Physiological systems integration in the optimisation of exercise tolerance

Lead Research Organisation: University of Liverpool
Department Name: Clinical Sciences

Abstract

The ability to sustain muscular exercise is a key determinant of health, quality of life, and mortality. A low tolerance for exercise contributes to a downward spiral of inactivity, which is debilitating in the elderly and an actual cause of many chronic diseases. Therefore, a better understanding of the mechanisms that allow exercise to be sustained is central to our ability to help maintain health, quality of life and promote longevity. Sustaining muscular exercise depends on the body's ability to provide energy through 'oxidative', or aerobic, pathways. These are chemical reactions that synthesise energy through the consumption of oxygen. However, bodily stores of oxygen are very limited so at exercise onset the lungs, heart and muscles must respond in a coordinated fashion to transport oxygen from the atmosphere to where it is used in the active muscles. In healthy individuals the required increases in pulmonary ventilation, cardiac output, muscle blood flow, and muscle oxygen utilisation occur in a well coordinated fashion. However, to achieve this coordination the responses of these systems lag behind the energy demands by about 3 minutes in normal healthy subjects. The kinetics with which oxygen transport and utilisation can respond therefore determines whether or not the body is able meet the energy demands through oxidative pathways. Because demands for activity fluctuate throughout the day (e.g. walking, stair climbing, etc), the response kinetics of energy providing pathways have a significant impact on the ability to carry out the tasks of daily living. It is of considerable concern, therefore, that these response kinetics are very slow in the elderly, and take about twice as long to reach their requirement compared to young individuals. In the elderly therefore there is a greater high reliance on alternative routes of energy provision (termed anaerobic, because they don't consume oxygen). These are detrimental to exercise tolerance because they are related to increased muscle fatigue, shortness of breath and pain. It is perhaps unsurprising, therefore, that physiological systems respond very rapidly in trained athletes. The mechanisms that determine the integrated responses of the pulmonary, circulatory and muscular systems, however, are currently unresolved. The studies in this proposal aim to improve our understanding of the interactions between oxygen delivery to, and utilisation in, the active muscles during the transition from rest to exercise. A better understanding of how these processes work will improve our ability to address the slow oxygen consumption kinetics in the elderly, as well as the optimisation of these processes in elite athletes. The experiments for these studies are organised into three tracks: 1) studies to elucidate how the kinetics of muscle fatigue and oxygen uptake contribute to limiting exercise tolerance in young, elderly and endurance trained subjects; 2) studies to elucidate how rates of aerobic and anaerobic energy provision are distributed throughout the active muscles; and 3) studies to generate a computer model to simulate energy provision and integrated physiological systems integration during exercise over a variety of conditions. All the experiments are made using non-invasive measurements during leg exercise in young (<30 years), elderly (>65 years) or elite endurance trained athletes (volunteers from the Great Britain cycling squad). The outcomes of this project will improve our understanding of how the body responds to the energy demands of physical activity, and how the provision and utilisation of oxygen is optimised to allow high work rates to be sustained. These studies will therefore underpin the development of new strategies (either pharmacological or exercise based) for ameliorating the mechanisms limiting exercise tolerance in humans, and thereby contribute to the maintenance of health, quality of life, and longevity.

Technical Summary

The ability to sustain muscular exercise is a key determinant of cardiovascular health, quality of life, and mortality. Exercise tolerance depends on the effective integration of the pulmonary, circulatory and muscular systems to transport and utilise oxygen. The effective integration of these systems dynamics, however, is still poorly understood. It is known that O2 transport and utilisation (VO2) kinetics are fast in endurance trained subjects and slow in the healthy elderly. Slow VO2 kinetics place an increased reliance on energy contributions from anaerobic sources that contribute to fatigue, dyspnoea and pain and thereby limit exercise tolerance. The purpose of this project is to develop a computational model to explain integrated dynamics of the pulmonary, circulatory and muscular systems across the continuum of healthy human biology. To facilitate this we will study cardiopulmonary and neuromuscular dynamics in healthy young, elderly and endurance trained subjects. Specifically we will investigate the relationship between the parameters of the power-duration curve (determining exercise tolerance) and VO2 kinetics (determining aerobic energy provision) using breath-by-breath gas exchange and instantaneous measurements muscle fatigue during dynamic exercise. In addition, we will measure the heterogeneity of regional muscle oxygenation, metabolism and recruitment using simultaneous near-infrared spectroscopy, magnetic resonance spectroscopy and imaging during exercise to the limit of tolerance. These data will be used to generate a systems biology framework to better understand energy provision during exercise over a variety of conditions. The findings from these studies will underpin the development of new strategies (either pharmacological or exercise based) for ameliorating the mechanisms limiting exercise tolerance, and thereby contribute to the maintenance of health, quality of life, and longevity.

Planned Impact

In line with the mission statement of The American College of Sports Medicine (of which Dr Rossiter is a Fellow), this collaborative research group is committed to promoting and integrating scientific research, education, and practical applications of exercise sciences to maintain and enhance physical performance, fitness, health, and quality of life. This commitment includes achieving impact through increasing knowledge and scientific advancement, communication, public engagement in health issues, contributing to healthcare policy, advancing UK Sport, and developing the research team. Our group has a good track record of knowledge exchange and impact activities, which will be continued during the proposed programme. For example, we are active in pursuing opportunities for public engagement in our research findings, and have given public lectures on exercise physiology both nationally and internationally. We contribute to knowledge transfer in the local community through the University of Leeds Centre for Health Enterprise, and run education and demonstration days on cardiopulmonary exercise testing for local high-school students. Our group has been involved in the public lecture series of the University of Leeds' 'Olympic Programme' since its outset in 2008, which aims to stimulate excellence, international awareness and engagement within the University and its external stakeholders. The nature of our research means that we are well placed to take advantage of the public interest in specific sporting events (The Oxford and Cambridge Boat Race, for example) to encapsulate the significance of some of our research and publicise findings via the national press (e.g. The Daily Telegraph, 2006; The Daily Mail, 2007). Given the broad implications and appeal of the proposed research (incorporating Olympic athletes and elderly subjects), we envisage this route of knowledge exchange will be particularly fruitful. These activities will be facilitated by our relationship with The University of Leeds press office a Leeds-based public relations company (CampusPR). The impact activities for the collaborative group will be run through the University of Leeds, but each member of the collaborative team will contribute toward their own strengths. Dr Kemp and Dr Benson will contribute to the scientific dissemination of the research through presentations and conferences, and Dr Kemp will access the support of the University of Liverpool, Department of Corporate Communications. Matt Parker from British Cycling will contribute to impact and knowledge transfer through University and public engagement activities based around Olympism (e.g. to University undergraduates, and within the 'Olympic Programme'). The post-graduate and post-doctoral members of the group will maintain the website for the study, which will outline the main aims and findings of our work, and assist with demonstrations and public engagement. We do not envisage direct commercially exploitable information to be gained from this work, however, we do expect to provide direct benefit to UK Sport. The relevant findings will be disseminated to athletes and coaches via oral presentation, in order to better understand the integrated physiology of exercise and benefit training specificity. We also aim accrue information to better understand exercise in the elderly and these findings will be disseminated to stakeholders via public presentations and our ongoing collaborations with clinical colleagues in the NHS (in musculoskeletal, anaesthesiology, cardiology, respiratory, and elderly care specialties). These activities would allow any relevant and/or serendipitous findings to be quickly translated to clinical trial and practice. Through these various activities we aim to heighten awareness of the principles of exercise physiology to have long-term impact on health, quality of life and longevity.

Publications

10 25 50

publication icon
Benson AP (2012) A validated and optimised model linking muscle and pulmonary oxygen uptake kinetics in Proceedings of Virtual Physiological Human Annual Conference, London 2012

publication icon
Benson AP (2013) A validated model of oxygen uptake and circulatory dynamic interactions at exercise onset in humans. in Journal of applied physiology (Bethesda, Md. : 1985)

publication icon
Bowen TS (2012) A dynamic overshoot in skeletal muscle deoxygenation is not evidence of a VO2 kinetic limitation in Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise

publication icon
Bowen TS (2014) The spatial distribution of absolute skeletal muscle deoxygenation during ramp-incremental exercise is not influenced by hypoxia in Proceedings of the International Society for Oxygen Transport to Tissue

 
Description This award had three aims: 1) studies to elucidate how the kinetics of muscle fatigue and oxygen uptake contribute to limiting exercise tolerance in young, elderly and endurance trained subjects; 2) studies to elucidate how rates of aerobic and anaerobic energy provision are distributed throughout the active muscles; and 3) studies to generate a computer model to simulate energy provision and integrated physiological systems integration during exercise over a variety of conditions

For Aim 1 we have developed a new method to measure how exercise intolerance is brought about during whole-body exercise. This has been validated in young healthy individuals and tested in elderly participants (60-85 yrs) and elite athletes (national/international level U23 triathletes). The data validating this method have been presented in abstract form, and the manuscript is currently under review. These data indicate that 'central fatigue' (the ability of the brain and spinal cord to voluntarily activate the muscles) is associated with peripheral fatigue (the ability of the muscle to produce force/power when stimulated) in young and trained individuals, but in some elderly subjects central fatigue may be dissociated from peripheral fatigue. This means that factors other than intrinsic muscle metabolism may limit exercise in the elderly.

For Aim 2 we have published an article demonstrating that only ~10% of active muscle may reach metabolically limitations to force production at the point of intolerance during bipedal exercise. We use regional magnetic resonance scanning to show that biochemicals that support muscle contraction are challenged only in a small region of the active muscle.

The Aim 3 we published a computational model that was able to explain how muscle metabolism and circulation integrated to determine gas exchange measured at the lung. It was proposed in the 1980s that gas exchange at the exercise muscle must respond more rapidly than pulmonary gas exchange at the lung. This was debated in the 1990s in the publication of a computer model. We further developed this original model and validated it with experimental data from humans during cycling. These data show that the dynamics of the circulation modulate muscle gas exchange as they transit to the lung. These data may be used to shed light on what constitutes 'normal values' of gas exchange kinetics measured non-invasively, such as during clinical cardiopulmonary exercise testing.

[Note: This is a joint project with BB/I00162X/1 (PI HB Rossiter, University of Leeds). The listed outcomes and findings are (with minor differences) the same for the two grants]
Exploitation Route Data from this study may be used by others to promote and integrate scientific research, education, and practical applications in the exercise sciences, to maintain and enhance physical performance, fitness, health, and quality of life. In the immediate term the data generate from this study will be used by academics to drive further inquiry into the factors limiting exercise tolerance in young, old and patients with chronic disease. New grant applications are in development. In the medium term, it is envisaged that the new methods developed for the assessment of fatigue may be used in research, sport or healthcare, including NHS, to investigate or diagnose mechanisms of exercise limitation, and therefore be used to promote physical activity, health and quality of life.
Sectors Healthcare

Leisure Activities

including Sports

Recreation and Tourism

Pharmaceuticals and Medical Biotechnology

 
Description The data generated by this work has yet to accrue significant impact outside academia. Newly developed exercise tests may have future impact in sport or healthcare. Public engagement to increase awareness of the benefits of physical activity in older age were accrued through press releases, public lectures and BBSRC-produced video reports
First Year Of Impact 2014
Impact Types Societal

 
Description 'BBSRC Business' article: 'From muscle in motion to exercise in ageing' 
Form Of Engagement Activity A magazine, newsletter or online publication
Part Of Official Scheme? Yes
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Stimulated some discussion and enquiries.

None measurable so far
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity
 
Description High-field 31P magnetic resonance spectroscopy in the study of muscle metabolism in vivo: 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Invited oral presentation at installation as Adjunct Professor, Center for Medical Physics and Biomedical Engineering, Medical University of Vienna, Austria, October 3, 2016
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016
 
Description Invited lecture: 'Determination of skeletal muscle mitochondrial function by NMR techniques 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact MiP Summer workshop 'Mitochondrial Physiology - Theory & Praxis', Panum Institute, University of Copenhagen, Denmark. August 26-30, 2013. Invited lecture: 'Determination of skeletal muscle mitochondrial function by NMR techniques'. Result - a review commissioned

None other yet
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2014
 
Description Invited lecture: 'MR spectroscopy approaches to quantifying muscle metabolism in vivo' 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Invited talk at British Chapter, International Society for Magnetic Resonance in Medicine, Cambridge 11 September 2012. Discussion and collaboration followed.

New collaboration
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2014
 
Description Invited speaker, A*STAR 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Invited speaker, A*STAR Singapore Bioimaging Consortium and Singapore Clinical Imaging Research Centre. 'Magnetic resonance spectroscopy as a tool to quantify muscle metabolism in vivo', September 4, 2013. Discussions around collaboration

New collaboration
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2014
 
Description Video: From muscle in motion to exercise in ageing 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? Yes
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Stimulated some enquiries and discussion

None so far
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity
URL http://youtu.be/tO8fpK1GWQE
 
Description Why can some people endure exercise better than others? 
Form Of Engagement Activity A press release, press conference or response to a media enquiry/interview
Part Of Official Scheme? Yes
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Media (as a channel to the public)
Results and Impact Press release (via University of Leeds, because of the parallel relationship of this grant to BB/I00162X/1 University of Leeds, PI Rossiter) Press release announcing award of BB/I001174/1 and BB/I00162X/1, plus BBC Radio Leeds interview by Dr Rossiter (University of Leeds)

no actual impacts realised to date
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2011