Source and maintenance of recognition cues in ant societies

Lead Research Organisation: Keele University
Department Name: Inst for Science and Tech in Medicine

Abstract

Distinguishing group members from non-group members underlies a vast array of key animal behaviours, such as territoriality, altruism and mating. This requires variation in recognition signals but it is not known how this variation is maintained. Invertebrates, and many vertebrates, primarily use chemicals to encode information about an individual's species, sex, age or caste, in addition to alarm and trail pheromones. Ants are among the most dominant animals in the world and employ particularly rich forms of chemical communication since they are social, living in colonies containing tens to millions of individuals. Ants comprise five of the world's top seventeen most costly pest insects. Despite their importance as both beneficial and pest species, there is little knowledge about the recognition signals they employ. In fact, it was over 100 yrs ago that it was first suggested that ant recognition was based on chemical cues present in the waterproof layer that coats the outer surface of all insects. Very recently this has been confirmed by demonstrating that chemicals known as cuticular hydrocarbons found on the surface of Formica ants are indeed used in nest mate recognition. We will exploit this recent knowledge to study the genetic and environmental forces that underpin the maintenance of variation in ant recognition signals. To achieve this, we will conduct behavioural, biochemical, genetic and theoretical studies on the ant Formica exsecta and several of its close relatives. Formica ants are a keystone ant genus, comprising over 160 species, including the well-known mound-building wood ants and thus are one of the best studied groups of insects. Therefore, there is already a vast wealth of chemical, genetic, spatial and behavioural data, especially for F. exsecta, which has being studied over the past 15 years by Helsinki University with whom we are collaborating. To achieve our main aim we will conduct three parallel studies: 1) A biochemical investigation to track the production, transportation and eventual secretion of the key cuticular hydrocarbons (CHC) in F. exsecta. This will allow us to understand how and where an individual odour develops. 2) A study aimed at dissecting the genetic and environmental components of variability of the CHC (odour) used by F. exsecta and other Formica species. This will be achieved using the latest molecular tools. For the first time, we will construct a family tree within a single population for over 100 colonies to work out the heritability of the chemical cues. We will then produce a genetic map which will allow the genes that are involved in the production of the key hydrocarbons to be localised. We will test the role of candidate genes, using the genomes of the honeybee and Drosophila, and test for evidence of balancing selection on these genes. 3) Finally, using agent-based modelling we will investigate theoretically the evolution and maintenance of recognition cue variation (at individual, colony, species levels), within a spatial environment that can be subject to different conditions. We will use our empirical data to avoid previous problems associated with over-simplification of the system. In addition to being at the forefront of the rapidly emerging field of chemical ecology, this study helps in two key areas of UK insect conservation. Firstly, in the UK, F. exsecta is a Category 1 threatened species, so we will provide vital information and expertise to underpin the species' conservation. Secondly, understanding how environmental forces interact with genetic variation will provide new insights into the evolution and maintaince of recognition systems not only in ants but in many species of insects since the chemicals we are investigating are synthesised by almost all invertebrates.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description The central aim of this project was to understand the variation in recognition cues between ants from different colonies, and the lack of variation within colonies, that is essential for the cues to function effectively. The ant, Formica exsecta, was used as a model since a simple blend of alkenes has been shown to confer nestmate recognition. Alkanes also present in the cuticular hydrocarbon profile vary with task and do not contribute to nestmate recognition.

Biochemical studies showed that biosynthesis of the alkenes and alkanes follow similar pathways starting from acetate (as in Drosophila) implicating elongases and desaturases as key candidates for control of blend. Blends in the Dufour's and post-pharyngeal glands do not match those on the cuticle, further implicating active transport, perhaps involving lipophorins.

Colonies were shown to be aggressive to ants from any other colony with more than a very slight profile difference, regardless of genetic similarity or distance. Profile variation among colonies was not correlated with any measured environmental variable or with genetic distance determined with a small number of microsatellite loci.

Hydrocarbon profiles of isolated adult or callow ants deviated from the colony profile and a component of this variation was found to be due to patriline. This allowed us to estimate the additive genetic variance in profile present in the population, which was low but significant, with important implications for nepotism within colonies. However, polygynous and monogynous, polyandrous colonies do not have higher variation among worker profiles than monogynous, monandrous colonies showing that a mechanism exists to maintain homogeneity of profile within a colony. Male and female reproductives have greater variation in profile than workers from the same colony.

We hypothesised that colony homogeneity might either be explained by sharing of hydrocarbons between workers (mixing or Gestalt hypothesis) or by active adjustment of individual blends to match the common blend. Experimental data support the matching hypothesis - an important new insight.
Exploitation Route The role of certain genes in the production of these hydrocarbons that regulates nestmate recognition, are potential good age indicators that can potentially be used in a forensic entomology context to age flies and hence help in post-mortem interval calculations.
Sectors Environment

Other

 
Description Our findings related to the nestmate recognition system in ants have been used resulting in a large number of research publications as well as several conference presentations. We have also used our data to apply for further funding. The key findings are also used in smaller research projects that followed from this grant.
First Year Of Impact 2009