The First World War and its Legacy 2020 and Beyond: Community, Collaboration and Conflict

Lead Research Organisation: University of Birmingham
Department Name: Education

Abstract

The historian Raphael Samuel described history as 'a social form of knowledge; the work in any given instance of a thousand hands' (Samuel 1994). In 2014 the AHRC funded five First World War Engagement Centres to work with community groups to explore the legacies of the First World War. Responsive to community agendas, the Centres offered skills workshops on recording local heritage, and digitization; content specific workshops based on using archive/museum collections or linked to commemorative events; and workshops which explored through a 'temporally inflected lens' issues around silences, representation and memorialisation. The result was that the Engagement Centres created unique community-academic collaborations, generating new knowledge about the First World War and about the value of the past to communities living in the UK today.

However, the nature, context and consequences of the centenary could only be fully appreciated at its conclusion. Similarly, the practices of co-production and multiple partnerships across universities, community and heritage organisations, demonstrated their full potential at a series of the cross-Centre Festivals across the UK in 2019. This proposal responds to both sets of outcomes. The First World War and its Legacy 2020 and Beyond: Community, Collaboration and Conflict aims to sustain the social and cultural impact of the work of 'a thousand hands' of citizen researchers through the co-design and co-production of a series of e-books which will keep in circulation community research as a living resource and in doing so offer a model for future heritage policy around community engagement and national commemoration.

Planned Impact

Who might benefit from this research?

- The four lead community Co-Investigators, who are citizen historians, community activists or heritage makers, and who bring distinctive audiences of participants, practitioners and specialists;
- Community participants who will be active in co-curating the project: adult learners, young people and BME community activists;
- The wider communities that engage with, or support, the project partners and participants, including under-represented or culturally marginalised groups in the UK: BME; young people, particularly those with experience of disadvantage; adult learners; older people and people with dementia;
- The community groups whose First World War (FWW) research is showcased in the books;
- Independent researchers whose First World War (FWW) research is included in the books;
- History communities and audiences interested in the FWW, including community activists and community organisations, citizen historians, members of the public;
- History communities and social groups who may be considering their own heritage research project on the FWW or other topics;
- Professionals interested in the potential of public history and heritage projects, including policy makers, civic society mediators, heritage professionals, cultural practitioners, research funders (e.g. the National Lottery Heritage Fund) and research users;
- Academics and HEIs with a focus on public engagement, research co-production and widening participation.


How might they benefit from this research?

- Community Co-Investigators will share leadership and therefore ownership of the project;
- Community Co-Investigators who have not previously worked together will form new relationships, with potential for future collaboration on other projects;
- Community participants will develop four new producer/user communities; they will have opportunities to gain experience and life skills through heritage in a supportive environment;
- History groups and independent researchers will be recognized for the new knowledge they contributed during the FWW centenary; they will become visible stakeholders in the project;
- Community groups across the UK will have opportunities to realise the extent to which they share specific historical interests with researchers elsewhere and therefore make new connections;
- Independent researchers, who often lack a support network and sounding board for their ideas, will be able to engage with others with similar interests;
- The books will bring under-researched and unfamiliar FWW stories to a wider audience;
- Through a series of summative reviews and guides to future research, the books will sustain the community research legacies of the FWW centenary, minimise the risk of future duplication and loss of expertise, and inspire further enquiry;
- The books aim to capture the learning relationships which enabled the generation of new knowledge about the FWW and its legacies;
- Collective reflective practice will facilitate the development of a model that nurtures community research networks and relationships with HEIs, and meets the expressed needs of community-based researchers.

Publications

10 25 50
publication icon
Andrews M (2021) Women and War

publication icon
Duffett R (2021) Children and Conflict

publication icon
Gauld N (2021) War and its Aftermath

 
Description In all four books (printed and electronic) there is an essay by Grosvenor and Lloyd entitled 'Beyond Commemoration: Community, Collaboration and Legacies of the First World War' which documents in detail the project's history, outputs and outcomes and the broader lessons learned in terms of participatory research involving communities. It also summarises key lessons learned re: public engagement with research:
Collaborative work arounds history and heritage encourages people to explore new stories relevant to their own lives and experiences;
Operating across the UK can bring different stories into focus and enable discussion of contested and uncomfortable pasts;
A sense of place and the local are critical to many community participatory projects;
Partnerships between universities, cultural organisations and community groups initiate challenging conversations and dialogue;
By devolving research funding to a series of multi-institution hubs, it has proved possible to create a structure which facilitates innovation and responsive community engagement.
Exploitation Route The process of production and collaboration documented in the Legacy project is transferable as a model of working for other academy/community heritage projects.
Sectors Education,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections

URL https://www.voicesofwarandpeace.org/2021/12/13/resource-beyond-commemoration-community-collaboration-and-legacies-of-the-first-world-war/
 
Description Details can be found in earlier sections of this report but in essence they relate to issues around how to work effectively with communities and the importance of keeping findings in general circulation.
First Year Of Impact 2019
Sector Education,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Cultural,Societal

 
Description Co-production 
Organisation Age Exchange
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution As the PI I had overview of the 4 Legacy e-books and worked with the five community organisations and five academics over twelve months to produce four e-books: Remaking Histories of the Nation Kevin Myers, Kiran Sahota, Garry Stewart; Children and Conflict Rachel Duffett, Ian Grosvenor, Rob Johnson, Natasha Macnab; Women and War Maggie Andrews, Selena Carty, Sarah Lloyd, Natasha Macnab; and War and its Aftermath Anna Hammerin, Nicola Gauld, Julie Moore, David Savill.
Collaborator Contribution The community partners researched, co-produced and co-designed the 4 e-books and presented their findings at a launch event in December 2021. Collectively the partners brought a unique insights and knowledge into the project.
Impact The open-access Remaking the Nation e-book
Start Year 2020
 
Description Co-production 
Organisation Investing In Children
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution As the PI I had overview of the 4 Legacy e-books and worked with the five community organisations and five academics over twelve months to produce four e-books: Remaking Histories of the Nation Kevin Myers, Kiran Sahota, Garry Stewart; Children and Conflict Rachel Duffett, Ian Grosvenor, Rob Johnson, Natasha Macnab; Women and War Maggie Andrews, Selena Carty, Sarah Lloyd, Natasha Macnab; and War and its Aftermath Anna Hammerin, Nicola Gauld, Julie Moore, David Savill.
Collaborator Contribution The community partners researched, co-produced and co-designed the 4 e-books and presented their findings at a launch event in December 2021. Collectively the partners brought a unique insights and knowledge into the project.
Impact The open-access Remaking the Nation e-book
Start Year 2020
 
Description Co-production 
Organisation Recognize Black Heritage & Culture CIC
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution As the PI I had overview of the 4 Legacy e-books and worked with the five community organisations and five academics over twelve months to produce four e-books: Remaking Histories of the Nation Kevin Myers, Kiran Sahota, Garry Stewart; Children and Conflict Rachel Duffett, Ian Grosvenor, Rob Johnson, Natasha Macnab; Women and War Maggie Andrews, Selena Carty, Sarah Lloyd, Natasha Macnab; and War and its Aftermath Anna Hammerin, Nicola Gauld, Julie Moore, David Savill.
Collaborator Contribution The community partners researched, co-produced and co-designed the 4 e-books and presented their findings at a launch event in December 2021. Collectively the partners brought a unique insights and knowledge into the project.
Impact The open-access Remaking the Nation e-book
Start Year 2020
 
Description Launch event for four First World War Legacy e-books 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact The event brought together community activists and academics who had worked on co-producing and co-designing four open access e-books: Remaking the Nation; Children and Conflict, Women and War; and War and Aftermath and gave them a platform to talk about the project, the problems and benefits of collaborative research, and the future of participatory research in history.. Grosvenor and Lloyd, the leading academics in the project produced a framing essay for the publications which was used to introduce the event and after four presentations there was an open online discussion.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
 
Description Reflective seminar 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact Reflective seminar with postgraduate students at the University of Umea, Sweden which addressed issues around public engagement with research and the tensions faced by academics when are seen by the sector to be too focused on working with communities
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021