Structural performance of slab-column connenctions under impact and blast loading

Lead Research Organisation: University of Surrey
Department Name: Civil and Environmental Engineering

Abstract

This project is primarily concerned with the structural performance (strength & deformation capacity) of flat slab-column connections in reinforced concrete (RC) structures subjected to impact and blast loading. Flat slabs have been widely used in construction in the UK and worldwide due to their low cost and quick construction. Over the last 30 years, the interest on RC structures with high resilience to impulsive loads due to impact and blast has increased significantly to improve protection against the threat of terrorist acts targeting infrastructure or industrial accidents such as gas explosions or vehicle collisions. These extreme events can have catastrophic consequences in terms of human losses, economic losses and environmental impact. Structures that are required to resist high dynamic loads are for example office buildings and parking garages with high levels of threat (e.g. diplomatic buildings or important centres for business and transportation), industrial and storage facilities, nuclear power plants, protective barriers and some bridge piers. Previous research suggests that design against blast loading should be risk-based in which the type, probability and consequences of the event need to be examined against the costs of the protection and the assumed potential loss. The reliability of this type of analysis depends greatly on the accuracy in the estimation of the behaviour of the structure against impact or blast loading. The prediction of the residual strength of RC structures subjected to impulsive loading can be extremely challenging due to strong material nonlinearities and the influence of high strain rates on the behaviour. Shear mechanisms generally govern the response of RC structures subjected to impulsive loads and joint regions are generally critical. Shear failures have been observed experimentally even in members that were designed for static loading to fail in a ductile flexural manner. This is concerning since shear failures are brittle and can lead to progressive collapse of the structure. The dynamic effects on punching shear and progressive collapse are not well understood in RC structures and up to date there is no known physical model to predict the strength and deformation capacity of punching shear under impulsive loading. The principal aim of this project will be to provide a theoretical model for the design and analysis of slab-column connections under impulsive loading which can be used in practice by researchers and designers. Existing experimental data will be used to validate the model and non-linear dynamic FE analysis will be carried out to support the theoretical model.

Planned Impact

The proposed project will contribute towards quantifying the structural performance of existing and new reinforced concrete infrastructure against impact and blast loading. This is particularly relevant for critical infrastructure in buildings, transportation and energy sectors in which structural failures can have severe consequences in terms of human and economical losses as well as environmental impact. The advancements in this area from the proposed work could help improving governmental policy making on infrastructure planning which directly affects the three pillars of sustainability: society, environment and economy. The two main types of economic and societal impacts generated from this research are (i) shaping and enhancing the effectiveness of our infrastructure and transforming evidence based policy in practice and (ii) influencing/informing practitioners and professional practice. The methodologies developed will also contribute to reduce uncertainty in appraisals and strengthening of critical structures and thus improving quality of life and national security against threats such as terrorist attacks or industrial accidents.

A direct beneficiary of the proposed project is Arup which has a well recognized experience of research & development around projects dealing with impact and blast loading through the Advanced Technology & Research Group and the Resilience, Security and Risk Group. Tony Jones and David Cormie who represent these two groups in Arup have shown their interest in the proposed topic and will be collaborating in the project by providing useful feedback and in-kind technical support. Work carried out in Arup included research on non-structural and structural elements. The model to be developed in the proposed research project will allow validating numerical tools for impact and blast design currently used in Arup and will also contribute in the area of progressive collapse and robustness. This area is a strong point of interest to Arup as shown in their latest report on robustness in 2011 for the Department for Communities and Local Government (DCLG) and the Centre for the Protection of National Infrastructure (CPNI). Both DCLG and CPNI could be indirect beneficiaries from the proposed research. Moreover, robustness is a topic that has also been raised at the Standing Committee On Structural Safety (SCOSS) which in turn has significant social impact through their studies and publications. The topic is also of relevance to documents on robustness and progressive collapse, which Arup is a key contributor (e.g. IStructE guideline documents).

The applications and suggestions for future work from the proposed project could also benefit the Future Infrastructure Forum (FIF) network supported by EPSRC, in which University of Surrey is involved in. Another potential beneficiary of this project in the UK could be the Concrete Industry Eurocode 2 Group (CIEG); the PI has been recently nominated to join this group. Both FIF and CIEG groups bring together UK academics, industry and governmental bodies. Some examples of industrial collaborators in these two groups include BRE, The Concrete Society, The Concrete Centre, Arup, Atkins, Buro Happold and Ramboll amongst others; some examples of governmental bodies involved include Network Rail, Highways agency, TFL and Infrastructure UK.

At an international level, the project could benefit the Fédération International du Béton (fib) which seeks advances in structural concrete technologies and design. Both fib and CIEG groups have recently expressed the need to carry out further research on punching shear which needs to be addressed in future codes of practise (refer to UK fib group forum in Birmingham 2011 and CIEGmkII meeting in January 2012). Hence, the project can have a relevant impact on UK design practice with social and economic benefits.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description The main outcome of this research project was the development of a novel theoretical model to predict the strength, type of failure and deformation capacity of flat slab-column connections in concrete buildings and bridges subjected to impact and blast loading. The proposed theoretical method is a significant move forward towards understanding and predicting the behaviour of concrete structures under accidental events.
The novelty of the proposed approach is that it considers dynamic effects in the material and structural response which until now was only possible by means of complex computer simulations. The proposed formulae can be applied manually for simple cases or aided by computer for complex geometries. The theoretical model was validated using existing experimental data of impact and blast tests of simply supported slabs. It was demonstrated that existing formulas for punching of slab-column connections described in current codes of practice are not suitable for dynamic loading since they were derived for static loading. The proposed theoretical model, which is based on first principles, highlights the main parameters that affect the capacity of the slab-column connections.

The preliminary findings of the project were presented at the international conference organized by the Federation International du Beton (fib) in Israel in 2013. The work was presented to a large audience which represented different sectors in construction, infrastructure planning and advanced technology development. The work was also presented to collaborators in Arup (London) and EPFL (Switzerland). These presentations gathered interest from researchers and designers at International level. The fundamentals of the theory were published in 2014 in the International Journal of Impact Engineering. This paper has been the most downloaded paper of the year (report in November showed 1,824 views with 90% of downloads from the Public Sector). Two additional papers were written with industrial collaborators to show the application and extension of the model for panels and slabs subjected to close-in detonations.
Important research questions opened up towards the end of the project regarding the interaction of the behaviour of the slab-column connection and the alternative load paths that can develop in structures during progressive collapse. In the past, the analysis of progressive collapse of flat slab structures was problematic due to the lack of physical or theoretical models for predicting the behaviour of slab-column connections. This project solved this question which will allow in the future to look at the interaction of different mechanisms; a holistic approach could be developed in the near future considering the different post-failure mechanisms involved, including the dynamic effects investigated in this project.
Exploitation Route The theoretical model can be used by researchers and practitioners in their designs of critical infrastructure. One potential use of the model is towards writing design guidelines for flat slab construction where there is a current gap of knowledge for accidental loading. Another direct application of the model is towards predicting structural behaviour of slabs and panels under accidental loading. The PI has been contacted by different international research institutions to explore whether the
Sectors Aerospace

Defence and Marine

Construction

Education

Energy

Other

 
Description The developed theoretical model in the project allows quantifying the structural performance of existing and new reinforced concrete infrastructure against impact, blast loading and column removal. This is particularly relevant for critical infrastructure in buildings, transportation and energy sectors in which structural failures can have severe consequences in terms of human and economical losses as well as environmental impact. The theoretical method developed also contributes to reduce uncertainty in appraisals and strengthening of critical structures and thus improving quality of life and national security against threats such as terrorist attacks or industrial accidents. The outcome of the project is currently being used by researchers and collaborators from Arup (London) and EPFL (Switzerland) to improve current standards for the design of flat slab structures under accidental actions. This work has a large impact if one looks at the role of construction industry and infrastructure in our society. Flat slabs are widely used in infrastructure in the UK and worldwide due to its low cost and quick construction. The Concrete Centre estimates that there are 300,000 flat slab-column connections in the UK alone. Changes in design codes have significant economic impact in construction industry; this sector contributes almost £90 billion to the UK economy. The advancements in this area from the work carried out in this project could help improving governmental policy making on infrastructure planning which directly affects the three pillars of sustainability: society, environment and economy. The PI was invited to present the work at fib task group 4.2.3 (2014) meeting in which new challenges for future code provisions for flat slabs in Europe (next generation of Eurocodes) and worldwide (e.g. new fib Model Code 2020) were discussed amongst invited experts and practitioners. In 2018, the PI was also invited to join the fib Action Group for Robustness for drafting Model Code 2020. The project resulted into two follow-up research projects (impact acceleration account projects); first project with industrial collaborator Arup (London) and research group at EPFL Switzerland and second project with ICITECH at Universitat Politècnica de València (Spain) in which the model was applied to real-scale buildings showing the benefits of using the proposed approach. The collaboration with ICITECH led to experimental work which has influenced the thinking of members of Project Team WG6.T2 (Robustness Rules in Material Related Eurocode Parts) when drafting robustness clauses in the next generation of Eurocodes.
First Year Of Impact 2013
Sector Aerospace, Defence and Marine,Construction,Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software),Education,Other
Impact Types Societal

Economic

Policy & public services

 
Description Considerations on Robustness (future guidelines for flat slabs)
Geographic Reach Europe 
Policy Influence Type Influenced training of practitioners or researchers
 
Description Participation on fib AG on Robustness for Model Code 2020
Geographic Reach Multiple continents/international 
Policy Influence Type Participation in a guidance/advisory committee
 
Description Commonwealth Scholarships (PhD scholarship)
Amount £75,000 (GBP)
Organisation Government of the UK 
Department Commonwealth Scholarship Commission
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 09/2014 
End 07/2016
 
Description Impact Acceleration Account (EPSRC-University of Surrey)
Amount £19,486 (GBP)
Funding ID Bid No. 114904 
Organisation Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 11/2014 
End 05/2015
 
Description Impact Acceleration Account (EPSRC-University of Surrey)
Amount £19,486 (GBP)
Funding ID Bid number 114904 (project RN0320B) 
Organisation Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 03/2019 
End 10/2019
 
Title Dynamic punching predictive method 
Description A set of analytical equations have been developed to assess the occurrence of punching under impact and blast loading. 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Year Produced 2014 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact Researchers and designers can apply the proposed method to predict punching failure of their structures under different types of extreme loading. Furthermore, the model could be extrapolated for the progressive collapse analysis of buildings. The model was described in a paper which is the most downloaded paper in that international journal from 2014-2016. 
URL http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ijimpeng.2014.04.003
 
Title Simplified reliability analysis method 
Description A methodology was proposed to carry out a simplified reliability analysis to assess the probability of punching in column-slab connections in buildings subjected to accidental actions. 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Year Produced 2015 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact The methodology is described in a paper which is under review. The preliminary results were presented to fib Task group 4.2.3 in Stockholm in 2015. The proposed tool was further explored with experts in the field acting as collaborators in the project during placement period in April 2015. 
 
Description Arup (industrial collaborators) 
Organisation Arup Group
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution The PI established this collaboration for the proposal of this grant in which the terms and conditions of the collaboration were discussed beforehand. During the project the PI and RA reported progress to Arup and feedback from collaborators was gathered at different milestones described in the work plan. The PI and RA organized phone meetings and presentation at the Headquarters of Arup in London to discuss the outcome of the project. The feedback was implemented in the work. The PI and RA led the work involved in producing two research papers with Arup.
Collaborator Contribution The collaborators provided useful feedback regarding the theoretical assumptions in the model proposed by the PI. The results were discussed in different phone and office meetings. Experts from overseas from Arup were invited during presentation to give additional feedback. The comments were implemented in the work and will help towards improving the quality of the outcome. The collaborators from Arup co-authored two research papers written towards the end of the project.
Impact - Two research papers have been written in collaboration with Arup (refer to list of publications). - A research proposal was prepared for a follow-up project (Impact Acceleration Account) in which Arup will continue the collaboration. A draft for a paper has been prepared for this work.
Start Year 2013
 
Description EPFL (academic collaborators) 
Organisation Swiss Federal Institute of Technology in Lausanne (EPFL)
Country Switzerland 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution The PI and RA discussed with collaborators the premises of the theory developed and put together the preliminary findings in a joint conference paper presented in Israel 2013. The PI and RA met the collaborators in Lausanne and Vienna to discuss the progress at different stages of the project. The PI led the work which resulted in a joint paper with IBETON.
Collaborator Contribution The collaborators in IBETON are world known for their expertise in the field of structural concrete and the development of punching shear design methods. They developed the Critical Shear Crack Theory for static loading. This theory was one of the basis for the model developed in this project. The collaborators provided a useful review and comments of the proposed formulation.
Impact - The premises of the theoretical model and preliminary findings were published in the fib Conference in Israel 2013 (refer to list of publications). - A joint paper with the fundamentals of the theory were published in 2014 in the International Journal of Impact Engineering (refer to list of publications).
Start Year 2013
 
Description Universitat Politècnica de València 
Organisation Polytechnic University of Valencia
Country Spain 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution This collaboration was part of an Impact Acceleration Account follow-up project in 2018-2019 hosted at University of Surrey. The theoretical model developed in the EPSRC project was applied and validated against experimental data provided by the collaborators. This has resulted in three joint publications and plans to carry out future tests together.
Collaborator Contribution The partners carried out a test of a purposely built building subjected to a column removal. The contributors process the data and discussed the results with University of Surrey working as a team and resulting in several joint publications.
Impact Although the formal collaboration started in 2018 as part of the IAA project, prior that, an informal collaboration with UPV was established in 2016 leading to other publications which are not mentioned here to avoid confusion. Since the start of the collaboration in 2018, five research papers were published jointly which have been in cluded in the list of publications in the project (see papers dated 2018-2021 with first author Buitrago M, and Garzón-Roca J). This collaboration has led to three visiting PhD students from UPV staying at Surrey for different periods of their research and, postdoctoral stay and one stay of a visiting Professor.
Start Year 2018
 
Description Exploitation of research - the successes and opportunities 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact Event at University of Surrey as part of the Impact Acceleration Account initiatives. The event consisted of different activities such as presentations, guided tours and showcase scenarios of different research projects. A poster was presented titled "Modelling progressive collapse of concrete structures" with video visuals aids to explain the research project to a large variety of audience (industry and industry community and students).
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2014
 
Description IStructE 18th Young Researchers Conference 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact A poster titled "When a good impact is bad" was presented by Micallef K. in the 18th Young's Researchers Conference organized by the Institution of Structural Engineers. This activity helped to disseminate the findings amongst the research community and to create future collaborations between different institutions in the UK.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016
 
Description Invitation to fib Task Group 4.2.3 (code provisions on robustness) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? Yes
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact The PI presented the findings and potential applications of the developed theoretical model in the field of robustness.

A revision of current Eurocodes is taking place, including Eurocode 2 for concrete structures, which is targeted to finish by 2016. The presentation highlighted the areas for improvement in Eurocode 2 regarding robustness and potential solutions for this. The UK plays a leading role in this field and therefore this activity contributed towards maintaining this status. The discussion after the presentation contributed towards reaching audience that plays different roles in code drafting and there
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2014,2015,2016
 
Description Seminar at Arup (London) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact A presentation was given to report on progress which was followed up by a discussion of areas of improvement. The presentation and discussion sessions were followed by experts in Arup (London, New York and Australia) using their teleconferencing system.

The main outcome was the list of suggestions provided by Arup. This included additional references in the literature and some technical comments to consider in the development of the model. In particular, it was raised the need to further validate the results with advanced computer simulations. This led us to increase our computational capacities and run a series of simulations on blast loading which provided satisfactory results. The outcome from this simulations was summarized in the second paper co-authored with Arup.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2014
 
Description Seminar at SOM (London) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact This was a presentation wrapping up the research findings during a 2-week secondment in SOM as a part of an Impact Acceleration Account project 2019-20.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
 
Description Seminars at IBETON (Switzerland) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact The presentation given by the RA and PI summarized the research project to a group of PhD researchers and MSc students from IBETON. The discussion afterwards clearly stimulated thinking and developing new research ideas among a very specialized audience.

The main impact was the engagement of the researchers at IBETON and the sharing of information. We also obtained useful feedback towards making some simplifications in our model to make it more transparent.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2014