Coherent Control and Manipulation of Natural and Un-Natural Parity Contributions to Electron Impact Ionization from Laser-Excited Atoms.

Lead Research Organisation: University of Manchester
Department Name: Physics and Astronomy

Abstract

Plasmas are ubiquitous in nature, with more than 99% of the universe being in this fourth state of matter. Plasmas can consist of a mixture of ions, electrons and neutral atoms or molecules, depending upon their temperature. At very high temperatures (e.g. at the centre of the sun) all atoms are ionized, so only ions and electrons are present in these regions. At lower temperatures (such as at the surface of the sun and in the stellar atmosphere, in fluorescent and neon lights, in interstellar space, in ion lasers or in the earths ionosphere) a plasma consists of a mixture of charged and neutral particles. The neutral particles are atoms or molecules that are either in their ground state, or they may be in an excited state. Electrons and ions in the plasma can then collide with these neutral particles, leading to an exchange of energy resulting in further ionization or excitation. The most common collisions are with electrons, since they move most easily within the plasma. The interactions are complex in nature, and lead to many of the features observed from a plasma, such as the production of light in neon tubes and fluorescent lights, in lightning and in auroras.

Physicists need to understand the dynamics of these collisions to allow them to accurately describe the plasma. This is important in a wide range of areas, from optimising the energy of plasmas used in science and industry, through to understanding and predicting the solar wind that affects our climate. It is hence important to provide accurate models of the collisions that can occur.

In the research proposed here we will experimentally and theoretically study ionizing collisions with excited atoms for the first time. This will be a combined international effort, with experiments being conducted in Manchester, and theory being developed in the USA. Understanding collisions with excited atoms is important, as the collision probability is usually greater than for ground-state atoms. This is because their cross-section (which effectively defines their 'area') is often much larger than when they are in the ground state. This occurs since the excited electron is in a higher orbital, and so is effectively at a larger distance from the nucleus. Even if the density of excited atoms in the plasma is lower than for ground-state targets, they may hence be of equal or greater importance when describing the dynamics.

Little is known about collisions with excited targets, since it is very difficult to produce a high density of excited atoms in the laboratory. This has recently changed, since we now have tuneable lasers that can create excited atoms in sufficient quantities to carry out the experiments. The University of Manchester has invested in a suite of lasers that allow these difficult experiments to be performed. To accumulate data of sufficient accuracy the laser wavelength has to be controlled to better than 1 part in 1 billion for long periods of time, which is extremely challenging. We have demonstrated that this is possible in a set of pioneering experiments, and as part of this new work we will build control systems to allow this precision and stability to be achieved for periods of up to several weeks.

A significant advantage of exciting atoms using lasers is that we can 'shape' them prior to the collision occurring. We have discovered that this allows us to probe the collision in a unique way, so that different contributions to quantum models of the interaction can be rigorously tested. In particular, we found that so-called 'un-natural parity' terms are very important, as they can contribute up to 50% of the cross-section. These terms are not included in current plasma models, so we believe they are badly underestimating the effect of excited atoms within the plasma. The experiments proposed here provide a unique way to study these terms, and they will allow new and precise models to be developed as part of this international collaboration.

Planned Impact

Efficient non-polluting energy generation is a goal that fusion reactors may deliver in the future, and so a large international effort is underway to understand and control these reactions. The UK is one of the main collaborators in this research, and is investing significant funding to achieve these goals. Controlled fusion usually occurs in a Tokamak, which is a large vacuum chamber that uses magnetic fields to confine a plasma that is heated to very high temperatures. If the plasma density and stability can be controlled so that the reaction is self-sustaining (i.e. more energy is released than is needed to maintain the reaction) then a net energy gain becomes possible. Instabilities and losses from the plasma must be minimized to achieve these goals. These occur through turbulence and through contamination of the plasma by atoms ejected from the vacuum walls. Subsequent collisions with these ejected atoms leads to further instabilities and further losses, and so it is important to understand these processes so that their effects can be minimized.

The research proposed here will study collisions from excited atoms, which may be created in the plasma through photon absorption or through ion or electron collisions. The ionization cross-sections from excited targets are usually much larger than for those in the ground state, and so collisions with excited atoms can lead to significant losses. The work proposed here will provide new data on these interactions, and will develop new models of the collision process. The results from these calculations can then be fed into kinetic models of the plasma to understand, control and minimize the effects of these collisions. This research will hence deliver benefits to the UK economy, by providing information that will allow more efficient energy generation from the fusion reactors of the future.

The combined experimental and theoretical research programme proposed here is an international effort that will deliver the first comprehensive measurements of excited atom ionization by electron impact. A series of experiments will be carried out using the unique facilities at the University of Manchester, so that new interaction models are fully tested. Results from the models will then impact on future areas of science and industry, ranging from fusion energy generation as described above, to optimizing the ionization cross-sections in ion lasers and lighting.

The results will also have impact in astrophysics, since they will be used in solar and planetary atmospheric models to better understand their dynamics. Dense stellar atmospheres have recently been predicted to contain a majority of excited atoms, and so accurate quantum calculations of collisions in these atmospheres are essential to predict the behavior of the sun and of other stars.

The current theories of excited-target collisions that are presently used in these areas have never been tested, due to an absence of experimental data. Recent work in Manchester and at the Los Alamos Laboratory in the USA has shown that these models do not include essential terms in the excited-state cross-section, and so are expected to be inaccurate. The new experiments proposed here will be the first to deliver a comprehensive set of data for these interactions, and precise and fully tested quantum calculations will be developed as part of this work. The combined experimental and theoretical research programme proposed here will hence deliver significant impact in all areas of science and in industry where plasmas are used or studied.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description We have now developed the software and hardware techniques that allow us to optimise and control both the laser systems and the electron spectrometers under computer control. This is now to be used for the experiments that are key to the success of this programme of work. Our collaboration with theoreticians in the USA continues to be fruitful, as we are providing precise data for their quantum models of the ionisation process. Our publications have worked with N2 & CH4 molecules, so that the theories can be refined to understand interactions with these targets (which are randomly aligned in space), in contrast to the laser-excited atoms we are now studying which we align with respect to our experimental geometry. The experimental development has been held back by enforced changes to the laboratory in Manchester due to the Royce Institute being given 70% of the building we are working in, so that we have had to reduce our lab space by ~50% and move the spectrometers and lasers. During this disruption we have managed to keep developing the techniques we require as well as work on new related ideas, and now that the lasers are back in operation we have completed integration of the laser control software into our programme.

Further work studying interactions using 2 laser beams that simultaneously ionize atoms has also been completed & published, demonstrating that the pathways to ionization must be added coherently. This has resulted in a new collaboration with theoretical colleagues in Germany who developed the theory of these interactions that agrees well with experiment. This work has now been published in Physical Review Letters, Physics Review A and has been published in the popular magazine 'Physics World' (Feb 2020). We continue development of the spectrometers and are getting back to operation with the laser systems which were non-operational for months due to the Royce refurbishments in the building. We now tested a new atomic beam oven that is now installed in a spectrometer and have measured coincidence events from ionization of calcium from this oven. This is in preparation for the experiments currently underway. We had a visit from Professor Don Madison who is our collaborator in the USA in 2018, and this has lead to a paper about to be submitted on ionization of CH4, as well as fruitful discussions on experiments in the perpendicular plane which we intend to start soon. We are about to have a visit from Professor James Colgan at Los Alamos Labs in the USA who is going to be here in April, and are also being visited by Professor Jamal Berakdar from Halle, Germany in that month (our collaborator on the double slit experiments). Our work has also been included in a recent 'roadmap' article published by the IOP which is a collaborative work from many of the major groups in atomic collision physics in the world.

We have also contributed to the development of an extensive number of new undergraduate lab experiments that have used our expertise in Labview and control system hardware developed as part of this project. This has lead to the upgrading and development of more than 25 new experiments in the second year undergraduate labs in Manchester. The development of these new experiments have also now been published in journals for use by other academics, as shown in the publications list. These were written during the first Covid based lock down in 2019.
Exploitation Route The development of these new techniques and findings has importance for other researchers working with lasers, and with electron spectrometers, since the techniques are applicable to users of these methods. Our newly published results on a double slit experiment in a single atom promises to open up a new area of research using coherent control of ionization, and we are considering this further as our work progresses. The results from the research is fundamental in nature and tests quantum collision theories, which are then refined to be used in other areas of work from Tokomak developments through to understanding stellar atmospheres.
Sectors Creative Economy,Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software),Education,Electronics,Energy

 
Description Our work on double slit interference has now been published in a recent Physics World magazine & so will be of interest to the general community who have interest in physics & quantum effects. The data from the experiments has been used by theoreticians for comparison to their models. Our work on the development of undergraduate experiments for teaching labs has now been published & will benefit others in physics throughout the world. This was from direct development of techniques associated with this project
First Year Of Impact 2018
Sector Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software),Education,Electronics
Impact Types Societal

 
Description 'Double-slit' and multiple-path Interference studies from Rb excited and ionized by high-resolution laser radiation.
Amount £567,853 (GBP)
Funding ID EP/V027689/1 
Organisation Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 09/2021 
End 08/2024
 
Description (e,gamma,2e) Threshold Spectroscopy - A new method to study collisional excitation of atoms using combined laser and electron beams
Amount £505,260 (GBP)
Funding ID EP/W003864/1 
Organisation Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 04/2022 
End 09/2025
 
Title A low jitter, low cost optical chopper 
Description We have developed a low jitter, low cost optical chopper using old hard disk drives that are actively stabilised for laser experiments and whihc provide comparable specs to commercial units but at a fraction of the cost. 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Year Produced 2020 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact These units are cheap to make and are useful in controlling laser beams in these types of experiment. 
 
Title An experimental control system for electron spectrometers using Arduino and LabVIEW interfaces 
Description We have developed new techniques to control electron spectrometers using an experimental control system using Arduino and LabVIEW interfaces 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Year Produced 2020 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact This new technique allows long term control of spectrometers so that the system can automatically adjust itself and maintain accuracy for long periods of time. 
 
Title Development of control systems for integration of lasers into electron spectrometers 
Description One of the key aims of this research programme is to develop modern techniques to integrate very high resolution laser radiation into the types of electron spectrometers that we use to precisely measure differential cross sections for ionisation from laser-excited targets. This is important as it allows us to measure ionisation from excited atoms - which is important in many areas ranging from plasmas in stars, to energy-loss mechanisms in future fusion reactors. We have now developed techniques that allow us to integrate control of the laser radiation with control of the electron spectrometers, by developing new systems for both the lasers and the spectrometers using a combination of Labview software, new electronic designs and interfacing to Labview using Arduino micro controllers. This integration is essential for success of the research programme as we have to keep the lasers tuned to an accuracy of better than 1 part in 1 billion for long periods of time (days to weeks), while maintaining the spectrometers at their optimum. 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Year Produced 2019 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact As above, we now have the tools to allow the experiments to be carried out (underway). The atomic beam oven, liquid nitrogen dewar and other hardware components are now built , and we have started our ionisation experiments on laser-excited atoms at this time. 
 
Title Digitally controlled laser frequency stabilization for a ring laser using saturated absorption 
Description A new method was developed to control laser frequencies using a Digitally controlled laser frequency stabilization technique for a ring laser using saturated absorption 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Year Produced 2021 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact stabilisation of lasers for long periods of time as required for this type of research. 
 
Description Collaboration with Madison's group in the USA 
Organisation Missouri University of Science and Technology
Country United States 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution We carried out the experimental measurements and our partners carried out the calculations for direct comparison to experiment. This work tests the calculations and experimental apparatus in preparation for the more difficult experiments using laser-excited targets.
Collaborator Contribution Our partners carried out detailed quantum calculations of the cross sections for direct comparison to the data, for Nitrogen molecules in a coplanar geometry.
Impact 10.1088/1361-6455/aa9eb9
Start Year 2017
 
Description Collaboration with theoretical group in Halle, Germany 
Organisation Martin Luther University of Halle-Wittenberg
Country Germany 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution A new collaboration has been setup with the group of professor Jamal Berakdar in Halle, Germany to study further the interactions of laser radiation with atoms leading to excitation & ionization.
Collaborator Contribution This collaboration has added theoretical calculations to experiments we carried out to look at a new type of double slit experiment in a single atom, which has lead to a Physical Review Letter publication in 2019.
Impact Physical Review Letter published February 2019. Further work is ongoing, through which we expect a second paper to be submitted soon.
Start Year 2017
 
Description collaboration with Dr Harvey & Dr Hussey for 3D metal printing 
Organisation Wayland Additive
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution Since Dr Harvey left the group and started working for the company Wayland additive we have had a small informal collaboration with him and Dr Martyn Hussey (also an ex-PDRA and PhD student) who are working on the development of 3D metal printing processes for a private company. This collaboration is small, and principally involves discussions about the process as well as ocassionally helping with components for testing.
Collaborator Contribution This involves mostly discussions every 2 weeks about how the project is progressing.
Impact None so far.
Start Year 2021
 
Title Hardware & software development for undergraduate teaching labs in Manchester 
Description Spinoffs from the development work we have been doing to improve the spectrometers in the research lab have been implemented in our teaching laboratories in Manchester where more than 20 new interfaces and experiments have been built for different experiments. This includes interfaces to the experiments using Labview, Arduino and ESP32 hardware, as well as extensive hardware development to interface different experiments to these CPU's. These experriments are now in operation in the laboratories in Manchester, and will be published in physics teaching journals in the near future. 
Type Of Technology New Material/Compound 
Year Produced 2018 
Impact This has substantially modernized the teaching labs in the physics department in Manchester. 
 
Title Software & Hardware integration into electron spectrometers 
Description One of the key aims of this research programme is to develop modern techniques to integrate very high resolution laser radiation into the types of electron spectrometers that we use to precisely measure differential cross sections for ionisation from laser-excited targets. This is important as it allows us to measure ionisation from excited atoms - which is essential for quantum models in many areas ranging from plasmas in stars, to energy-loss mechanisms in future fusion reactors. We have now developed hardware and software techniques that allow us to integrate control of the laser radiation within our electron spectrometers, by developing new systems for both the lasers and the spectrometers using a combination of Labview software, new electronics and software interfacing to Labview using Arduino micro controllers. This allows us to control the lasers and spectrometer precisely, and to automatically optimise the operation of the experiments to maintain productivity 
Type Of Technology Systems, Materials & Instrumental Engineering 
Year Produced 2018 
Impact The software and hardware interfacing is currently being tested, after which it will be published in one of the technical journals in physics (e.g. Review of Scientific Instruments). Since these systems are used in different research communities, it is expected that this will then be taken up by other parties so as to carry out more sophisticated experiments than are currently possible. 
 
Description Publication in Physics World on new interference experiments in a single atom 
Form Of Engagement Activity A magazine, newsletter or online publication
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Media (as a channel to the public)
Results and Impact An article was published in Physics World in February 2019 detailing new experiment on interference in a single Rb atom akin to the famous 'Double Slit' experiment by Young. The article discussed the new experiments and showed the experimental and theoretical evidence that this process occurs, demonstrating the wave-like nature of electrons in a completely new way, where 2 laser were used to select the pathways to ionization and hence controlled the interference effect.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019