversaries. The title is taken from Donald Judd's essay Specific Objects (1964). The piece is part of the series divisions that could be autonomous but that comprise the whole (2009- ) and was written for Rhodri Davies. It is dedicated to Tim Parkinson and Angharad Davies, and first performed at their wedding. 
Type Of Art Performance (Music, Dance, Drama, etc) 
 
Title nothing reveals itself without at the same time concealing something else 
Description nothing reveals itself without at the same time concealing something else (2011) comprises a series of overlapping sounds at low volumes. The title is taken from Mel Bochner's statement Seriality and Photography (1967). The piece is part of the series divisions that could be autonomous but that comprise the whole (2009- ) and was written for [rout]. 
Type Of Art Composition/Score 
 
Title nothing reveals itself without at the same time concealing something else 
Description nothing reveals itself without at the same time concealing something else (2011) comprises a series of overlapping sounds at low volumes. The title is taken from Mel Bochner's statement Seriality and Photography (1967). The piece is part of the series divisions that could be autonomous but that comprise the whole (2009- ) and was written for [rout]. 
Type Of Art Performance (Music, Dance, Drama, etc) 
 
Title opposition between the two spaces and their common mediation 
Description opposition between the two spaces and their common mediation (2011) creates a situation where sounds made using a variety of sources emerge in sequence from a constant noise tone. The title is taken from Dan Graham's Three Projects for Architecture and Video / Notes (1977). The piece is part of the series divisions that could be autonomous but that comprise the whole (2009- ) and was written for Angharad Davies and Tim Parkinson. 
Type Of Art Composition/Score 
 
Title opposition between the two spaces and their common mediation 
Description opposition between the two spaces and their common mediation (2011) creates a situation where sounds made using a variety of sources emerge in sequence from a constant noise tone. The title is taken from Dan Graham's Three Projects for Architecture and Video / Notes (1977). The piece is part of the series divisions that could be autonomous but that comprise the whole (2009- ) and was written for Angharad Davies and Tim Parkinson. 
Type Of Art Performance (Music, Dance, Drama, etc) 
 
Title surfaces 
Description surfaces is part of James Saunders' ongoing project on the sonic properties of materials. Each piece in the series explores the way in which elementary actions elicit sounds from specific types of materials. In surfaces, all of the materials are flat. The sounds are produced through manual manipulation or the use of tools and objects in conjunction with the surfaces. The score uses verbal descriptions to specify action types; these vary between singular instructions and longer, more complicated sequences. Instructions may be repeated, reapplied to the same surface or transferred to a different one. Over the course of the performance, the surfaces become transformed, potentially resulting in detritus. 
Type Of Art Composition/Score 
 
Title surfaces 
Description surfaces is part of James Saunders' ongoing project on the sonic properties of materials. Each piece in the series explores the way in which elementary actions elicit sounds from specific types of materials. In surfaces, all of the materials are flat. The sounds are produced through manual manipulation or the use of tools and objects in conjunction with the surfaces. The score uses verbal descriptions to specify action types; these vary between singular instructions and longer, more complicated sequences. Instructions may be repeated, reapplied to the same surface or transferred to a different one. Over the course of the performance, the surfaces become transformed, potentially resulting in detritus. 
Type Of Art Performance (Music, Dance, Drama, etc) 
 
Title things whole and not whole 
Description things whole and not whole (2011) takes its title from the tenth fragment of Heraclitus, which states 'Things grasped together: things whole and not whole, what is drawn together and what is drawn asunder, the harmonious and the discordant. The one is made up of all things, and all things issue from the one.' The starting point for the piece was the analysis of flocking behaviour in birds made by Craig Reynolds, in which he made computer-graphic simulations of flocking 'boids'. Their movement was governed by three simple rules: a clumping force which keeps the flock together, a separation force which keeps them apart, and an ability to match velocity. The individual boids follow these rules, and the flock movement emerges from their interaction. In things whole and not whole, the interaction of the players is governed by rule-based cueing: players make sounds in response to those made by other players, choosing different reference players for each new sound. They also have some autonomy in the selection of sound-producing materials. From the perspective of the birds or players, the immediate world is in flux, but seen from the outside the whole is more readily apparent. things whole and not whole develops my interest in group behaviour as an organising principle, and in the use of collaborative approaches to score-making. things whole and not whole was commissioned by Basel Sinfonietta with the support of the Ernst von Siemens Music Foundation. 
Type Of Art Composition/Score 
 
Title things whole and not whole 
Description things whole and not whole (2011) takes its title from the tenth fragment of Heraclitus, which states 'Things grasped together: things whole and not whole, what is drawn together and what is drawn asunder, the harmonious and the discordant. The one is made up of all things, and all things issue from the one.' The starting point for the piece was the analysis of flocking behaviour in birds made by Craig Reynolds, in which he made computer-graphic simulations of flocking 'boids'. Their movement was governed by three simple rules: a clumping force which keeps the flock together, a separation force which keeps them apart, and an ability to match velocity. The individual boids follow these rules, and the flock movement emerges from their interaction. In things whole and not whole, the interaction of the players is governed by rule-based cueing: players make sounds in response to those made by other players, choosing different reference players for each new sound. They also have some autonomy in the selection of sound-producing materials. From the perspective of the birds or players, the immediate world is in flux, but seen from the outside the whole is more readily apparent. things whole and not whole develops my interest in group behaviour as an organising principle, and in the use of collaborative approaches to score-making. things whole and not whole was commissioned by Basel Sinfonietta with the support of the Ernst von Siemens Music Foundation. 
Type Of Art Performance (Music, Dance, Drama, etc) 
 
Title things whole and not whole 
Description things whole and not whole (2011) takes its title from the tenth fragment of Heraclitus, which states 'Things grasped together: things whole and not whole, what is drawn together and what is drawn asunder, the harmonious and the discordant. The one is made up of all things, and all things issue from the one.' The starting point for the piece was the analysis of flocking behaviour in birds made by Craig Reynolds, in which he made computer-graphic simulations of flocking 'boids'. Their movement was governed by three simple rules: a clumping force which keeps the flock together, a separation force which keeps them apart, and an ability to match velocity. The individual boids follow these rules, and the flock movement emerges from their interaction. In things whole and not whole, the interaction of the players is governed by rule-based cueing: players make sounds in response to those made by other players, choosing different reference players for each new sound. They also have some autonomy in the selection of sound-producing materials. From the perspective of the birds or players, the immediate world is in flux, but seen from the outside the whole is more readily apparent. things whole and not whole develops my interest in group behaviour as an organising principle, and in the use of collaborative approaches to score-making. things whole and not whole was commissioned by Basel Sinfonietta with the support of the Ernst von Siemens Music Foundation. 
Type Of Art Performance (Music, Dance, Drama, etc) 
 
Title various distinct spatial or temporal locations 
Description various distinct spatial or temporal locations (2011) is for realisation by individuals using a takeaway coffee cup and a selected surface. Each realisation involves drawing the cup across the surface to make a sound. All realisations constitute the single performance of various distinct spatial or temporal locations. The title is taken from Dan Graham's 'The Glass Divider, Light and Social Division', part of his Three Projects for Architecture and Video / Notes (1977). The piece is part of the series divisions that could be autonomous but that comprise the whole (2009- ). 
Type Of Art Composition/Score 
 
Title with the same material or still, to vary the material 
Description with the same material or still, to vary the material (2011) explores similarities between frictions sounds created by bowing objects. The title is taken from Herve Fischer's essay Theory of Sociological Art (1979). The piece is part of the series divisions that could be autonomous but that comprise the whole (2009- ) and was written for Patrick Farmer and Sarah Hughes. 
Type Of Art Composition/Score 
 
Description Interview with Robert Worby 
Form Of Engagement Activity A press release, press conference or response to a media enquiry/interview
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Interviewed by Robert Worby and broadcast on BBC Radio 3, Hear and Now

Interviewed by Robert Worby about the performance of 'things whole and not whole'.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2011
 
Description Pre-concert talk 
Form Of Engagement Activity A magazine, newsletter or online publication
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Pre-concert panel discussion in advance of performance of 'things whole and not whole' in Huddersfield. Recorded by BBC Radio 3

Discussion between composers featured in the From Scratch project, with Rober Worby from BBC Radio 3
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2011
 
Description things whole and not whole 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Media (as a channel to the public)
Results and Impact DRS 2 broadcast of Basel performance

Broadcast of Basel performance on DRS2
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2011
 
Description things whole and not whole 
Form Of Engagement Activity A press release, press conference or response to a media enquiry/interview
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Broadcast on BBC Radio 3

Broadcast of the Huddersfield Contemporary Music Festival performance by Basel Sinfonietta.

BBC Radio 3, Hear and Now.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2011