Women's Work and Working Women: A Longitudinal Study of Women Working in the British Film and Television Industries (1933-1989)

Lead Research Organisation: Newcastle University
Department Name: Sch of English Lit, Lang & Linguistics

Abstract

This project assesses the contribution women have made to film/TV production in Britain, during a period of considerable social change for women and substantial institutional change for the industries: 1933-89. Whilst a minority have worked in 'above-the-line' roles (directors, costume designers), thousands have been employed in 'below-the-line' roles as hairdressers, continuity 'girls', production assistants, and negative cutters, yet their history has barely been studied. Much of their work has been undervalued by academic scholarship which has privileged auteur-directors, and its study hampered by scarce archival sources. This research project looks at the historical relations between women & production by exploring women's contribution through ACT/T trade union records and oral history testimony. From 1933-89 film & commercial TV operated as a closed shop and BBC employment was similarly regulated. By tracing women's contribution through union membership this project will provide empirical data about how many women worked in the industries, their roles and their movement between film/TV. This data will be supplemented by oral history interviews with women which explore their working lives. In bringing these two approaches together this project will unlock previously hidden evidence about women's work, and develop new ways of conceptualising and historicising the film/TV industries through the experiences of below-the-line workers. This will have a wider impact on both the study of film/TV and our understanding of the role of women in 20thC creative arts/industries.
This 3.5-year project has 2 key parts. Part 1, based at the Universities of Newcastle & Sunderland, is led by the PI (Dr Melanie Bell) and CI (Dr Vicky Ball) and comprises a Research Associate (RA), a PhD, a major conference and papers, union training workshops, a website, an oral history project, and a monograph. The PhD will use historical union data to survey women in a chosen industry grade (e.g. producer, editor), and use written, oral & visual evidence from films to produce a number of case studies which analyse women's contributions to the field, thus extending our knowledge of women's work. The conference will draw together academics, archivists, TV/film industry personnel, and policy-makers to explore how long-established working practices have shaped the various dimensions of women's employment in the industries. The RA will lead the oral history component, recording interviews with 25 women, prioritising grades where few historical records remain e.g. make-up, wardrobe, continuity. The interview material will be hosted on a project website and used in BECTU union training workshops with current industry practitioners. The final project outcome (yr 3.5) will be a monograph by the PI/CI which analyses gender and production culture in ACT/T's 3 branches (Film Production, Laboratory, TV) and the BBC, assesses women's campaigning activities (ACTT Equality Committee) and provides case studies of women's work in Costume, Make-Up and Scriptwriting. Part 2, sub-contracted to the British Universities Film & Video Council, will produce a database of ACT/T union membership application data under agreement with the film/TV union, now named BECTU. Whilst the project team will work specifically on women's grades & pay, the database will hold membership application data for both women & men (67,000 apps. in total) ensuring its future potential as a major digital resource for other researchers. Published in yr 3 it will be hosted on a contextual website containing case studies & oral history material and maintained by the BUFVC beyond the life of the project. By bringing into clearer focus the historical gendering of working patterns & production cultures the project's findings will benefit academics/students of film/TV/gender/labour history, and provide a body of evidence which industry personnel/policy-makers may draw upon to intervene in current policy/practice.

Planned Impact

The first area of impact comes from the project's partnership with BECTU. The BUFVC project website and its digitised resources (ACT/T membership application data, oral histories interviews) will make a major contribution to the history of women's work in the production of film and television. BECTU will also benefit from the oral history learning resource developed by the project for use in union training sessions and workshops, which will prompt discussion amongst its members about equality and diversity. This output has significant impact potential which will be measured through workshop participant feedback and BECTU-administered questionnaires in subsequent years. The RA will publish a self-reflexive account of methodology, of interest to trainers/oral historians in other subject-specific contexts.

Secondly, the materials housed on the BUFVC website (searchable database, application data, oral histories, case studies, self-reflexive report on database design and research methodology, and PhD self-reflexive diary) will be of use to archivists, users of media archives, industry workers, their representative bodies and the general public, beyond the scope and life-span of this project. The self-reflexive report on research methodology will suggest alternative ways of using the database and digitised application forms. The PhD's self-reflexive diary will provide a toolkit for researchers and students. Both research outputs will benefit researchers across a number of disciplines (see outputs & academic beneficiaries).

Thirdly, findings from the project will be used for advocacy purposes at events organised by industry groups Women in Film & TV (WFTV) & Skillset. They will be used in three main ways:
1. to raise awareness and promote discussion of equality and diversity practice;
2. to promote women's contributions to film and television production;
3. to raise new expectations and point to new career aspirations for girls/young women.

The fourth output designed to engage potential beneficiaries with the research is the project conference (July 2016) which has four panels targeting the industry, archival and academic sectors:
1. The 'Women & Industry' panel will highlight the relevance of our historical study to the current context and women's position therein. The research and findings from our project will be able to historicise/contextualise findings and trends identified in post-1995 government commissioned reports. The conference will be a crucial forum to bring together representatives from government and industry who have a vested interest in equal opportunities; DCMS, Skillset, BFI, Arts Council, BBC, ITV and CH 4, as well as workers themselves and their representative groups (WFTV & BECTU).
2. The 'Women & Work' panel will celebrate and debate women's creative contributions to film/TV, past and present, by inviting a cross-generational panel of women to discuss their work and working practices.
3. The 'Women & the Unions' panel will feature representatives from BECTU's Equality Committee (past and present), their training team, and their Young Persons Forum to speak about the union's relationship to equality and diversity issues, and debate future pathways.
4. The 'Women & the Archives' panel will invite representatives from national/regional film and TV archives, company archives such as Granada and curators, librarians and researchers. The panel will address future pathways to enable the education, research and preservation of materials related to women's film/TV history.
The project's conference will therefore provide a stimulus, in terms of impact, to policy-makers and industry groups, women workers, BECTU, archivists and researchers to debate the key issues relating to women's work in film and television production (both past, present and future) and, via the project website and media publicity, bring the project and the issues it raises to wider public attention.
 
Description Using a diverse range of non-traditional evidence including oral histories and trade union records, the project excavated the contribution made by ordinary women (as opposed to directors), to British film and television production, in the years after the coming of sound (1927) and before the demise of the unions through broadcasting legislation (1990). Drawing on contacts provided by the project's partner, the media union BECTU, Bell co-ordinated the recording of a number of 'life story' oral history interviews with retired media practitioners drawn from female-dominated specialisms which are rarely included in media histories (costume and wardrobe, editing, production support, animation painting amongst others). Bell also supervised the digitisation of a complete collection of historical trade union records for the 1927-90 period (67,000 records), which provide hitherto unseen access to women (and men's) work in film and television production (and allied industries including radio broadcast and music recording). These materials were shared with project partners (BECTU) and stakeholders (women media practitioners) through discussion at conferences and other workshop events.Analysis of these materials revealed the complexity of women's labour at particular historical junctures and in different production contexts. Women emerged as leading figures in the field of foley sound whilst women editors in factual film production were shown to have made a significant creative contribution to outputs. The project analysed the mechanisms through which different work sectors were feminised, and recuperated women's craft skills, creativity and innovation in these roles, concluding that questions of gender are unique in revealing how media industries are organised.
Exploitation Route Findings are being used by the cultural/heritage sector who are drawing on them to develop events which engage with a general public interested in women's film history. (see Impact narrative for further details).
Sectors Creative Economy

Education

Culture

Heritage

Museums and Collections

 
Description Findings have been used in three ways: (i) BECTU Women's Conference (2015): behavioural change and contributing to policy change At the core of the project was a one-day event co-organised with the project's partners BECTU to share and debate project findings with women media practitioners, with a remit to stimulate change. The PI and RA developed the 'Voices for Change' methodology, where extracts from oral history testimony were used to shape a guided discussion around key themes and issues impacting women's experience of media work. Forty women participated in the conference and these discussions were recorded and transcripts analysed. The 'Voices for Change' format encouraged participants to draw on narratives of continuity and difference to make sense of similar gender-based dilemmas in their work as media practitioners. Twenty-five participants completed feedback surveys which highlighted attitudinal change and increased commitment to work-place activism: 'I am looking out for others more and am more alive to the issues'; 'It definitely made me think more about what I can do for women's rights [in the workplace]'. A six month follow-up with participants elicited eight responses, and demonstrated continued behavioural change: 'I am more likely to be vociferous about inequality at work in my role as union rep.'. BECTU's Equality Committee used the discussion and feedback generated by the event, alongside pre-existing data from a membership survey, to develop a pilot mentoring scheme for women in the media industries. The pilot ran from October 2017-March 2018, trained ten mentors and supported fifteen women in industry, with particular emphasis on new entrants and career changers/returners. (ii) Media practitioners conference: increased awareness, wellbeing and job satisfaction The 'Voices for Change' method was presented, by invitation, to media industry delegates attending a one-day conference at Greenwich University, London (2017). Entitled 'Trailblazing Women' the remit of the event was to share experience and stimulate dialogue between different generations of women media practitioners. Feedback questionnaires were distributed amongst sixty delegates with a small number (4) reporting an increase in awareness and wellbeing around women's issues. This was especially significant amongst young women (aged 20-25) who were just beginning to navigate the gender discrimination of the workplace and particularly welcomed listening to oral history testimony which they reported as helping them explore and consolidate their own professional identities, which in turn enhanced their job satisfaction: 'Hearing about women fighting for titles of "technician" or "artist" or "designer" inspired me to use terms that clearly indicate I am a professional and I owe it to those women to own it'. (iii) Film programming 'Women's Histories': informing cultural practice Presentation by the PI at an AudioVisual Heritage event in 2017 brought the research to an audience of cultural heritage institutions (libraries, museums, galleries and cultural exhibitors). This inspired professionals working in the regional film community who subsequently drew on the research to support their development of new cultural events (Square Chapel, Halifax, April 2019) for a cinema-going public interested in women's film history.
First Year Of Impact 2015
Sector Creative Economy,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Cultural

Societal

 
Title Learning on Screen (BUFVC): Women's Work in British Film & Television 
Description The database has been developed in collaboration with the British University Film and Video Council (now known as 'Learning on Screen') and will go live at the end of the award. This database is a repository of the quantitative data (union records) from which statistical reports can be generated and qualitative data (oral history interviews, both new and legacy). It also contains 'how to' videos, self-reflexive reports, historical timelines and explanations of the recruitment process and methodology. In order to meet the requirements of the data protection act, and the wishes of interviewees, certain elements of data have been anonymised. This is explained on the resource. Parts of the site are 'open access' and will reach the general public; other parts have federated access, restricted to those with Learning on Screen membership, principally those in higher and further education. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact Scholarship within the research team is already being underpinned by this resource (conference papers and journal articles). When the resource goes live at the end of the grant funding period we anticipate its materials will have a notable impact on gender and film and television histories. 
 
Description BECTU Women's Committee (London) 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact PI and RA attended and presented at the BECTU Women's Committee, attended by 60 participants from across the UK. BECTU is the media and entertainment union (representing professionals across all media including film, television, radio, theatre). The Women's Committee meet annually to set goals and initiatives around equality and diversity. We gave a formal presentation and ran workshops using oral history interview material gathered from the research project. This material was used as a stimulus for debates around equality and diversity within the media. The Steering Group of the Women's Committee reported that the majority of delegates rated the event 'very successful' in their feedback forms.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2015
 
Description Gender Equalities at Work 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Frances C. Galt and Sarah Boston (2021) 'In Conversation with Sarah Boston', Gender Equalities at Work [Podcast]. 29 August.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://www.genderequalitiesat50.ed.ac.uk/2021/08/29/new-podcast-in-conversation-with-sarah-boston/
 
Description Leeds International Film Festival 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Presentation / introduction to a cinema audience regarding the work of editor Thelma Connell, which generated debate about the 'forgotten' history of women film editors.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
 
Description Podcast 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Frances C. Galt and So Mayer (2021) 'Interview with Frances Galt to mark publication of Women's Activism Behind the Screens', Raising Films. April.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://www.raisingfilms.com/frances-galt-interview-womens-activism/
 
Description Trade Unions and Gender Inequality in the British Film and Television Industries 
Form Of Engagement Activity A broadcast e.g. TV/radio/film/podcast (other than news/press)
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Frances C. Galt and Dave O'Brien (2021) 'Women's Activism Behind the Screens: Trade Unions and Gender Inequality in the British Film and Television Industries', New Books Network [Podcast]. 5 March. Available via: https://newbooksnetwork.com/womens-activism-behind-the-screens
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
 
Description Wikipedia Edit-A-Thon 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Third sector organisations
Results and Impact 20 participants took part in an edit-a-thon which amended existing pages about women film-makers on Wikipedia with the goal to enhance knowledge about those women and make their presence more visible on the site. The women played a central role in making British cinema but their contribution and presence has been under-reported. the edit-a-thon workshop corrected this lack of visibility.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
 
Description podcast 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact Frances C. Galt (2021) 'Women's Activism Behind the Screens', Transforming Society. 12 March.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://www.transformingsociety.co.uk/2021/03/12/womens-activism-behind-the-screens/