Gender, young people and schooling: Pathways for challenging gender norms

Lead Research Organisation: Durham University
Department Name: Education

Abstract

Gender inequalities are an increasingly high profile societal problem and represents a significant issue within educational institutions. In a wider political context, the recent increasing awareness of the gender pay gap, gender- based discrimination (e.g. #MeToo), and sexism in schools and workplaces demonstrates the importance of my research to challenge the taken-for-granted gender norms which permeate educational discourse in the UK. Therefore, to acknowledge the complexity of gendered identities in young people is important to promote agency, individuality and minimise the negative consequences for young people's mental health. Gender roles and expected behaviours can place significant pressures on young people to conform to these idealised identities. This is particularly significant for young people because the period of adolescence is a transitional time characterised by flux and uncertainty. My PhD research which used physical education (PE) as a lens to view gender inequalities in schools, suggested that there is the potential for negative consequences of gender norms, exacerbated by social comparison in relation to one's embodied appearance. The rise of social media as a significant problem faced by young people (Royal Society for Public Health, 2017) emphasises the need to ensure practitioners and policy-makers understand the specific experiences of young people. In critically examining the gendered experiences of young people within education (and more specifically, PE), my work offers a lens through which interventions and ways of challenging entrenched gender norms can be achieved. Through demonstrating that gender norms often operate at a non-conscious level, my previous research offers the possibility of using this knowledge to challenge and change the experiences of young people, allowing for the possibility of a more inclusive and sensitive school experience for many. A key purpose of this proposed fellowship is to engage practitioners with my research, supported by my own better understanding of pathways to impact in this field, thus encouraging a critical reflexivity and increased awareness of how gender can be problematic for young people in educational fields.

My research therefore addresses these taken-for-granted gender norms influencing how young people interpret their gendered identities, underpinned by a theoretical perspective which utilises the conceptual tools of Pierre Bourdieu. Drawing upon my previous PhD research, this fellowship will allow me to maximise the routes to impact by:
1. Publishing three articles arising from my doctoral research.
2. Completing a small-scale research project (as a form of knowledge exchange activity) to disseminate and
reflect on my PhD research with key stakeholders and decision makers in schools. This element ensures that my doctoral research is fully fed-back to key stakeholders with the intention of challenging schools to address instances of gender inequality.
3. Developing research networks and collaborations, both within the world of academia, with teacher practitioners, and in wider sports/PE networks. These collaborative networks are critical for my own career development in terms of receiving feedback on draft papers/grant proposals and establishing potential future cross-institutional research projects.
4. Developing a project proposal for Leverhulme and/or ESRC New Investigator Grants to continue my research in the context of interventions and strategies to challenge gender norms in practice. This project will be methodologically framed in participatory action research principles to illustrate the impact of interventions designed to challenge the taken-for-granted gender norms in schools.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description The project developed impact and engagement activities with schools, teachers and other youth based organisations to challenge the gender norms that permeate how PE is experienced in schools. The activities challenged preconceived ideas, specifically by illustrating to teachers the specific experiences of their students and the impact that these have on their own wellbeing and enjoyment of PE. The award allowed the development of a qualitative survey of girls aged 10-20 during lockdown that demonstrated significant importance of freedom and connection in the development of wellbeing. This led to an open letter, signed by myself, the Youth Sport Trust, Sported and Women in Sport to Matt Hancock MP calling on the UK Government to change is messaging around the importance of physical activity.
Exploitation Route The outcomes of the Covid project on wellbeing and physicality are important to take forward and develop recommendations for wellbeing that may last beyond the end of the Covid-19 pandemic.
Sectors Education,Healthcare,Leisure Activities, including Sports, Recreation and Tourism

 
Description The findings have been used in an open letter to Matt Hancock MP calling on the government to reprioritise physical activity and exercise during lockdown. It has also led to positive relationships with different national organisations (Women in Sport, Sported, Youth Sport Trust) who have used the different research findings internally for their own report and informing their own decision making around exercise and Covid-19. The development of the Action Research Project has led to changes to how PE is structured and taught in the school in which this was piloted.
Sector Education,Leisure Activities, including Sports, Recreation and Tourism
Impact Types Societal,Policy & public services

 
Description County Durham Sport 
Organisation Sport England
Department County Durham Sport
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution My research informed CPD sessions and training for County Durham Sport; as well as contributing to discussions and planning for activities to target issues around gender inqualities and young people.
Collaborator Contribution The support of County Durham Sport aided the project by opening doors for access to different groups, schools and individuals to engage with the outputs of the research project.
Impact None to report at this moment.
Start Year 2019
 
Description Youth Sport Trust 
Organisation Youth Sport Trust
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution Research and discussions have informed initiatives and programmes delivered by Youth Sport Trust, and challenged the current status quo on how PE and school sport could be packaged.
Collaborator Contribution Partnership with YST allowed the reach of research activities to be far wider and representative; obtaining a larger sample of participants for the 2020 Lockdown physicality project.
Impact Ongoing, article and report to be finalised in 2021.
Start Year 2019
 
Description PE Seminar 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact 60 academics, teachers and teacher educators attended a seminar to discuss the impact of schools and gender inequalities on how young people experience their PE. The seminar event developed a discussion about the meaning of PE, its role in the curriculum, and possible pathways for progress out of lockdown.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
 
Description PE Teacher Workshops 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact 20 PE Teachers (including Heads of PE) attended a workshop hosted by Durham County Council to discuss research findings, share good practice, and discuss the challenges associated with gender inequality in PE.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019,2020