FACCE ERA-NET+ Climate Change Adaptability of cropping and Farming systems for Europe (Climate-CAFÉ)

Lead Research Organisation: Scotland's Rural College
Department Name: Research

Abstract

The Climate-CAFE project focuses on increasing the "adaptive capacity" of arable and forage crops to climate change (CC). We will use an interdisciplinary approach to evaluate traditional and more novel regional adaptation and mitigation strategies along a North-South climate gradient in the EU and propose new farming system designs for adaptation to CC. The evaluation includes synergies and trade-offs between strategies using different scales and indicators for IPCC scenarios in 2050 and 2100. Synthesis of existing data from experimentation and expert knowledge (advisors and farmers) will be used to propose adaptation measures for a selection of Adaptation Pilots based on representative regional cropping and farming systems located in consortium countries. These pilots will be defined and used to design and evaluate adaptation strategies based on multicriteria economic and environmental analyses. The proposed adaptation strategies will focus on improved soil and water management via ecological intensification, including new cultivars, novel rotations, alternative tillage options, and the inclusion of legumes and intercrops, to enhance the buffering capacity of the soil-crop system and capitalize on emerging value chains in the bio-economy. The STICS and DAYCENT models will be used to simulate scenarios at the cropping system level (plot scale and rotation
duration). Existing long-term experiments, including FACE and Ecotron specific experiments will be used for analyzing the quality of predictions and where necessarymodels will be improved to accommodate new processes (e.g. introduction of O3 effects in STICS). Over the short / medium term, the STICS soil-crop model will be run on the RECORD modelling and software platform to make multiple simulations for testing the
potential efficiency of proposed CC adaptation measures for maintaining crop production without degrading environmental impacts. In addition, the DAYCENT soil model will be used to evaluate the long-term impact of adaptation measures on soil carbon sequestration and greenhouse gas emissions (CO2, N2O, and CH4). The Modam and Farm-design models will be used to assess the impact of CC adaptation measures on the
farms' economic and environmental performances. In addition, the Farm-design model will be applied to evaluate these outcomes at the supra-farm level, considering the regional constraints of agri-food chain organization and pedoclimatic conditions. The expected results of the Climate-CAFE project are: i) an overview of potential CC adaptation measures in accordance with farm constraints, ii) simulation of adaptation measures and their ranking in terms of efficiency and costs, iii) simulation of the impact of IPCC scenarios 2050 and 2100 in interaction with adaptation measures on European agriculture production, considering a wide range of EU countries representing a North-South climate
gradient in Europe.

Technical Summary

Climate-CAFE will focus on increasing the "adaptive capacity" to climate change (CC) and variability of EU arable and forage crops. We will propose and evaluate a wide range of adapted high-performance strategies for EU areas with different climatic threats to re-design farming systems for adaptation to CC. The evaluation will reveal synergies and trade-offs between adaptation and mitigation at different scales for IPCC scenarios in 2050 and 2100. The project will also includes the assessment of adaptation strategies based on multi-criteria economic and environmental analyses at the farm and supra-farm level by taking into account regional agri-food chain and pedo-climatic constraints.
We aim to design adaptation measures in order to achieve multiple system level benefits, by bringing together farmers, advisors and different scientific disciplines in order to allow mutual learning and to profit from a wide range of knowledge.

Adapted measures will be evaluated at all relevant scales by synthesis the state-of-the-art and using i) soilcrop models at the field and plot scale, and ii) farm models at the regional scale. At the cropping system level, the STICS soil-crop model will be used and implemented on the RECORD modelling and software platform in order to make numerous simulations for testing the potential efficiency of proposed adaptation
measures. In addition, the DAYCENT soil model will be used in order to evaluate ex-ante effects of CC adaptation on long term soil C sequestration and GHG emissions.

The farm and supra-farm level modelling will elucidate trade-offs between key indicators of CC adaptation. With the help of the supra farm approach we will show how cooperative behavior between farmers may contribute to resource efficiency and the resilience of existing production structures.

Planned Impact

Climate CAFE project will impact on the agri-food and land-use sectors, conservation bodies, the water industry and the scientific community.
Research undertaken within this project will allow the development of evidence-based policies and societal benefits at the European and National levels through the promotion of improved understanding of the links between agriculture and our changing environment.
The following societal benefits will be supported:
* Increased resilience of farming systems in the face of CC
* Reduced GHG emissions
* Soil protection and improvement
* More efficient use of nutrients (including manufactured fertilisers and on- and off-farm organic
resources)
* Greater diversity in cropping systems
* Continental and global food security
* Improved water use efficiency and the improvement of ground and surface water quality
* Protection of non-farmed habitats.
The impact of Climate CAFE will depend on credibility of research results, saliency for the stakeholders and legitimacy of intervention of the project in the CC adaptation debate.

Credibility
Climate CAFE will:
* Result in novel understanding of options for adaptation of EU agriculture to CC and consequences of the agricultural impact on mitigation of CC by pulling together a wealth of long-term field experiments and state-of-the-art models.
* Reduce uncertainty in estimation of GHG emissions and C sequestration from cropping systems as a result of improved and enhanced soil crop models.
* Result in a first evaluation of the effectiveness of innovative CC adaptation in terms of production, food security and environmental impacts based on Adaptation Pilots and long-term cropping system trials across a European climate gradient.

Saliency
Climate CAFE will:
* Translate the generic knowledge on bio-technical effectiveness of CC adaptation to locally relevant options by working with stakeholders through effective knowledge exchange pathways including the use of models in scenario evaluation, hence maximizing their capacity to strategically manage climate risk. The direct involvement with the stakeholder community in working with and modifying participatory tools will help land managers/farmers to improve their understanding of published projections of CC. In other words it will help to increase the saliency of CC projections.
* Produce new and salient information for use in National and European policy communities for an efficient CAP greening based on multi-criteria goals (socio-economic, environmental and energy efficiency). Saliency will be ensured by active interaction in the public debate and policy fora through a dedicated work package and through the partners of the consortium which are member of such European and national fora. Information and tools that are built with farm advisors will ensure a salient legacy from the project for advisory services.

Legitimacy
* Through a dedicated work package on communication and dissemination, Climate CAFE will make itself known as a partner in the public debate based on informed knowledge of CC and adaptation options at cropping system and farming system levels. We will make appropriate efforts to interact with policy-makers in the EU and national parliaments through briefings and dialogue.

Adaptation Pilots will ensure local presence of the project and involvement in local strategic CC adaptation debates, thus strengthening the role of scientific results in regulatory and voluntary measures.
 
Description We addressed climate change adaptation measures in arable agriculture in terms of their complexity and time scale. We also collated information on adaptation measures across different European bioclimatic regions. Many adaptation measures were common across Europe but drivers of the adaptation measures differed regionally. For example, cover crops are used in North and West Europe with the aim of reducing nitrate leaching losses while in Southern Europe their role is frequently the prevention of organic matter loss. Similarly, attitudes to water management varied with those in Southern Europe concerned primarily about drought, while farmers in Scotland were more concerned about flood risks. We tested the use of 3 farmer friendly tools for looking at the impact of adaptation measures on aspects of farm performance. The tools chosen are complementary in that ROTOR (http://www.zalf.de/en/forschung_lehre/software_downloads/Pages/default.aspx) evaluates alternative cropping strategies and associated nitrogen balances while Soil Explorer (https://www.nmi-agro.nl/en/tools/soil-explorer-new) assesses the effects of these rotations on the soil carbon balance and nitrogen losses. Finally, AgRECalc (https://www.sruc.ac.uk/info/120175/farming_for_a_better_climate/1333/agricultural_resource_efficiency_calculator_agre_calc) can determine the effects of these changes on greenhouse gas emissions from the farming system. We found that using a combination of these tools allowed an integrated estimate of the results of adaptation scenarios, e.g. by expressing changes related to soil and crop management into overall GHG-emission per hectare. However, differences in the tools do exist with respect to sensitivity and reliability. The stakeholders acknowledged that the tools were useful for understanding the impacts of both familiar and unfamiliar adaptation measures. Regional validation and benchmark values would be useful for all the tools. For these purposes, participation of farmers is needed at early stage of development."

New and novel measurements of soil biological activity were carried out in the SRUC long-term crop rotations trial at Aberdeen. The trial compares legume based rotations with and without grazing sheep. The novel 'Tea Bag Index' (http://www.teatime4science.org/) technique where green and rooibos tea bags are buried in soil was used in 2016 and 2017 under different crops (grass/clover, cereals, beans, potatoes and swedes). The Tea Bag Index (TBI) calculates a stabilization factor, which is the degree to which litter breaks down, and a decomposition factor relating to the rate at which this occurs. The TBI showed clear differences between crops within the rotation and differences between years as well as the implication of climatic differences between growth seasons. Results showed that within the stocked rotation the highest decomposition rates were seen under Swedes (2016) and Oats (2017) and undersown barley (2016) and undersown oats (2017) within the stockless (no sheep) system. Largest stabilisation of labile material estimated by TBI was found between 1st and 2nd year grass/clover in the stocked rotation and in beans (2016) to undersown barley (2017) in the stockless system. The TBI method provides knowledge on the role of crop type and climate in the turnover of labile material. Understanding more about the relationship between crops and soil biological activity will help use to manage agricultural systems more effectively and also help us to protect our soils.
Exploitation Route An understanding of the value of tools for predicting the impact of adaptation measures is useful for farmers and advisors. The project groups we worked with felt that there was a lot of educational value in these tools and they could be used to stimulate discussion amongst groups of farmers or with individuals as to adaptation options. These types of tools are not for direct decision support but can help to guide future direction of agricultural practices. These tools can also be used by students in FE/HE as a way of helping to understand climate change impacts and adaptation measures in relation to arable agriculture.
The TBI method was test over 2 growth seasons within all plots at the Tulloch organic rotation (Aberdeen, Scotland) and it is anticipated that this will continue in future seasons to develop a database of decomposition and stabilisation indicators over the full 6 year rotational period covering all crop types and variable weather. Raw data for decomposition rates (TBI) specific to each crop type, and auxiliary site data available (soil characteristics, grain yield and weather) provides an invaluable data source, which can provide key information on soil health and rotation design for farmers. The simple yet effective method provides an avenue for education for students and farmers in understanding the decomposition of litter and nutrient availability for future crops as well as providing a valuable dataset for modelling future scenarios.
Sectors Agriculture, Food and Drink,Environment,Other

URL https://www6.inra.fr/climate-cafe
 
Description Research results have been shared with agricultural advisors and farmers who will utilise their results in future decision making. They have also been shared with agricultural students who are the farmers and advisors of the future. This has led to much interesting discussion about real and perceived changes in weather patterns and the need to adapt farming practices. Research results from this project contributed to the EU work on 'Development of Plant Proteins in the European Union'. The work was discussed at one of 4 Commission workshops used to inform the strategy development.
First Year Of Impact 2015
Sector Agriculture, Food and Drink
Impact Types Economic,Policy & public services

 
Description 2021 Joint Call ERA-NET Cofund ICT-AGRI-FOOD, FACCE ERA-GAS, SusCrop and SusAn "MI BICYCLE"
Amount € 1,382,000 (EUR)
Funding ID SCF0326 
Organisation Department For Environment, Food And Rural Affairs (DEFRA) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 03/2022 
End 02/2025
 
Description European Commission H2020 Legumes Translated (Translating knowledge for legume-based farming for feed and food systems)
Amount € 215,904,375 (EUR)
Funding ID Grant agreement ID: 817634 
Organisation European Union 
Sector Public
Country European Union (EU)
Start 11/2018 
End 10/2021
 
Description H2020 SFS 02 2016 ReMIX
Amount € 5,000,000 (EUR)
Organisation European Commission 
Sector Public
Country European Union (EU)
Start 04/2017 
End 03/2021
 
Description Horizon 2020; Sustainable Food Security - Resilient and resource-efficient value chains
Amount € 4,999,927 (EUR)
Funding ID 727973-TRUE 
Organisation European Commission 
Sector Public
Country European Union (EU)
Start 04/2017 
End 03/2021
 
Description Improved estimation and mitigation of nitrous oxide emissions and soil carbon storage from crop residues
Amount € 1,876,000 (EUR)
Organisation Department For Environment, Food And Rural Affairs (DEFRA) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 12/2017 
End 11/2020
 
Description Multi-actor and transdisciplinary development of efficient and resilient MIXED farming and agroforestry-systems
Amount € 7,000,000 (EUR)
Funding ID 862357 
Organisation European Commission H2020 
Sector Public
Country Belgium
Start 10/2020 
End 09/2024
 
Description Review and update the UK agriculture MACC to assess the abatement potential for the 5th carbon budget period and to 2050
Amount £50,000 (GBP)
Organisation Committee on Climate Change (CCC) 
Sector Charity/Non Profit
Country United Kingdom
Start 03/2015 
End 06/2015
 
Description South Asian Nitrogen Hub
Amount £18,000,000 (GBP)
Funding ID NE/S009019/1 
Organisation United Kingdom Research and Innovation 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 04/2019 
End 03/2024
 
Description SusCrop Increasing productivity and sustainability of European plant protein production by closing the grain legume yield gap
Amount € 1,800,000 (EUR)
Organisation European Commission 
Sector Public
Country European Union (EU)
Start 04/2019 
End 03/2022
 
Description Blacklands crofting workshop on adaptation to climate change. N Uist, 22-23 Feb 2016 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact Presentation made around experiments on an island croft. Other crofters and local farmers interested in using the techniques discussed on their own farms.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016
 
Description EIP Focus Group Mixed Farming 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Policymakers/politicians
Results and Impact Christine Watson was selected for and is particpating in the EIP Mixed Farming Focus Group - one of the issues is how mixed farming is related to adaptation to climate change and the resilience of mixed farming systems to climate change. This is of direct relevance to the project and will it's development as well as the transfer of knowledge from the porject to this exercise.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2015,2016
URL https://ec.europa.eu/eip/agriculture/en/content/mixed-farming-systems-livestockcash-crops
 
Description Farmer workshop 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Elgin Arable Farmers Group meeting on "Cropping Alternatives to Increase Options, Efficiency and Profit". A presentation was given which included a discussion of how climate change will influence cropping in North East Scotland. This focused on positive options for the future but also discussed how climate will affect soil workability etc
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
 
Description Schools event at Kemnay Academy 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact Kemnay Academy, Aberdeenshire - Learning for Sustainability event. Soils, Crops & the Environment. 22 May 2017. This was an interactive workshop with secondary school pupils. The topic was around how climate change will influence the way in which we manage soils and what crops will be suitable for production in the region in the future.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
 
Description Student workshop 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Undergraduate students
Results and Impact Workshop with 3rd year agriculture students on adaptation to climate change. Students, mostly from farns, were asked to give views on how they coudl adapt their own businesses to cliamte change and what the biggest threats were,
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2009,2016