Cracking of drying films

Lead Research Organisation: University of Cambridge
Department Name: Materials Science & Metallurgy

Abstract

This aim of this proposal is to study an unsolved but incredibly common, conceptually pleasing and industrially relevant problem: Why colloidal films crack when they dry. There is clear experimental evidence that associates the capillary pressure with the tendency of a film to crack during drying and shows that the observed cracking patterns are those expected for a film in tension. This has led to ideas which predict cracks that grow into material where it was either still fluid or where the pores have begun to empty of fluid. Neither is observed. Instead the cracks grow in a liquid-filled particle array with some mechanical strength and on which the capillary pressure should impose a compressive stress.Using alumina suspensions we have recently shown that there was a shrinkage of the liquid-filled particle array and that this shrinkage was associated with the onset of cracking. Using existing fluid flow analyses and the position of the growing cracks we have predicted the pressure required for this shrinkage to be of the order of the capillary pressure, much larger than other colloidal forces.Because the shrinkage is so clearly associated with cracking in these alumina suspensions, we wish to understand the processes that lead to the shrinkage, and learn to control it. To achieve this understanding, we will study how the shrinkage events vary in different systems; the nature of the liquid-filled particle array; how the array changes as it shrinks, presumably under stress and, having established the underlying mechanisms occurring, to analyse the cracking quantitatively. There has recently been a considerable scientific activity in both drying, cracking and the nature of very short range forces in colloids, driven primarily from the coatings industries and the two investigators have been fortunate to be involved in the dissemination process. As discussed below the stress profile in the drying film is becoming clear and the experiments necessary to elucidate the physics of film cracking are now possible. It is the aim of this work to develop our new ideas in this area, taking advantage of the colloid expertise of AFR and the fracture expertise of WJC.

Publications

10 25 50
publication icon
Goehring L (2011) Wavy cracks in drying colloidal films in Soft Matter

publication icon
Goehring L (2010) Solidification and ordering during directional drying of a colloidal dispersion. in Langmuir : the ACS journal of surfaces and colloids

publication icon
Goehring L (2013) Plasticity and fracture in drying colloidal films. in Physical review letters

 
Description This aim of this work was to study an unsolved but incredibly common and industrially relevant problem: Why colloidal films crack when they dry. There is clear experimental evidence that associates the capillary pressure with the tendency of a film to crack during drying and various sophisticated analyses exist. However there was no direct confirmation either of the stress-states predicted by these sums, neither is it clear whether the capillary force acts directly to drive cracking or. whether cracking is driven by some other process, such as the sudden shrinkage, which is known to occur.

To see if cracking was caused directly by capillary forces, initial experiments were carried out by rewetting a network of alumina particles that were in touching contact. Such networks were made by plastic mixing and burning out the polymer allowing sheets to be made without cracking of much greater thickness than is possible by colloidal techniques. No cracking was ever observed even in notched samples. However subsequent experiments showed that on drying, in the case of alumina at least, the particles never came into touching contact without heating. An alternative approach to try and distinguish between the direct action of capillary forces and some shrinkage was to study why wavy cracks, that had been observed formed. As the theoretical stress profiles in a drying body had been confirmed, it was possible to determine the stress field that might cause a shrinkage and the crack driving force that might result from such a stress profile. It was found that the wavy cracks followed the path of maximum crack driving force, or energy release rate. Apart from giving an explanation of the wavy crack phenomenon itself for the first time, it provides compelling evidence that cracking in drying is driven by the direct action of capillary forces. Furthermore it was also shown that cracking was not a purely brittle process but irreversible processes, such as deformation of the drying colloid, increased the energy required to cause cracking.
Exploitation Route The most important finding was that only 9/10th of the energy required for cracking was used to drive irreversible flow. This gives a potential approach to preventing cracking during drying.
Sectors Agriculture, Food and Drink,Chemicals,Electronics,Pharmaceuticals and Medical Biotechnology

 
Description European Union Framework 7 (MULTILAYER)
Amount £192,684 (GBP)
Funding ID 214122-2 
Organisation Sixth Framework Programme (FP6) 
Sector Public
Country European Union (EU)
Start 10/2008 
End 09/2012