An Atomic-Scale Characterisation Facility for Active Nuclear Materials
Lead Research Organisation:
University of Oxford
Department Name: Materials
Abstract
The design, build and maintenance of next generation fission and fusion reactors must be underpinned by research into how materials for their construction will degrade when exposed to the harsh reactor environment. This deterioration is largely driven by the extensive bombardment of high energy neutrons, which both damage the structure of the materials, and ultimately over extended periods can transform it, changing its properties. This process is initiated at the atomic level. Hence a better understanding of how the microstructure evolves, from this scale, under the combination of extreme temperature and irradiation conditions within the reactor, and correlating this to the deterioration of mechanical properties, is essential to predict safe operating lifetimes of critical components.
This proposal is to establish a state-of-the-art Active Atom Probe Facility as a national user facility for UK researchers. Atom probe tomography (APT) is a type of microscopy that provides unique insight into 3D atomic distributions within materials at a scale that even the most advanced electron microscopes cannot routinely achieve. APT can be used to identify and characterise the very onset of irradiation-induced damage in nuclear materials. It is now an indispensable materials characterisation tool utilised in a wide variety of research and development into nuclear materials.
APT is a destructive characterisation technique, meaning that when active specimens are analysed, during the experiment sample material will be deposited within the instrument. In the case of active materials, this represents serious logistical and safety concerns for the maintenance and operation of the instrument. Hence, for UK researchers to undertake such analyses routinely, effectively and safely requires the establishment of an APT facility dedicated to the characterisation of radioactive materials.
The Active Atom Probe Facility represents a collaboration between the University of Oxford and the UKAEA's Materials Research Facility (MRF) to maximise the effectiveness of UK expertise and infrastructure. While the atom probe instrumentation will be installed at Oxford, prior to analysis APT specimens must be prepared from larger, significantly more radioactive samples. This will be undertaken utilising a Focused Ion Beam instrument to be installed at the MRF, which has the experience and facilities for safe handling, preparation and examination of irradiated reactor materials.
This Active Atom Probe Facility will provide fully-supported access and training to scientists from UK academia and industry across every step of the APT experiment, from specimen preparation through to data analysis and interpretation of the results. Users of the new instruments will be trained to an expert level in all aspects of the technique, with an emphasis on all specific precautions required to undertake experiments radioactive materials. It will therefore play a key role in the development of the next generation of UK scientists who will contribute to re-establishing international leadership in nuclear materials research. Access to this unique capability will support research across a range of different stages in the fission and fusion nuclear energy cycle, including: design and manufacture of new irradiation resistant materials for next generation reactors, contributions to safety critical reactor monitoring, validating ion/proton irradiation as a neutron surrogate, developing effective, long-lasting waste storage solutions and steering research for future fusion plants.
This proposal is to establish a state-of-the-art Active Atom Probe Facility as a national user facility for UK researchers. Atom probe tomography (APT) is a type of microscopy that provides unique insight into 3D atomic distributions within materials at a scale that even the most advanced electron microscopes cannot routinely achieve. APT can be used to identify and characterise the very onset of irradiation-induced damage in nuclear materials. It is now an indispensable materials characterisation tool utilised in a wide variety of research and development into nuclear materials.
APT is a destructive characterisation technique, meaning that when active specimens are analysed, during the experiment sample material will be deposited within the instrument. In the case of active materials, this represents serious logistical and safety concerns for the maintenance and operation of the instrument. Hence, for UK researchers to undertake such analyses routinely, effectively and safely requires the establishment of an APT facility dedicated to the characterisation of radioactive materials.
The Active Atom Probe Facility represents a collaboration between the University of Oxford and the UKAEA's Materials Research Facility (MRF) to maximise the effectiveness of UK expertise and infrastructure. While the atom probe instrumentation will be installed at Oxford, prior to analysis APT specimens must be prepared from larger, significantly more radioactive samples. This will be undertaken utilising a Focused Ion Beam instrument to be installed at the MRF, which has the experience and facilities for safe handling, preparation and examination of irradiated reactor materials.
This Active Atom Probe Facility will provide fully-supported access and training to scientists from UK academia and industry across every step of the APT experiment, from specimen preparation through to data analysis and interpretation of the results. Users of the new instruments will be trained to an expert level in all aspects of the technique, with an emphasis on all specific precautions required to undertake experiments radioactive materials. It will therefore play a key role in the development of the next generation of UK scientists who will contribute to re-establishing international leadership in nuclear materials research. Access to this unique capability will support research across a range of different stages in the fission and fusion nuclear energy cycle, including: design and manufacture of new irradiation resistant materials for next generation reactors, contributions to safety critical reactor monitoring, validating ion/proton irradiation as a neutron surrogate, developing effective, long-lasting waste storage solutions and steering research for future fusion plants.
Planned Impact
The Active Atom Probe Facility will underpin research into design and manufacture of new materials across a wide range of nuclear materials applications, under a variety of EPSRC themes, such as Physical Sciences, Manufacturing the Future, Engineering and Energy. This highlights a key reason for the recent growth in influence and impact of APT, namely a rapid broadening in the range of research topics which require 3D atomic-scale chemical information to develop the next generation of high performance materials. This is evident in the fact that nuclear materials research already accounts for more than half of current APT usage in the UK, despite access for the analysis of active materials being highly constrained. Given the critical effects that neutron irradiation has on the in-service performance of structural reactor materials and waste-forms, and the increasingly prominent role of APT in UK nuclear materials research, it is clear that the Active Atom Probe Facility will have immediate, and long-term impact in this area.
A central feature of our vision for the new facility is that it will deliver important, novel results and understanding to university partners and their industrial collaborators. This is not an activity that will have to be built up from scratch, as many of the investigators already hold a substantial portfolio of projects funded by UK industry. However, the range, depth and significance of output on problems related to the design and performance of nuclear materials that are scientifically extremely challenging and of direct and immediate commercial relevance will be substantially increased by the availability of this unique facility. With academic partners, we will generate impact by output of first class papers in the scientific literature.
Access to the new Active Atom Probe Facility will also benefit researchers at earlier stages of their careers, ensuring adequate access for them to explore ambitious lines of new research. A key emphasis will be placed on training. Users of the new instruments will be trained to an expert level in all aspects of the technique. Furthermore, the MRF provides an excellent training ground for young researchers to learn all aspects of how to safely plan and run experiments using radioactive materials. Hence it will play a vital role in training and development for the next generation of students and ECRs who will take up nuclear-focused roles in UK academia and industry. This is critically important in the field of nuclear research where there is emphasis on re-establishing technical competency and international leadership.
More than 8 UK and international companies are actively involved in projects outlined in this proposal. These collaborators share ambition to use the new facility to underpin development of next-generation materials across a range of nuclear engineering applications. The new facility will make critical contributions to multi-institutional collaborative research programmes, supported by both UKRI and industry, with the potential for immediate real-world impact to manufacturing in the UK.
Examples of projects that we plan to undertake with these industrial partners underpins materials research across many different stages in the nuclear energy cycle: examining structural materials for GenIV reactors, contributing to safety-critical monitoring of reactor steels, developing effective waste storage solutions and steering research for future fusion plants. Furthermore, we are continually in discussion with new partners who have problems that will benefit from the access to unique insights offered by the new instrument.
Another important impact of this project is to ensure that academia and industry has access to competitive facilities within the UK. Without this, there is real risk that industrial partners could move entire projects, not just the APT aspects, to international competitors who are actively installing similar facilities.
A central feature of our vision for the new facility is that it will deliver important, novel results and understanding to university partners and their industrial collaborators. This is not an activity that will have to be built up from scratch, as many of the investigators already hold a substantial portfolio of projects funded by UK industry. However, the range, depth and significance of output on problems related to the design and performance of nuclear materials that are scientifically extremely challenging and of direct and immediate commercial relevance will be substantially increased by the availability of this unique facility. With academic partners, we will generate impact by output of first class papers in the scientific literature.
Access to the new Active Atom Probe Facility will also benefit researchers at earlier stages of their careers, ensuring adequate access for them to explore ambitious lines of new research. A key emphasis will be placed on training. Users of the new instruments will be trained to an expert level in all aspects of the technique. Furthermore, the MRF provides an excellent training ground for young researchers to learn all aspects of how to safely plan and run experiments using radioactive materials. Hence it will play a vital role in training and development for the next generation of students and ECRs who will take up nuclear-focused roles in UK academia and industry. This is critically important in the field of nuclear research where there is emphasis on re-establishing technical competency and international leadership.
More than 8 UK and international companies are actively involved in projects outlined in this proposal. These collaborators share ambition to use the new facility to underpin development of next-generation materials across a range of nuclear engineering applications. The new facility will make critical contributions to multi-institutional collaborative research programmes, supported by both UKRI and industry, with the potential for immediate real-world impact to manufacturing in the UK.
Examples of projects that we plan to undertake with these industrial partners underpins materials research across many different stages in the nuclear energy cycle: examining structural materials for GenIV reactors, contributing to safety-critical monitoring of reactor steels, developing effective waste storage solutions and steering research for future fusion plants. Furthermore, we are continually in discussion with new partners who have problems that will benefit from the access to unique insights offered by the new instrument.
Another important impact of this project is to ensure that academia and industry has access to competitive facilities within the UK. Without this, there is real risk that industrial partners could move entire projects, not just the APT aspects, to international competitors who are actively installing similar facilities.
Organisations
People |
ORCID iD |
Michael Moody (Principal Investigator) | |
Paul Bagot (Co-Investigator) |
Publications
Carter M
(2022)
On the influence of microstructure on the neutron irradiation response of HIPed SA508 steel for nuclear applications
in Journal of Nuclear Materials
Gault B
(2021)
Atom probe tomography.
in Nature reviews. Methods primers
Jenkins B
(2022)
APT and TEM study of behaviour of alloying elements in neutron-irradiated zirconium-based alloys
in Scripta Materialia
Jenkins B
(2023)
Experimental and modelling evidence for hydrogen trapping at a ß-Nb second phase particle and Nb-rich nanoclusters in neutron-irradiated low Sn ZIRLO
in Journal of Nuclear Materials
Jones M
(2022)
Improving the Quantification of Deuterium in Zirconium Alloy Atom Probe Tomography Data Using Existing Analysis Methods
in Microscopy and Microanalysis
Klups P
(2022)
PosgenPy: An Automated and Reproducible Approach to Assessing the Validity of Cluster Search Parameters in Atom Probe Tomography Datasets
in Microscopy and Microanalysis
Lloyd M
(2022)
Interaction of transmutation products with precipitates, dislocations and grain boundaries in neutron irradiated W
in Materialia
Ma K
(2023)
Chromium-based bcc-superalloys strengthened by iron supplements
in Acta Materialia
Description | Irradiation damage in novel steels for advanced modular reactors The neutron irradiation response of a novel hot isostatically pressed SA508 Grade3 steel was studied, such to deduce any influence this unconventional RPV microstructure has on radiation response. In particular, the role of elevated ferrite fraction was investigated. Atom probe tomography detected the presence of irradiation damage in the form of Mn-Ni-Si type clusters in both microconstituent phases. The ferrite microstructure showed a greater percentage of solute atoms available to form clusters than bainite, but it also contained a lower cluster volume fraction and number density compared to the bainite. Extensive studies were also undertaken comparing ion-irradiated materials as a surrogate for exposure to neutrons. The ion irradiation studies shed new light on atomic scale damage mechanisms in irriadiated steel but also higlhighted key differences with the response to reactor materials. Tungsten for application in fusion reactors Transmutation due to neutron irradiation of pure single crystal W led to the formation of a W-1.20 ± 0.11 at.%Re-0.11 ± 0.05 at.%Os-0.03 ±0.01 at.%Ta alloy. Comparison between FISPACT-II results and APT demonstrated that FISPACT-II is a very reliable way of quantifying transmutation in neutron irradiated material. This sample is of particular importance for the study of the evolution of materials in a fusion environment as it has undergone a high temperature irradiation and has a transmutation induced composition similar to a W first wall component after several years of operation in a fusion reactor. Under irradiation APT showed clusters of mainly of Re, with Os at the centre, which were on average 8 nm in diameter. Analysis of the reconstruction indicated that voids within the clusters may have contributed to an artefact which could have disrupted the inner structure of the clusters seen in APT. |
Exploitation Route | Irradiation damage in novel steels for advanced modular reactors The response of HIP materials to irradiation was shown to be similar to traditionally forged materials, open this manufacturing route for further investigation into its viability for RPV components.Further understadning was gained into the nucleation and evolution of detrimental solute clustering due to irradiation damage in RPV steels. Tungsten for application in fusion reactors This work shows the importance of using transmutation compositions when ranging the APT data produced on samples containing non-natural abundances of elements, and raises questions about the validity of using ion implantation which typically does not facilitate void formation. New neutron irradiation campaigns, and more modelling studies, which include the full range of transmutation products are needed to fully understand the impact transmutation will have in reactor components. |
Sectors | Aerospace Defence and Marine Energy Environment Manufacturing including Industrial Biotechology Other |
Description | The Nuclear Materials Atom Probe (NuMAP) Facility has been successfully established as part of the National Nuclear Users Facility. The facility provides fully supported access for UK academics and industry to APT for the analysis of materials with applications to the generation of fission and fusion energy. The NuMAP facility has already supported experiments from researchers from the Universities of Bristol, Bangor, Birmigham, Sheffield-Hallam and Imperial College, as well as the National Nuclear Laboratory. Materials investigated include irradiated steels, novel BCC superalloys, high entropy allys and zirconium alloys for potential use in the build and safe operation of nuclear reactors as well as novel borosilicate glasses and copper materials which have applications for storage of nuclear waste. |
First Year Of Impact | 2020 |
Sector | Energy,Environment,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology |
Impact Types | Cultural Economic |
Description | Industrial Sponsorship of PhD Project |
Amount | £150,000 (GBP) |
Organisation | National Nuclear Laboratory |
Sector | Public |
Country | United Kingdom |
Start | 09/2023 |
End | 04/2027 |
Description | NEURONE |
Amount | £788,000 (GBP) |
Organisation | UK Atomic Energy Authority |
Sector | Public |
Country | United Kingdom |
Start | 03/2023 |
End | 04/2028 |
Description | Birmigham BCC superalloys |
Organisation | University of Birmingham |
Country | United Kingdom |
Sector | Academic/University |
PI Contribution | atomic scale analysis of novel bcc superalloys at atomic scale |
Collaborator Contribution | design and development of BCC superalloy for high temperature applications as components in nuclear reactors |
Impact | a journal article has been published, and this work will be part of the research incorporated in the UKAEA funded NEURONE programme of research |
Start Year | 2021 |
Description | High Entropy Alloys - Sheffield |
Organisation | University of Sheffield |
Country | United Kingdom |
Sector | Academic/University |
PI Contribution | Characterisation of micrstructural resistance to ion irradiation at the atomic scale use atom probe tomography |
Collaborator Contribution | desigin and developmentof novel high entropy alloys for fission reactor components |
Impact | APT data generated, results presented at international conference, writing of paper in progress |
Start Year | 2022 |
Description | M A Auger |
Organisation | Charles III University of Madrid |
Country | Spain |
Sector | Academic/University |
PI Contribution | Enabled atomic scale analyses of irraidated ODS steels, and other steels, with applications to the build of fission and fusion reactors |
Collaborator Contribution | Development of the next generation of high performance steels for a variety of applications as components of nuclear reactors |
Impact | https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jnucmat.2021.152842 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.mtla.2020.100946 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jnucmat.2020.152466 |
Start Year | 2019 |
Description | Nb3Sn superconductors |
Organisation | Florida State University |
Country | United States |
Sector | Academic/University |
PI Contribution | Developed APT techniques for atomic scale characterisation of superconductor materials |
Collaborator Contribution | developed cutting edge Nb3Sn superconductor materials |
Impact | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-021-97353-w |
Start Year | 2019 |
Description | RPV Imperial |
Organisation | Imperial College London |
Department | Faculty of Engineering |
Country | United Kingdom |
Sector | Academic/University |
PI Contribution | analysis of ex-reactor pressure vessel steels at the atomic scale using atom probe |
Collaborator Contribution | provision of ex-reactor steel smaples for nuclear fission reactor structural components |
Impact | experiments and write up of the results currently in progress |
Start Year | 2022 |
Description | SU RPV Steel Project |
Organisation | Rolls Royce Group Plc |
Country | United Kingdom |
Sector | Private |
PI Contribution | APT analysis of detrimental solute cluster evolution in RPV steels with applications for Advanced Modular Reactors |
Collaborator Contribution | Rolls Royce developed and maufactured the steels studied in this program. Rolls Royce oversaw the neutron irradiation of these alloys as part of the ATR-2 program in the United States and enabled the transport of materials to the UK |
Impact | This collaboration has enabled a PhD studentship to investigate the evolution of atomic-scale microstructural damage in neutron-irradiated RPV steels |
Start Year | 2021 |