COVID 19 - The Hidden Rise in Toxic Air Pollution during the COVID-19 Pandemic: is our response worsening the respiratory burden of particulate matter

Lead Research Organisation: University of Brighton
Department Name: Sch of Environment and Technology

Abstract

Recent research has highlighted the concerning paradigm that reducing ambient concentrations of legislated air pollution, in the form of PM2.5, may lead to a decline in air quality by increasing the concentration of more harmful ultrafine particles (UFP; diameter less than 100nm). It has been shown that PM2.5 plays a crucial role in suppression of UFP numbers, with larger PM2.5 particles acting to scavenge the more toxic UFP from the air. Consequently, removal of PM2.5 as a UFP sink may result in enhanced ambient UFP numbers, particularly if UFP emissions and gaseous precursor concentrations remain unchecked. With the outbreak of the COVID-19 pandemic, anthropogenic activity around the globe has decreased in a vast and unprecedented manner, to such an extent that concentrations of commonly measured primary air pollutants have decreased dramatically. However, levels of secondary pollutants (which often correlate with finest UFP fractions) have already begun to rise. It follows that this sudden, global drop in anthropogenic activity and ambient PM2.5 has the potential to drive an unexpected and potentially significant increase in UFP concentrations and associated detrimental health effects. If we are now inadvertently adding an unlooked-for cardio-respiratory pollutant into the air at a time when many are vulnerable to a virus that impacts the respiratory system, we risk widening the COVID-19 'window of vulnerability', where increased UFP exposure acts to exacerbate underlying conditions for individuals with pre-existing co-morbidities, who may otherwise be considered 'lower risk', and worsen the impact of the virus for those already considered as 'at risk'.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description What were the most significant achievements from the award?
Objective 0 - Preliminary Study (COMPLETED): A preliminary study was conducted prior to collection of project specific ultrafine particle (UFP) data. This study employed an ensemble of measurement and modelling techniques to investigate changes in air quality, atmospheric composition and boundary layer reactivity in the South East of the UK post-lockdown. Results showed that NO2 concentrations had decreased, but O3 concentrations had increased by as much as 15%. It was found that under the hydrocarbon-limited ozone production regime, the total NOx decreased proportionally greater than total non-methane hydrocarbons which led, under clear sky conditions, to an increase in total hydroxyl, peroxy and organic peroxy radicals.
Objective 1 - Network Deployment (COMPLETED): Monitoring stations have been successfully set up in both Brighton and Leicester and are recording data as laid out in the original proposal (collecting UFP and a full range of other air quality parameters).
Objective 2 - Data Analysis (ON-GOING): UFP and air pollution data from Brighton and Leicester have now been recorded, and are 90% ratified. They will be analysed over the next 6-months and will be uploaded to the NERC CEDA data centre. As well as recording data from the dedicated sites in Brighton and Leicester, the project planned to access and analyse freely available data from open networks; data collection, ratification and analysis for these sites is now complete. Initial findings indicate a potential rise in the concentration of the smallest size fractions of ultrafine particles (UFP) during the COVID-19 lockdown period in 2020, particularly during the afternoon between ~12:00 and 16:00. There is some evidence that PM2.5 mass concentration was lower during this time period than previous years, although more analysis is required to conclusively determine if linkages between these two occurrences exist.
Objective 3 - Forecasting UFP timeseries trends (ON-GOING)
Objective 4 - Development of recommendations for decision/policy makers (ON-GOING): Two initial interim reports have been written for presentation to decision makers.

To what extent were the award objectives met? If you can, briefly explain why any key objectives were not met.
Objective 0 - Preliminary Study (COMPLETED)
Objective 1 - Network Deployment (COMPLETED)
Objective 2 - Data Analysis (ONGOING)
Objective 3 - Forecasting UFP timeseries trends (ON-GOING)
Objective 4 - Development of recommendations for decision/policy makers (ON-GOING)

How might the findings be taken forward and by whom?
A series of final recommendations will be drafted and presented to decision makers. These will be useful for policy makers and stakeholders in terms of planning effective emissions reduction strategies in moving forward towards a net-zero future. In particular, the results of this project and the policy guidance will be useful in contributing towards filling the knowledge gap regarding, as yet unlegislated for, ultrafine particles.
Exploitation Route Development of recommendations for decision/policy makers. Two initial interim reports have been written for presentation to decision makers and a final policy recommendations document will be produced. The information presented, particularly in the final recommendations document, will be useful for decision makers and stakeholders in terms of planning effective emissions reduction strategies in moving forward towards a net-zero future. In particular, the results of this project and the policy guidance will be useful in contributing towards filling the knowledge gap regarding, as yet unlegislated for, ultrafine particles.
Sectors Environment

 
Description Is exposure to airborne fine and ultrafine particulate matter a determining factor in COVID-19 infection and outcome within the UK?
Amount £40,068 (GBP)
Funding ID HDRUK2020.142 
Organisation Health Data Research UK 
Sector Private
Country United Kingdom
Start 01/2021 
End 06/2021