Harnessing knowledge of lifespan biological, health, environmental and psychosocial mechanisms of cognitive frailty for integrated interventions

Lead Research Organisation: Lancaster University
Department Name: Division of Health Research

Abstract

The primary aim of the Cognitive Frailty Interdisciplinary Network (CFIN) is to promote collaborative, multidisciplinary research that moves along the pathway from basic laboratory studies through to having a real impact on lives. The focus is on research that addresses the challenge of alleviating the development of age-related cognitive frailty and related reduced healthspan (years, or proportion of one's life spent in good health), and poor quality of life. Cognitive frailty is defined as a variable condition characterised by simultaneous presence of physical frailty and age-related cognitive impairment, but the exclusion of existing dementia.

The issue of age-related cognitive frailty is a major societal challenge in terms of its increasing impact on quality of life in our ageing populations, but it is also a challenge in terms of bringing together research from diverse fields. Currently, much research on ageing takes place within disciplines. We are thus beginning to learn much about the biological mechanisms of the ageing process, the psychological and neurophysiological processes of cognitive ageing and the external environmental, social or personal health behaviour factors that impact on the development of frailty or cognitive decline in humans. Despite this wealth of knowledge already available on cognitive ageing, there has been little discourse and knowledge exchange between disciplines such that there has been little progress in recent years in finding multi-dimensional interventions to prevent, rehabilitate, or reduce progress in cognitive frailty in later life. This network aims to bridge the gaps between basic, clinical and social science research to foster the translation of the scientific understanding of ageing.

The objectives are focused on building and operationalising an important network in this area across disciplines including Biology, neuroscience, psychology, epidemiology, social science and citizen engagement, with an array of linked network support organisations including the NHSA and the National Innovation Centre for Ageing. With links to the NIHR NWC ARC, the use of a health inequalities assessment tool (the HIAT) will be incorporated into all research and activity outcomes of this network, to ensure that everything we do attempts to address, rather than make inequalities worse. The network is ideally constructed to deliver impact, with a significant international External Advisory Group (EAG) in place, an experienced PI/Co-I team, and an initial group of expert members across leading institutions. In addition to building the network Nationally and Internationally, via our own discipline networks, multidisciplinary research centres, learned societies, and via the network conference to be held early on, outcomes include production of a consensus paper on multi-factor pathways for intervention, an evidence synthesis of the interaction between biological mechanisms and external predictors of cognitive frailty, a series of mini-project development studies, and from these, a series of larger multidisciplinary outcome research proposals. Capacity development, particularly the development of Early Career Researchers (ECRs) will be a focus, with a mentorship programme whereby cross-disciplinary mentoring partnerships are set-up. We will also invite Co-Is and members to submit ideas for an ECR mini-conference/summer school. Involvement of older adults and other stakeholders such as carers is a crucial part of this network, which will be supported by the inclusion of a Co-I from VOICE, a well-established organisation that harnesses the mental capital, insights, and ideas of the public. They will be able to strengthen the reach and diversity of meaningful public engagement and participation in the mini collaborative projects and across the network. VOICE will strengthen links to and collaboration between citizens and a range of voluntary and community organisations (including charities).

Technical Summary

The Cognitive Frailty Interdisciplinary Network (CFIN) will promote multidisciplinary research tackling development of age-related cognitive frailty and associated reduced healthspan and quality of life. This is both a major societal challenge in our ageing populations and a research challenge to integrate findings from multiple fields into effective prevention and therapeutic interventions across the life course that are implementable in real contexts. The primary goal of this proposal is thus network building across disciplines (including biology, neuroscience, psychology, epidemiology, social science and citizen engagement) and groups (researchers, clinicians, learned societies, business, clinicians, support organisations, older adults and carers) to foster transformative collaborative research for the purpose of better understanding and alleviation of the burdens of cognitive frailty. Network creation will be achieved by forming an external advisory group (EAG) and convening meetings, building membership through existing networks of investigators and members, and by use of social media and judicious linking of a network website. The CFIN will be fully activated at a networking conference at 6 months. Specific outcomes in addition to the EAG and researcher network will be the production of a cross disciplinary evidence synthesis of biological mechanisms and exogenous factors as related to cognitive frailty, identifying gaps, to inform creation of interdisciplinary collaborations with specific goals. Specific small projects will be funded, forming the basis of further Network-based funding proposals to external funders. There will also be a consensus document produced using a two stage Delphi process bringing together membership expertise on the most evidentially supported multi-dimensional interventions for cognitive frailty. Both papers will be submitted for publication. A Mentorship programme and summer school for ECRs will also be supported.
 
Description The challenge area of this Interdisciplinary network is Cognitive Frailty, which is defined as co-existing physical frailty and cognitive impairment with no dementia. There is a large literature on risk factors and potential predictors of cognitive frailty and it is clear that the risk factors for this are not always the same as those for frailty alone, or cognitive impairment alone. Importantly, mechanisms for cognitive frailty are not necessarily the same as mechanisms for Alzhemiers Dementia (that is, CF is not just early Alzheimers in older people who may also be living with physical functional impairments).
To address this challenge, our aims as a network are:
? To gain an integrated understanding of cognitive frailty and implementation of multidimensional interventions.
? To develop understanding of how cognitive impairments precipitates occurrence of multi-system physiological changes, or vice versa, and how we could intervene immediately after the first signs of cognitive or functional changes to prevent or delay associated cognitive frailty.
? to work across the basic to translational spectrum, in order to respond to the challenges of ageing, focused on cognitive frailty
We are asking:
? how do health, educational and environmental inequalities impact these processes?
? What are key transition points or drivers?
? Are there key mediators in relationships (e.g. stress, health behaviour, environmental conditions, nutrition), and can we effectively target them

A large part of our activities to address this challenge is the multidisciplinary scoping of mechanisms of cognitive frailty, aiming to go further than any previous work by including the full range of potential mechanisms that include everything from social determinants of health to basic biological mechanisms. We are conducting three literature reviews, which will also act as gap analyses for research plans. These are: (i) A multidisciplinary scoping review of research focusing on understanding biological mechanisms and exogenous factors as related to cognitive frailty. (ii) Impacts of social engagement and activity on CF (ii) Pollution and access to green space in mechanisms for cognitive frailty. All three reviews focus on the links between inequalities, physiological mechanisms (for example via vascular disease risk or via impacts of mental health disorders) and cognitive and functional decline. Examples of inequality related factors we have identified as having an impact on underlying biological mechanisms such as inflammation, gut microbiota or oxidative stress, and also on risk of cognitive decline, include the environments where people live (pollution, access to green space, accessibility and age friendliness of environments), levels of education and access to cognitive stimulating occupations, association of poverty to poor nutrition, modifiable health behaviour and to stress, anxiety and depression. Importantly, this synthesis of work has led to identification of specific mediators and moderators in the link between physical frailty and cognitive decline which has led to further funding applications to develop both statistical models with human data, and model organism methods to enable further research and link to potential interventions.

An important outcome of the network activities is the significant multidisciplinary and multi-sector network built. As at March 2023, there were 139 members including 17 international partners, 35 early career researchers, and 9 Business/NGO partners, with members covering biological, social and clinical sciences
Exploitation Route The primary outcome of a developed and active interdisciplinary network in this area of research, which now consists of over 139 members in the UK and internationally, is a resource that will continue to have an important impact on research, dissemination and use of the findings of the work and of subsequent planned research and is already acting as an impetus in this challenge area, an example being pump priming work funded by the network within members (see collaborations section), and recent members' applications for further development research funding.
The key point of this network area is that cognitive frailty may be potentially more modifiable than neurodegenerative conditions such as dementia, but may eventually, if not intervened with, lead to dementia, loss of independence and significant health and care needs. Our interdisciplinary scoping reviews (in progress) are identifying key modifiable predictors, mechanisms and mediators that we intend in future funding will be developed into frailty tools (e.g. combinations of assessments to produce a cognitive frailty profile) and animal models of behavioural assays that can then be used in further research by the research and clinical communities.
Our ongoing work in the network to produce a consensus on interventions that may have an impact specifically on cognitive frailty (our Delphi study) will also provide a unique set of recommendations for potential interventions, with participants including research and clinical experts across the disciplines, but also including older adults who are experiencing cognitive frailty or have cared for people who have. The outcomes of the Delphi study may be useful for groups developing interventions.
Sectors Communities and Social Services/Policy,Environment,Healthcare,Leisure Activities, including Sports, Recreation and Tourism

URL https://www.ukanet.org.uk/cfin/
 
Description The cognitive frailty network has so far begun to bring together researchers from a range of disciplines with the impact that: - the research area and the important pattern of co-occurrence of physical frailty with cognitive impairment outside of dementia is beginning to be better understood and differentiated from neurodegenerative conditions within both the academic and clinical network members. - disparate research areas with relevant input to the topic have been brought together and are beginning to be consolidated -mutual development of ability to work across disciplines, e.g. development of terminology understanding or the chance to work with real world end-users of research (frailer older adults and carers) has been described as transformative by researchers involved. The knowledge exchange between those who have expertise in frailty and cognitive decline in humans (academic and non-academic) with equivalent concepts in model organisms has been particularly striking, as has the knowledge exchange between expertise in psychological impacts on aspects of physical health and those with expertise in underlying biological ageing mechanisms.
First Year Of Impact 2022
 
Description Development of collaboration with Ageing Group at Sunway University; QR travel & Collaboration funding
Amount £22,500 (GBP)
Funding ID UTB1003XS05 
Organisation Lancaster University 
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom
Start 02/2023 
End 03/2023
 
Description NIHR Applied Research Collaborations Dementia Capacity Building (Post-doctoral training programme)
Amount £317,546 (GBP)
Funding ID NIHR200182 
Organisation National Institute for Health Research 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 01/2023 
End 12/2025
 
Description A pilot study to explore the neurovascular status of older individuals with a preclinical gait speed decline 
Organisation University of Edinburgh
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Components of this pump priming research will be led by a CFIN Co-I and a network member at Aston University. Contributions at Aston will be to set-up the brain MRI sequences to assess the brain vascular condition in collaboration between Aston University and Edinburgh, and to implement/test the experimental paradigms (Aston); obtain information on sociodemographic and health of a group of older participants: to contribute, with partners to: characterising physical, sensory and neuropsychological condition and frailty status; measuring brain and retina blood flow and perfusion and determine the presence of structural abnormalities using brain MRI sequences, TCD, and OCTA; to assess the level of serum inflammatory markers in relation to the neurovascular status (Aston CFIN Co-I); determine the association between the degree of vascular ageing and the brain dynamics derived from the EEG signal (Aston CFIN member). Aston University will organise PPI activity
Collaborator Contribution The Edinburgh University collaborator will work with the CFIN member at Aston University to: set-up the brain MRI sequences to assess the brain vascular condition; give training to the Aston members in transcranial doppler ultrasound (TCD); lead on measurements of brain and retina blood flow and perfusion and determine the presence of structural abnormalities using brain MRI sequences, TCD, and OCTA The University of Huddersfield collaborator will contribute the opthalmic scanning The Sheffield Hallam University collaborator will support cognitive testing.
Impact No outcomes as yet
Start Year 2022
 
Description A pilot study to explore the neurovascular status of older individuals with a preclinical gait speed decline 
Organisation University of Huddersfield
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Components of this pump priming research will be led by a CFIN Co-I and a network member at Aston University. Contributions at Aston will be to set-up the brain MRI sequences to assess the brain vascular condition in collaboration between Aston University and Edinburgh, and to implement/test the experimental paradigms (Aston); obtain information on sociodemographic and health of a group of older participants: to contribute, with partners to: characterising physical, sensory and neuropsychological condition and frailty status; measuring brain and retina blood flow and perfusion and determine the presence of structural abnormalities using brain MRI sequences, TCD, and OCTA; to assess the level of serum inflammatory markers in relation to the neurovascular status (Aston CFIN Co-I); determine the association between the degree of vascular ageing and the brain dynamics derived from the EEG signal (Aston CFIN member). Aston University will organise PPI activity
Collaborator Contribution The Edinburgh University collaborator will work with the CFIN member at Aston University to: set-up the brain MRI sequences to assess the brain vascular condition; give training to the Aston members in transcranial doppler ultrasound (TCD); lead on measurements of brain and retina blood flow and perfusion and determine the presence of structural abnormalities using brain MRI sequences, TCD, and OCTA The University of Huddersfield collaborator will contribute the opthalmic scanning The Sheffield Hallam University collaborator will support cognitive testing.
Impact No outcomes as yet
Start Year 2022
 
Description Associations of lipophilic micronutrients with oxidised lipids in persons with mild cognitive impairment 
Organisation University Hospital Cologne International
Country Germany 
Sector Hospitals 
PI Contribution This pump priming project is led by the CFIN co-investigator based at Aston University, who will contribute their biosciences and mathematics expertise, in addition to providing the highly skilled technician with the required expertise for the analyses
Collaborator Contribution The study will use banked plasma samples from persons with mild cognitive impairment n=100) aged 65 years and older, free from major organ failure and not taking antioxidant supplements collected as part of CogLife study (University Hospital of Cologne, Cologne, Germany). The ethical approval was granted by the University Hospital of Cologne, Germany (Deutsches Register Klinischer Studien (DRKS) under DRKS00015036), where persons were evaluated for cognitive outcomes. Participants were asked to self-complete a qualitative food-frequency questionnaire modified to assess intake of fruits and vegetables, in order to identify those individuals consuming a diet rich in fruits and vegetables (high intake) and those consuming a diet poor in fruits and vegetables (low intake).
Impact no outcomes yet Disciplines: Biosciences, Mathematics, Neuroscience
Start Year 2022
 
Description Cognitive frailty: A conceptual overview and risk factors 
Organisation Heriot-Watt University
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution to contribute expertise in qualitative methods, gerontology, and support the dissemination of the planned survey. To support the outcome public event.
Collaborator Contribution To contribute primary care expertise and support access to patients
Impact No outcomes yet Disciplines: Cognitive Epidemiology, Psychiatry, Neuroscience, Dementia, Public Health, Psychology, Primary Care
Start Year 2022
 
Description Cognitive frailty: A conceptual overview and risk factors 
Organisation University of Sussex
Department Brighton and Sussex Medical School
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution to contribute expertise in qualitative methods, gerontology, and support the dissemination of the planned survey. To support the outcome public event.
Collaborator Contribution To contribute primary care expertise and support access to patients
Impact No outcomes yet Disciplines: Cognitive Epidemiology, Psychiatry, Neuroscience, Dementia, Public Health, Psychology, Primary Care
Start Year 2022
 
Description Distinguishing cognitive frailty from early dementia: the differential role of potential predictors. 
Organisation University of Sussex
Department Brighton and Sussex Medical School
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution we will be adding expertise in Psychology, data science, health economics and health inequalities to planned secondary data analysis
Collaborator Contribution They will be adding expertise in epidemiology, neuroscience and specific data resources.
Impact No outputs as yet disciplines included are Psychology, data science, health economics, health inequalities, epidemiology, neuroscience
Start Year 2022
 
Description External Advisory Group 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Our external advisory group (20 members) attend a meeting up to 3 times per year where they are informed on the network aims, they offer input on the progress of the network activities, offer involvement in specific network activities (including interdisciplinary/intersectoral mentoring of researchers, supporting recruitment of experts by experience or greater diversity for the Delphi panel) and offer their point of view from their own background.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022,2023
URL https://www.ukanet.org.uk/cfin/
 
Description Network development conference 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Cognitive Frailty Interdisciplinary Network Development Conference was held on 15-16 September 2022: Online conference, 68 delegates from 5 countries and 32 institutions and including some lay members from our External Advisory Group.
Conference included presentations on the two scoping reviews, paper presentations and the following network development activities:
• What does interdisciplinary work mean, and are we doing it? (presentation and discussion from experts)
• Presentation on Interdisciplinary/cross sector Mentoring, followed by a matchmaking session
• Delphi study: A consensus study on interventions for cognitive frailty - stage 1 (2nd stage ongoing at the moment, including lay members, professional practitioners, 3rd sector as well as academic and clinical researchers)
• Consortia development
An important success of both the conference and the CFIN network activities generally is the increased focus and understanding of cognitive frailty already achieved. This is important as cognitive frailty has important modifiable elements but lack of intervention could result in significant negative outcomes.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://www.ukanet.org.uk/cfin/2022/09/20/cognitive-frailty-interdisciplinary-network-development-co...