Pliocene history of the Indian Monsoon: new data from IODP Expedition 353

Lead Research Organisation: UNIVERSITY OF EXETER
Department Name: Camborne School of Mines

Abstract

It is important to understand how Earth's climate varied during past periods of higher atmospheric CO2, so we can better predict how the climate might evolve in the near future due to human activity. Of particular concern is the future behaviour of the Asian Monsoon, which in the modern world provides water for, and influences the lives of, billions of people. The response of the monsoons to higher CO2 and global temperatures is unknown, but latest modelling results suggest that the summer monsoon will get stronger and more prolonged, raising the possibility of severe and widespread flooding, as seen in India in 2013 and Pakistan in 2015.

Past temperature and rainfall patterns associated with the Indian Monsoon can be reconstructed by studying marine sediments recovered from deep-sea cores in the basins surrounding the Indian subcontinent. New sediment cores have been recovered from the NW Indian Ocean region, including the Bay of Bengal and the Andaman Sea, during International Ocean Discovery Program (IODP) Expedition 353 (Dec 2014-Jan 2015). The aim of this expedition is to try and understand the past behaviour of the Indian Monsoon from the Holocene to the late Miocene (present day to 10 million years ago), by taking cores in a part of the Indian Ocean that has never been scientifically drilled before. By examining the geochemistry and microfossil content of the sedimentary cores, and indeed the composition of the sediments themselves, many interesting features of the ancient ocean and monsoons that influence them can be reconstructed.

For the overarching project, we propose to examine the geochemistry and sedimentology of sediments from two sites cored during IODP Exp. 353, Sites U1445 of the NE coast of India and Site U1448 in the Andaman Sea, with the aim of reconstructing the rainfall and temperature patterns associated with the Indian Monsoon during the enigmatic Pliocene period (~5.4-2.6 million years ago). This time period was the most recent in Earth's history where atmospheric CO2 levels were similar to those predicted for our near future, and so it may be a good model for predicting how the Asian monsoons will behave as the Earth heats up in the coming century. By taking sediment samples of Pliocene age and applying sophisticated organic geochemical techniques, we will reconstruct the sea surface temperature (SST) and the rainfall intensity at very high resolution, which will increase our understanding of how the monsoon affected the Indian during a time of great global environmental change. Using this new organic geochemistry data, we will be able to see how the Indian monsoons responded to repeated heating and cooling cycles (glacials and interglacials) triggered by the change in Earth's orbit around the sun.

Specifically in this grant, we first need to determine exactly how old the sediments are before we can apply the organic geochemistry techniques. To do this we will generate stable oxygen isotope data from the shells of microfossils (foraminifera), which we can then compare to a global reference set that has been calibrated to orbital-forcing, in order to generate an "orbitally-tuned" aged model. This age model will be the foundation block on which all subsequent data, and our deeper understanding of the Indian Monsoon, is built.

Planned Impact

The overarching project will create impact beyond the academic community, in both the world of policy and outreach (see Pathways to Impact).

The Indian monsoon provides water for drinking, washing and irrigation for billions of people, but can also bring devastating floods or droughts depending on its strength and duration from year to year. Therefore, understanding its stability in the coming centuries in the context of a warming climate is of utmost concern. During the warm Pliocene, when CO2 levels were the same as they currently are in 2015 (~400 ppmv), sea level was 20 m higher and the world was on average 3-4C warmer. Therefore, the Pliocene study outlined in this proposal will add to our knowledge of the past behaviour of the monsoons under similar conditions to those of our very near future, which will help scientists to ground-truth their predictive models for monsoon strength under anthropogenic conditions. These predictions are important for policy makers, who must decide how best to mitigate the effects of changing monsoonal rain patterns over the countries of southern Asia. The consequences of continuing emissions over the coming century should be taken into account by policy makers when considering where to set caps on emissions and which emission scenario industrialised countries should seek to follow.

This project will also have impact in the sphere of public outreach, through the PIs involvement with local schools, higher education institutes and the wider public. During the expedition Dr Littler maintained a blog (http://deepseadiscovery.wordpress.com/), which detailed the goals and achievements of the cruise, as well as the nitty-gritty of what it is like to live and work at sea for months on end as a research scientist. Dr Littler has continued to make updates to the blog during the onshore sampling party and beyond into the research phase of the project, in order to give followers an insight into the life-cycle of a large multifaceted research project. While at sea, Dr Littler led two Skype seminars with students at the Camborne School of Mines and Geography Department, University of Exeter, and with the Department of Earth Sciences at the University of Oxford. This allowed students to gain a first-hand look at how science is done at sea and encouraged them to appreciate the valuable insights into past climates that scientific ocean drilling affords us. Dr Littler was also involved with several Skype seminars with primary and secondary schools whilst at sea, in collaboration with the onboard educators. Upon returning to dry land in 2015, Dr Littler has resumed the outreach work she carries out with local schools in Cornwall, armed with new photographs, videos and materials collected during her time on Expedition 353, and will continue to do this through the lifetime of this grant.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description This short grant was intended to help with the initial processing of the sediment samples from IODP Expedition 353, and to generate oxygen isotope data to assist with the age model. All of the samples we set out to process (freeze-dry, wash, sieve) have been processed by the undergraduate workers I was able to hire as part of this grant. The washed samples were sent to my co-supervised PhD student, Ms. Yasmin Bokhari-Friberg at the Open University, who completed the process of picking the benthic foraminifera and generated the oxygen isotope data (in collaboration with Prof. Melanie Leng at NIGL). This data has now been used to build an orbital age model for this site, and has been deposited with NERC (embargoed until 2022). This age model will be built upon in subsequent studies to better understand the Indian monsoon during the Pliocene. So although there are no tangible published "outcomes" at this time, the grant has been used successfully to further our understanding of the age model of these cores, as set out in the grant proposal.
Additionally, the award was also used to generate XRF elemental data from IODP Site U1448. This data is currently being analysed and shows some very interesting cyclicty and long-term trends in monsoon-sensitive parameters. Further work will build on this record.
Exploitation Route This initial data is being used by my PhD students (Bokhari Friberg, Gan, Young), in my group to build on our knowledge of Indian monsoon variability during the initiation of Northern Hemisphere Glaciation at the close of the Pliocene. it is the foundational work on which all the other palaeoclimate reconstruction work for this site hinges. It will be these subsequent projects and studentships rather than this small pump-priming grant, which will deliver tangible outcomes of use to the wider community.
Sectors Other

 
Description PhD studentship: Tracking the ancient Indian monsoon: investigating the geochemistry of deep-sea sediments from the Bay of Bengal and Andaman Sea
Amount £85,000 (GBP)
Funding ID 690039558 
Organisation Natural Environment Research Council 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 09/2019 
End 03/2023
 
Description Open University and BGS collaboration 
Organisation British Geological Survey
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Funds associated with this award has been used to build a new collaboration with Dr Pallavi Anand and Dr Phil Sexton at the Open University (OU) through the co-supervision of Miss Yasmin Bokhari Friberg's PhD project (2016-2021). Specifically, funds were used to wash and process sediment from International Ocean Discovery Program (IODP) Site U1445 at the University of Exeter (UoE), in preparation for analysing the benthic/ planktic foraminifera contained within. In further collaboration with Prof. Melanie Leng at the British Geological Survey Isotope Geoscience Laboratory (NEIF), the funds were used to pay for benthic foraminiferal oxygen isotope data from IODP Site U1445 sediments spanning the late Pliocene and early Pleistocene. This data is fundamental to underpinning the age model which all of Yasmin's additional geochemical data is built on, and as such it will underpin the subsequent publication(s) that are currently in prep. This grant and ensuing data also provided the springboard for the subsequent successful application to NEIF in September 2020 (NEIF number: 2305.0920) to generate the age model for the U1448 sister site.
Collaborator Contribution Dr Pallavi Anand is the primary supervisor for Miss Bokhari Friberg's PhD project, and Dr Phil Sexton is the secondary supervisor. As such, they have day to day responsibility for overseeing this aspect of the project and for guiding Yasmin to a successful completion of her PhD. Miss Bokhari Friberg picked the majority of the benthic foraminifera from the IODP Site U1445 samples (Kate Littler picked other samples at the UoE) and was responsible for the analysis of the samples at the NIGL under the supervision of Prof. Melanie Leng. Dr Anand and Dr Leng are now also the co-supervisors on a related NERC-funded PhD studentship (Miss Chloe Young, University of Exeter, 2019-2023) and a Chinese Scholarship Council-funded PhD studentship (Mr Jinrong Gan, University of Exeter, 2019-2023) both of whom are investigating the Indian monsoon using the Exp 353 material.
Impact Miss Bokhari Friberg has presented her dataset ("Reconstructing Indian Summer Monsoon variability during the late Pliocene") at several conferences and meetings including: - UKIODP conference, UK, 2016. - IODP Exp. 353 Post-cruise Science Meeting, India, 2018 - Chapman Conference on the Evolution of the Monsoon, Biosphere and Mountain Building in Cenozoic Asia, Jan 2020 Further publications will arise from both Yasmin's work (near completion) and the work of the linked PhD studentships to Gan and Young.
Start Year 2016
 
Description Open University and BGS collaboration 
Organisation Open University
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Funds associated with this award has been used to build a new collaboration with Dr Pallavi Anand and Dr Phil Sexton at the Open University (OU) through the co-supervision of Miss Yasmin Bokhari Friberg's PhD project (2016-2021). Specifically, funds were used to wash and process sediment from International Ocean Discovery Program (IODP) Site U1445 at the University of Exeter (UoE), in preparation for analysing the benthic/ planktic foraminifera contained within. In further collaboration with Prof. Melanie Leng at the British Geological Survey Isotope Geoscience Laboratory (NEIF), the funds were used to pay for benthic foraminiferal oxygen isotope data from IODP Site U1445 sediments spanning the late Pliocene and early Pleistocene. This data is fundamental to underpinning the age model which all of Yasmin's additional geochemical data is built on, and as such it will underpin the subsequent publication(s) that are currently in prep. This grant and ensuing data also provided the springboard for the subsequent successful application to NEIF in September 2020 (NEIF number: 2305.0920) to generate the age model for the U1448 sister site.
Collaborator Contribution Dr Pallavi Anand is the primary supervisor for Miss Bokhari Friberg's PhD project, and Dr Phil Sexton is the secondary supervisor. As such, they have day to day responsibility for overseeing this aspect of the project and for guiding Yasmin to a successful completion of her PhD. Miss Bokhari Friberg picked the majority of the benthic foraminifera from the IODP Site U1445 samples (Kate Littler picked other samples at the UoE) and was responsible for the analysis of the samples at the NIGL under the supervision of Prof. Melanie Leng. Dr Anand and Dr Leng are now also the co-supervisors on a related NERC-funded PhD studentship (Miss Chloe Young, University of Exeter, 2019-2023) and a Chinese Scholarship Council-funded PhD studentship (Mr Jinrong Gan, University of Exeter, 2019-2023) both of whom are investigating the Indian monsoon using the Exp 353 material.
Impact Miss Bokhari Friberg has presented her dataset ("Reconstructing Indian Summer Monsoon variability during the late Pliocene") at several conferences and meetings including: - UKIODP conference, UK, 2016. - IODP Exp. 353 Post-cruise Science Meeting, India, 2018 - Chapman Conference on the Evolution of the Monsoon, Biosphere and Mountain Building in Cenozoic Asia, Jan 2020 Further publications will arise from both Yasmin's work (near completion) and the work of the linked PhD studentships to Gan and Young.
Start Year 2016
 
Description University of Kiel 
Organisation University of Kiel
Country Germany 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution The NERC award paid for XRF elemental data to be generated from the IODP Site U1448 cores of Pliocene age, in collaboration with Prof. Wolfgang Kuhnt at the University of Kiel, Germany. This data is currently being worked up by my PhD student, Mr Jinrong Gan (funded by University of Exeter, 2019-2023) and will be published once the associated d18O age model is complete (separate NEIF award - data being generated in April 2021).
Collaborator Contribution Prof. Kuhnt oversaw the generation of the data at Kiel. He will be involved with subsequent publications that arise from this data, in the context of additional data collection that is ongoing. Mr Jinrong Gan (University of Exeter) will lead this publication as part of his PhD studies.
Impact There are currently no publications arising from this collaboration, as the data needs to be viewed in the context of an orbital-resolution benthic oxygen isotope age model, which is still under development (separate NEIF award, dataset under construction).
Start Year 2016
 
Description Aliens, atmospheres and ancient climates 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact In June 2016, Dr Kate Littler and Dr Nathan Mayne (Physics, UoE) hosted an evening of talks and discussions at the Penryn Campus, designed to showcase the links between studying the ancient climate of Planet Earth and the strange atmospheres of far-off exoplanets. A variety of different paleoclimate connundrums were discussed, including the behaviour of the Indian monsoon during the Pliocene - directly linked to this award.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016
URL http://emps.exeter.ac.uk/csm/research/globalchange/#a1
 
Description Geography in Action conference 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact Giving a talk entitled "Stories from the ancient seas: Earth's dynamic carbon cycle", to ~800 A Level Geography students in London in Nov 2019. Presented a variety of research including discussing the Indian Monsoon research that this grant has supported.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL https://thetrainingpartnership.org.uk/study-day/geography-in-action-6-11-2019/