High-Throughput Luminescence Assay for Sulfotransferase Activity

Lead Research Organisation: Loughborough University
Department Name: Chemistry

Abstract

Living things develop and grow, adapt to constant changes in their environment and energy sources, reproduce and resist disease. These things they achieve through communication between organisms and between cells within an organism, often by changing the chemical make-up of molecules. A common route is to add or remove a small charged chemical such as phosphate or sulfate, which act as switches, altering the information that is communicated. This dictates the biological outcome, which may be as varied as cell movement, cell death, and successful (or not) infection. The addition of a negative sulfate group is performed by specific enzymes called sulfotransferases, but we lack the technology to easily measure the activity of these enzymes.

Sulfotransferases catalyse the transfer of sulfate to alcohols (-OH) on proteins, large sugars (glycans) and many small molecules, including hormones. There has been focussed research on small selective subsets of these enzymes and on some of their sulfated products. Glycan sulfation in animals plays key roles in development, wound repair and is associated with ageing, neurodegenerative diseases and infection by viruses. Sulfation of proteins on the amino acid tyrosine results in changes in protein-protein interactions related to immune function and virus infectivity. In plants, tyrosine sulfation produces hormones, and can be used by pathogens as part of their infection strategy. Bacterial sulfotransferases can sulfate a wider range of small molecule targets than animals, and some of these enzymes have potential as replacements of currently unsustainable chemical production of personal care and food products.

Efforts to understand the global significance of sulfation and to harness it have faced an unsurmountable obstacle: there is no simple and accessible means to measure the sulfation of a target by a sulfotransferase. The consequence is piecemeal research, which is largely unable to deliver the depth and breadth of fundamental knowledge and advances necessary to harness sulfation for our benefit in animal and plant health, and in product synthesis.

Our proposal aims to develop a simple, cheap and versatile assay technology that will allow all researchers to measure the addition of a sulfate to any biological or indeed man-made molecule by a sulfotransferase. Such assays have proven to be the key to understanding and exploiting related chemical modifications to biological molecules, such as phosphorylation.

Sulfotransferases use a universal sulfate donor, PAPS, which upon transfer of its sulfate group becomes PAP. Measuring PAP provides a direct measure of sulfation. We will develop molecular probes based on a rare earth element, Europium, which emit red light upon bind reversibly to PAP. Measurement of the emitted light is very sensitive and provides a real-time readout of the activity of the sulfotransferase. This will be independent of the molecule the sulfotransferase is attaching the sulfate to. In this way the assay will be fast, real-time and eliminate the need for chemically modified reagents, radioactivity, antibodies and expensive equipment not generally available.

Our proposed molecular probes have enormous potential to make the measurement of sulfotransferase activity routine and reduce the cost and time required to conduct high-throughput screening assays. These probes will provide a vital step towards the rapid, accurate determination of sulfotransferase kinetics and mechanism. This will enable better selection and validation of sulfotransferase inhibitors (drug leads), and of mutant enzymes for industrial use. The new technology will pave the way for understanding biological sulfation and exploiting it in the contexts of health and disease, and of product manufacture.

Technical Summary

Sulfation of proteins, sugars and other substrates is an important regulatory modification, which is directly linked to homeostasis and disease in animals and plants. Moreover, many industrial products are sulfated using non-sustainable chemical routes, which for polymers are poorly controlled. Sulfation is catalysed by sulfotransferases (STs), which utilise the sulfonyl donor PAPS to sulfate a variety of acceptors (polysaccharides, proteins, metabolites and xenobiotics), generating PAP in the process.

STs have been demonstrated to be druggable, yet this aspect of drug discovery is underexplored whereas engineering of STs to optimize activity with industrially relevant substrates is not currently possible. Progress in ST research is limited by the lack of rapid, label-free tools for conducting high throughput screens of ST activity. Existing medium throughput assays rely upon expensive equipment and require fluorescently labelled acceptor substrates. This restricts the acceptors that can be used and hence the range of STs that can be analysed. Due to the lack of a generic assay, sulfation is understudied in living organisms, and requires technological innovation.

This project will develop a generic assay technology for real-time monitoring of ST reactions. Luminescent probes will be synthesised to reversibly bind and discriminate PAP and PAPS, providing a real-time readout of the PAP/PAPS ratio. This novel approach to ST monitoring will overcome significant limitations in existing assays, obviating the need for: (1) chemically labelled acceptors; (2) expensive equipment, radioactivity or antibodies; and (3) isolation or purification steps. We will transform HTS assay development to provide the first cost-effective method for quantifying ST activity, revolutionising the discovery of ST inhibitors and engineered STs, and pave the way for measuring PAP/PAPS intracellularly.

Planned Impact

Success in this project will deliver a generic and accessible technology for the measurement of sulfotransferase (ST) activity. This is analogous to the popular 'Kinase Glo" assays used for the analysis of kinases. The main beneficiaries of the knowledge generated from the pump priming project are:

1. Academic biologists, clinicians and chemists. The major bottleneck in biological sulfation and its enzymology is the inability to quantify sulfotransferase activity without a specialised small synthetic substrate. This generally prevents the correlation of enzyme activity with phenotype. In structural biology, there may be a need to sulfate sugars, proteins or other molecules in a controlled manner to produce molecules with the appropriate modifications. This would be particularly important in the analysis of co-crystals of functional complexes and in enzyme engineering. High throughput assays of STs, where different acceptors can be used with the same enzyme, would facilitate the discovery of tool compounds that inhibit the enzyme.

The assay would be of interest to pharmacologists and clinicians looking to prolong the pharmacokinetics of drugs inactivated by sulfation and so reduce frequency of administration. Other clinicians might need to measure sulfation as biomarkers in a pathological or medical process, whereas medicinal chemists would integrate the assay into screening platforms with synthetic chemistry to produce and identify well-validated probe compounds.

2. Industrial biotechnology. A range of sulfated molecules, particularly alcohols and polysaccharides (e.g., xyloglucans, carrageenans) are widely used in the food and personal care industries. Current synthesis methods are resource-inefficient, not sustainable, particularly 'green' or precise, with post-sulfation tests necessary to determine the commercial viability of batches. Enzymatic sulfation, using designer enzymes with novel specificities produced via high throughput screening of mutants with the acceptor-independent PAP/PAPS assay would contribute towards a green and sustainable production of these consumer molecules.

3. Pharmaceutical industry. The development of selective ligands with the necessary specificity and efficacy is important in developing new resources in response to the challenges of ageing, including inflammation and neuronal stress. STs are druggable, but progress has been hampered by the lack of generic high throughput assays. One goal of this project is for our assay to be adopted by pharmaceutical companies to facilitate identification and validation of new potent ST ligands.

4. Agritech. The discovery of sulfated peptide hormones in plants and of a rice pathogen ST provides new strategies to ensure food security, dependent on ST assays. Further, the proposed probes can be tuned to detecting different anions and adapted readily for applications in environmental monitoring organisations, e.g., detecting harmful phosphates and sulfates (herbicides, pesticides) in watercourses, enabling better management of agricultural resources to reduce these pollutants.

5. Government agencies involved in drug safety and agriculture, working to understand how targeting drugs to subpopulations (personalised medicine) might be more efficacious clinically and ensuring food and water security.

6. The general public. The proposed research will contribute towards personalised medicine, sustainable sulfation of industrial products, improved crop growth and pathogen control, enhanced pharmacokinetics of existing drugs and new drugs, which will positively impact on health and environmental sustainability. More effective treatments of diseases and improved food security are areas that capture public interest and support, enabling us to engage the general public and young audiences, raising awareness of the power of synthetic chemical biology to advance drug discovery, agitech and biotechnology research.
 
Title Back cover art for Chemical Science 
Description Inside front cover art in RSC Chemical Science, promoting the paper 'Sterically Demanding Macrocyclic Eu(III) Complexes for Selective Recognition of Phosphate and Real-time Monitoring of Enzymatically Generated Adenosine Monophosphate'. S. E. Bodman, C. Breen, S. Kirkland, S. Wheeler, E. Robertson, F. Plasser and S. J. Butler*. Chem. Sci., 2022, DOI: 10.1039/d1sc05377a 
Type Of Art Artwork 
Year Produced 2022 
Impact cover art will be released in the next issue of Chemical Science 
 
Title Front Cover Art for RSC Chemical Science 
Description Front Cover Art for RSC Chemical Science. The associated publication is 'Advances in anion binding and sensing using luminescent lanthanide complexes', Chem. Sci., 2021, 12, 2716-2734. 
Type Of Art Artwork 
Year Produced 2021 
Impact Received high interest on social media platforms. The Chemical Science paper was subsequently highlighted in the Special Collection 'Most Popular 2021 Supramolecular Chemistry Articles'. 
URL https://pubs.rsc.org/en/content/articlelanding/2021/sc/d1sc90042k
 
Description In this project we have delivered a simple, cheap and versatile luminescence assay that allows researchers to measure the addition of a sulfate group to any biological or indeed man-made molecule by a sulfotransferase enzyme. Such assays have proven to be the key to understanding and exploiting related chemical modifications to biological molecules, such as phosphorylation.
Sulfotransferases are poorly understood due to the lack of a convenient tool for screening their activity. These enzymes use the anion PAPS as a donor for a broad range of acceptor substrates, including carbohydrates, producing sulfated compounds and PAP as a side product. We have developed a europium(III)-based probe that binds reversibly to both PAPS and PAP, producing a larger luminescence enhancement with the latter anion. We have utilised this greater emission enhancement with PAP to develop the first direct real-time assay of a heparan sulfate sulfotransferase using a multi-well plate format.
Exploitation Route The development of a generic sulfotransferase assay based on the PAP/PAPS ratio will benefit a wide range of scientists investigating biological sulfation across the kingdoms of life. The accessibility of the technology allows all research involving sulfation to measure enzyme activity, regardless of the acceptor substrate and without the need for specialist equipment.

During this project we have developed a partnership with Unilever, who are interested in using our assay to monitor industrial scale sulfation reactions. A range of sulfated molecules, particularly alcohols and polysaccharides, are widely used in the food and personal care industries. Current synthesis methods are resource inefficient, not sustainable, particularly 'green' or precise, with post-sulfation tests necessary to determine the commercial viability of batches. Enzymatic sulfation, using designer enzymes with novel specificities produced via high throughput screening of mutants with the acceptor-independent PAP/PAPS assay would contribute towards a green and sustainable production of these consumer molecules.
Sectors Agriculture, Food and Drink,Chemicals,Environment,Healthcare,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology,Pharmaceuticals and Medical Biotechnology

 
Description Development of a biotechnology platform for enzymatic sulfation of industrial products based on sulfotransferases
Amount £252,430 (GBP)
Funding ID BB/V003372/1 
Organisation Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (BBSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 03/2021 
End 09/2022
 
Description EPSRC DTP Loughborough University
Amount £60,000 (GBP)
Funding ID EP/N509516/1 
Organisation Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 10/2020 
End 03/2024
 
Title Luminescent probes for real-time enzymatic monitoring 
Description During this project we have developed a new class of luminescent europium(III) probes capable of binding and discriminating between nucleoside tri-, di- and monophosphate anions. Probe 1 has the ability to distinguish between ADP and ATP and has been exploited for real-time monitoring of kinase activity in microplate format, offering a potentially powerful tool for high-throughput screening of kinase inhibitors, obviating the need for expensive antibodies or labelled substrates. We have identified key probe design features for tuning phosphoanion binding selectivity, enabling a further two probes to be designed that enable real-time monitoring of sulfotransferases and phosphodiesterases, respectively. 
Type Of Material Technology assay or reagent 
Year Produced 2020 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact A new partnership with Unilever was initiated in the context of monitoring enzymatic sulfation, in collaboration with University of Liverpool. 
 
Description Development of a biotechnology platform with Unilever and University of Liverpool 
Organisation Unilever
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution The collaboration involves Loughborough University, Unilever and University of Liverpool and involves the development of a biotechnology platform for enzymatic sulfation of industrial products based on polysaccharide sulfotransferases. Together with Unilever, we aim to develop enzymatic methods to achieve sulfation, offering better control of the process and the products generated, as well as, crucially, enabling environmentally responsible production of biodegradable materials and waste products. My research team have developed
Collaborator Contribution Unilever scientists are working alongside Liverpool and Loughborough University researchers to access state of the art equipment for materials characterisation and formulation. As a team, we are assembling a generic enzyme-engineering HT platform, suitable for application to a wide range of enzyme-driven processes to illustrate the use of the platform by using STs to modify polysaccharides and glycolipids, which are one example of high value renewable materials.
Impact Publication: Anion binding to a cationic europium(III) probe enables the first real-time assay of heparan sulfotransferase activity. S. Wheeler, C. Breen, Y. Li, S. H. Hewitt, E. Robertson, E. A. Yates, I. L. Barsukov, D. G. Fernig and S. J. Butler. Org. Biomol. Chem., 2022, 20, 596-605. DOI: 10.1039/D1OB02071D - Featured in the Special Collection 'The Supramolecular Chemistry of Anions'
Start Year 2020