Towards forecast-based climate resilience and adaptation in the water sector

Lead Research Organisation: University of Sheffield
Department Name: Civil and Structural Engineering

Abstract

Usual applications of forecasts to resilience assessments in water systems ask the question "What are the benefits of forecasting product X for water system Y?". This project proposes to start asking instead: "What are the forecast characteristics that would increase the resilience of a water system to climate-related risks? what variables? what lead times? and with what accuracy?" Such an approach puts the focus on the needs of forecast users. This will enable water managers, government agencies, and communities, to identify more easily which forecasts would be useful to them. It will also help forecast providers such as the Met Office to focus forecast improvement efforts to areas where they would be most beneficial.

The work as part of this embedded researcher scheme aims to:

A) Start tackling the question of mapping the potential benefits of forecasts depending on their performance, by building a freely available, open-source Python toolbox that does that for a single planned water infrastructure asset (e.g. a storage reservoir with pumps and treatment plant). The toolbox will implement a stress testing procedure to determine which events or combination of events present a risk to the performance of the asset (supply disruption, financial risk, etc.). It will then incorporate a simple synthetic forecast generator to evaluate the ability of forecasts to accurately forewarn of climate-related hazards that can affect system performance. In a final step, the toolbox will be linked with simple multi-objective optimisation algorithms to trade off the benefits of investing in mitigation / adaptation actions to avoid bad performance, vs. the cost of implementing these actions as a result of a false alarm given by the forecast. This will help to understand which forecasts should be used to trigger appropriate mitigation and / or adaptation actions at the asset level, and what forecast precision is required for this.

B) Develop a long-term collaboration between the host organisation Anglian Water (AW) and Dr Charles Rougé (CR). The successful implementation of the open-source Python toolbox, and its application to a key asset in AW's long-term adaptation plans, will only be a first step in that direction. Planned activities during with CR embedded at AW will lead to the submission of grant proposals to extend that work, with AW as key partner and beneficiary.

1) A first proposal will (i) design the next generation of synthetic forecast generators to simulate forecasts for several climate variables at once, with different forecast lead times, while reproducing desired statistical properties (precision, correlation between the different forecasts, etc); and (ii) apply this new synthetic forecast generator to the development of flexible forecast-based adaptation plans where new water infrastructure investments decisions would be triggered not only by climate events but also by the availability of new forecast products with the potential to improve how water systems can be managed. This proposal will be submitted during the project and will have the Met Office as its other key partner.

2) Further work will scope out how forecast-based resilience tools can help to support the further development of strategic water planning models used by water utilities to make long-term adaptation plans. This work will focus on assessing a new functionality of one such model, which enables return flows (effluents from water treatment plants) to vary dynamically as a function of water demand. Representing them would enable to detect unintended consequences of demand management as it may reduce effluent discharges sustaining environmental flows at key locations. Consequences on adaptation depend on forecast supply and demand during drought conditions, as they are projected to evolve in coming years and decades.
 
Description (Outcomes rather than key findings)

1) A new method to systematically explore the relationship between the skill of a forecast (e.g., rainfall, temperature, streamflow) and its value to our water resources (e.g., reduced operational costs, increased water supply availability). Publication in preparation on this.

2) A funded studentship (EPSRC DTP CASE studentship) funded for "Integrating Climate Risk to Reservoir Water Quality into Water Infrastructure Planning". Partner Anglian Water will contribute £32.5k towards the research. The award builds on research done with the partner throughout this award, and will let it flourish as a long-term collaboration.

3) An submitted proposal (EPSRC New Investigator Award, EP/X009459/1) to develop new modelling tools to (i) evaluate the impact of energy transition scenarios on water sector adaptation plans, and (ii) propose altered infrastructure design and / or operational protocols so water resource systems adapt to a radically energy system, as well as climate change and population growth. The award was developed in close collaboration with the project partner, Anglian Water, and its submission was a key planned outcome.
Exploitation Route Key outcomes are grants (submitted or funded) and publications.
The publication from key outcomes (1) will come with open access Python code that can be accessed and put to use by any user. That work has been showcased at 1 international conference and another in May 2022 (see "Other outputs / Outcomes")
Key outcome (2) will develop open source code that can be taken forward by any modeller. Results will be published and presented at international conferences.
Key outcome (3), if funded, will develop new methods for the evaluation of energy impacts in water systems that will be open source (this includes code but also data). Results will be published and presented at international conferences, and other dissemination activities are planned.
Sectors Environment,Other

 
Description EPSRC DTP CASE studentship 2022
Amount £112,936 (GBP)
Funding ID 175347 
Organisation University of Sheffield 
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom
Start 10/2022 
End 09/2026
 
Description Flexible design and operation of water resource systems to tackle the triple challenge of climate change, the energy transition, and population growth
Amount £375,593 (GBP)
Funding ID EP/X009459/1 
Organisation Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 04/2023 
End 03/2026
 
Description Research collaboration on developing new techniques to assess the value of forecasts and forecast improvements. 
Organisation University of Bristol
Department Department of Civil Engineering
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution I developed a new technique to systematically explore the relationship between the skill of a forecast and its value to decision makers. After presenting that technique at vEGU2021 (annual meeting of the European Geosciences Union, see "Generating families of synthetic forecasts of different skills from an existing forecast product" in "Ohter outputs/ Outcomes"), I contacted my collaborators who have an ideal case-study to illustrate this technique. We are finalising a publication which I am leading. The application will
Collaborator Contribution Dr Francesca Pianosi (Senior lecturer, U Bristol) and Dr Andres Penuela (U Cordoba, Spain, formerly PDRA at U Bristol with Dr Pianosi) published a paper https://hess.copernicus.org/articles/24/6059/2020/ that presents a framework for assessing the value of an existing forecast. This framework is applied to the case of a water resource system in the UK. The collaborators contribute the modelling infrastructure from that paper to our collaboration (model of water system & code). This serves as an application to the methodology I developed. The method + application is the topic of a publication in preparation for a special issue of the Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management.
Impact Abstract for EGU2022 (see "Other outputs / outcomes"), and a publication is in preparation as an outcome to this collaboration.
Start Year 2021
 
Title charlesrouge/forecast_families: Zenodo release 
Description Release to upload repository on Zenodo. 
Type Of Technology Software 
Year Produced 2022 
Open Source License? Yes  
Impact This repository presents the source code, along with a Jupyter Notebook demo, for the "forecast families" methodology presented in the paper by C. Rougé, A. Peñuela and F. Pianosi: "Forecast families: a new method to systematically evaluate the benefits of improving the skill of an existing forecast" published to the Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management at doi:10.1061/JWRMD5.WRENG-5934 
URL https://zenodo.org/record/7327755
 
Description UK Climate Resilience webinar 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Webinar to describe the otucomes of the research project, with industrial partner Dr Geoff Darch (Anglian Water) providing a response to my presentation. This sparked a series of questions from the audience.
158 registrants, about half showed up. 76 view for video put online on Youtube (as of 14 Feb 2023)
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
URL https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WmBG3C_82I8