📣 Help Shape the Future of UKRI's Gateway to Research (GtR)

We're improving UKRI's Gateway to Research and are seeking your input! If you would be interested in being interviewed about the improvements we're making and to have your say about how we can make GtR more user-friendly, impactful, and effective for the Research and Innovation community, please email gateway@ukri.org.

Transcendence, fantasy and desire: the affective infrastructures of neoliberalism

Lead Research Organisation: University of East Anglia
Department Name: Politics Philosophy Lang & Comms Studies

Abstract

My research critically engages with contemporary discourses of neoliberalism, a socio-economic doctrine associated with politicians like Margaret Thatcher and Ronald Reagan, and with economists like Friedrich Hayek and Milton Friedman. In general, neoliberalism is characterised by its belief in the primacy of markets, in the benefits of competition, in constraints on governmental intervention and in individual economic freedom. For neoliberal thinkers the market can solve all social problems. For example, neoliberals argue that climate catastrophe can be averted through carbon trading markets that incentivise ecological behaviour for multinational corporations. For its critics, neoliberalism has entrenched and extended global inequality, dispossession and poverty.

The global crises of the last fifteen years - from the 2008 financial crash, the 2016 Brexit vote and election of Donald Trump to the current COVID-19 pandemic - have been accompanied by proclamations about the end of neoliberalism. During these crises, even the governments most committed to non-interventionism have deviated from neoliberal diktat and suspended the primacy of the market. However, we keep being surprised by what Colin Crouch evocatively calls "the strange non-death of neoliberalism" (2011). To understand neoliberalism's persistence, we need to understand how neoliberal ideologies are embedded in institutions, imaginaries and everyday lives.

My project argues that to explain neoliberalism's longevity, we must understand its affective dimensions, psychic powers and embodied effects. We need to grasp how these ideas shape our desires and our ways of living together; how they may feel attractive, exciting or appealing while at the same time operating through mechanisms of exclusion, violence and disposession. My critical political economy approach complements existing sociological works on economic imaginaries (Beckert, 2016) and on the experience of economic orders (Dardot and Laval, 2010) with insights from psychoanalytical theory. I examine neoliberalism not just as an economic doctrine, but also as an affective infrastructure that mobilises fantasies of self-realisation, self-control, and self-transcendence.

My project has three branches. First, it complements the existing scholarship on neoliberal thought (Mirowski and Plehwe, 2009) by reinterpreting canonical texts of neoliberal theory (Hayek 2011a; 2011b; 2013; Becker 1976) through a psychoanalytically-informed theoretical framework. Second, I am interested in how tropes found in neoliberal economic theory (like the idea of risk-taking as self-realisation) are invested and transformed in popular culture; I will publish my research on two entrepreneurs close to the neoliberal movement, Peter Thiel and Elon Musk. Lastly, the project will also extend the claims made in my thesis via a broader scope of analysis that incorporates new sources that highlight how economics is practiced and imagined today, specifically recent pop-economics bestsellers (like the Freakonomics series) and discursive representations of financial instruments (like the VIX, a volatility index popularised as the 'fear index'). The overall aim of the project is to denaturalise so as to re-politicise these discursive productions, and thereby to practically contribute to the elaboration of new alternative imaginaries on the left.

It will do so by disseminating my research in academic circles via the publication of three peer-reviewed articles in leading journals, as well as the organisation of a conference at the University of East Anglia. To reach non-academic audiences, I will develop blogpost and podcast series about economic imaginaries with the Political Economy Research Centre. I will also organise a stakeholder workshop about neoliberal calls for the privatisation of space at the World Transformed 2023 Festival in partnership with the think-tank Common Wealth.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description ESRC early career fellowships are designed to support longer-term research career aspirations. From this perspective, the four objectives I had designed for this award have been met already or will be met within the next two years.
The first objective was to build my publication record by developing sections of my PhD into journal articles. As part of the award, I have written and submitted four articles, which are now at different stages of publication (one accepted, two in review and resubmit stages and one under review). The main one, on the political philosophy of tech entrepreneurs Elon Musk and Peter Thiel, is about to be published by the Journal of Cultural Economy.
My second objective was to enhance the impact of my research by working with stakeholders. As part of the award, I designed a policy report with the think tank Common Wealth on the threats that endanger the international status of space as humanity's commons. The report is at production stage and will come out within 6 months.
My third objective was to produce and curate thematical blogpost and podcast series to build networks and develop impact opportunities. I have done so by publishing two blog series on Goldsmiths' Political Economy Research Centre about 'Silicon Valley Ideology' and 'Neoliberal Visions of Health', which are in free access and bring together contributions by leading experts in the fields of political economy, sociology, political theory and the Law.
Lastly, my fourth objective was to undertake further research associated with my PhD, including archival work in an internationally leading research organisation, which I have met by spending a week at the Liberas archives in Ghent, which hold the archive of the Mont Pèlerin Society.
Exploitation Route The outcomes of this funding can be taken forward and put to use by others in three specific ways.

First, the theoretical framework I defined in my Journal of Cultural Economy article to speak about Elon Musk and Peter Thiel's political philosophy may be used by other researchers working on this topic.
Secondly, the blog series on 'Silicon Valley Ideology' and 'Neoliberal Vision of Health' are two resources free of access and written for the general public to think about how Silicon Valley and Neoliberalism reshaped global institutions and affect our everyday lives. Both series are conceived as open ended and on going: new contributors can still contact me as the editor-in-chief to have their work published.
Lastly, the report written with the think tank Common Wealth may be used by policy makers to think about the UK's position when it comes to the revision of the status of space in international law. The partnership with Common Wealth is on-going and will be follow-up by round tables with expert in the field and policy briefs.
Sectors Aerospace

Defence and Marine

Creative Economy

Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software)

Government

Democracy and Justice

URL https://www.perc.org.uk/project_pages/silicon-valley/
 
Description PERC specialised series on Silicon Valley Ideology and Neoliberal Visions of Health 
Organisation Goldsmiths, University of London
Department Political Economy Research Centre
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution I have been the editor-in-chief of, as well as a contributor to, two blog series for PERC - 'Silicon Valley Ideology' and 'Neoliberal Visions of Health' - as part of my ESRC awards. This has involved contacting and recruiting international experts in the field, coordinating the calendar of their contribution, and editing their work. I also offered support to doctoral students with expertise in the fields to participate in these series, with has required significant editing work. Currently, the 'Silicon Valley Ideology' series counts eleven contributions (including two by myself) with a 12th on the way and another 2 potentially scheduled) and 'Neoliberal Visions of Health' is still on-going.
Collaborator Contribution PERC's Director, Will Davies, has offered mentorship and support. He also contributed to the 'Silicon Valley Ideology' series, and his reputation has been crucial to convince international experts to participate in the projects. PERC has also offered technical support by making its blog and website freely available to publish the two series, as well as its social media accounts to ensure their promotion. PERC's communication assistant has had a crucial role in managing the publicising of each of the posts.
Impact As stated above, the partnership has resulted in the publication of two series. "Silicon Valley Ideology' series currently has 11 contributions by renowned international and British experts, with another scheduled to be published within the next month (and another two potential leads). The series has been mentioned in the Syllabus and on Adam Tooze's podcast. 'Neoliberal Vision of Health' has two published posts by renowned Britain-based experts - with another 3 scheduled. Two distinctive French media platforms has since contacted me to demand permission for translating them. They since have been translated and published in French.
Start Year 2022
 
Description PERC Silicon Valley Ideology and Neoliberal vision of Health series 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact As stated elsewhere, some of the contributions of the series reach a vide readership. As two-examples, Will Davies's post was reported in the Syllabus (a knowledge curation platform with wide readership - https://twitter.com/syllabus_tweets/status/1584922760815542273), as well as in Adam Tooze's podcast (https://adamtooze.com/2022/10/21/liz-truss-halloween-and-listener-questions/)
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://www.perc.org.uk/project_pages/silicon-valley/