The constitution of 'urban' electricity demand
Lead Research Organisation:
CARDIFF UNIVERSITY
Department Name: Cardiff School of Planning and Geography
Abstract
It is widely acknowledged that achieving the net-zero carbon emissions target will require 'large-scale' change in how electricity is generated, supplied and consumed (BEIS, 2017; National Grid, 2018). Within this context, the 'city' has been positioned as a central site and scale through which climate change targets, such as net-zero, could be attained (Betsill and Bulkeley, 2006; Bulkeley et al., 2014; BEIS, 2017, 2019; National Grid, 2018). This framing is based on long-prevalent ideas within and beyond academia about the strong symbiotic relationships between the socio-economic ordering of cities and the energy infrastructures that underwrite them (Tarr and Dupuy, 1988; Graham and Marvin, 2001; Betsill and Bulkeley, 2006; Moss, 2008; Guy et al., 2010; Bulkeley et al., 2014; Graham and McFarlane, 2015; BEIS, 2017, 2019; National Grid, 2018). According to this framing, electricity demand and supply are urban phenomena, which can be reshaped at the scale of the city and at least in part at the behest of local authorities. This urban framing tends to overlook key issues concerning the spatial constitution and ordering of electricity demand, including how and why electricity consumption takes shape in different sites over time, and how the reordering of consumption relates to and depends on the management of the electricity system at different scales. Building on my PhD research, the proposed programme of work
addresses these quandaries, which are imperative for attempts to mitigate climate change.
Addressing the quandaries noted, I would develop and disseminate two clear insights and the related
implications of my PhD research as part of the fellowship. The insights generated in my thesis are as follows: 1) the reordering of urban electricity-demanding geography is not clearly to do with the physical and socioeconomic restructuring of the city, particularly at the hands of local authorities; 2) the management and organisation of electricity supply takes shape at multiple scales and according to different organisational challenges and aggregations of demand, which are not always clearly linked with localised city priorities. These insights have implications for those interested in conceptualising and studying energy demand, and those, including town planners, policymakers and network regulators, involved in mitigating and organising energy consumption and supply in ways that support efforts to alleviate climate change.
To achieve the aim of developing and disseminating my research and establishing a career as an energy researcher, I aim to write three academic articles during the fellowship. I would further develop my research network by participating in two international conferences, providing a presentation at the RGS and convening a session concerning clean energy transitions at 4S. Seeking to build an academic network and disseminate my work, I would also deliver a School Research Seminar and spend a month as a visiting scholar at the Urban Institute in Manchester, engaging and working with scholars and stakeholders in my field.
Finally, the resources and time provided by the fellowship would be utilised to bolster my skills and the bearing of my research outside academia. Specifically, I would undertake three professional training courses. The first involving GIS training and the second and third focused on project management. These would support how I am able to communicate with stakeholders and convey my research findings. I also aim to bring together twenty stakeholders for a workshop to discuss urban energy transitions and related challenges. As a result of the event, a publication would be written about key cross-cutting challenges and solutions linked with the topic of clean energy transitions. To hone my teaching skills, I would deliver two guest lectures on department modules related to my topic area.
addresses these quandaries, which are imperative for attempts to mitigate climate change.
Addressing the quandaries noted, I would develop and disseminate two clear insights and the related
implications of my PhD research as part of the fellowship. The insights generated in my thesis are as follows: 1) the reordering of urban electricity-demanding geography is not clearly to do with the physical and socioeconomic restructuring of the city, particularly at the hands of local authorities; 2) the management and organisation of electricity supply takes shape at multiple scales and according to different organisational challenges and aggregations of demand, which are not always clearly linked with localised city priorities. These insights have implications for those interested in conceptualising and studying energy demand, and those, including town planners, policymakers and network regulators, involved in mitigating and organising energy consumption and supply in ways that support efforts to alleviate climate change.
To achieve the aim of developing and disseminating my research and establishing a career as an energy researcher, I aim to write three academic articles during the fellowship. I would further develop my research network by participating in two international conferences, providing a presentation at the RGS and convening a session concerning clean energy transitions at 4S. Seeking to build an academic network and disseminate my work, I would also deliver a School Research Seminar and spend a month as a visiting scholar at the Urban Institute in Manchester, engaging and working with scholars and stakeholders in my field.
Finally, the resources and time provided by the fellowship would be utilised to bolster my skills and the bearing of my research outside academia. Specifically, I would undertake three professional training courses. The first involving GIS training and the second and third focused on project management. These would support how I am able to communicate with stakeholders and convey my research findings. I also aim to bring together twenty stakeholders for a workshop to discuss urban energy transitions and related challenges. As a result of the event, a publication would be written about key cross-cutting challenges and solutions linked with the topic of clean energy transitions. To hone my teaching skills, I would deliver two guest lectures on department modules related to my topic area.
People |
ORCID iD |
Torik Holmes (Principal Investigator / Fellow) |
Publications
Holmes T
(2021)
Roles, responsibilities and capacities: Theorizing space, social practice, and the relational constitution of energy demand in and beyond Manchester
in Energy Research & Social Science
Holmes T
(2021)
'Spatio-market practices': conceptualising the always spatial dimensions of market making practices
in AMS Review
Holmes T
(2023)
Where are low-carbon places made? Conceptualising and studying infrastructure junctions and the power geometries of low-carbon place-making
in Norsk Geografisk Tidsskrift - Norwegian Journal of Geography
Holmes T
(2021)
Locking-down instituted practices: Understanding sustainability in the context of 'domestic' consumption in the remaking
in Journal of Consumer Culture
Description | A key finding of this research is that the aggregate constitution of energy demand and related challenges in a city are not only the product of the city or only to do with energy policy. This is important for attempts to achieve net zero for the following reasons: 1) It brings into question the idea that cities are best placed to lead transitions to net zero; 2) it heightens the importance of understandings the effects various policies have in terms of where, how, and when energy is demanded. By proxy, my research shows that policy alignments across various scales of governance and domains of everyday life should form a key focus of research and policymaking. Such alignments are crucial to accelerate net zero transitions in and beyond cities. Another key finding of my research is that the organisation and management of the electricity system do not necessarily support net zero transitions. This is in part due to regulation, which prohibits network extension before need and due to the burden of investment being placed on connecting customers. It is also linked with a commitment to asset sweating. This raises new questions about the specific regulatory changes that are required to facilitate network investments that support net zero ambitions. |
Exploitation Route | Policymakers (in and beyond cities) would benefit from engaging with the unintended effects of various and connected policies and further thinking about what it would take to rejig policies to mitigate demand and achieve net zero. Network regulators could act on the insights generated in this research, making changes that spur on investments and changes that support net zero. |
Sectors | Electronics Energy Environment Government Democracy and Justice |
Description | The research findings contributed to a collaborative video focused on where low-carbon cities are made. A piece was also written for The Conversation on the sustainability implications of lock-downs in the UK. The latter resulted in engagement with INetWork - a public sector collaboration project. |
First Year Of Impact | 2022 |
Sector | Energy |
Impact Types | Societal Policy & public services |
Description | Cardiff University School of Geography and Planning, workshop co-convenor, 'The making and shaping of 'net zero' infrastructures in and beyond the 'city'' |
Form Of Engagement Activity | Participation in an activity, workshop or similar |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | International |
Primary Audience | Professional Practitioners |
Results and Impact | The online workshop brought together over 80 people to discuss how infrastructures are being managed to meet net zero. |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2021 |
URL | https://blogs.cardiff.ac.uk/geographyandplanning/the-making-and-shaping-of-net-zero-infrastructures-... |
Description | Hybrid working is fuelling demand for more tech and bigger homes - both are bad news for the planet - The Conversation |
Form Of Engagement Activity | A magazine, newsletter or online publication |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | International |
Primary Audience | Public/other audiences |
Results and Impact | An article for The Conversation, titled Hybrid working is fuelling demand for more tech and bigger homes - both are bad news for the planet. Within a week it reached over 10,000 reads. |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2021 |
URL | https://theconversation.com/hybrid-working-is-fuelling-demand-for-more-tech-and-bigger-homes-both-ar... |
Description | Sustainable Consumption Institute (SCI) Workshop convener, '(Re)making infrastructures in response to sustainability and climate emergencies: challenges, strategies, and opportunities', |
Form Of Engagement Activity | Participation in an activity, workshop or similar |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | National |
Primary Audience | Professional Practitioners |
Results and Impact | This in-person workshop brought over 35 people together to discuss climate emergencies and infrastructures in conjunction. |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2022 |
URL | https://www.manchester.ac.uk/discover/news/sci-workshop-remaking-infrastructures-in-response-to-sust... |