European, Ethnic and Expatriate: A Longitudinal Comparison of German and British Social Networking and Associational Formations in Modern-day Asia

Lead Research Organisation: Northumbria University
Department Name: Sch of Arts and Social Sciences

Abstract

Asia, while having seen a substantial degree of outmigration in recent years, has consistently received its share of European arrivals since the seventeenth century, and, given the region's economic growth over the last two decades, continues to witness an increase in their number. For these migrants, thrust into an alien cultural environment, ethnic associationalism and social networking are among the most common responses to life in the new home. By utilising such formal and informal strategies of sociability, they are building on an enduring tradition that has long since been part of the migratory chain. Yet despite its long history, the persistence of ethnic associations and networks among migrants in the Far East has received little attention, particularly when it comes to the new generation of expatriates. This research, therefore, will offer the first sustained reading of present-day expatriate social networks and associational forms in Asia within the wider context of their historical antecedents. By moving beyond the traditional focus on Anglophone cultures in the former British Empire in Asia, this project will compare contemporary migrant community life of migrants from the British Isles and Germany. This comparison throws up the prospect of better understanding both groups, facilitating scrutiny of the role of language and intercultural differences in expatriate social networking. The project will concentrate on how social networks in the two communities are channelled by different ethnic and cultural organisations, including ethnic societies, such as St Andrew's societies and German clubs, but also cultural organisations like the Goethe Institute or the British Council, and diplomatic missions, recognising their quasi-ethnic associational roles. Informal sociability, for instance through hashing, will also be explored.

Based on an analysis of activities in a select number of Asian case study locations, namely Mumbai (India), Bangkok (Thailand), Kuala Lumpur (Malaysia), Singapore (Republic of Singapore), Hong Kong (Special Administrative Region (SAR) of the People's Republic of China), Shanghai and Beijing (People's Republic of China), and Tokyo (Japan), the project will collect diverse types of data, including data on association activities and membership, to shed light on expatriate social networking processes. Interviews with expatriates in the sites of study will form an intrinsic part of the research. The proposed project's overall aim is to unravel what expatriate social networks can tell us about present-day migrant life and identity in Asia, and shed light on the reasons behind the continued importance of ethnicity in migrant communities.

A wide group of academics and non-academics will benefit from the research, which offers a knowledge-shaping new approach to the transnational study of expatriate community life, networking and ethnicity. The core monograph and articles will make a major contribution to knowledge and be of interest to scholars in history (e.g. social history and migration history) and social sciences (e.g. human geography; anthropology; and political sciences). The end-of-project conference will bring together presenters from a wider geographical range than this project covers, seeking to facilitate new research networks beyond the proposed project's lifetime.

Knowledge exchange and user engagement is an intrinsic part of this project. Several public events will extend considerably beyond the academy. The data gathered throughout the project, some of which will be showcased in an exhibition online, will be accompanied by tailored community activities to directly engage users with the research, making it accessible to expatriate communities and the organisations under investigation. Impact strategies will ensure involvement of users, stakeholders and policy makers as the research progresses.

Planned Impact

The project is carefully designed to ensure that the wider public will benefit from the research. First, the proposed programme of community engagement will ensure the dissemination of findings among the immediate user groups. This chiefly includes members of British and German expatriate communities in the Asian sites of study. These communities will benefit from the research as details on association activities and networking processes will offer them a new perspective on their immediate life experiences. The project website will showcase material and provide an interactive platform to facilitate transnational interaction and user exchange throughout Asia and beyond.

Secondly, research findings will be relevant for the cultural organisations and embassies identified. Many activities they promote, though not outwardly 'ethnic', are a key channel through which interactions of expatriates are filtered. Therefore, it is hoped that research findings will aid the development of more targeted engagement between organisations, their respective user groups, and the host society. This may extend to stakeholders in the host society, specifically those in the culture and heritage sector, facilitating collaborations between culture organisations from abroad and local museums or community groups. As a result, the research also holds potential to inform, and contribute directly to, educational and cultural initiatives in the culture sector in the sites of study, constituting a timely contribution to the wider debates about migration and identity in Asia.

To ensure that the non-academic users concerned have ample opportunities to benefit from the research, engagement activities in all sites of study will be integral to the project from the outset. In view of the specific primary user group of the research, a range of different impact strategies will be pursued to ensure that users will benefit from the research as fully as possible. The project website and user exchange platform will be supplemented by communication activities within expatriate communities, utilising social media as well as more traditional means of communication. Research findings will be prepared in a suitable way for this type of exchange, tailored towards users. Most importantly, there will be a series of events in the Asian sites of study at three points in time throughout the project's lifetime, with a dedicated impact phase taking place at the end of the project. These events will directly engage users groups with the research, and, where possible, activities will include training sessions for association members and expatriates in which they will be able to actively use research outcomes to learn about their immediate life world. Communication channels within expatriate communities will be utilised to ensure effective and wide circulation of information on research findings and events, seeking to facilitate opportunities for user engagement. The end-of-project conference, while also targeting an academic audience, will be developed to suit a 'blended' constituency of academics and non-academics, the latter including stakeholders and policy makers who are beneficiaries of this research (e.g. staff from the Foreign & Commonwealth Office). With that in mind, the PI will explore opportunities to host the conference in conjunction with relevant stakeholders or think tanks (e.g. Counterpoint).

Media liaison will be integral to disseminating the results of this project. The local press in the Asian sites of study will be contacted in advance of research visits to ensure wide dissemination of the research, and also to publicise events to be held. Ideally, there will also be opportunities for research findings to feed into press reports and local radio programmes. The media in Britain and Germany will also be approached with findings, as it too runs stories dealing with expatriate communities abroad.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description Framed by a transnational and longitudinal line of inquiry, the project's overall aim was to trace change and/or persistence in the role ethnic and cultural organisations play in British and German expatriate social networking in Asia. Within the context of this aim, the project has generated significant new knowledge about the lives of present-day expats and how they see the role of ethnic associations today. Interviews and surveys reveal that ethnicity continues to shape behaviour, but that the extent to which this happens today is dependent on a wider range of factors than has historically been the case. As the project's history component has revealed, when ethnic clubs and associations were first established in the nineteenth century, the offered one of only a very limited number of tools expats could employ to make home in Asia, a sojourner world. In the present, online platforms and other innovations in networking mean that a much broader range of tools are available to expats. Nevertheless, the research still points to the fact that ethnic associations remain a strong response to the challenges of a highly transient environment, particularly in places where the differences in lifestyle and everyday challenges are more pronounced (e.g. Beijing).

The project identified a number of new research resources, including the records of associations catering for expats who returned to Britain and Germany, and a number of previously unknown community magazines from ethnic clubs and societies. Where possible these have been collected and digitised (e.g. annual reports of the China Association) to facilitate future research. Moreover, towards the end of the project new material relating to questions concerning old age and elderly care in British and German expat communities in Asia was unearthed; a new research project has already been developed as a result.

A number of unforeseen practical challenges had to be dealt with throughout the project's lifetime, and subsequently did have a minor impact on the research plan. This was the case because both Thailand and China, two of the project's sites of study, saw a number of political upheavals and subsequent changes to visa regulations that meant that some of the planned research trips had to be changed, and one (to Thailand) cancelled altogether due to security concerns at the time. While it was possible to divert activities to other case study sites, this has meant a reduced number of interviews for some sites. To offset this to some extent, methods were adapted to provide for an additional data capturing method (online survey-style interviews). Overall, this has not changed the nature of the study nor had a detrimental impact, but it is worth considering the imbalance in material and this is something I will address in the methods sections of the project monograph.

Apart from data outputs (interviews, surveys and databases of associations) and impact outputs (co-produced community history), the academic outputs to date include one journal article (as planned this was co-authored with the project's postdoc) and a book chapter in an edited collection. At present I am preparing the draft of the monograph, which will be the principal project output.
Exploitation Route There are two principal ways in which I will take findings forward:

Development of new research
The most immediate path forward relates to new materials shedding light on elderly care in British and German diaspora communities in Asia. There are significant numbers of expats who, although they would like to return home, are, for financial reasons, unable to do so. I thus developed a research project to open a new inroad into examining immigrant health, particularly the question of elderly care, through the lens of ethnicity, focusing on the provisions made by ethnic associations and related groups such as the China Coast Community in Hong Kong. In particular, I am interested in how such groups utilise ethnicity and ethnic heritage to develop elderly care solutions, with a view to exploit such solutions for present-day dementia care. A funding bid for seed funding was submitted to the Wellcome Trust.

For impact purposes
With all data now gathered, there remains an important impact route to pursue with policy makers and companies (to work with them on how they can better engage expats), as well as ongoing work with ethnic associations in the sites of study (this will include more community history projects and I am presently also exploring the idea of developing an app for expats to engage them with the history of clubs and their sites of residence).
Sectors Communities and Social Services/Policy,Government, Democracy and Justice,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections

 
Description Impact will continue to develop. Initial impacts beyond the academy are traceable already through work with the immediate research users of the research - current expats in Asia, especially around their life experience of ethnic association. Results from the research were used, for example, to co-produce, together with a Society Chieftain of the Hong Kong St Andrew's Society, a history of key aspects of the association's activities, and use this to engage this group (500+) with its own history. More significantly in terms of wider cultural and societal impact, developments have since taken place in collaboration with the National Museum of Scotland. The Museum is looking to redevelop its Scotland Galleries and seeking to integrate the history of Scotland's commercial diaspora more fully into the Galleries - which connects that ambition directly to a number of research outcomes from my ESRC research. On the back of that ambition and connection, museum curators and I have developed a new project, part-funded by the Royal Society of Edinburgh, to move this forward. As part of this wider work, my ESRC research and work with expat community groups and companies in Asia is currently being utilised directly for further impact generation, particularly through links I established with HSBC. In collaboration with the Museum, research outcomes from my ESRC project are also feeding into wider societal impact through work with school children (through the Museum's Schools programme), and events where they, as well as returned expats, are generating their own histories to critically engage the issue of migration and expat life. All of this is directly informed by my ESRC research and I am contributing and leading activities. Impact from these activities is already measurable in attendance numbers for events and changes in museum practice, and will be further increased through the subsequent redevelopment of the Scotland Galleries. Beyond this work another impact initiative that has developed from my ESRC research, though this is still in its infancy at this point: work with elderly care providers in Asia who specifically cater for expats who are staying there. My research has revealed this to be a big question, with many unable to return, and I am exploring how the ESRC research, in combination with my wider work on the role of ethnic association and identity in immigrant communities, can serve to inform elderly care with providers. More recently, the findings about expat networking and the use of associations for collective action has also been used to generate new impact in relation to the role of associations of EU citizens in the context of Brexit. Similar to developments examined for the ESRC project, these groups to combine a civic and social function, addressing community problems. Networks also play a key role.
First Year Of Impact 2016
Sector Communities and Social Services/Policy,Education,Government, Democracy and Justice,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections,Other
Impact Types Cultural,Societal,Policy & public services

 
Title Association databases 
Description Individual membership databases for British and German ethnic associations in case study locations (Bangkok, Kuala Lumpur, Singapore, Hong Kong, Beijing and Shanghai); these databases vary in terms of information and scope - simply as a result of the very diverse local source bases and available material for the different locations. Consequently, this also means that details vary in terms of types of information as well as actual membership numbers included: some databases include details for less than 10 members, with little more than their name, while others are more extensive and include broader sets of information like gender, or employment information. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact Use for outputs; will form significant part of monograph. 
 
Title Expat Survey database 
Description The database contains the results of an expat survey reating to expat experiences of settlement and general expat life in Asia, with particular reference to the role of expat/ethnic associations in expat life. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact The database has only been compiled, impacts will develop once we disseminate findings arising from it. 
 
Title ReShare Data Collection: British and German expat life in Asia 
Description This data collection is comprised of different types of data relating to British and German expat life in Asia in longitudinal perspective. It contains: (1) transcripts of interviews (N=28) with British and German expats in a select number of sites of study throughout Asia; (2) results from a survey (N=53) of British and German expats in Asia, containing basic details on age, gender, occupation and nationality, as well as wider details on expat life (3) databases relating to the membership of ethnic associations in Asia, including historical data. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact Ongoing. 
URL http://reshare.ukdataservice.ac.uk/852556/
 
Description 'Trading places' workshop with National Museum of Scotland on Scottish trade diaspora -- builds on work from this project to inform gallery development 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact 'Trading Places' is a programme of events as part of a collaborative project with the National Museum of Scotland. This involved workshops to inform the development of the Museum's Scotland galleries; the workshop brought together scholars, curators and a representative from HBC to explore links in Asia. This is also where the link to this project comes in. Additionally, there was a public engagement event for the wider public, and a learning event for schools. A final workshop will take place this spring/summer.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
URL https://www.nms.ac.uk/collections-research/our-research/current-research/trading-places/
 
Description Co-production of Hong Kong St Andrew's Ball history 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact Co-production of a short history of the Hong Kong St Andrew's Ball with current St Andrew's Society Chieftain. Disstribution and launch of history at 2015 St Andrew's Ballin print vesion; online version also available. St Andrew's Society on association under investigation for project, so engagement and co-production of knowledge with immediate research user group. Online version of history has international reach and can be used by St Andrew's Society members as well as others interested in history of ethnic associations.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2015
URL http://standrewsballshk.thescottishdiaspora.net/
 
Description Exhibition opening 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact I was invited to the exhibition opening of 'Early Views of Hong Kong' held in Hong Kong. In particular the exhibition shows images of the transformation of Hong Kong in the late 19th and early 20th centuries as a result of the British presence there, including exhibits relating to the associational culture of early expats (which is, in part, the focus of my ESRC project). The aim was for me to get a chance to engage with other guests - mostly British expats living in Hong Kong now - about my ESRC project, sharing information about it as well as stimulating their thinking about expat life.

imrpoved understanding among expats of the historical role of social networking; however, at this stage the impact is necessarily limited still as my project has not advanced enough yet to carry activities to their fullest potential -- this will happen in the future. In that sense this initial engagement was a facilitation activity for future initiatives.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2014
 
Description Kuala Lumpur St David's Society engagament, St David's Day Ball 2015 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Dissemination of initial findings re: expat project among attendees of St David's Society Ball -- the organisation is one investigated for the research, so dissemination among immediate research users.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2015
 
Description Policy work with Friedrich-Ebert-Foundation 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Policymakers/politicians
Results and Impact This activity is an extension of the focus of my ESRC project, linking questions of expat life to current developments in relation to Brexit and wider concerns about identity and social networks that underpin wider concerns around citizens' rights. This is very much the beginning phase of wider work that relates my work to current developments. A policy brochure was developed for the Friedrich-Ebert-Foundation and work in now ongoing with policymakers and parliamentarians.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
 
Description discussion with team of Friedrich-Ebert Foundation in London 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact discussion designed to inform about my project; sparked questions and brought on the way a discussion re: future collaborations for the purpose of wider public engagement; might involve policymakers etc within the wider context of British-German relations that the Friedrich-Ebert Foundation seeks to foster

generation of interest in the topic of expat social networking among Britons and Germans in Asia
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2014