Component processes of human face perception in typical and atypical individuals

Lead Research Organisation: Birkbeck, University of London
Department Name: Psychological Sciences

Abstract

Face perception is an essential component of human social interaction. It guides how we interact with others by enabling us to recognize individuals, identify their emotional state, and judge their attractiveness and trustworthiness. Because face perception operates so effortlessly and reliably, we rarely give it a second thought. But in fact, face perception and recognition are difficult achievements that are based on complex and poorly understood mechanisms. The real difficulty of face processing only becomes apparent when meeting people without any general perceptual or intellectual impairment, and without any history of neurological damage, who find it extremely hard to recognize family and friends from their faces. Behavioural tests of various aspects of face processing conducted by us and by other groups have shown that many of these people with developmental prosopagnosia (DP) have no comparable problems with object recognition, which indicates that faces and non-face objects are processed by different mechanisms. All DPs show severe deficits in the processing of identity, but other aspects of face processing, such as the perception of face parts and face configurations or the processing of emotional facial expression, can be intact or impaired, suggesting that DP is a heterogeneous condition.
In our current ESRC-funded research project, we use a combination of behavioural and electrophysiological measures (event-related brain potentials, ERPs) to gain new insights into which aspects of face processing are damaged in DP. Our results so far point to early visual-perceptual stages of face processing as a major cause of the face recognition problems that affect individuals with DP. For example, people with intact face perception process upright faces and inverted faces very differently, which is interpreted as evidence that the perception of upright faces is "configural" or "holistic", whereas inverted faces are processed in a qualitatively different "part-based" fashion. We have found that people with DP do not show these typical processing differences between upright and inverted faces, indicating that their ability to process upright faces in a configural/holistic fashion did not develop properly.
To find out more precisely how face perception differs between DPs and people with intact face processing, we will conduct a series of experiments with face and non-face stimuli that are specifically designed to engage different aspects of face processing (e.g., the perception of salient face parts such as the eyes, the processing of facial configurations, perceiving faces from different viewpoints, using face perception to remember individual faces), to find out which processes operate normally and which are impaired in people with DP. We will also study whether DPs and non-impaired people look at faces differently, and whether they use different parts of a face when trying to identify it.
Finding out which aspects of face perception work well and which are impaired in DPs will have important implications for our understanding the mechanisms that underlie face perception in people with intact face processing abilities. It will also greatly expand our knowledge of why some people have severe deficits in face recognition. Such deficits can have an enormous impact on their social lives. Many have difficulty maintaining friendships due to perceived snubs and their recognition difficulties at work can be extremely troubling.

Planned Impact

Developmental prosopagnosia (DP) is surprisingly common and can cause serious social difficulties. Individuals affected by this condition formed contact groups aimed at providing assistance and support, increasing public understanding of DP, and supporting research aimed at uncovering the causes of DP. Our current ESRC-funded project is at the centre of these activities in London and south-east England. The London-based group of DPs involved in our research is the world's largest group, and has become a focal point for formal and informal contacts between DPs, and for a series of initiatives that go well beyond our core research into DP, as listed below. We will further develop and increase these
and related impact activities in the coming years,

- Organisation of an annual face-blindness Open Day Event at Birkbeck, aimed to provide people with prosopagnosia in the London area with an opportunity to meet each other and to learn about recent research findings. Our first Open Day held on 20 September 2011 was attended by about 40 DPs, representing the largest meeting of DPs ever. See article in the face-to-face newsletter edition: http://www.faceblind.org/links/Face%20to%20Face%20Newsletter%20-%20Winter%202012.pdf

- Contributions to a bi-annual newsletter ("Face-to-Face"), available at faceblind.org (4 issues to date). Its aim is to keep DPs and interested members of the public updated about the latest prosopagnosia research, about our ongoing and planned research studies, and to share stories and experiences. We are currently planning the first edition of our own London-based newsletter.

- Maintaining a dedicated facebook page for London-based DPs: http://www.facebook.com/permalink.php?story_fbid=173408949437929&id=100003064768549#!/groups/117013401655030/


- Contributing to meetings of the London-based DP support group and hosting it on a quarterly basis at the Henry Wellcome Building. We will provide drop-in and information sessions, which are particularly important for those DPs recently diagnosed so that they meet other people similarly affected and to get a more in-depth understanding of their condition. These sessions will be open to those currently attending the London Faceblind group at its location at the Westminster Pastoral Foundation building in Central London, recently diagnosed participants that were tested in our lab, and other DPs that we will notify of the group via both the faceblind.org website and the DP facebook group.

In addition to providing a forum for individuals with DP, we also aim to contribute to the public understanding of DP and its nature as a common and serious condition by communicating our research findings to the media, and facilitating contacts between the media and individuals with DP that will increase public understanding of this condition. Recent press coverage on DP includes articles in the The New York Times (26 December 2011), Sunday Times (20 November 2011, The Daily (8 June 2011), the British Medical Journal (23 March 2011), the Daily Record (20 March 2011), Science News (10 December 2010), and The New Yorker (30 August 2010).

Publications

10 25 50

publication icon
Fisher K (2016) Reduced sensitivity to contrast signals from the eye region in developmental prosopagnosia. in Cortex; a journal devoted to the study of the nervous system and behavior

publication icon
Fisher K (2017) Face identity matching is selectively impaired in developmental prosopagnosia. in Cortex; a journal devoted to the study of the nervous system and behavior

publication icon
Towler J (2016) Electrophysiological evidence for parts and wholes in visual face memory. in Cortex; a journal devoted to the study of the nervous system and behavior

publication icon
Towler J (2015) Early stages of perceptual face processing are confined to the contralateral hemisphere: evidence from the N170 component. in Cortex; a journal devoted to the study of the nervous system and behavior

publication icon
Towler J (2018) Holistic face perception is impaired in developmental prosopagnosia. in Cortex; a journal devoted to the study of the nervous system and behavior

 
Description Developmental prosopagnosia (DP) is a selective impairment in face perception and recognition in the absence of any obvious brain damage, low-level visual problems, or intellectual deficits. The objective of this grant was to obtain new insights into the factors that are responsible for the face processing deficits in individuals with DP, with a particular focus on impairments in face perception. To do this, we measured electrical responses to faces and other types of stimuli in participants with DP and compared these to responses measured for groups of age-matched control participants without face processing impairments.
This research project has successfully met all grant objectives, and obtained new insights into the factors that contribute to DP. Research findings have so far been published in 12 peer-reviewed publications, and several other articles are currently being prepared. Main achievements to date are now briefly described:

• We recorded electrical brain responses to normal upright intact faces and face images where the eyes, nose, and mouth were spatially scrambled, creating rather unusual-looking grotesque face images (Towler, Fisher, & Eimer, 2016, Cortex). Control participants showed clear differences in their brain responses to these types of faces within less than 200 milliseconds, demonstrating that their face perception system is very sensitive to any deviations from the expected canonical spatial layout of face images. In marked contrast, there was no such differential brain response in individuals with DP. This demonstrates a remarkable lack in the sensitivity of face perception mechanisms to extreme deviations from canonical face templates, which is likely to contribute to the face recognition problems in DP. Importantly, DPs show normal brain responses to Mooney faces (two-tone images can be readily perceived as faces, but do not include face parts that are recognizable in isolation; Towler et al., 2016, Journal of Neuropsychology), indicating that they can utilize holistic information about face structure for categorical discriminations between faces and non-face objects. We discuss the theoretical implications of these findings in an extensive review article (Towler, Fisher, & Eimer, in press, QJEP).
• We showed that DPs are impaired in processing contrast Information from the eye region, which is critical for face recognition. Early face-selective brain responses in DP are less sensitive to contrast information in face images, and that this it is the eye region that is selectively affected (Fisher, Towler, & Eimer, 2016, Cortex). This provides the first direct evidence for a highly selective deficit in perceptually processing identity-related visual signals in DPs, which is likely to be a major contributor to their face recognition impairments.
• To test whether successful face recognition differs between DPs and control participants, e measured brain responses generated during face recognition (Parketny, Towler, & Eimer, 2015, Neuropsychologia). The activation of visual face memory for previously unknown learned faces and the subsequent conscious recognition of these faces were strongly delayed in DPs. Two of the DPs tested even failed to recognize an image of their own face during the experiment, and these DPs also showed no selective brain response to their own face.
Exploitation Route Developmental prosopagnosia (DP) is surprisingly common and can cause serious social difficulties. Individuals affected by this condition formed contact groups aimed at providing assistance and support, increasing public understanding of DP, and supporting research aimed at uncovering the causes of DP. This ESRC-funded project was at the centre of these activities in London and south-east England. The London-based group of DPs involved in our research is the world's largest group, and has become a focal point for formal and informal contacts between DPs, and for a series of initiatives that go well beyond our core research into DP, as listed below. We have developed and increased these and related impact activities (participation in televised and radio coverage of DP, e.g. BBC Radio 4, ITV, Channel 4) in the course of this grant.
We organise an annual face-blindness Open Day Event at Birkbeck, aimed to provide people with prosopagnosia in the London area with an opportunity to meet each other and to learn about recent research findings. Our first Open Day held on 20 September 2011. During the duration of the current grant, two further Open Days were held at Birkbeck. On 20th June 2014 we hosted a "Prosopagnosia: Living with and Researching Face Blindness" Symposium, with over 50 attendees from locations across the UK. On 1st July 2015, we facilitated Face Blind UK holding their first Open Meeting, at our research institute at Birkbeck, which was attended by members with face blindness, directors of Face Blind UK and our lab's researchers.
The London Faceblind Group held support group meetings, every two months, in our research building, from the start of the grant. We also contribute to a bi-annual newsletter ("Face-to-Face"), available at faceblind.org (4 issues to date). Its aim is to keep DPs and interested members of the public updated about the latest prosopagnosia research, about our ongoing and planned research studies, and to share stories and experiences. We are currently planning the first edition of our own London-based newsletter.
In addition, we maintain a dedicated facebook page for London-based DPs: http://www.facebook.com/permalink.php?story_fbid=173408949437929&id=100003064768549#!/groups/117013401655030/
All of these activities are planned to continue beyond the end of the current grant period.
Sectors Communities and Social Services/Policy,Education,Healthcare

URL http://www.prosopagnosia.bbk.ac.uk/
 
Description Update on our impact-related activities (reported after the end of the award period, April 2017): Developmental prosopagnosia (DP) is surprisingly common and can cause serious social difficulties. In the context of our ESRC-funded DP research, individuals affected by this condition have formed contact groups aimed at providing assistance and support, increasing public understanding of DP, and supporting research aimed at uncovering the causes of DP. The current ESRC-funded project was at the centre of these activities in London and south-east England. The London-based group of DPs involved in our research is the world's largest group, and has become a focal point for formal and informal contacts between DPs, and for a series of initiatives that go well beyond our core research into DP, as listed below. We will further develop and increase these and related impact activities in the coming years. Our main areas of impact-related activities include: - Organisation of an annual face-blindness Open Day Event at Birkbeck, aimed to provide people with prosopagnosia in the London area with an opportunity to meet each other and to learn about recent research findings. Our first Open Day held on 20 September 2011 was attended by about 40 DPs, representing the largest meeting of DPs ever. See article in the face-to-face newsletter edition: http://www.faceblind.org/links/Face%20to%20Face%20Newsletter%20-%20Winter%202012.pdf. During the duration of this specific ESRC grant, two further Open Days were held at Birkbeck. On 20th June 2014 we hosted a "Prosopagnosia: Living with and Researching Face Blindness" Symposium, with over 50 attendees from locations across the UK. On 1st July 2015, we facilitated Face Blind UK holding their first Open Meeting, at our research institute at Birkbeck, which was attended by members with face blindness, directors of Face Blind UK and our lab's researchers. The next Face Blind Open Day at Birkbeck is currently being planned, and is scheduled to take place in September 2017. - Contributions to a bi-annual newsletter ("Face-to-Face"), available at faceblind.org (5 issues to date). Its aim is to keep DPs and interested members of the public updated about the latest prosopagnosia research, about our ongoing and planned research studies, and to share stories and experiences. We are currently planning the first edition of our own London-based newsletter. - Maintaining a dedicated facebook page for London-based DPs: http://www.facebook.com/permalink.php?story_fbid=173408949437929&id=100003064768549#!/groups/117013401655030/ - Contributing to meetings of the London-based DP support group and hosting it on a bimonthly basis at the Henry Wellcome Building. We provide drop-in and information sessions, which are particularly important for those DPs recently diagnosed so that they meet other people similarly affected and to get a more in-depth understanding of their condition. These sessions will be open to those currently attending the London Faceblind group at its location at the Westminster Pastoral Foundation building in Central London, recently diagnosed participants that were tested in our lab, and other DPs that we will notify of the group via both the faceblind.org website and the DP facebook group. - The PI and RAs involved in this ESRC grant have participated in televised and radio coverage of DP, e.g. BBC Radio 4, ITV, Channel 4) in the course of this grant period. For example, a BBC Radio 4 program ("Who are you again?"; 30 min, first broadcast on Radio 4 on Friday 1st July at 11am; repeated on Sunday 19th November, and also broadcast on the BBC World Service, available on BBC iPlayer Radio: http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b07hj65h) featured research on prosopagnosia at Birkbeck, including an interview with Professor Martin Eimer, the PI on this ESRC grant. All of these impact-related activities are planned to continue beyond the end of the current grant period.
First Year Of Impact 2014
Sector Communities and Social Services/Policy,Education,Healthcare
Impact Types Cultural,Societal