Rise of the Rentier: France and the Making of Financial Modernity, 1830-1930

Lead Research Organisation: University of Manchester
Department Name: Arts Languages and Cultures

Abstract

The global financial crisis of 2008 and the great recession that ensued have made economic inequality an urgent issue, sparking intense debate over the role of finance in modern life. Rise of the Rentier: France and the Making of Financial Modernity, 1830-1930 will explain how average people starting in the nineteenth century came to view financial investment as an ordinary, mundane activity, one increasingly entwined with their daily lives. This was the period in which capital experienced its first globalization, and the number of investors grew dramatically, incorporating even very small savers as members of a new investor 'class.' This research focuses on France, one of the largest capital-exporting nations of the modern era, but also one that pioneered techniques of the modern mass investor society. Paris was the world's second largest financial market by 1900, and the depth and breadth of France's investing public was exceptional among advanced capitalist countries. Particularly eager to send capital abroad, modest French investors rewrote landscapes and lives from Panama to South Africa, from California to Russia. Their steps into financial markets were supported by state, judicial, and corporate measures that made investment easier and more accessible, but which also helped turn the 'small saver' or 'petit rentier' into a potent political category, able to make demands on their representatives. The nature of France's investing public and the country's republican traditions placed finance at the heart of political contestation, allowing us to study how people simultaneously came to think of themselves as national citizens and members of a global economic order.

Unlike conventional economic histories, which typically appraise financial markets chiefly as elements and indicators of national economic growth, this research approaches mass investment as a political and cultural as much as economic project, arguing that small investors are crucial to how financial systems gain legitimacy and persuasive capacity despite generating destabilizing inequality in democratic polities. It excavates the understandings, aspirations, and activities of ordinary people as they plunged - and were pulled - into finance, opening intimate realms in which individuals imagined and built their (economic) futures. These personal projections refracted through the political arena, helping configure relations between wealth and political power. From the pocketbook of the small investor, then, we can build a history of finance from the bottom up that takes seriously the hopes, anxieties, and traumas that both motored and resulted from financial development.

This perspective demands new sources and voices in our histories of economic life, and the project will incorporate analysis of financial ephemera, like manuals and circulars; traveling securities' salesman; investor letters to state and financial institutions; journalistic accounts of financial scandal; and police surveillance of financial probity. It also requires new research strategies, such as approaching financial behavior through the lens of consumption studies; analyzing the aesthetics of investment instruments and advertising; reconstructing the spaces of financial engagement, from exchange districts to bank lobbies. I will privilege and expand on methodologies that allow us to incorporate lay knowledge and practice into our examination of rarified economic realms. Both the subject matter and methodology of this project thus encourages a more pluralistic and democratic engagement with the economic, within and outside the academy.

Planned Impact

By inquiring into the social and cultural history of finance and the elaboration and understanding of global inequalities, this research addresses pressing social issues and stands to make important contributions to skills development, enhancing the knowledge economy, and enriching quality of life in the UK. It has been designed from the outset with an eye to engaging a set of non-academic beneficiaries, summarized below, and will be managed to expand the scope of these beneficiaries as the research progresses.

Key beneficiaries in the private sector are the Business Archives Council (registered charity) and several corporations whose archivists will participate in a 'day school' that will place these professionals in contact with researchers in the interdisciplinary study of capitalism. Through these collaborations, corporate archivists will be better positioned to shape the development and exploitation of their collections, and the BAC will enjoy expanded opportunities to publicize its mission (especially to new enterprises developing archival collections) and enhance its organizational capacity within the sector.

Third sector and the wider public will enjoy benefits from this research via public events crafted around two themes and modes of engagement. The first involves collaboration with organizations concerned with improving financial literacy and capacity, such as the Citizens' Advice Bureau Manchester. The second will take the form of a public event organized with creative artists addressing the themes of emotions and communities of debt. This project will thus support the work of third sector organizations and creative professionals, delivering new knowledge and perspective for both groups, and extending opportunities for improving the knowledge and skills of the publics they engage.

Professional/practitioner beneficiaries of this research include professional bodies concerned with financial transparency and reporting such as the Financial Reporting Council, the body that regulates auditors, accountants, and actuaries in the UK. This project will extend research currently ongoing on the Accounting Standards Committee (1952-1990) and Auditing Practices Committee (1971-1991) collections at the Special Collections of the University of Manchester. This research will provide opportunities to the FRC to develop public awareness of its work and expand its public consultation program, thus informing developments in professional practice.
 
Description The award I still ongoing and continues to generate original and significant research into the history of mass investment, economic culture in modern France, as well as to develop methodological innovations concerning the history of economic life. To date, the project has developed several original data sets concerning investors in the second half of the nineteenth century, translating manuscript archival material into standardized digital formats in preparation for geographic and narrative analysis. This has given new insight into the demographics of nineteenth century investment, leading - for example - to a publication on the nature and extent of female investment in nineteenth-century France. Continuing analysis of the discursive frameworks of investor writings has clarified the political claims of 'communities of capital' around foreign investment and its claims on the French state in the nineteenth century. A working group on Intimacy and the History of Economic Life has held two paper-development meetings and produced a public-facing output (a podcast with History Workshop Online) on revised approaches to economic history. The PI and postdoctoral researcher have drafted a co-authored article on investment and imperial infrastructure, focusing on small shareholders and the construction of the Suez Canal, bringing a new perspective to this critical multinational enterprise. Successful bids for additional funding will see the PI convene an international workshop on 'Odious Investment' in the coming months, with a policy panel attached. Two final deliverables of the project - a workshop with business archivists and a data visualization project - will be completed in the final months of project funding.
Exploitation Route Our preliminary research into the nature and extent of investor communities will provide models for further and comparative development of similar analyses in other geographic contexts. It is also hoped that forthcoming research on intimacy as a category of analysis in the history of economic life will provide a methodological turn for future researchers in this area.
Sectors Financial Services, and Management Consultancy,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections,Other

URL https://sites.manchester.ac.uk/riseoftherentier/blog/
 
Description Hallsworth Conference Funding
Amount £14,000 (GBP)
Organisation University of Manchester 
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom
Start 07/2023 
End 07/2023
 
Description Interview and consultation with national newspaper 
Form Of Engagement Activity A press release, press conference or response to a media enquiry/interview
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact My insight on the history of the Haitian debt and its investors was solicited by journalist Matt Apuzzo (winner of a Pulitzer Prize) of the New York Times for a long investigative piece into the history of Haitian debt and the role of French financial and political classes in the country's economic development.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
 
Description Podcast for History Workshop Online 
Form Of Engagement Activity A broadcast e.g. TV/radio/film/podcast (other than news/press)
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Six members of a working group associated with the project participated in a discussion about new methodologies in narrating economic histories. This discussion was recorded by the prominent history journal, History Workshop, for its website and disseminated as an episode of its podcast. It has been listened to more than six hundred times in one month.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://www.historyworkshop.org.uk/podcast/intimacy-and-economic-life/
 
Description Presentation for financial professionals 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact I spoke about the history of how ordinary people understood financial markets in the past as part of a scholarly panel on the History of Risk and Innovation hosted by De Nederlandsche Bank (The Netherlands Central Bank) for its employees and stakeholders, 12 March 2021. This was a virtual event, owing to the public health situation, but upwards of 70 professionals attended the day-long event, including approximately 30 at our individual session. There was a lively discussion about the role of history in evaluating popular perceptions of risky economic activity/phenomena.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021