Tools of Knowledge: Modelling the Creative Communities of the Scientific Instrument Trade, 1550-1914
Lead Research Organisation:
National Museums Scotland
Department Name: Science & Technology
Abstract
Scientific knowledge has helped shape the modern world. It has responded to and facilitated global exploration and commerce, the industrial revolution and medical understanding. While popular narratives celebrate famous discoveries and scientists, they usually overlook the makers of the technologies on which they relied. Scientific instruments embodied current knowledge and practice, both enabling and constraining our understanding of the world. It is the stories of these artefacts, and of the men and women involved in the trade that produced them, during three and a half centuries, that the 'Tools of Knowledge' project will recover and share.
'Tools of Knowledge' will assemble a large volume of diverse data to which it will apply cutting-edge methods of digital analysis. The research will be grounded in the existing Scientific Instrument Makers, Observations and Notes (SIMON) dataset, comprising more than 10,000 records on individual instrument makers and firms from Great Britain and Ireland. To this will be added data from existing legacy databases, collections catalogues and new metallurgical research, as well as material newly extracted from historical texts or generated using advanced digital methods. The aggregated data will be remodelled using semantic knowledge representation, to encode expert understanding of the meaning of this data in a machine-readable form and enable linking across datasets. For the first time, information about people, places, practices, institutions, materials and objects will be accessible for study in combination and at scale. Textual and graphical interfaces, designed to allow the construction of complex and nuanced queries, will allow researchers to dynamically form and test new hypotheses about the relationship between different factors in the lives of the instruments themselves, and the development of the trade.
The research enabled by 'Tools of Knowledge' extends across historical periods and spatial scales, to explore how individuals and companies structured their activities, and how urban space and national infrastructure influenced the instrument trade. It is organised around seven Case Studies, tackled by four Co-Is and three researchers. The questions to be investigated stretch back to the manufacture of instruments in the mid-16th century: the sources of raw materials, their trade, and who gained commercial advantage from novel methods of working them. They extend forward through the 18th and 19th centuries to address the geography of the instrument trade (urban, national, global), and the interplay of expertise, company organization, and industrial development. They also encompass how different kinds of instruments - variously used for teaching, experimentation, discovery and regulation - circulated, the impact of their distribution on other industries, and how the trade was perceived by the public at large. A rich panoramic view of a creative and commercial community will emerge, at once broad and detailed, revealing new subjects and compelling stories, and raising public awareness of the complex relationship between the practical, intellectual and commercial activities that underpin the technology of the world we inhabit.
Under the leadership of Prof Liba Taub, Director of the Whipple Museum of the History of Science, this thirty-month project assembles an interdisciplinary team from the Universities of Cambridge (Dr Boris Jardine, Dr Joshua Nall), Sussex (Dr Alex Butterworth) and Kent (Dr Rebekah Higgitt) with extensive expertise in the history of science, museum curation, digital methods and visualisation design. The project is in partnership with the Science Museum, London, and Royal Museums, Greenwich, holder of the core SIMON database. Using 'triplestore' database technology from the Royal Netherlands Academy of Arts and Sciences, 'Tools of Knowledge' will deliver a persuasive example of Linked Data generating transformative research in a tightly defined field.
'Tools of Knowledge' will assemble a large volume of diverse data to which it will apply cutting-edge methods of digital analysis. The research will be grounded in the existing Scientific Instrument Makers, Observations and Notes (SIMON) dataset, comprising more than 10,000 records on individual instrument makers and firms from Great Britain and Ireland. To this will be added data from existing legacy databases, collections catalogues and new metallurgical research, as well as material newly extracted from historical texts or generated using advanced digital methods. The aggregated data will be remodelled using semantic knowledge representation, to encode expert understanding of the meaning of this data in a machine-readable form and enable linking across datasets. For the first time, information about people, places, practices, institutions, materials and objects will be accessible for study in combination and at scale. Textual and graphical interfaces, designed to allow the construction of complex and nuanced queries, will allow researchers to dynamically form and test new hypotheses about the relationship between different factors in the lives of the instruments themselves, and the development of the trade.
The research enabled by 'Tools of Knowledge' extends across historical periods and spatial scales, to explore how individuals and companies structured their activities, and how urban space and national infrastructure influenced the instrument trade. It is organised around seven Case Studies, tackled by four Co-Is and three researchers. The questions to be investigated stretch back to the manufacture of instruments in the mid-16th century: the sources of raw materials, their trade, and who gained commercial advantage from novel methods of working them. They extend forward through the 18th and 19th centuries to address the geography of the instrument trade (urban, national, global), and the interplay of expertise, company organization, and industrial development. They also encompass how different kinds of instruments - variously used for teaching, experimentation, discovery and regulation - circulated, the impact of their distribution on other industries, and how the trade was perceived by the public at large. A rich panoramic view of a creative and commercial community will emerge, at once broad and detailed, revealing new subjects and compelling stories, and raising public awareness of the complex relationship between the practical, intellectual and commercial activities that underpin the technology of the world we inhabit.
Under the leadership of Prof Liba Taub, Director of the Whipple Museum of the History of Science, this thirty-month project assembles an interdisciplinary team from the Universities of Cambridge (Dr Boris Jardine, Dr Joshua Nall), Sussex (Dr Alex Butterworth) and Kent (Dr Rebekah Higgitt) with extensive expertise in the history of science, museum curation, digital methods and visualisation design. The project is in partnership with the Science Museum, London, and Royal Museums, Greenwich, holder of the core SIMON database. Using 'triplestore' database technology from the Royal Netherlands Academy of Arts and Sciences, 'Tools of Knowledge' will deliver a persuasive example of Linked Data generating transformative research in a tightly defined field.
Planned Impact
Tools of Knowledge provides an exemplary analysis of a particularly important trade, namely scientific instruments. The resources created will provide highly accessible information on the history of science in Britain, 1550-1914, specifically as it relates to commerce, industry, teaching, and questions of local, national and international geography.
Research generated by the project naturally dovetails with museum collections, adding substantial human and local interest to a vast number of scientific objects. The main non-academic impact of the project will therefore be among museum visitors and amateur researchers (in local history, genealogy and the history of science and industry). Tools of Knowledge will provide quick information in addition to deep context on thousands of objects on display and in collections around the world. In addition, the information in SEMSIM will benefit museums and collections professionals, allowing accurate object context to be found quickly. In this way, Tools of Knowledge will quickly reach wider audiences via in-gallery interpretation, online catalogues, and in public programmes. The lead role of the Whipple Museum and our partnerships with The Science Museum and National Maritime Museum will provide important amplifiers of impact, as will members of the Advisory Group with institutional links (History of Science Museum, Oxford; National Museum of Scotland; Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam; Boerhaave, Leiden).
Because Tools of Knowledge will provide immediate access to information over such a broad scale, and will give context through its case studies, it will be of use to cultural institutions concerned with the history of science (e.g the BBC; the Royal Society). It will also benefit the ever-increasing number of organizations using social media and podcasts to communicate stories about the nature and history of science. All of these need relatable stories, often linking to specific objects or individuals and going beyond a limited and familiar canon of great scientists and discoveries. The project will offer 'ground level', artisanal and practical perspectives to raise public understanding and awareness of the complex relationship between the craft know-how, intellectual and commercial activities that have helped make the modern world.
Pedagogical impact will be achieved, in part, through collaboration with the 'Cabinet' platform, developed by the University of Oxford for secondary students and undergraduates. One or more curated audiovisual packages (including manipulable 3D object scans) will situate the insights generated by the project within thematic strands.
The most technically innovative aspect of the project is its use of semantically modelled Linked Open Data (LOD), and the potential to use the indexicality and implicit knowledge represented in the data to drive new forms of complex query, and even dynamic simulations. The advantages to be derived from the insights that the project generates will accrue most obviously to those GLAM institutions that hold data about complex cultural objects, with an obligation to make these interesting and meaningful to a wider public. The specific impact here will be in encouragement of the adoption of LOD approaches, demonstrated by the project's exemplary practical outputs and potential to reveal new stories, which the project will pro-actively share with and through such stakeholders.
The generalisable methods of data modelling, visualisation and analysis employed by the project will be of interest to a potentially broad range of other professional fields: from digital tools design, through spatial and urban analysis, and strategic infrastructure planning. The project may also inform initiatives to foster the development of creative communities, by offering historical instances of growth, dispersal and collaboration, viewed through the spatial and network relationships of actors and visualised using explorable graphical interfaces.
Research generated by the project naturally dovetails with museum collections, adding substantial human and local interest to a vast number of scientific objects. The main non-academic impact of the project will therefore be among museum visitors and amateur researchers (in local history, genealogy and the history of science and industry). Tools of Knowledge will provide quick information in addition to deep context on thousands of objects on display and in collections around the world. In addition, the information in SEMSIM will benefit museums and collections professionals, allowing accurate object context to be found quickly. In this way, Tools of Knowledge will quickly reach wider audiences via in-gallery interpretation, online catalogues, and in public programmes. The lead role of the Whipple Museum and our partnerships with The Science Museum and National Maritime Museum will provide important amplifiers of impact, as will members of the Advisory Group with institutional links (History of Science Museum, Oxford; National Museum of Scotland; Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam; Boerhaave, Leiden).
Because Tools of Knowledge will provide immediate access to information over such a broad scale, and will give context through its case studies, it will be of use to cultural institutions concerned with the history of science (e.g the BBC; the Royal Society). It will also benefit the ever-increasing number of organizations using social media and podcasts to communicate stories about the nature and history of science. All of these need relatable stories, often linking to specific objects or individuals and going beyond a limited and familiar canon of great scientists and discoveries. The project will offer 'ground level', artisanal and practical perspectives to raise public understanding and awareness of the complex relationship between the craft know-how, intellectual and commercial activities that have helped make the modern world.
Pedagogical impact will be achieved, in part, through collaboration with the 'Cabinet' platform, developed by the University of Oxford for secondary students and undergraduates. One or more curated audiovisual packages (including manipulable 3D object scans) will situate the insights generated by the project within thematic strands.
The most technically innovative aspect of the project is its use of semantically modelled Linked Open Data (LOD), and the potential to use the indexicality and implicit knowledge represented in the data to drive new forms of complex query, and even dynamic simulations. The advantages to be derived from the insights that the project generates will accrue most obviously to those GLAM institutions that hold data about complex cultural objects, with an obligation to make these interesting and meaningful to a wider public. The specific impact here will be in encouragement of the adoption of LOD approaches, demonstrated by the project's exemplary practical outputs and potential to reveal new stories, which the project will pro-actively share with and through such stakeholders.
The generalisable methods of data modelling, visualisation and analysis employed by the project will be of interest to a potentially broad range of other professional fields: from digital tools design, through spatial and urban analysis, and strategic infrastructure planning. The project may also inform initiatives to foster the development of creative communities, by offering historical instances of growth, dispersal and collaboration, viewed through the spatial and network relationships of actors and visualised using explorable graphical interfaces.