Transport and Ageing: An Examination into Digitally Enabled Flexible Public Transport Services and the Opportunities and Barriers for Older Citizens

Lead Research Organisation: University College London
Department Name: Centre for Advanced Spatial Analysis

Abstract

The focus of this research project is to examine the role and value of new modes of digitally enabled Flexible Public Transport Services (here after FTS) within the context of a deregulated transport market in Oxford, UK. Specifically, this PhD will examine the new Demand Responsive Transport service - PickmeUp - operated by Oxford Bus Company and in relation to the existing fixed route bus services in deprived areas of Oxford with low-car occupancy. Special attention will be given to the impact and roles of this new type of service and how it will impact the lives of vulnerable citizens, such as the elderly. The project will also aim to understand the impact of this service on policy and community transport services from a local authority perspective; for example, in relation to evidence that could determine whether such new services should be eligible or supported with funds for concessionary travel. The project will be divided into three sequential phases: 1) Using participatory methodology - Delphi method - to determine what matters to people in their daily lives in relation to transport and mobility. The aim of which is to first determine a set of people-orientated indicators to examine the DRT service in phase 2, but also to compare this localised survey with existing National Household Transport surveys. 2. Phase 2 will involve a spatial and temporal analysis of 1 year's worth of DRT ridership in Oxford. Using the findings from phase 1 and 2, the final phase of the PhD aims to synthesise the first two phases and assess how such learnings can be used to support specific Community Transport policy decisions (Section 19/22), as well as how this service fits in to the wider debate around transport and ageing. This PhD research adopts a mixed methods approach: qualitative public and private sector engagement activities and desk-based review of literature, as well as quantitative approaches for analysis of anonymised bus ridership and aggregated transport data.

Main Research Questions:

What matters to older citizens in their daily lives in relation to transport and mobility in their neighbourhood?
How does the existing fixed routed public transport service in Oxford meet the needs of older/vulnerable citizens?
How does the new Flexible Public Transport Service in Oxford meet the unfulfilled needs of older/vulnerable citizens?


Novel Methods/Approaches:

1. a) A novel approach using the Delphi technique to develop transport/mobility indicators based on what people value in their daily lives, b) a localised transport study - new data
2. New DRT ridership dataset - exclusive assess from Oxford Bus Company which will add to knowledge of previous studies that use synthetic data.
3. Real world DRT data (anonymised) to compare with existing public transport (fixed route); ridership, destinations, time of travel, cost of travel reimbursement cost of concessionary travel)


Alignment with EPSRC:

Within the EPSRC's themes of the 'built environment' and 'infrastructure and urban systems', this PhD will undertake research under the following strategic themes: the built environment and public health, by focusing on design for wellbeing and inclusivity. Infrastructure and urban systems - improving the performance, capacity and connectivity of transport networks; a holistic view of cities and their systems, including dependencies between them and critical infrastructure. This research can also be strongly linked to the themes of Healthcare technologies, and Digital Economy (sub-themes of 'value creation and capture', 'data, information and knowledge').

Publications

10 25 50

Studentship Projects

Project Reference Relationship Related To Start End Student Name
EP/N509577/1 30/09/2016 24/03/2022
1936499 Studentship EP/N509577/1 08/10/2017 08/12/2025 Paul Mullins
EP/R513143/1 30/09/2018 29/09/2023
1936499 Studentship EP/R513143/1 08/10/2017 08/12/2025 Paul Mullins
EP/W524335/1 30/09/2022 29/09/2028
1936499 Studentship EP/W524335/1 08/10/2017 08/12/2025 Paul Mullins
 
Description Public Sector -Need to revise how concession card data is stored and processed to allow for interrogation and gain insights in an efficient and timely manner.
First Year Of Impact 2019
Sector Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software),Government, Democracy and Justice,Transport
Impact Types Policy & public services

 
Description Oxford County Council and the usability/fragmentation of Concession Data to make policy and funding decisions - Mobility and community workshop
Geographic Reach Local/Municipal/Regional 
Policy Influence Type Influenced training of practitioners or researchers
 
Title Kantian Delphi Technique: To co-define evaluation outcome indictors based on what people value 
Description Development of a novel methodology, using a the Delphi Technique to co-define with stakeholders an agreed minimum set of indicators of how to evaluate impact based on what people value in their daily lives. Never been used for evaluation outcome indictors. 
Type Of Material Physiological assessment or outcome measure 
Year Produced 2020 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact Method is had been tested and validated in an EU Horizon 2020 project - Cities-4-People and presented to the EU Commission, as part of a mid-review technical presentation: 'Methodology for Developing Core-Outcome-Set of Indicators, 25 Jan, Brussels. 2019. In addition this method has also been adopted by CIVITAS as part of the suite of evaluation methodologies which they endorse in 'Sustainable Urban Mobility Projects'. 
 
Title Oxford Bus Company - new 'PickMeUp' DRT service, anonymised trip dataset 2018/2019 
Description After signing an NDA with Oxford Bus Company, they provided 7 months of anonymised spatial and temporal trip data for the 'PickMeUp' DRT service 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2019 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact The impacts of this model in conjunction with Nation House Hold Travel Survey (NHTS) and NHS performance Outcomes framework will be used to make additional business case evidence between Oxford Bus Company and Oxford County council; from health and wellbeing benefit particularly around supporting concession card usage. 
 
Description International Conference: Urban Transitions: 'Integrating Urban and Transport Planning. Environment and Health for Healthier Urban Living', 25 - 27 November 2018 | Sitges, Barcelona Spain. 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Third sector organisations
Results and Impact Presentation of a new way to co-produce impact indicators at one of largest international conference with a focus on policy/transport/health experts:

The research in this presentation intended to provide a methodological framework to co-develop a common baseline of outcomes -- known as a Core-Outcome-Set (COS) -- regarding what should be measured based on the outcomes valued by citizens. The development of a COS is a key aspect of Cities-4-People (C4P), an EU Horizon 2020 research and innovation project, that aims to implement a pilot program running at five urban and peri-urban areas (Oxford, Hamburg, Budapest, Istanbul, Trikala). To develop the COS, the Delphi Method was chosen as a systematic means to gather opinions from the mobility communities in each city. Two sequential and iterative rounds of Delphi questionnaires were sent out, anonymous responses were aggregated and shared with all participants after each round of consensus building. The Delphi panel consisted of a structured sample of fifteen participants, from across all five EU cities, recruited by the city facilitators utilizing the existing C4P project citizen mobility labs and community structures to ensure a balance of heterogenous participants in each city. The main issues in the study related to the translation of the Delphi questionnaire materials into five different languages; specifically, the potential for information to be misinterpreted and to ensure the nuances of carefully crafted questions were consistent, as well as the pressure of time added to the overall process between rounds. In the context of urban mobility, this people-centred COS methodology provides a new transferable approach to derive evidence based on what citizens value, which can be used alongside existing objective indicators. Such evidence is not only essential for stakeholders engaged in decision making processes, especially in relation to gaining public support, but also for the sustainability of projects by empowering local communities.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018