acceleratAR

Lead Research Organisation: University of Liverpool
Department Name: Physics

Abstract

We aim to bring some of the most positive aspects of the experience of visiting the Daresbury Laboratory to the pupils who don't attend out current public engagement events (incuding the Particle Phsics Masterclass, PPMC). In recent years there have been significant developments in virtual and augmented reality (VR and AR), with 2016 being labelled as a breakthrough year for the technology. We will use these developments to deliver an interactive and immersive experience of particle accelerators to classrooms and living rooms across the UK and beyond. By doing this, we hope to make our work accessible to pupils irrespective of geographical location or socioeconomic background, improving the understanding young people have of science and promoting the opportunity of a career in STEM subjects to all.

The annual Daresbury PPMC gives 250 A-level students the opportunity to explore particle accelerator facilities and gain hands on experience as they carry out short experiments. Importantly, they are given insight into the applications and societal benefits of the science they learn at school and meet scientists who may serve as role models, showing pupils the path to a career in science. We aim to offer similar opportunities to GCSE aged pupils through an AR/VR app.

Each year close to 50000 pupils take GCSE science exams (Department for Education). These pupils will be making decisions on further education that will determine their career path, decisions which are influenced by socioeconomic inequalities (www.suttontrust.com/newsarchive/supporting-stem/) and likely to be influenced by a shortage of teachers with specialist subject knowledge (www.nao.org.uk/report/training-new-teachers/). By producing educational, engaging and interactive AR and VR content that is differentiated for a range of abilities and accessible through Android and iOS handheld devices, we can provide a highly tech literate generation of pupils with the benefits of insight into a specialist subject, without requiring specialist knowledge from a teacher.

The app we produce as part of this project will be tested in 24 schools (25% of which should be classed as under-performing), engaging approximately 4000 pupils. We hope to show, by using before/after questionnaires, that pupils have a better understanding of the work of scientists at STFC's Daresbury Laboratory (as well as at key partner universities, including the Universities of Liverpool, Manchester, Lancaster and Strathclyde) and of the physics involved. Beyond this, the app will be free to download from the internet and from Android Play Store and iTunes, and will be promoted through public engagement events and teams; the potential for engaging with a much larger number of people is significant.

One of the main activities planned will allow pupils to build a particle accelerator (albeit a virtual one) in their classroom. Pupils will also be given insight into local accelerators including ALICE, VELA and CLARA as well the contribution of UK scientists to large collaborations such as the LHC. Simple modifications will allow materials to be tailored for use within school environments, at exhibitions and by anyone with a general interest in science.

Other key aims of the project include:
* providing early stage PhD students with the opportunity to develop skills in communicating their work to a range of audiences whilst also developing skills relevant to the scientific aspect of their studies.
* offering PhD students as role models, helping to showcase the diversity of the people who work in STFC funded science, and showing pupils potential pathways to a career in science.

Planned Impact

The resources produced by this project will mainly be software that is free to download from the Cockcroft Institute website, Google Play Store and iTunes. A significant number of the pupils that we initially engage will be taught at the 24 initial partner schools. Beyond this, the number of people engaged by our project is dependent upon how effectively we raise awareness rather than a limitation on the availability of any resource.

Members of public engagement teams at Daresbury Laboratory, the Universities of Liverpool and within ASTeC have already expressed support for this project: Phill Day, public engagement manager at Daresbury, believes that the acceleratAR project would contribute to the national labs public engagement team objective of incorporating technology into the delivery of outreach; assistance in the testing of educational software has been offered by staff at the University of Liverpool's Central Teaching Laboratory; applicants Lee Jones and Rob Appleby are responsible for public engagement at the Cockcroft Institute (with Lee also being responsible for public engagement within ASTeC). We will work closely with these interested parties to ensure that awareness of the project is raised through their contacts within schools and other public engagement teams. The initial partner school will also be identified through these connections.

The Cockcroft Institute contributes to a number of public engagement events, including the Big Bang fair which welcomed 80000 visitors in 2015, we will use these events as a further opportunity to raise awareness of the project with members of the public and fellow scientists, educators and communicators.
Teaching others the skills necessary to produce AR and VR outreach materials is one of the main aims of this project. Initially, this teaching will be aimed at Cockcroft Institute members. However, if the project proves successful, then we would be very interested in extending the reach of teaching. Strong relationships exist between the Cockcroft Institute, Rutherford Appleton Laboratory, John Adams Institute and Universities of Strathclyde and Huddersfield, amongst others, these connections could offer opportunities to further extend the scope of the project.

Since its release in 2011, the STFC funded Android app LHSee has been downloaded more than 50000 times from the Android Play Store. We estimate our initial target audience to be 8000 people; approximately 4000 pupils made up of year 10 and 11 pupils at the 20 partner schools and a further 4000 reached through other public engagement activities. We will look to the successful LHSee app as an example when marketing our own app.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Title acceleratAR 
Description accleratAR is an augmented reality app that allows members of the public to build their own desktop particle using paper cubes. The current public version features a particle source, dipole/quadrupole magnets and an rf cavity. 
Type Of Technology Software 
Year Produced 2017 
Impact The app has been downloaded 600 times, and we know that in many of these cases the app has been used by teachers as a demonstration in lessons (further extending the reach). The app is regularly used to support STFC/Cockcroft Institute activities at events including the Big Bang. The app is aimed at improving public understanding of STFC funded work. Evaluation of the second version of this app (currently being prepared) will seek to understand the impact of the app on public understanding of and attitudes towards particle accelerator research. 
URL http://www.acceleratar.uk/
 
Description Participation in an activity, workshop or similar - Schools sessions 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact The Interaction Point spin-off project that was developed alongside Liverpool arts organisation, FACT (with additional funding through University of Liverpool's Knowledge Exchange and Innovation fund), has continued. This project has involved deep engagement with three groups of young people (15 young people per group for 9 sessions each), who have taken part in a series of STEAM workshops. For this aspect of the project we are working with a primary and two secondary schools that have a high proportion of pupil premium pupils and are in some of the most deprived areas in the UK. The project artists are completing a series of videos that will be used alongside the Tunnels launch.
The young people involved have indicated a positive change in their attitude towards physics.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
URL https://www.fact.co.uk/interaction-point
 
Description Big Bang North West 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact Working along STFC's Daresbury Public Engagement team we introduced The Tale of Two Tunnels to a mostly school based audience at the Big Bang North West. At this event we aimed to introduce physics research to a school audience, to raise awareness of the Two Tunnels project and to get initial audience input to the science trail design. University of Livepool researchers Chris Edmonds and and a team of PhD and undergraduate students engaged the public with activities that explored the working of particle accelerators and their application to nuclear, medical and particle physics. We worked alongside Liverpool arts organisation, FACT, to deliver STEAM based activities. We engaged with 1826 young people, students and teachers.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
 
Description Schools sessions - ongoing 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact 95 children have so far contributed to The Tale of Two Tunnels at schools sessions.
Earlier sessions involved a 30 min research talk on the topics of particle accelerator physics (led by Chris Edmonds) or the application of accelerators to nuclear and particle physics (led by Laura Harkness-Brennan and Barry King respectively). This was followed by an arts activity led by a project artist (with the aim of gaining insight into the young people's understanding of and aspirations for physics research).

Conversations surrounding these sessions led to a developing relationship with the learning team of a local arts organisation (FACT) and a spin off project called Interaction Point (with addition funding through University of Liverpool's Knowledge Exchange and Innovation fund). This ongoing project involves deep engagement with three groups of young people (15 young people per group for 9 sessions each), which is investigating a deep engagement of young people with physics research through a STEAM approach to learning.
For this aspect of the project we are working with a primary and two secondary schools that have a high proportion of pupil premium pupils and are in some of the most deprived areas in the UK.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018,2019
 
Description Talking Science 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Talking Science event organised by STFC public engagement team, hosted at University of Liverpool.
The 2 hour event introduced The Tale of Two Tunnels to a public audience and involved the audience in a co-design process for the final science trail. The event was divided into three phases -
- A 45 minute talk that introduced particle accelerator, particle and nuclear physics research (with the talks delivered by Liverpool academic Chris Edmonds, Laura Harkness-Brennan and Barry King).
- Hands on demonstrations led by PhD students. These activities (including acceleratAR) were designed to deepen understanding in the research areas covered by the talks and to provide a space for the audience to engage with researchers on a one to one basis.
-An arts session (led by Neil Winterburn of the FACT learning team) were the audience could reflect upon the scientific content of the event and design an experiment for the future. A key goal of this activity was to identify what messages from the talks and hands on sessions had been most important to the audience and to gain insight into what aspirations the audience has for physics research.

The conversations held between researchers and the audience and outputs from the arts activities are influencing the design of the science trail.

51 people attended the event in person.
The event was covered by local printed and online media (including the Liverpool Echo and Art In Liverpool) extending the reach.
The project PI was interviewed on BBC radio Merseyside's breakfast show on the morning of the event.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
URL https://www.artinliverpool.com/going-underground-liverpool-residents-invited-to-take-part-in-unique-...
 
Description acceleratAR use in public activities 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact acceleratAR is an augmented reality particle accelerator that aims to make some accelerator physics concepts accessible to a general audience. Users can gain insight into the purpose of the long chains of components they see in photos of the LHC and other particle accelerators.
acceleratAR has been used in formal and informal settings for learning across the globe.
Some examples include:
- bluedot festival (2973 engaged)
- Tale of Two Tunnels public sessions
- Physics of Star Wars event at Daresbury Laboratory
- FACT's (a Liverpool based art organisation) Young at Art (over 60s) group
- undergraduate and postgraduate teaching
Communications regarding use of the app at events at the following labs/universities have taken place :
-CERN
-Royal Holloway University
-Universidad de Peurto Rico
-Brazilian Synchrotron Light Laboratory
-Autonomous University of Sinaloa
-Ankara University
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018,2019
URL https://www.popsci.com/best-science-apps#page-9