The Importance of Photoevaporation in the Evolution of Protoplanetary Discs
Lead Research Organisation:
University of Cambridge
Department Name: Institute of Astronomy
Abstract
Protoplanetary discs consist of gas and dust leftover from the star formation process orbiting a central star. Lasting a few million years, these are the birth environments of planets, from small rocky worlds to the large gaseous ones, which represent one possible fate for the material in the disc.
However, the planet formation process competes with other processes for this material. For example, if the material in the disc is heated, it can be blown off of the disc in the manner of a wind. This process is known as photoevaporation. The source of the heating may be other nearby stars - "external photoevaporation" - or the central star itself - "internal photoevaporation". Understanding photoevaporation is key because if it acts quickly enough, it may limit the material available for the formation of planets; other theories suggest it could instead promote it. The project seeks to understand the relative importance of photoevaporation processes to the evolution of these discs from two directions: a) simulations of the process itself, b) comparisons of observational trends to photoevaporation models.
a) The rates at which winds driven by photoevaporation remove mass from a disc are still uncertain and vary between models, for example, whether the heating is driven by radiation in the ultraviolet or x-ray part of the spectrum. Understanding how different physical processes act to set the mass loss rates will help resolve this tension and determine the strength of the photoevaporation process. I am tackling this by running numerical hydrodynamical simulations, building up from the simplest models with just the most important features. While simple models have been run before, we are planning a more diverse set that explore, for example, the angle that the wind originates at. These will be useful for interpreting direct observations of the winds. Moreover, at each stage as we add complexity (the first level would be gravity and centrifugal force, more novel aspects would be improved chemistry or relaxing the assuming of radiative equilibrium) to our models, we will compare our results to those from the most advanced models to see which changes have an important effect; we can also apply consistent analysis across these models, such as tracing the radiation, to understand why they may disagree.
b) Existing observational surveys, particularly those conducted using the Atacama Large Millimetre Array (ALMA), are providing data that show a number of correlations between the properties of protoplanetary discs within clusters of young stars. Changes can also be seen with age from cluster to cluster, giving an insight into how the discs evolve. By combining the end results of photoevaporation models with models for the evolution of the disc's dust, we will investigate how the different processes that occur in discs interact. Hence, we will assess whether different photoevaporation models are necessary or helpful in explaining the observed properties, or whether other processes such as planet formation or the "radial drift" of dust are more important in shaping them. Hopefully, this may help place limits on various models of the photoevaporation process or on the intrinsic or initial properties of these discs.
However, the planet formation process competes with other processes for this material. For example, if the material in the disc is heated, it can be blown off of the disc in the manner of a wind. This process is known as photoevaporation. The source of the heating may be other nearby stars - "external photoevaporation" - or the central star itself - "internal photoevaporation". Understanding photoevaporation is key because if it acts quickly enough, it may limit the material available for the formation of planets; other theories suggest it could instead promote it. The project seeks to understand the relative importance of photoevaporation processes to the evolution of these discs from two directions: a) simulations of the process itself, b) comparisons of observational trends to photoevaporation models.
a) The rates at which winds driven by photoevaporation remove mass from a disc are still uncertain and vary between models, for example, whether the heating is driven by radiation in the ultraviolet or x-ray part of the spectrum. Understanding how different physical processes act to set the mass loss rates will help resolve this tension and determine the strength of the photoevaporation process. I am tackling this by running numerical hydrodynamical simulations, building up from the simplest models with just the most important features. While simple models have been run before, we are planning a more diverse set that explore, for example, the angle that the wind originates at. These will be useful for interpreting direct observations of the winds. Moreover, at each stage as we add complexity (the first level would be gravity and centrifugal force, more novel aspects would be improved chemistry or relaxing the assuming of radiative equilibrium) to our models, we will compare our results to those from the most advanced models to see which changes have an important effect; we can also apply consistent analysis across these models, such as tracing the radiation, to understand why they may disagree.
b) Existing observational surveys, particularly those conducted using the Atacama Large Millimetre Array (ALMA), are providing data that show a number of correlations between the properties of protoplanetary discs within clusters of young stars. Changes can also be seen with age from cluster to cluster, giving an insight into how the discs evolve. By combining the end results of photoevaporation models with models for the evolution of the disc's dust, we will investigate how the different processes that occur in discs interact. Hence, we will assess whether different photoevaporation models are necessary or helpful in explaining the observed properties, or whether other processes such as planet formation or the "radial drift" of dust are more important in shaping them. Hopefully, this may help place limits on various models of the photoevaporation process or on the intrinsic or initial properties of these discs.
Organisations
People |
ORCID iD |
Cathie Clarke (Primary Supervisor) | |
Andrew Sellek (Student) |
Publications
Sellek A
(2022)
The importance of X-ray frequency in driving photoevaporative winds
in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
Sellek A
(2021)
The general applicability of self-similar solutions for thermal disc winds
in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
Sellek A
(2020)
A dusty origin for the correlation between protoplanetary disc accretion rates and dust masses
in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
Studentship Projects
Project Reference | Relationship | Related To | Start | End | Student Name |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
ST/S505304/1 | 30/09/2018 | 29/09/2022 | |||
2277492 | Studentship | ST/S505304/1 | 30/09/2019 | 30/03/2023 | Andrew Sellek |
ST/T505985/1 | 30/09/2019 | 29/09/2023 | |||
2277492 | Studentship | ST/T505985/1 | 30/09/2019 | 30/03/2023 | Andrew Sellek |
Description | Winds are potentially able to remove material from protoplanetary (planet-forming) discs, but the strength and significance of these winds is not well understood. The winds may be driven by to magnetic fields in the disc or simply by heating from the central star (thermal winds). In particular, there remain theoretical uncertainties as to whether the thermal winds are best heated by extreme ultraviolet (EUV) or X-ray radiation, which has important consequences for the state of the wind, and the amount of mass it can remove from the disc. In Sellek, Booth & Clarke 2020, we found that this mass loss is likely needed to reproduce the trends seen in surveys of larger numbers of these discs, but that its rate should be relatively low, perhaps more appropriate to EUV-driven winds or the X-rays produced by low mass stars. We have investigated the reasons for the disagreements between different models of winds, finding that the energy that the X-rays or EUV are assumed to have in these models is a key determinant of whether the resulting winds appear to be driven by the X-rays or the EUV. |
Exploitation Route | The understanding we have gained about the key factors influencing the launching of winds will be instrumental in identifying the correct set of conditions to use in future models to get a definitive determination of the strengths of the winds. These calculations can then be implemented into models of planet formation in discs to understand the effect the host star could have on the number, size and habitability of any planets formed. From an observational perspective, astronomers may be better able to interpret observations of line emission from winds due the understanding we have built around the kinematics of thermal winds and their cooling. |
Sectors | Other |
Title | SelfSimilarThermalWinds |
Description | A python package allowing the calculation of streamlines and launch velocities for self-similar thermal winds, which can be used to photoevaporative winds. The results were benchmarked against hydrodynamical simulations as part of Sellek, Clarke & Booth 2021. This package is designed to allow the easier calculation of approximate flow structure for winds, which could be used for calculating observable signatures of winds. |
Type Of Technology | Webtool/Application |
Year Produced | 2021 |
Open Source License? | Yes |
Impact | Was used by Sellek, Clarke & Booth 2021 to determine that the most critical factor setting the flow velocity of winds is typically the inclination of the wind base, and then to consider how this might affect the blueshifted line profiles of forbidden line emission. |
URL | https://academic.oup.com/mnras/article/506/1/1/6298241 |
Description | Open Evening Talk |
Form Of Engagement Activity | A talk or presentation |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | Regional |
Primary Audience | Public/other audiences |
Results and Impact | 25 minute Public Talk as part of my department's regular open evening talks, streamed live over YouTube. Title: Where do protoplanetary discs go? (How winds set the stage for planet formation). I summarised the main processes dispersing protoplanetary discs, how my research has been trying to pin down the potential role of photoevaporatve winds in this context and why this could be important for our understanding of planet formation. There was a short Q&A at the end. |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2022 |
URL | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UbNlhRSOgsE |
Description | TCSS Symposium Talk |
Form Of Engagement Activity | A talk or presentation |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | Local |
Primary Audience | Undergraduate students |
Results and Impact | Talk to the Trinity College Science Society as part of their annual symposium. Title: How winds set the stage for planet formation. I summarised the current uncertainties about the role of photoevaporative winds in the evolution of protoplanetary discs and how my research has been trying to resolve these and hence understanding the impact of winds on both discs and any planet formation therein - through hydrodynamic, radiative transfer, and dust evolution modelling. Some audience questions followed and I continued some discussions over the refreshments. |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2022 |