3D Numerical Modelling of Large, Rapid, Violent Geologic Processes

Lead Research Organisation: Imperial College London
Department Name: Earth Science and Engineering

Abstract

Meteorite impacts, large long-runout landslides, volcanic collapse, submarine landslip, and the tsunamis generated when such events occur in a marine environment, are part of a family of large, rapid, violent geologic processes that have potentially catastrophic consequences. Public awareness of these phenomena is high, but our fundamental understanding of them is far from complete. This is in large part because such high-energy processes are impossible to simulate on the laboratory scale and they have been difficult and expensive to simulate numerically until now. The aim of the proposed research is to develop an advanced, 3D numerical model for simulating impacts and other violent geologic processes, and to use this model to investigate the poorly understood natural hazards of meteorite impact, large sub-aerial and sub-marine landslip, and impact- and collapse-generated tsunamis, to predict their behaviour, and ultimately to help mitigate their destructive consequences. In recent times, impact cratering has emerged as an influential process in the evolution of the Earth and life as it exists today. It is now believed that impacts caused at least one mass-extinction, the formation of the moon, and possibly created habitats for primitive life and caused the transfer of life across the solar system, via the high-speed ejection of near-surface rocks. The catastrophic role of impact cratering in Earth history and its far-reaching consequences make imperative the need to understand impacts and the hazard that they pose. However, fundamental gaps remain in our knowledge of the impact process. The vast majority of our current understanding is derived from models and experiments where the target material is uniform and the impactor strikes perpendicular to the target surface. In reality, such events are extremely unlikely to occur on Earth; oblique impacts are far more common than near-vertical impacts, and almost nowhere on the Earth can its near-subsurface be considered uniform (for example, 70% of the Earth's surface is covered by water). The effect on the cratering process of the angle of the impactor's trajectory to the target surface, and variations in the composition and strength of the target surface, are poorly understood. Laboratory experiments and preliminary modelling work suggest that both these factors may change substantially the size and shape of the crater, and the amount of hazardous, hot vaporised rock formed during an impact, but sophisticated 3D modelling is required to fully quantify the effects. In this work the necessary impact simulations will be performed to determine the environmental consequences of impacts on Earth for any size asteroid or comet, at any velocity and angle and into any type of target surface. Two other poorly understood geologic processes that are either an immediate consequence of impacts, or involve similar physical processes, are large rock avalanches and tsunamis generated by landslides or impacts. Large rock avalanches travel vast horizontal distances with only a comparatively small vertical drop in height. Their rapid movement and extensive reach makes them a significant natural hazard, despite the rarity of their occurrence. However, the physical explanation for their high mobility has not yet been ascertained, and hence no reliable model exists for predicting their behaviour. Underwater landslides and oceanic impact events can trigger a type of local tsunami with high run-up and potentially devastating consequences. However, the generation, propagation and breaking of these waves are not yet understood, which has led to wildly differing views on the hazard that these types of tsunamis pose. The model developed as part of this research will also be adapted to simulate these processes. The models will be used to investigate how large rock avalanches can travel so much further than small ones, and to reassess the landslide- and impact-tsunami hazard.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description Meteorite impacts, volcanic collapse, large subaerial or submarine landslides, and the tsunamis generated when such events occur in a marine environment, are part of a family of large, rapid, violent geologic processes that have potentially catastrophic consequences. Public awareness of these phenomena is high, but our fundamental understanding of them is far from complete. This is in large part because such high-energy processes are impossible to simulate on the laboratory scale and they have been difficult and expensive to simulate numerically. A major technical outcome of this research is the development, enhancement and validation of two advanced, efficient three-dimensional (3D) numerical tools for simulating these processes: iSALE2D/3D for simulating impact processes (http://isale-code.de) and the open source Fluidity (http://launchpad.net/fluidity) for simulating other violent geologic processes, such as earthquake, landslide and impact-generated waves and pyroclastic flows. A significant enhancement to Fluidity produced by this research is the ability to simulate the interaction between dispersed fine particles and Earth's atmosphere and oceans. This new technology is important, as the major hazard posed by both massive volcanic eruptions and large meteorite impacts is the global distribution of fine particles that inhibit photosynthesis and potentially cause catastrophic climate perturbations.



Major scientific outcomes of this research were realised by using these models to investigate the poorly understood natural hazards of meteorite impact and tsunamis generated by impact, landslides and earthquakes.



Prior to this project, most studies of impact crater formation used models or experiments where the target material was uniform and the impactor strikes perpendicular to the target surface. In reality, such events are extremely unlikely to occur on Earth; oblique impacts are far more common than near-vertical impacts, and almost nowhere on the Earth can its near-subsurface be considered uniform (for example, 70% of the Earth's surface is covered by water). Using a new, efficient 3D numerical impact model, this research has shown the important influence that both impact angle and surface properties can have on the consequences of impact, such as crater size, shape, and subsurface structure, as well as heating, melt production, and the fate of the asteroid. This knowledge is of direct benefit in the identification of impact structures, in the use of crater morphology to infer the near-surface structure of inaccessible planets, such as Mars, and in connecting large impacts to mass extinctions events. Through the numerical simulation of the Chicxulub crater, in particular, this work has provided new and improved predictions of the consequences of the most important impact in Earth's history and reaffirmed the causal link between the Chicxulub impact and the KPg mass extinction.



Large water waves generated by earthquakes, large landslides and meteorite impacts were also investigated in this research. 2D & 3D numerical simulations of landslide-generated and earthquake waves accurately reproduced both controlled laboratory experiments and observational data from historical wave height records. As well as quantifying the hazard of impact generated waves (http://impact.ese.ic.ac.uk), this research is of direct benefit in assessing the hazard to the UK posed by potential large subaerial slides from the Canary Islands and massive submarine landslides from the Arctic. For example, the Storegga landslide that occurred 8,200 years ago offshore Norway and now covers an area larger than Scotland generated a tsunami that ran up to heights of 3 to 6 metres along the UK coastline. There are few other natural processes that could cause as much damage to the UK, making imperative the need to fully understand both how such slides fail and what controls the size of the waves generated.
Exploitation Route iSALE model development has also engaged industrial partners. 3D numerical modelling of dynamic impact processes has obvious and important industrial and defence applications. During this research the PI has enhanced a working relationship with AWE (Atomic Weapons Establishment), which has led to funding of a PhD project on iSALE model developement (began May 2011) and a benchmarking exercise between iSALE and AWE codes, which has led to a publication in a conference proceeding (April 2012). Advances in the understanding of impact cratering stemming from this research are of benefit to scientists studying the consequences of impacts on Earth, such as microbiologists investigating the habitability of impact craters for primitive life, geologists studying hydrothermal circulation in craters, and paleontologists investigating the KT mass extinction. Impact cratering is a ubiquitous process in the solar system; many areas of planetary science will also benefit from this research, from those using crater morphology as an indicator of near-subsurface rheology to those attempting to relate lunar crater size- frequency distributions to the observed population of Near-Earth Objects.



Decision makers and scientists alike should benefit from the quantification of the hazard posed by tsunamis from landslides and impacts that are outcomes of this research. Cost-effective investment in coastal defence and evacuation strategy depends critically on accurate assessment of these natural hazards, as does interpretation of suspected tsunamis deposits in the geologic record.



The three-dimensional modelling tools developed for simulating impacts and other natural hazards have many potential applications in addition to those examined in this project. The models, both iSALE and Fluidity, can easily be adapted for many engineering applications, from coastal engineering to impact engineering. The technology developed as part of this work is transferable to many fields of computer science and computational physics, and of interest to model developers in many fields.
Sectors Environment

URL http://impact.ese.ic.ac.uk
 
Description Planetary Origins and Evolution at Imperial (2016-2019)
Amount £879,190 (GBP)
Funding ID ST/N000803/1 
Organisation Science and Technologies Facilities Council (STFC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 04/2016 
End 03/2019
 
Title iSALE shock physics code 
Description iSALE (impact-SALE) is a multi-material, multi-rheology shock physics code for simulating high speed impacts and other violent geophysical phenomena. iSALE includes constitutive and porous-compaction models specifically developed for impact simulations. The code is being continually developed, improved and maintained by research groups at the Museum für Naturkunde, Berlin and Imperial College London. 
Type Of Technology Software 
Year Produced 2006 
Open Source License? Yes  
Impact iSALE has been used in pioneering studies of the formation of large impact craters on the Earth and the influence of target property variations on crater formation, the influence of a water layer on crater formation, as well as investigating the mobility of large rock avalanches.The software has been extensively validated against laboratory experiments and used to show, for the first time in numerical simulations, the important effect of friction and porosity on crater growth in granular materials. 
URL http://www.isale-code.github.io
 
Description Chicxulub Impact 
Form Of Engagement Activity A press release, press conference or response to a media enquiry/interview
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact A Science article that I co-wrote, describing evidence that a meteorite impact was the cause of the KT mass extinction and the demise of the dinosaurs was widely reported by various media sources, including newspapers, TV and radio.

I received many emails from the general public with questions about the impact. In addition, my Impact Effects web page, received a large increase in visits.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2010
URL http://www3.imperial.ac.uk/portal/page/portallive/people/g.collins/media
 
Description Impact: Earth! 
Form Of Engagement Activity A magazine, newsletter or online publication
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact As part of this Fellowship and in collaboration with international colleagues I updated my very successful, interactive web program for estimating the consequences of impacts on Earth [http://impact.ese.ic.ac.uk]; from the size of the crater and the probability of such an event occurring, to the speed of the winds from the blast wave and thermal radiation from the hot vapour plume. Users of the site include the general public and scientific community, from primary and secondary school children, through university undergraduates, to professional scientists and journalists. Recent improvements include a new, more visual interface, additional features (such as predictions of tsnumai wave heights) and projection of damage contours onto Google Earth.

The release of our updated web program was front-page news on the BBC website and received widespread media attention, e.g.:



BBC http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-11685803

USA Today http://content.usatoday.com/communities/sciencefair/post/2010/11/asteroid-impact-calculator/1

Time http://www.time.com/time/health/article/0,8599,2029288,00.html

Science http://news.sciencemag.org/sciencenow/2010/11/scienceshot-destroy-earth-from.html?ref=hp
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity Pre-2006,2006,2007,2008,2009,2010,2011,2012,2013,2014,2015,2016,2017,2018,2019,2020,2021
URL http://impact.ese.ic.ac.uk