Bio-inspired sulfide nanocatalysts: From proof of concept to 'real' catalysis
Lead Research Organisation:
CARDIFF UNIVERSITY
Department Name: Chemistry
Abstract
Sustainable energy and climate change are areas of global societal concern, which is a recognised strategic priority area of the RCUK through their Energy Programme, managed by EPSRC. Catalysis, moreover, is the lynchpin of a large number of industrial processes, which are instrumental in maintaining global wealth and health, as well as playing a key role in developing processes that are both environmentally and economically sustainable.
Despite the high thermodynamic stability of CO2, biological systems are capable of both activating the molecule and converting it into a range of organic molecules, all of which under moderate conditions. It is clear that, if we were able to emulate Nature and successfully convert CO2 into fuel or useful chemical intermediates without the need for extreme reaction conditions, the benefits would be enormous: One of the major gases responsible for climate change would become an important feedstock for the fuel, chemical and pharmaceutical industries!
Iron-nickel sulfide membranes formed in the warm, alkaline springs on the Archaean ocean floor are increasingly considered to be the early catalysts for a series of chemical reactions leading to the emergence of life. The anaerobic production of acetate, formaldehyde, amino acids and the nucleic acid bases - the organic precursor molecules of life - are thought to have been catalyzed by small cubane (Fe,Ni)S clusters (for example Fe5NiS8), which are structurally similar to the surfaces of present day sulfide minerals such as greigite (Fe3S4) and mackinawite (FeS).
Contemporary confirmation of the importance of sulfide clusters as catalysts is provided by a number of proteins essential to modern anaerobic life forms, such as ferredoxins, hydrogenases, carbon monoxide dehydrogenase (CODH) or acetylcoenzyme A synthetase (ACS), all of which retain cubane (Fe,Ni)S clusters with a greigite-like local structure, either as electron transfer sites or as active sites to metabolise volatiles such as H2, CO and CO2.
In Phase 1 of the project, we have used a comprehensive combination of computational, synthetic and electrochemical expertise to mimic Nature and produce Fe-S and Ni-doped Fe-S nanoparticles to catalyse the conversion of CO2. Careful and sensitive testing of the computationally designed materials, prepared through novel synthesis routes, has shown unequivocably that the nanoparticles have the power to adsorb CO2 and reduce it to formic acid - a useful chemical intermediate. A particularly promising aspect is that the catalytic conversion of CO2 takes place at room pressure and temperature and at the sort of low voltages that could be obtained from solar energy, thus making it a sustainable process. Following this success, in Phase 2 of the project we aim to optimise the catalysts to improve yield and adapt for further product formation e.g. methanol, acetate and, eventually, dimethyl ether (DME) - all proven pre-cursors to fuels and fine chemicals - and to develop materials and processes that are robust enough to perform under 'real' conditions.
Work in this area, in collaboration with a number of industrial partners, requires the dove-tailed interplay of experiment and computation to design, synthesise, characterise and catalytically test the potential transition metal-sulfide nano-catalysts, followed by scale-up of the nanoparticle production and evalulation in an industrial environment. The aim at the end of Phase 2 is to have created a commercially viable catalytic system for CO2 reduction, that performs in an industrially relevant environment.
Despite the high thermodynamic stability of CO2, biological systems are capable of both activating the molecule and converting it into a range of organic molecules, all of which under moderate conditions. It is clear that, if we were able to emulate Nature and successfully convert CO2 into fuel or useful chemical intermediates without the need for extreme reaction conditions, the benefits would be enormous: One of the major gases responsible for climate change would become an important feedstock for the fuel, chemical and pharmaceutical industries!
Iron-nickel sulfide membranes formed in the warm, alkaline springs on the Archaean ocean floor are increasingly considered to be the early catalysts for a series of chemical reactions leading to the emergence of life. The anaerobic production of acetate, formaldehyde, amino acids and the nucleic acid bases - the organic precursor molecules of life - are thought to have been catalyzed by small cubane (Fe,Ni)S clusters (for example Fe5NiS8), which are structurally similar to the surfaces of present day sulfide minerals such as greigite (Fe3S4) and mackinawite (FeS).
Contemporary confirmation of the importance of sulfide clusters as catalysts is provided by a number of proteins essential to modern anaerobic life forms, such as ferredoxins, hydrogenases, carbon monoxide dehydrogenase (CODH) or acetylcoenzyme A synthetase (ACS), all of which retain cubane (Fe,Ni)S clusters with a greigite-like local structure, either as electron transfer sites or as active sites to metabolise volatiles such as H2, CO and CO2.
In Phase 1 of the project, we have used a comprehensive combination of computational, synthetic and electrochemical expertise to mimic Nature and produce Fe-S and Ni-doped Fe-S nanoparticles to catalyse the conversion of CO2. Careful and sensitive testing of the computationally designed materials, prepared through novel synthesis routes, has shown unequivocably that the nanoparticles have the power to adsorb CO2 and reduce it to formic acid - a useful chemical intermediate. A particularly promising aspect is that the catalytic conversion of CO2 takes place at room pressure and temperature and at the sort of low voltages that could be obtained from solar energy, thus making it a sustainable process. Following this success, in Phase 2 of the project we aim to optimise the catalysts to improve yield and adapt for further product formation e.g. methanol, acetate and, eventually, dimethyl ether (DME) - all proven pre-cursors to fuels and fine chemicals - and to develop materials and processes that are robust enough to perform under 'real' conditions.
Work in this area, in collaboration with a number of industrial partners, requires the dove-tailed interplay of experiment and computation to design, synthesise, characterise and catalytically test the potential transition metal-sulfide nano-catalysts, followed by scale-up of the nanoparticle production and evalulation in an industrial environment. The aim at the end of Phase 2 is to have created a commercially viable catalytic system for CO2 reduction, that performs in an industrially relevant environment.
Planned Impact
The research in this project will clearly have impact on:
* Society, by developing effective catalysts for the utilisation of CO2, instead of rapidly dwindling fossil fuel resources, for the production of fuels and chemicals under mild and sustainable reaction conditions, thus assisting in stabilising energy supplies and maintaining our quality of life, as well as alleviating pressure on the environment;
* The Economy, through the design of new (photo)catalytic materials - for commercialisation by catalyst manufacturers - and devices for alternative and sustainable routes to important products. Catalysis is at the heart of the chemical industry - an immensely successful and important part of the overall UK economy, generating in excess of £50 billion per annum.
* Knowledge, both academic and commercial, as the new atomic-level insight into the structure and performance of the active site(s) and the nano-catalysts as a whole - obtained from the computational models, in situ synchrotron experiments and electrochemical screening - will deliver significant advances in catalyst design and optimisation and more widely in materials (nano-)science, and will thus enhance the knowledge base of chemical, energy and other relevant industries;
* People, through the technical expertise developed by the researchers during the project, the training received by them in societal and ethical issues, the fruitful links with industry initiated through the project, and the transferable skills developed in engagement with the media, the general public, policy makers and legislators.
In addition to the obvious benefits to academic researchers in the field (see Academic Beneficiaries section), the research will benefit in particular (i) ) the UK and global commercial sector, but also (ii) the general public, (iii) the public sector, and, more speculatively (iv) voluntary workers and charities.
(i) Commercial sector
Many industrially crucial processes, e.g. the water-gas shift reaction, still take place under extreme conditions of pressure and temperature, thus making them environmentally unsustainable in the long term. Furthermore, existing catalysts often depend on the use of expensive noble metals (Pt, Pd, Au) and transition metal compounds (e.g. ceria), which are often only available from limited sources and countries, or toxic elements, such as chromium in iron-oxide catalysts, whose use is increasingly limited by EU legislation. The development of novel catalysts, which operate under milder conditions and can utilise a sustainable alternative to fossil fuels, will clearly benefit both the catalyst manufacturing industry and the companies employing these catalysts in their production processes, e.g. pharmaceuticals and chemicals manufacturers and CO2-to-fuel producers.
(ii) The General Public
Everyone, whether living in highly industrialised countries or in the developing world, is affected by climate change and rising costs of energy and commodities. A robust and sustainable route for the recycling of CO2 into synthetic fuels and chemicals will ensure stable and predictable energy prices, especially as synthetic fuels, unlike other energy alternatives, do not require extensive changes to existing infrastructure
(iii) Government/Public Sector
With ever more stringent legislation put in place to guarantee a cascade of international agreements to reduce CO2 and other greenhouse gases to acceptable levels, viable routes to CO2 utilisation are clearly of prime importance to policy makers and legislators.
(iv) Third Sector
More speculative beneficiaries of this research are charities and voluntary organisations, who are called on for help in weather-induced disasters due to climate change, or disruption and hardship caused by rising energy costs.
* Society, by developing effective catalysts for the utilisation of CO2, instead of rapidly dwindling fossil fuel resources, for the production of fuels and chemicals under mild and sustainable reaction conditions, thus assisting in stabilising energy supplies and maintaining our quality of life, as well as alleviating pressure on the environment;
* The Economy, through the design of new (photo)catalytic materials - for commercialisation by catalyst manufacturers - and devices for alternative and sustainable routes to important products. Catalysis is at the heart of the chemical industry - an immensely successful and important part of the overall UK economy, generating in excess of £50 billion per annum.
* Knowledge, both academic and commercial, as the new atomic-level insight into the structure and performance of the active site(s) and the nano-catalysts as a whole - obtained from the computational models, in situ synchrotron experiments and electrochemical screening - will deliver significant advances in catalyst design and optimisation and more widely in materials (nano-)science, and will thus enhance the knowledge base of chemical, energy and other relevant industries;
* People, through the technical expertise developed by the researchers during the project, the training received by them in societal and ethical issues, the fruitful links with industry initiated through the project, and the transferable skills developed in engagement with the media, the general public, policy makers and legislators.
In addition to the obvious benefits to academic researchers in the field (see Academic Beneficiaries section), the research will benefit in particular (i) ) the UK and global commercial sector, but also (ii) the general public, (iii) the public sector, and, more speculatively (iv) voluntary workers and charities.
(i) Commercial sector
Many industrially crucial processes, e.g. the water-gas shift reaction, still take place under extreme conditions of pressure and temperature, thus making them environmentally unsustainable in the long term. Furthermore, existing catalysts often depend on the use of expensive noble metals (Pt, Pd, Au) and transition metal compounds (e.g. ceria), which are often only available from limited sources and countries, or toxic elements, such as chromium in iron-oxide catalysts, whose use is increasingly limited by EU legislation. The development of novel catalysts, which operate under milder conditions and can utilise a sustainable alternative to fossil fuels, will clearly benefit both the catalyst manufacturing industry and the companies employing these catalysts in their production processes, e.g. pharmaceuticals and chemicals manufacturers and CO2-to-fuel producers.
(ii) The General Public
Everyone, whether living in highly industrialised countries or in the developing world, is affected by climate change and rising costs of energy and commodities. A robust and sustainable route for the recycling of CO2 into synthetic fuels and chemicals will ensure stable and predictable energy prices, especially as synthetic fuels, unlike other energy alternatives, do not require extensive changes to existing infrastructure
(iii) Government/Public Sector
With ever more stringent legislation put in place to guarantee a cascade of international agreements to reduce CO2 and other greenhouse gases to acceptable levels, viable routes to CO2 utilisation are clearly of prime importance to policy makers and legislators.
(iv) Third Sector
More speculative beneficiaries of this research are charities and voluntary organisations, who are called on for help in weather-induced disasters due to climate change, or disruption and hardship caused by rising energy costs.
Publications
Aparicio-Anglès X
(2015)
Gadolinium-Vacancy Clusters in the (111) Surface of Gadolinium-Doped Ceria: A Density Functional Theory Study
in Chemistry of Materials
Bersani M
(2016)
Combined EXAFS, XRD, DRIFTS, and DFT Study of Nano Copper-Based Catalysts for CO 2 Hydrogenation
in ACS Catalysis
Dzade N
(2016)
DFT-D2 Study of the Adsorption and Dissociation of Water on Clean and Oxygen-Covered {001} and {011} Surfaces of Mackinawite (FeS)
in The Journal of Physical Chemistry C
Dzade N
(2016)
DFT-D2 simulations of water adsorption and dissociation on the low-index surfaces of mackinawite (FeS)
in The Journal of Chemical Physics
Dzade NY
(2017)
Periodic DFT+U investigation of the bulk and surface properties of marcasite (FeS2).
in Physical chemistry chemical physics : PCCP
Dzade NY
(2018)
Adsorption and Desulfurization Mechanism of Thiophene on Layered FeS(001), (011), and (111) Surfaces: A Dispersion-Corrected Density Functional Theory Study.
in The journal of physical chemistry. C, Nanomaterials and interfaces
Dzade NY
(2015)
Activation and dissociation of CO2 on the (001), (011), and (111) surfaces of mackinawite (FeS): A dispersion-corrected DFT study.
in The Journal of chemical physics
Dzade NY
(2017)
Structures and Properties of As(OH)3 Adsorption Complexes on Hydrated Mackinawite (FeS) Surfaces: A DFT-D2 Study.
in Environmental science & technology
Gupta K
(2016)
Highly efficient electro-reduction of CO 2 to formic acid by nano-copper
in Journal of Materials Chemistry A
Description | Sustainable energy and climate change are areas of global societal concern, which is a recognised strategic priority area of the RCUK through their Energy Programme, managed by EPSRC. Catalysis, moreover, is the lynchpin of a large number of industrial processes, which are instrumental in maintaining global wealth and health, as well as playing a key role in developing processes that are both environmentally and economically sustainable. Despite the high thermodynamic stability of CO2, biological systems are capable of both activating the molecule and converting it into a range of organic molecules, all of which under moderate conditions. It is clear that, if we were able to emulate Nature and successfully convert CO2 into fuel or useful chemical intermediates without the need for extreme reaction conditions, the benefits would be enormous: One of the major gases responsible for climate change would become an important feedstock for the fuel, chemical and pharmaceutical industries! Iron-nickel sulfide membranes formed in the warm, alkaline springs on the Archaean ocean floor are increasingly considered to be the early catalysts for a series of chemical reactions leading to the emergence of life. The anaerobic production of acetate, formaldehyde, amino acids and the nucleic acid bases - the organic precursor molecules of life - are thought to have been catalyzed by small cubane (Fe,Ni)S clusters (for example Fe5NiS8), which are structurally similar to the surfaces of present day sulfide minerals such as greigite (Fe3S4) and mackinawite (FeS). Contemporary confirmation of the importance of sulfide clusters as catalysts is provided by a number of proteins essential to modern anaerobic life forms, such as ferredoxins, hydrogenases, carbon monoxide dehydrogenase (CODH) or acetylcoenzyme A synthetase (ACS), all of which retain cubane (Fe,Ni)S clusters with a greigite-like local structure, either as electron transfer sites or as active sites to metabolise volatiles such as H2, CO and CO2. In Phase 1 of the project, we have used a comprehensive combination of computational, synthetic and electrochemical expertise to mimic Nature and produce Fe-S and Ni-doped Fe-S nanoparticles to catalyse the conversion of CO2. Careful and sensitive testing of the computationally designed materials, prepared through novel synthesis routes, has shown unequivocably that the nanoparticles have the power to adsorb CO2 and reduce it to formic acid - a useful chemical intermediate. A particularly promising aspect is that the catalytic conversion of CO2 takes place at room pressure and temperature and at the sort of low voltages that could be obtained from solar energy, thus making it a sustainable process. Following this success, work in progress aims to optimise the catalysts to improve yield and adapt for further product formation e.g. methanol, acetate and, eventually, dimethyl ether (DME) - all proven pre-cursors to fuels and fine chemicals - and to develop materials and processes that are robust enough to perform under 'real' conditions. Work in this area, in collaboration with a number of industrial partners, requires the dove-tailed interplay of experiment and computation to design, synthesise, characterise and catalytically test the potential transition metal-sulfide nano-catalysts, followed by scale-up of the nanoparticle production and evalulation in an industrial environment. Work in progress is four-fold: 1) Computation is rapidly screening potential sulfide structures for reactivity towards reactants and selectivity towards products; 2) High-throughput synthesis methods to mimic hydrothermal vent systems are being developed to provide a scaled-up sustainable production of the nano-catalysts with defined sizes and shapes; 3) A photo-catalytic device, which will integrate the catalysts in an automated conversion process is in the developmental stage and is currently being tested with known copper oxide catalysts. |
Exploitation Route | The findings may be taken up by chemical engineers to scale up production of the nano-catalysts; automate the CO2 conversion process; and incorporate the catalysts into an integrated solar-powered CO2 conversion device. The new catalysts may also be of interest to industrial researchers, e.g. our project partners Johnson Matthey, to develop into commercially viable catalytic systems. |
Sectors | Chemicals Energy Environment |
Description | Peer-reviewed scientific publications, presentations at (inter)national conferences, interactions with industry, editorials in international newspapers |
First Year Of Impact | 2015 |
Sector | Chemicals,Energy,Environment |
Impact Types | Cultural Societal Economic |
Description | 4CU |
Amount | £4,500,000 (GBP) |
Funding ID | EP/K001329/1 |
Organisation | Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) |
Sector | Public |
Country | United Kingdom |
Start | 08/2012 |
End | 03/2017 |
Description | FOM |
Amount | € 250,000 (EUR) |
Organisation | Netherlands Organisation for Scientific Research (NWO) |
Department | Foundation for Fundamental Research on Matter |
Sector | Public |
Country | Netherlands |
Start | 09/2014 |
End | 09/2017 |
Title | Forcefields |
Description | Forcefields for materials research |
Type Of Material | Model of mechanisms or symptoms - in vitro |
Provided To Others? | Yes |
Impact | Forcefields for materials modelling are developed as and when required and published in the open literature, as well as provided to academic colleagues |
Title | CO2 interaction with the violarite FeNi2S4{001} and {111} surfaces |
Description | The spinel structured violarite (FeNi2S4) is a ternary transition metal sulfide with an intermediate composition within the solid solution formed between Ni3S4 and greigite (Fe3S4) as end members. FeNi2S4 has structural similarities to Fe3S4, which has attracted considerable interest as a potential catalyst for the CO2 adsorption, activation and conversion. This work involved studying the structure and stabilities of various non-polar terminations of the FeNi2S4{001} and {111} surfaces by means of density functional theory (DFT) calculations. We have also investigated the CO2 interaction with the most stable terminations of FeNi2S4{001} and {111} surfaces. The data described here are ASCII files containing the atomic charges and spin moments of all the naked surface terminations and CO2 interaction geometries. Calculations were carried out using the Vienna Ab-initio Simulation Package (VASP). |
Type Of Material | Database/Collection of data |
Year Produced | 2018 |
Provided To Others? | Yes |
Title | Kinetic model of water adsorption, clustering and dissociation on Fe3S4{001} |
Description | The dataset contains information on adsorption geometries (inter- and intra-molecular distances and angles), energies and charge transfers as well as dipole moments upon water adsorption. We have developed also a microkinetic model to explore the molecules arrangement under macroscopic conditions of temperature and concentration. The extensive information obtained as output is also included in this dataset. |
Type Of Material | Database/Collection of data |
Year Produced | 2017 |
Provided To Others? | Yes |
Title | Surface Oxidation of Troilite FeS |
Description | The dataset was generated during density functional theory and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy studies of the prismatic surfaces of the troilite FeS catalyst in an oxidising environment. Iron sulfides are very reactive towards molecular oxygen, which is easily incorporated into their surfaces. In order for the catalytic mechanisms to be understood, it is crucial to achieve a detailed knowledge of the oxidised substrate available to the reactants. Data consist of 1) VASP CONTCAR files with the optimised coordinates of the clean (01-10) surface of troilite and incorporating one, two and three oxygen atoms; 2) Plain text files containing the Fe2p and S2p XPS spectra of Fe(1-x)S nanoparticles. |
Type Of Material | Database/Collection of data |
Year Produced | 2018 |
Provided To Others? | Yes |
Title | Thermodynamic properties of FeS polymorphs |
Description | The dataset was generated during a density functional theory study of the thermodynamics properties of the FeS polymorphs based on the quasi-harmonic theory of lattice vibrations. FeS polymorphs are of significant relevance to condensed matter physics and planetary science. In particular, they are thought to form the cores of Earth and Mars, which is suggested by their presence in many meteorites. Data are plain text files containing the relative volume expansion, molar heat capacity and molar entropy of the FeS phases at different pressures as a function of temperature. |
Type Of Material | Database/Collection of data |
Year Produced | 2017 |
Provided To Others? | Yes |
Description | ESRF |
Organisation | European Synchrotron Radiation Facility |
Country | France |
Sector | Charity/Non Profit |
PI Contribution | Computational and experimental research of sulfide catalysts |
Collaborator Contribution | 2x studentship plus beam time |
Impact | scientific publications |
Start Year | 2010 |
Description | Johnson Matthey Technology Centre |
Organisation | Johnson Matthey |
Country | United Kingdom |
Sector | Private |
Start Year | 2005 |
Description | UCL |
Organisation | University College London |
Department | Chemical Engineering |
Country | United Kingdom |
Sector | Academic/University |
PI Contribution | Collaboration with relevant colleagues in UCL Chemistry and UCL Chemical Engineering |
Collaborator Contribution | Experimental research to be guided by and validate computational research |
Impact | Joint grant applications and joint publications |
Start Year | 2015 |
Description | Utrecht |
Organisation | Utrecht University |
Country | Netherlands |
Sector | Academic/University |
PI Contribution | I provide computation to understand experimental observations |
Collaborator Contribution | They provide experimental testing of computational predictions |
Impact | Scientific papers, successful funding applications |
Start Year | 2006 |