From Protest to Propaganda: A History of Activist Art in Britain, 1845-1918

Lead Research Organisation: Queen Mary University of London
Department Name: History

Abstract

This project aims to change the paradigm by producing the first definitive account of the origins and history of art activism. When we think of activist movements, often the first thing that comes to mind is an image: the peace sign of the anti-war movement, the raised fist of Black Power, and, more recently, the Guy Fawkes mask of the Occupy Movement. Activists have long recognised the power of images, not only to symbolise their campaigns, but also as tools to facilitate social or political change. The production of art designed to provoke change, known as art activism, is today a common practice, and art activists like Ai Weiwei and the Guerrilla Girls are celebrated by the art establishment, their artworks and methods scrupulously analysed and theorised by historians of contemporary art. Yet scholars of art activism have thus far focused nearly exclusively on art produced over the last thirty years. Research has therefore overlooked the true depth of the practice's history, which began much earlier and was far more widespread than current narratives suggest.

Vastly extending the chronological scope of the field, this research will demonstrate that the values and political strategies we see in today's productive culture of art activism were preceded by hugely influential-but thus far unstudied-artistic programmes devised by activist movements between the mid-nineteenth century and the end of the First World War in Britain. The nation hailed as having 'created the social movement' (Tilly, 1982), Britain was also at the vanguard in the use of art as a political strategy. Beginning with a select group of politically-minded artists in the 1840s (e.g. Watts, Richard Redgrave, Daniel Macdonald), the practice of art activism quickly spread to become a critical method for groups like the Chartists, Socialists, anti-child labour campaigners, Irish Home Rule supporters, Suffragettes, deaf equality advocates, and promotors of dress reform and animal rights, amongst others. These groups put the visual arts to use in systematic campaigns to generate change, commissioning images designed for the purpose of changing minds and spurring action. Such was the success of these tactics that by 1914, having witnessed the influence of art produced by groups like the suffrage movement, the British government adopted an equivalent artistic programme as a key home front strategy in the First World War.

By foregrounding art's significance in activist campaigns throughout the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, this portfolio of research and engagement activities will recover the crucial role of images in British political movements, tracing its transformation from an experimental political strategy into a method so successful that it was ultimately adopted by the very government it had so often been designed to undermine. Contributing to ongoing critical debates in the study of both art activism and political movements, this project aims to alter both fields by integrating art within discussions of activist history and demonstrating how art's influence revises scholarly understandings of the growth of political participation and social campaigning during the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. Furthermore, through an innovative interdisciplinary approach, combining forms of analysis from art history, history, and sociology, this project will develop and implement a new, transferrable methodology, capable of being applied to future studies of art activism in both historic and contemporary contexts. Extensive archival research, primarily undertaken in London, will enable rigorous scholarly assessment of individual activist artists, artworks, and art movements in order to contextualise them within their social and political milieux, assess their strategies and influence, and evaluate their impacts. The research will result in a monograph, scholarly articles, an exhibition, a workshop, and an art masterclass.

Planned Impact

This project will reach a wide range of stakeholders beyond academia, as follows:

1) Organisations and individuals in the creative and cultural industries will benefit, including:

a) Watts Gallery: This project helps fulfil its central mission 'to be a national centre for the study of Victorian and early 20th century art, design, and social history' by staging an exhibition that will increase its intellectual profile and shed new light on the Victorian and Edwardian era's culture and politics. The scale of the exhibition (Watts Gallery received 65K visitors last year), the compelling nature of its theme, and a public talk by art activists the Guerrilla Girls will help to expand Watts Gallery's audience by attracting visitors from the surrounding area, London, and beyond. Increased footfall will facilitate wealth creation, increasing revenue through ticket sales (avg. admission £4.18), memberships, shop and café purchases (avg. spend per visitor £8.51 and £6.04, respectively), as well as drawing new visitors to the pubs, shops, and other services in the village of Compton.

b) Artists: The project will benefit activist artists in different stages of their professional careers, including emergent as well as eminent artists. The masterclass will provide 15 emerging art activists with the opportunity to enrich their understanding of the history of their practice and discuss ways of incorporating historic art activist approaches into their work; present their artistic plans for feedback; network with other practitioners; and attend an art activism talk and training session with the Guerrilla Girls. Eminent activist artists, the Guerrilla Girls (who have agreed to participate), will fulfil their aim of increasing awareness of activism and assisting others to produce art activist projects by holding a talk (open to the public) and a training session (for masterclass participants).

c) Platform London: By collaborating with Platform London on the interdisciplinary workshop, this project will provide a key networking opportunity for the charity, drawing together an international audience of researchers, activists, and artists with a vested interest in the group's art activist programmes, leading to potential new collaborations and funding sources. The journal article I will co-author with PL's James Marriott and Jane Trowell to submit to October will help position the group at the forefront of discussion on the long-term impacts of art activist interventions, a key concern for the charity.

2) The general public: The exhibition, workshop, feature articles, and public talk by the Guerrilla Girls will enhance and enrich the public's awareness of activist art, both its historic manifestations and its contemporary practices. These activities will also increase public understanding of art's relationship to politics and its capacity for influencing change, a concept crucial in reinforcing the value of art at a time of declining funding for the arts and art education. The collaboration with Platform London will ensure that the workshop is publicised to wide publics engaged with art activism, including activists, artists, and charity workers. Feature articles will be pitched to The Guardian and Art News, the most widely circulated arts magazine, ensuring maximum coverage. With assistance from the Watts Gallery education team, the exhibition will be enhanced by programmes for audiences with particular needs, giving tailored exhibition access to children and adults with limited access to the arts, as detailed in Pathways to Impact.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Title Collaborative Art Project between Lily Ash Sakula and Community Groups 
Description Lily Ash Sakula was hired as artist in residence during the Art and Action exhibition at Watts Gallery. During the exhibition, she hosted a series of workshops to share ideas and explore the themes of Art and Action with participants from the Art for All Learning Programme. Participants included families and young people, as well as members of the charities halow (young people with learning disabilities), User Voice (people struggling with mental illness), the Woking Women's Support Centre (women affected by domestic abuse, homelessness, and other gender specific issues), and Amber (vulnerable and disadvantaged young people). 70 participants were involved over 13 live Zoom events. Participants' drawings and audio recordings of the workshop discussions were shared with Lily who then made an animation informed by both the workshop discussions and the exhibition narrative, answering the question, "how can art make change?" One participant wrote, "I loved seeing my drawings move in the animation. I think we did a very good job. Our movie is important." 
Type Of Art Artwork 
Year Produced 2020 
Impact The resulting co-produced animation became part of Watts Gallery's learning resources which are used when engaging audiences with the social realist paintings of G F Watts. The process was also shared with the public via the Watts Gallery website and social media channels (via blog posts, Instagram or Twitter takeovers etc). The artist reported that the project "grew my confidence to develop resources that successfully engage people with art across a wide range of ages, backgrounds and abilities" and allowed her to establish a new partnership as an artistic mentor for the charity Disability Arts in Surrey. 
URL https://www.lashesofsakula.com/project/drawing-the-future
 
Title Original artwork commissioned from graphic artist Soofiya 
Description Soofiya was commissioned to design original graphic artwork and logos for the conference "Who Owns Histories of Art Activism in Britain?" Her work was used for programmes, posters, mail shots, Facebook, Twitter, and Eventbrite. 
Type Of Art Artwork 
Year Produced 2019 
Impact Support and publicity for a working activist artist. 
URL http://Soofiya.com
 
Title Restoration of Time, Death and Judgment Cartoon 
Description The grant enabled the wholesale restoration of a work of art that was in perilous condition; without treatment, the artwork might never have been restored to public view. The full colour cartoon of G.F. Watts's "Time, Death and Judgment" was created by Cecil Schott (Watts's studio assistant) as a plan for a mosaic that was installed on the side of St Jude's church, Whitechapel, in 1884. The mosaic, designed by the famous Salviati design firm, commemorated the success of the annual Whitechapel art exhibitions, which brought art to the people of the East End. Schott's cartoon, which planned how the painting should be translated into the mosaic, piece by piece, had long been in the Watts Gallery's collection, but was in too damaged a state to move, let alone to display in the gallery. AHRC funding gave the opportunity to hire professional conservators to restore the cartoon so that it could be displayed as a centrepiece of the exhibition. Its condition is now stable, allowing it to be preserved for future generations. 
Type Of Art Artwork 
Year Produced 2020 
Impact As a result of the restoration of the cartoon and its inclusion in the exhibition, it was chosen as the cover image for the 23 January issue of The Tablet, the international Christian magazine, which reviewed the exhibition. The Tablet has a readership of 59k. 
 
Description -New knowledge about the history of activist art has been discovered and presented to a general audience through the digital and in-person components of the "Art and Action" exhibition at Watts Gallery.
-Numerous complimentary events delivered this knowledge to new audiences through an adult education programme, a specialist learning programme, and a Zoom lecture series for the general public.
-Watts Gallery's Curatorial Trainee played a critical role in the research and planning for the exhibition, giving her important training that will allow her to contribute her new skills to other exhibitions in the future.
Exploitation Route -The Curatorial Trainee will be able to use her new skills and knowledge to curate future exhibitions.
-Other museums may use the "Art and Action" exhibition and the digital materials it generated to plan further events/exhibitions about the history of activism, the interaction between Victorian art and politics, and the use of art for political purposes.
Sectors Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections

URL https://www.wattsgallery.org.uk/whats-on/art-and-action/
 
Description The findings from my research have been used as the basis for the public art exhibition "Art and Action: Making Change in Victorian Britain." The exhibition has brought income to Watts Gallery and the local area, and has been the focus of numerous events for the general public, educational groups, and under-served community groups. An ArtUK article I wrote about the exhibition is now part of the German art school curriculum where it is used to teach English language skills and the history of 19th century British art to 12th grade students.
First Year Of Impact 2020
Sector Education,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Cultural,Societal,Economic

 
Description ArtUK article used in German art school curriculum
Geographic Reach Europe 
Policy Influence Type Contribution to new or improved professional practice
URL https://artuk.org/discover/stories/art-for-reform-and-social-change-in-victorian-britain
 
Description Collaboration with Platform London to stage a conference 
Organisation Platform London
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution Collaborated in organising and running the "Who Owns Histories of Art Activism in Britain?" conference. Worked jointly to develop the theme of the conference, recruit speakers, publicise the event, run a panel, and perform post-event evaluation. Consulted on issues of engagement with the academic sector, managed the financial organisation for the event, communicated with delegates, and arranged the venue.
Collaborator Contribution Collaborated in organising and running the "Who Owns Histories of Art Activism in Britain?" Worked jointly to develop the theme of the conference, recruit speakers, run a panel, publicise the event, and perform post-event evaluation. Consulted on issues of engagement with the arts and charity sectors and provided administrative support.
Impact Conference: "Who Owns Histories of Art Activism in Britain?" on 10 September 2019. This was a multi-disciplinary event. Relevant areas included art history, history, politics, policy, activism/social movements, fine art, and curatorship.
Start Year 2019
 
Description Collaboration with Watts Gallery to stage the exhibition Art and Action 
Organisation Watts Gallery - Artist's Village
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution The purpose of this partnership was to curate the exhibition Art and Action: Making Change in Victorian Britain. As lead curator, I devised the theme and narrative of the exhibition, researched potential loans, wrote the interpretation texts, advised on learning and public events, delivered lectures, contributing to the creation of digital content, and wrote a promotional article for the media.
Collaborator Contribution The staff of Watts Gallery contributed to the exhibition Art and Action: Making Change in Victorian Britain by negotiating the loans, planning and supervising the installation, producing digital content, handling the marketing, and organising complimentary learning and public events.
Impact The outcome of this collaboration is the exhibition Art and Action: Making Change in Victorian Britain, which opened in December 2020 and closed in May 2021, as well as its associated 1) digital outputs (a video tour, an audio tour with the app Smartify, and a website), 2) related events (a public lecture programme, an adult education programme, and consultation sessions with educational groups), and 3) artistic products (produced by an artist in residence).
Start Year 2019
 
Description "Who Owns Histories of Art Activism in Britain?" conference 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact This event facilitated dialogue between artists, scholars, activists, curators, and the charity sector to pool insights about which narratives of art activism have shaped thinking and practices. Organised jointly with art charity Platform London, the conference was based on the premise that as art activism becomes ever more visible and in vogue, we must deepen our understanding of its histories. The conference's speakers challenged the framing of art activism and considered practices that have been under-explored or marginalised, that disrupt traditional narratives, or that reach deep into the past. Through our discussions, we debated issues like, "How have the visual arts generated change, as well as reflected it?" and "What is the role of art activism today?" The audience reported that the event provided them a useful opportunity to network with practitioners outside their immediate sector and to debate the issues around which their practices revolved.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL https://www.eventbrite.co.uk/e/who-owns-histories-of-art-activism-in-britain-tickets-68114950651?aff...
 
Description Art and Action Exhibition 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact This art exhibition at Watts Gallery explained how Victorian painting and illustration served political aims. The two-floor exhibition featured around one hundred artworks, historical objects, and printed materials by some of the foremost British artists of the nineteenth century. Audiences reported learning something new about art and its relationship to Victorian politics.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020,2021
 
Description Art and Action History of Art Course 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact This five-week online course was programmed to contexualise themes and ideas raised by the Art & Action exhibition, offering an opportunity for deeper engagement and learning. Lectures included an introduction to Victorian Art and Social Movements, the Arts & Crafts Movement and Social Responsibility and Art of the Suffrage Movement. The course lectures were delivered by different speakers each week, including Dr Chloe Ward and Abbie Latham, co-curators of the exhibition, and Dr Lucy Ella Rose, an academic at the University of Surrey. One participant reported that the course helped them "understand much more about the Suffragettes, their aims and who they were and how brave they were." Another said that "this course was such a welcome opportunity to stay engaged" during the pandemic and that they "learnt the power of art in raising social issues."
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
 
Description Art and Action Postal Packs 
Form Of Engagement Activity A magazine, newsletter or online publication
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact Postal packs with images and activities related to the Art and Action exhibition were delivered to groups without access to the exhibition itself. This included: 50 households supported by the Guildford Park Barn Centre, which provides services and activities for vulnerable people aged 55 and over and their families; 9 people supported by the Woking Women's Support Centre, which offers a safe space for women who have faced difficulties like domestic abuse, substance misuse, and homelessness; 60 residents of HMP YOI Bronzefield, the young offenders prison (accompanied by an introduction to the exhibition broadcast on prison TV); 30 residents of HMP Send, the women's prison. One participant wrote, "This was such a nice thing to get in the post. During a time when we couldn't come to the gallery I loved getting the printed images from the exhibition. I really appreciated how these drawings helped me think hopefully and positively as I imagined the world I would like to live in."
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020,2021
 
Description Art and Action Press Coverage 
Form Of Engagement Activity A press release, press conference or response to a media enquiry/interview
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact The Art and Action exhibition received wide-ranging press coverage by news outlets like The Daily Telegraph, The Tablet (the international Christian magazine), Best of British, and Art Quarterly. The twenty-one known reviews and mentions of the exhibition, most of which were the result of direct press inquiries in response to our press release, reached a total readership of more than 1.6 million people.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020,2021
 
Description Art and Action Public Lecture Series 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Watts Gallery held a series of online evening talks and panel discussions exploring the contemporary relevance of issues and ideas raised in the Art & Action exhibition. These were pitched as suitable for 14+ and attracted a new and broad audience for the gallery, with diverse speakers and audience members joining from across the UK. All the recordings have been uploaded to YouTube and shared with local schools and university partners.

The titles and speakers included:

Art, Action & Queering Spaces:
This talk explored the role of queer activism and creativity and the need to reposition public spaces, exhibitions and opportunities for those from the Queer community.
Chaired by Dan Vo (Project Manager of the Queer Heritage & Collections Network, supported by Art Fund), the speakers included Corinne Cumming (Pride Inside UK), Patrick McCrae (Founder of Queer Frontiers), artist and curator Guillaume Vandame and award-winning artist and campaigner Ashton Attzs.

Art, Action & Design:
This talk examined the potential of collective design in tackling society's biggest challenges, including climate change, wealth inequality, racial justice and loneliness. Led by Nick Stanhope (CEO) and Tayo Medupin (Innovation Director) of Shift, the talk included a Q&A and discussion exploring inclusivity, equity and how design will change the world in the future.

Art, Action & Craft:
Programmed to mark International Women's Day, this talk looked at how craft has been used as an activist tool throughout history to addressing and changing issues of social cohesion, gender equality and political change. It was led by Sarah Corbett, Founder & Director of the Craftivist Collective.

Art, Action & Poverty:
An "in conversation" between world-renowned photographer, Jillian Edelstein, and Abigail Scott, former Deputy Director of Advocacy at the Joseph Rowntree Foundation, this talk discussed the responsibility of artists and philanthropists to work together to highlight the stories and experiences of those living in poverty today.

One participant wrote that the event was "genuinely inspiring and exactly what I need during this time when visiting galleries and events is so difficult."
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020,2021
 
Description Art for All Learning Workshops 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact A series of workshops were designed to share ideas and explore the themes of Art and Action with participants from the Art for All Learning Programme. Participants included members of the charities halow (young people with learning disabilities), User Voice (people struggling with mental illness), the Woking Women's Support Centre (women affected by domestic abuse, homelessness, and other gender specific issues), and Amber (vulnerable and disadvantaged young people). 44 participants were involved 10 live Zoom events. Participants reported "realising how [art] relates to today and today's serious issues," increases in self esteem, the development of a better understanding of art history, and a pleasant distraction from the stresses of everyday life. Some participants reported having been inspired to do their own research into art history as a result of the sessions. One participant wrote, "I don't like art but I like doing this -- artists who were angry and made art to change -- that's for me."
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020,2021
 
Description BBC Radio 4 Interview 
Form Of Engagement Activity A press release, press conference or response to a media enquiry/interview
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Interviewed for the BBC Radio 4 programme "Transcendence: How Can I Feel Art Again?" and was subsequently contacted by colleagues and members of the public who were interested in continuing to discuss the issues I had raised.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/m000qxzx
 
Description Bronze Arts Award Course 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact Over 6 weeks, a group of 13 young people attended weekly Zoom sessions and, working with artist Lynn Weddle, explored the artworks, artists and overarching themes of the Art & Action exhibition. Through discussion, research and a variety of creative activities, they generated responses to questions such as "can art make change?" On completing the course, all participants gained an Arts Award, with 11 receiving Bronze level and two receiving Discover. One parent reported that the activity "really kept [their daughter] going through this lockdown and had a very positive impact on her mental health." One participant wrote, "I have learnt that art is a voice."
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020,2021
 
Description Digital Content for Art and Action 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact The exhibition included multiple digital offerings, which became increasingly important as the pandemic forced the exhibition to close for extended periods. These digital offerings included a video tour, an enhanced website, an audio guide, and entries on the Watts Gallery blog.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020,2021
URL https://www.wattsgallery.org.uk/art-action/
 
Description Family Activities 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact A range of activities were produced for children and families based on the Art and Action exhibition. These included the following. 1) A family trail: aimed at ages 8+, the trail was created to enhance families' engagement with the Art and Action exhibition. The trail included questions and discussion points based on the themes of the exhibition and the final page of the booklet was designed as a blank postcard for families to make a creative response to the exhibition and send to a friend. 2) An Art Club, a series of three workshops developed by artist Annie Mar, in response to the themes of the Art and Action exhibition. The course was delivered through pre-recorded video tutorials and downloadable resource packs filled with art inspiration, activities, and tips to make art with a message. The course explored visual diaries, textiles/tapestry, and zines. 3) Art & Action Make Space: Lily Ash Sakula, the artist leading a collaborative community project, created an Art & Action activity pack for families that explored the question "can art change the future?" though drawing, writing and sculpture activities. Lily ran a live Zoom workshop for families to share their responses to the activity pack and take part in some interactive drawing exercises based on imagining a better future. Families shared their work with Lily to be included in the co-produced animation. A parent of a child that participated in Make Space wrote, "The interactiveness, especially the asking children questions, making them think more about their answers--most art webinars just tell children what to do. This was the first one that made them think."
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020,2021
 
Description Guildford College "Engaging with an Audience through Art and Design" 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact Students students studying Art, Design & Photo Level 3 (UAL qualification, equivalent to A Level) at Guildford College took a module based on the Art and Action exhibition. The module required students to examine the themes of the exhibition, and research and develop creative outcomes to engage with contemporary issues or concerns through art.
Students attended online talks from Watts Gallery staff and researched and responded to the collection, exhibitions, and audience according to themes like health/illness, racial equity, and representation in gallery spaces. As a result of the project, Guildford College have staged further collaborations with Watts Gallery, including a careers day for 450 students the South East colleges network.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020,2021
 
Description Research talk at RHUL 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact C. 50 members of the public and the university community of Royal Holloway attended my research talk at the Royal Holloway University of London Centre for Victorian Studies. The talk was followed by engaged discussion and several members of the audience followed up to request further information or request my participation in their own research events.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019