ESRC-FAPESP Creating competitive advantage by serving marginalised communities: UK multinationals and inclusive development in Latin America
Lead Research Organisation:
University of Birmingham
Department Name: Strategy and International Business
Abstract
Multinational Enterprises (MNEs) are often blamed for only serving the elite population when they operate in emerging markets. In addition, they require local governments to create infrastructure and arrangements that can support their activities in the respective country, thus diverting resources from underserved communities within the country towards serving the elite population. The purpose of this study is to explore how multinationals from advanced markets can contribute to the achievement of the United Nations' Sustainable Development Goals by addressing the needs of underserved populations and marginalised communities in emerging markets, while also providing expectations of long-term economic return to their shareholders. Considering the increased awareness of doing good while doing well, MNEs are beginning to realise that profit maximization is not the only route to success. They need to improve their image and demonstrate that their existence is beneficial for the society in general, that is a more long-term route to achieve a competitive advantage. We intend to uncover the mechanisms and actions required by these companies to serve marginalised communities and to create a positive image in the society. To do so, we build from stakeholder theory, social entrepreneurship and value creation literature, and offer a qualitative cross-country study in Latin America. We will focus specifically on the experience of UK multinationals in Brazil and Colombia. We will collect data through focus groups and in-depth interviews with multiple actors (such as multinationals' executives, NGOs, underserved consumers, community leaders, local government representatives, investment promotion organizations, and local entrepreneurs). We will triangulate by comparing data from focus groups, interviews, and secondary sources to draw trustworthy conclusions. Further, we will use pattern matching and case comparison to analyse and make sense of data and draw conclusions.
To address this complex research question, resources and expertise from the UK and Brazil will be combined. Principal and co-investigators have a successful track record in conducting research on MNEs impact in developing countries, on local firms, on engaging in training for managers, and working directly with policy makers. Key investigators are well-known international business scholars and experts with numerous relevant high-level publications. The UK team will contribute with theoretical framing, sharing research and training skills with local researchers, taking the lead in the analysis of data, producing actionable documents for stakeholders, and drafting academic publications. The Brazilian team will provide in-depth knowledge of the research context, drawing on wider networks with businesses locally and close engagement with local societies while collecting data. As results we will provide guidelines for multinationals and other stakeholders as to how inclusive development can be achieved.
To address this complex research question, resources and expertise from the UK and Brazil will be combined. Principal and co-investigators have a successful track record in conducting research on MNEs impact in developing countries, on local firms, on engaging in training for managers, and working directly with policy makers. Key investigators are well-known international business scholars and experts with numerous relevant high-level publications. The UK team will contribute with theoretical framing, sharing research and training skills with local researchers, taking the lead in the analysis of data, producing actionable documents for stakeholders, and drafting academic publications. The Brazilian team will provide in-depth knowledge of the research context, drawing on wider networks with businesses locally and close engagement with local societies while collecting data. As results we will provide guidelines for multinationals and other stakeholders as to how inclusive development can be achieved.
Publications
Azémar C
(2023)
World Investment Report 2022: International tax reforms and sustainable investment United Nations Conference on Trade and Development, Geneva and New York, 2022, 219 pp. ISBN: 978-9211130492
in Journal of International Business Policy
Fu X
(2023)
Tackling exigent grand challenges through corporate social innovation: Evidence from the COVID-19 pandemic
in Journal of Product Innovation Management
Fu X
(2023)
Platform-based business model and entrepreneurs from Base of the Pyramid
in Technovation
Ghauri P
(2022)
Digital technology-based entrepreneurial pursuit of the marginalised communities
in Journal of International Management
Ghauri P
(2022)
The Role of Multinational Enterprises in Achieving Sustainable Development Goals
in AIB Insights
Giroud A
(2024)
World Investment Report 2023: Investing in sustainable energy for all United Nations Conference on Trade and Development, Geneva and New York, 2023, 205 pp.
in Journal of International Business Policy
Giroud, A.
(2024)
Handbook on International Business Policy
Lee J
(2022)
The Impact of Social Media and Digital Platforms Experience on SME International Orientation: The Moderating Role of COVID-19 Pandemic
in Journal of International Management
Description | The semi-systematic literature review resulted in the generation of a new database of 144 articles that focus on understanding how MNEs and disadvantaged communities interact in emerging and developed markets. The early career researchers have gained new knowledge in conducting semi-systematic literature reviews, including developing search strategies, inclusion and exclusion criteria and a system for multiple researchers to collaborate and assess relevance of articles for inclusion in the database. The initial search strategy and keywords used were refined using feedback received from peers at academic conferences. A book chapter on 'MNEs and disadvantaged communities in emerging markets: Paths to SDG8' has been published (March 2024) based on the database of articles. Preliminary findings from interviews conducted with multinationals and their stakeholders are shedding light on the types of marginalised communities targeted by multinationals, nature of and drivers to multinational - community interactions, challenges faced by MNEs in interacting with disadvantaged communities and how these might be overcome, the extent to which other stakeholders are involved in facilitating interactions between multinationals and communities and possible outcomes for multinationals and communities. We are building case studies around a number of multinationals and their stakeholders to gain an in-depth understanding of the mechanisms, strategies and actions multinationals can implement to include disadvantaged communities in social and economic ecosystems. Following this approach we are currently working towards meeting the award's original objectives. Based on our findings, we will provide guidelines for multinationals and other stakeholders as to how inclusive development can be achieved. Together the website and LinkedIn profile are currently being used to disseminate the project's findings to a range of stakeholders. |
Exploitation Route | The database of articles has been used to develop a conceptual model that can be used by researchers who are seeking to advance knowledge on how multinationals interact with disadvantaged communities. Based on our findings from primary interviews, we will (1) refine the conceptual model initially developed based on the literature review, and (2) provide guidelines for multinationals and other stakeholders as to how inclusive development can be achieved. |
Sectors | Communities and Social Services/Policy Financial Services and Management Consultancy Government Democracy and Justice Other |
Title | Research protocol |
Description | The research protocol has been designed to send to potential interviewees when initially contacting them to provide a synopsis the research, the types of questions that will be addressed in the interview, potential benefits of participating and brief information on the lead researchers. |
Type Of Material | Improvements to research infrastructure |
Year Produced | 2022 |
Provided To Others? | No |
Impact | The protocol is being used with the aim of enhancing participation rates and providing potential interviewees with clear and concise information on the project. |
Title | Series of individual interview guidelines for companies, civil society, policy makers, local entrepreneurs and local communities |
Description | Lead researchers have developed a set of individual interview guidelines for companies, civil society, policy makers, local entrepreneurs and local communities. The questions developed for companies cover aspects such as: • Are there any relationships between the company and stakeholders from local marginalised communities (such as, as suppliers / customers / employees / others)? • Does the company incorporate disadvantaged communities in its activities, strategies, new product development or any other activity? • What are the challenges and constraints to include disadvantaged communities into company's mainstream economic activities? • How can the company's activities incorporate people from disadvantaged communities? • Does the company work with key stakeholders (such as, policy makers, civil society, NGOs) to incorporate / work with people from disadvantaged communities? The set of questions for civil society actors are designed to examine the relationship (if any) between the actor and foreign firms in projects for disadvantaged communities, and/or the actor's perception of how foreign firms impact upon (or are impacted by) disadvantaged communities. The research team applied for and were granted full ethical approval for use of the research instruments from University of Birmingham, University of Manchester, and FGV Sao Paulo School of Business Administration. |
Type Of Material | Improvements to research infrastructure |
Year Produced | 2022 |
Provided To Others? | No |
Impact | The interview guidelines will facilitate cross- analysis of data collected from different stakeholders. In doing so, this will contribute to understanding the actions, mechanisms and strategies employed by companies to orchestrate resources and coordinate multi-actor perspectives to address the needs of disadvantaged communities and include these communities in the social and economic ecosystem. |
Title | Interview database |
Description | To date, 38 semi-structured interviews have taken place with managers of multinational firms with headquarters in Europe, and the subsidiaries in Brazil or Colombia, as well as with their stakeholders. The number of interviews for each actor are as follows: Multinational Headquarters and their subsidiaries (16 interviews), NGOs (7 interviews), social entrepreneurs (4 interviews), community leaders (5 interviews), policy makers (5 interviews) and a trade association (1 interview). 18 interviews have been conducted in English and 20 in Portuguese. The interviews that took place in Portuguese have been translated into English. Transcriptions are being stored on NVivo as the data is collected, and the data collected to date is currently being coded. |
Type Of Material | Data analysis technique |
Year Produced | 2023 |
Provided To Others? | No |
Impact | The interviews are in the process of being conducted. The results will be used to refine the conceptual framework that has been developed based on the systematic literature review. |
Title | Literature database - Multinational Enterprises impact on disadvantaged communities |
Description | A systematic literature review was conducted to consolidate existing studies on how Multinational Enterprises impact on disadvantaged communities in emerging markets using three major databases. To be considered relevant, articles needed to focus on three core themes: (1) multinationals, (2) marginalised/disadvantaged communities and (3) either emerging or developed markets (irrespective of the level of economic development). The resulting database includes 144 articles published across multiple literature domains in the fields of management, economics, development and area studies. |
Type Of Material | Data analysis technique |
Year Produced | 2023 |
Provided To Others? | No |
Impact | The systematic literature review was presented at three conferences in 2023 (Academy of International Business Latin America and Caribbean chapter (AIB LAC), AIB UK & Ireland and European International Business Association (EIBA) annual conference. The database has led to the refinement of a conceptual framework to study the impacts of Multinational Enterprises on disadvantaged communities. |
Description | Collaboration with FGV EAESP, Sao Paulo School of Business Administration and Alliance Manchester Business School, University of Manchester |
Organisation | University of Manchester |
Department | Manchester Business School |
Country | United Kingdom |
Sector | Academic/University |
PI Contribution | Joint team meetings are generally held 3-4 times a month to ensure the project is running efficiently. The UK team are contributing to theoretical framing, sharing analytical research and training skills with researchers in Brazil. The UK and Brazilian teams have collaborated to conduct a systematic literature review and a database of articles relevant to the topic. Three papers on the systematic literature review have been presented at three conferences, one in the UK (AIB UKI), one in Brazil (AIB LAC) and one in Portugal (EIBA). The UK and Brazilian teams have collaborated to engage in primary data collection. To date, 38 interviews have taken place with managers of multinational firms with headquarters in Europe, and the subsidiaries in Brazil or Colombia, as well as with their stakeholders. The number of interviews for each actor are as follows: Multinational Headquarters and their subsidiaries (16 interviews), NGOs (7 interviews), social entrepreneurs (4 interviews), community leaders (5 interviews), policy makers (5 interviews) and a trade association (1 interview). |
Collaborator Contribution | The Brazilian team have provided in-depth knowledge of the research context, have facilitated access to participants in Brazil and have engaged in primary data collection with multiple stakeholders including multinationals, Non-Governmental Organisations and social entrepreneurs operating in Brazil. Lead researchers in Brazil and the UK have established a long-standing research relationship through conducting numerous projects in cognate fields of study. |
Impact | The systematic literature review developed as a result of this collaboration has been presented at three conferences, one in the UK (AIB UKI), one in Brazil (AIB LAC) and one in Portugal (EIBA). The systematic literature review was submitted to the International Journal of Management Reviews (IJMR) and is currently being revised in preparation to resubmit. A database of interviews has been created with various stakeholders operating in Brazil (details are outlined in Research datasets section). A book chapter has been published on 'MNEs and disadvantaged communities in emerging markets: Paths to SDG8'. In R. Sinkovics, & O. Kuivalainen (Eds.), International Business and SDG8 - Are we on course? (The Academy of International Business). This collaboration is not multi-disciplinary. |
Start Year | 2022 |
Description | Delivered presentation on "Multinational Enterprises and Sustainable Development Goals in Latin America : role of NGOs and Social Enterprises" |
Form Of Engagement Activity | A talk or presentation |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | Local |
Primary Audience | Other audiences |
Results and Impact | Research fellow Dr Jayne Cathcart provided a presentation to colleagues in the Strategy and International Business department at Birmingham Business School, University of Birmingham on "Multinational Enterprises and Sustainable Development Goals in Latin America : role of NGOs and Social Enterprises". The presentation sparked questions and discussion among the academic audience afterwards. |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2023 |
Description | Linked In profile to disseminate information on the project Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel |
Form Of Engagement Activity | Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | International |
Primary Audience | Other audiences |
Results and Impact | The LinkedIn page was created to disseminate the project website and updates/findings on the project to academics, students, practitioners and the wider public. Currently, the Linked In page has reached over 200 people and has 95 followers based in the UK, Europe and the Americas. The page has generated interest from LinkedIn users who are interacting with content posted on the page, contacting the page administrator for further information on the project, and following the link to the website. |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2023 |
URL | https://www.linkedin.com/company/mne-develop-multinationals-and-disadvantaged-communities-in-latin-a... |
Description | Organised panel discussion on "Multinationals' Investment in Southeast Asia: how Impact has Changed over time" at EAMSA Euro-Asia Management Studies Association, Keio University, Japan |
Form Of Engagement Activity | A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | International |
Primary Audience | Other audiences |
Results and Impact | One of the lead researchers Prof. Axele Giroud organised a panel on "Multinationals' Investment in Southeast Asia: how Impact has Changed over time", with Prof Chie Iguchi (Keio University, Japan), Prof Hikari Ishido (Chiba University, Japan), Dr Upalat Korwatanasukal (Waseda University, Japan), Dr Hendrik Meyer-Ohler (National University Singapore), and Dr Andrew Staples (The Economist, Regional Head APAC). |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2022 |
Description | Organised panel discussion on "Multinationals and Inclusive Development in Latin America and the Caribbean" at Consortium for International Marketing and Research (CIMaR) annual conference at University of Fortaleza, Brazil. |
Form Of Engagement Activity | A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | National |
Primary Audience | Other audiences |
Results and Impact | Two of the lead researchers Prof. Pervez Ghauri and Dr Jorge Carneiro participated in a panel discussion on "Multinationals and Inclusive Development in Latin America and the Caribbean" with Darline Oliveira (Head of ESG at Diego) and Thays Garcia (Head of Sustainability at M. Dias Branco). |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2023 |
Description | Panel discussion on "Multinational Enterprises and Responsible Business" at British Academy of Management (BAM) |
Form Of Engagement Activity | A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | National |
Primary Audience | Other audiences |
Results and Impact | One of the researchers Professor Axele Giroud chaired a Panel discussion event at British Academy of Management (BAM) called "Multinational Enterprises and Responsible Business", with Prof. Timothy Devinney, Dr Stefan Zagelmeyer, Dr Asmund Rygh, Dr Matthew Alford and Dr Dimitrija Kalanoski (Alliance Manchester Business School). The audience included academics and practitioners from across the UK. The panel sparked questions and discussion from the audience afterwards. |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2022 |
Description | Participation in University of Birmingham Brazil Institute meetings |
Form Of Engagement Activity | Participation in an activity, workshop or similar |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | National |
Primary Audience | Other audiences |
Results and Impact | Research fellow Dr Jayne Cathcart introduced the project to attendees at the first meeting of the Brazil Institute at the University of Birmingham and became an affiliate to the Brazil Institute. This sparked interest and discussion among academics associated with the Brazil Institute in the project. |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2024 |
URL | https://www.birmingham.ac.uk/international/global-engagement/brazil |
Description | Presented paper on "Multinational Enterprises and disadvantaged communities in emerging markets: A literature Review" at Academy of International Business (AIB) Latin America & Caribbean chapter at at Escola Superior de Propaganda e Marketing (ESPM), São Paulo |
Form Of Engagement Activity | A talk or presentation |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | International |
Primary Audience | Other audiences |
Results and Impact | Research Fellows Dr Renan Oliveira and Dr Jayne Cathcart presented a paper on "Multinational Enterprises and disadvantaged communities in emerging markets: A literature Review". The presentation sparked interest amongst academics, leading to useful questions and discussion. Outcome is to refine theoretical concepts and results from the project. |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2023 |
Description | Presented paper on "Multinational Enterprises and disadvantaged communities in emerging markets: A literature Review" at Academy of International Business (AIB) UK & Ireland Chapter Conference at University of Glasgow, Scotland. |
Form Of Engagement Activity | A talk or presentation |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | International |
Primary Audience | Industry/Business |
Results and Impact | Research Fellows Dr Renan Oliveira and Dr Jayne Cathcart presented a paper on "Multinational Enterprises and disadvantaged communities in emerging markets: A literature Review". The presentation sparked interest amongst the audience, leading to useful questions and discussion. Outcome is to refine theoretical concepts and results from the project. |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2023 |
Description | Website on project |
Form Of Engagement Activity | Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | International |
Primary Audience | Industry/Business |
Results and Impact | A website has been developed to inform relevant stakeholders (industry practitioners, policy makers, NGOs and communities) of the project and to foster engagement/participation in primary data collection. The website also seeks to disseminate relevant publications relevant to academics, industry practitioners, policy makers, NGOs and communities. In particular, the website outlines the aims and potential outcomes of the project, introduces the research team, offers an academic resource centre (where insights relating to the research will be shared as they emerge, and publications/reports relating to the research will be uploaded and shared with stakeholders). |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2023 |
URL | http://www.mnedevelop.com |