Epithelial Sheet Dynamics during Primitive Streak Formation as Active Matter

Lead Research Organisation: University of Dundee
Department Name: School of Life Sciences

Abstract

An important goal of the study of development of higher animals including humans is understanding gastrulation. Gastrulation is a critical stage in early embryonic development where the main body plan of the embryo is laid down and the main body axes emerge. It involves large-scale, long-range cell movements during which cells of the three tissue layers, the ectoderm, the mesoderm and endoderm take up their correct positions in the embryo. The endoderm is located innermost in the embryo and adult, lining the digestive tract and associated glands. It is surrounded by the mesoderm that will give rise to the muscles and the skeleton, which is in turn covered by the outmost layer, the ectoderm, which will form the epidermis and the nervous system. Defects in cell movements during gastrulation result in severe cases in death and in less severe cases form the basis of many birth defects.

The cellular processes and chemical signalling underlying gastrulation in higher vertebrates (such as humans) are experimentally studied in so-called model systems, especially chick and mouse embryos. The chick embryo has the advantage that development takes place outside the mother and is therefore easily experimentally accessible. It is also flat and translucent which helps observation of cell movement during gastrulation. Gastrulation in chick embryos greatly resembles gastrulation in humans, which means that findings can be extrapolated to human development. During very early stages development the chick embryo consists of two concentric disks of tissue sitting on top of the yolk; the inner, one cell layer thick, ring will form the embryo proper. Cells in a sickle shaped domain on one side of this epiblast disc will differentiate into the mesoderm and endoderm. During gastrulation this sickle shaped domain of mesendoderm cells deforms into a stripe of tissue extending from one edge of the embryo through the central midline; the structure is known as the primitive streak. The central cells of the primitive streak then move inwards and away from this site of ingression to form the inner mesodermal and endodermal layers of the embryo.
In this project we will study gastrulation in the chick embryo using two complementary approaches. First, we use experiments to follow the mechanical and chemical cell-to-cell signalling in the developing embryo at a cell-level detail. In order to do so we have developed and built a novel type of microscope, a light-sheet fluorescence microscope, that allows us to see almost all the cells in the embryo (50,000-200,000) in a special chick strain in which the cell membranes of all cells are marked with a green fluorescent protein. We study how different cell behaviours such as division, shape changes and motion are coordinated to generate these tissues and which chemical and mechanical cell-cell signalling mechanisms control them. Second, we build a computational model based on active, interacting cells using concepts from the physics of collective motion and use it to understand cell flow both at the local and the full embryo scale.
Our study of the interplay between cell-cell signalling, cell differentiation, proliferation and migration is not only important to the community of researchers whose interest is focused on embryogenesis but will also be of great importance to scientists whose research is centred on processes such as wound healing, tissue repair and regeneration. Furthermore, in order to progress with the proposed research we will develop several new mathematical and computational techniques which are expected to be of great value for further mathematical investigation of other biological and biomedical/engineering problems.

Technical Summary

This study focuses on characterising the signals and cellular mechanisms that drive gastrulation in the chick embryo, closely combining experiments and physical modelling. Using advanced Light Sheet Microscopy imaging we have shown that the large-scale tissue flows that drive streak formation result from complex spatiotemporal patterns of shape changes, ingressions and intercalation of mesendoderm cells. While appearing stochastic at the cell-level, these events result in highly robust behaviour at the tissue level. Our experiments strongly suggest that myosin-dependent mechanical cell interactions play critical roles in the spatial coordination of these behaviours. We will now further characterise these cellular interactions experimentally and use concepts and modelling methods from soft active matter physics to understand emergence of the global behaviour. Specifically we will further develop computational methods to detect and quantify the direction and frequency of cell intercalations during streak formation. Using a combination of laser cutting, local and global mechanical perturbation experiments we will investigate whether these intercalations are tension dependent resulting in elastic propagation. We will address the role of tension-dependent MyosinII cable assembly in elastic propagation and begin addressing the signalling pathways that control it. Characterizing the spatiotemporal patterns and mode of mesendoderm cell ingression will allow us to assess their role in tension generation and address whether secreted factors are involved in the integration of these mechanical processes. These experimental results will feed into soft active matter models at the cell and at the continuum scale, that will allow us to understand how individual disordered cell behaviours lead to highly organised behaviour at the tissue level. Embryo-scale simulation will allow us to explore parameter regions not readily accessible to the experiment and guide experimental design.

Planned Impact

The research proposed here investigates the mechanisms governing gastrulation, a central process in the development of all higher animals. Findings made here will greatly increase our understanding of how cell-cell signalling directs cellular events, like differentiation, proliferation and migration. This is important for understanding development and the origin and cause of many congenital defects. Gastrulation is core material in many Life Sciences and Medical textbooks. Key research findings made here could become textbook material and therefore affect students of the medical and life sciences.
Soft and active matter are recent directions within the physical sciences. They are specifically set up to deal with out of equilibrium, living systems and the patterns they form. As such, the research proposed here forms part of a concerted effort to construct a general theory of living things, in this case the collective properties of cells behaving as a tissue. Development, with its germ layers, patterning and segmentation, and geometrical constraints, is one of the most promising areas for this approach. Research findings from this proposal are expected to find their way into teaching materials for students in the new, interdisciplinary field of biological physics / quantitative biology.
The key processes of gastrulation such as directed collective migration, ingression and EMT are also central to other biological processes using similar cellular mechanisms like wound healing, tissue repair and regeneration. Failure to properly control these is key to the development of autoimmune diseases and metastasis of cancer cells. Therefore findings made here will be directly relevant to these areas. Understanding these developmental processes is also essential for the rational use of embryonic stem cells in regenerative medicine. It is by no means clear how embryonic stem cells migrate to the right positions and organise themselves correctly to repair defects in-situ. Clearly, successful manipulation of stem cells will require understanding of directed cell migration, cell-cell interactions and interactions between behaviour and signalling. Therefore, in the 5-10 year term, the research proposed here will undoubtedly have practical applications in these increasingly important areas of medicine and healthcare, affecting researchers and practitioners in both the academic and the commercial sector.
An important aspect of the proposed research is that it will strengthen links between the Biology and Physics communities. This closer integration will be beneficial to both: Biology will benefit from the depth of modelling experience, and wealth of analytical and numerical techniques developed in the statistical mechanics community, and Physics will benefit from opening up to a new community and gaining impact on a rapidly developing area. A vital aspect here is the development of a productive interdisciplinary culture. Though this is accepted reality, current undergraduate and postgraduate training remains largely monodisciplinary. Important interdisciplinary training will be provided to the PDRAs involved as well as associated PhD and master students. For example, Dr Manli Chuai was trained as a medical doctor but is now also trained in methods of advanced LSFM and large scale data analysis. Hence, an important added benefit of our proposed research will be to develop careers within an interdisciplinary culture.
The Life Sciences sector has an important economic impact in Dundee, contributing around 16% of the city's GDP. A range of activities and organisations in the city connect scientists with the public. In recognition of the economic and social impact of these interactions, the College of Life Sciences won the BBSRC "Excellence with Impact" Award in 2011.
Finally, this research generates exquisite experimental and simulated images. These have been and will be part of exhibitions at the local, national and international level.
 
Title Reconstruction of distinct vertebrate gastrulation modes via modulation of key cell behaviors in the chick embryo 
Description Movie S1. Development of control embryo from stage HH1 to HH3+. The movie shows the development of a control embryo (left panel) and a zoom-in of the formation of the primitive streak (right panel). Inset side 650 µm. The time interval is 3 minutes., Movie S2. Strain rates and deformation grid of control embryo from stage HH1 to HH3+. The movie shows a bright field image (top panel) and strain rate tensor of the same embryo (bottom panel) Isotropic strain rate is colored blue (contraction) to red (expansion) scale bar 500 µm. The time interval is 3 minutes. Movie S3. Development of embryo treated with FGF signaling inhibitor LY287455. The movie shows a bright field image (top panel) and strain rate tensor of the same embryo (bottom panel). Isotropic strain rate is colored blue (contraction) to red (expansion) scale bar 500 µm. The time interval is 3 minutes. Movie S4. Formation of an ectopic circular primitive streak in FGF2 treated embryo. The movie shows the development of an FGF2-treated embryo (left panel) and a zoom-in of the formation of the ectopic circular primitive streak (right panel). Inset side 650 µm. The time interval is 3 minutes. Movie S5. Strain rates and deformation grid of embryo treated with FGF2. The movie shows a bright field image (top panel) and strain rate tensor of the same embryo (bottom panel) Isotropic strain rate colored blue (contraction) to red (expansion) scale bar 500 µm. The time interval is 3 minutes. Movie S6. Migration of mesoderm cells after addition of FGF2. Focusing deeper into the embryo shows that the mesoderm cells ingressing through the circular primitive streak migrate towards the center of the embryo. The time interval is 3 minutes. Movie S7. Formation of large invagination of the central epiblast in embryos treated with CHIR+LDN. The movie shows the development of a CHIR + LDN treated embryo (left panel) and a zoom-in of the formation of the large invagination in the central epiblast (right panel). Inset side 650 µm. The time interval is 3 minutes. Movie S8. Strain rates and deformation grid of embryo treated with CHIR+LDN. The movie shows a bright field image (top panel) and strain rate tensor of the same embryo (bottom panel) Isotropic strain rate colored blue (contraction) to red (expansion) scale bar 500 µm. The time interval is 3 minutes. Movie S9. Formation of an invaginating lip in an embryo treated with Axitinib. The movie shows the development of an Axitinib-treated embryo (left panel) and a zoom-in of the formation of the invaginating lip (right panel). Inset side 650 µm. The time interval is 3 minutes. Movie S10. Strain rates and deformation grid of embryo treated with Axitinib. The movie shows a bright field image (left panel) and strain rate tensor of the same embryo (right panel) Isotropic strain rate colored blue (contraction) to red (expansion) scale bar 500 µm. The time interval is 3 minutes. Movie S11. Comparison of the tip of streak formation in control embryo and embryo treated with 100 nM Axitinib. The time interval is 3 minutes. 
Type Of Art Film/Video/Animation 
Year Produced 2022 
URL https://discovery.dundee.ac.uk/en/datasets/reconstruction-of-distinct-vertebrate-gastrulation-modes-...
 
Description We have developed an active vertex model that will be used to describe large scale tissue morphogenesis. The paper is in submission and can be accessed at
http://biorxiv.org/content/early/2016/12/18/095133 the sofware can be accessed at https://github.com/sknepneklab/SAMoS

We have investigated the role of specific cell behaviours that execute the formation of the primitive streak during gastrulation in the chick embryo. We have characterised the ingression of many cells out with the forming primitive streak and shown that they contribute to tissue flow. Furthermore we have found that the ingressions are linked to cell divisions to reach a size homeostasis of the embryonic area , by linking ingressions to a particular cell cycle phase. We are currently investigating the basis for this link.
In a further set of experiment we have perturbed the cell-cell signalling that control critical behaviours like differentiation and ingression. We have shown that besides primitive streak formation it is possible to recreate different gastrulation modes in the chick embryo, typical for lower vertebrates such as a blastoporal grove typical for reptiles, a germ band ring typical for fish and and a blastopore typical for frogs. These results are written up for publication at present.
Finally we have been part of the development of the calculation of Lagrangian coherent structures, that allow us to characterise tissue flow organising structures such as repellers, separation boundaries between different tissues and attractors, places where tissue accumulates such as the primitive streak. This allows us to draw far reaching conclusion on tissue specific dynamics and ontogeny from the dynamics of flow fields. This work has been published.
Exploitation Route The results of the modeling and associated software will be of interest to other researchers in the fields of the study of development and tissue dynamics as well as researchers in the field of active matter and computational modeling
Sectors Pharmaceuticals and Medical Biotechnology,Other

 
Description this is a grant coupled with theoretical work going on by Dr Silke Henkes Department of physics University of Aberdeen 
Organisation University of Aberdeen
Department Department of Physics
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution The Dundee and Aberdeen groups collaborate on the integration of the experimental results and theoretical modeling. The Dundee group develops new lightsheet microscopy methods and investigates the integration of cell behaviours during gastrulation in the chick embryo. the Dundee group provides experimental data and biological hypotheses to be tested through modeling tissues as active matter. They also provide computational expertise in large scale modeling. The Aberdeen group is involved in developping novel methods for large scale data analysis. Furthermore they work on developping mathematical and computer models to test the various biological hypotheses and
Collaborator Contribution The first collaborative paper is currently under revision for publication in PLOS Computational Biology
Impact papers are in progress
Start Year 2014