Characterisation of cue-dependent behaviour in plant parasitic nematodes (PPNs); the neurobiology of host plant invasion
Lead Research Organisation:
University of Southampton
Department Name: Centre for Biological Sciences
Abstract
Nematodes are rounds worms that live in many habitats ranging from the highest mountains to the deepest seas. There are a number of different nematodes that have evolved for distinct life-styles. They encompass both non-parasitic and parasitic worms. Amongst the latter are parasitic nematodes that use agriculturally important crops and animals as hosts often affecting their vitality and/or viability. Such parasites lead to disease processes that cost billions of pounds and reduce the capability for food self-sufficiency and security. In the UK and across the world we face an increasing problem from nematodes that infect animals and also plant parasitic nematodes that infest crops. For the latter, this is worsened by the growing realization that current treatments are becoming increasingly unacceptable due to environmental and human health implications and their withdrawal from use. This places farming in a very vulnerable position. The plant parasitic nematodes (PPNs) directly cause damage and also act as secondary carriers for diseases. In the UK they place a severe burden on potato crops. The life cycle of the PPNs involves the maturation of the worm in the host's root where it diverts plant nutrients to its own development and reproduction. This is followed by release of a free living form, from resource exhausted infected roots, that goes onto re-invade a different root. Some of these nematodes show a selective taste for one kind of plant while others can target a range of hosts. In either case the parasites often infect and reduce yields from intensively farmed and economically important crops. An essential aspect of the successful completion of the PPN life cycle is movement through the soil from the point of release to locate and reinvade new host roots. This is achieved through a simple three step process. Firstly, the free living worm detects signals from the root. Secondly it uses its sensor organs to detect these tell-tale host cues. Thirdly it uses these cues to track towards the new root. The details of what the worm's sensors are and how they guide its movement to an appropriate host are poorly understood but clearly very important for maintaining the parasite's life cycle. This is in complete contrast to the detailed understanding we have for another species of nematode, the so-called 'model' organism, C. elegans. This non-parasitic worm has been extensively studied by biologists since the 1960s and its success as a biological model is manifest by the fact that it was the first animal to have its genome sequenced (1998). Indeed, it has been instrumental in the award of three Nobel prizes. Neurobiologists have defined in precise detail the molecular, cellular and behavioural mechanisms through which this worm senses food and moves towards it. Furthermore, chemicals that act against parasitic nematodes also have effects on C. elegans consistent with the view that the latter provide a good model for understanding signalling and behaviour in PPNs. We will use the techniques, expertise and understanding of C. elegans and translate these to a detailed analysis of host location behaviour in PPNs. We will use laboratory based investigations in which root extracts from host plants modify PPN behaviour and investigate chemicals that could act against PPNs to prevent their ability to locate and/or move towards the host plant. This will be facilitated by ongoing genome sequencing for PPNs which will reveal the molecular identity of new targets through which nematicidal chemicals act. This will be done with a view to identifying new chemical targets for nematicides. These efforts will be facilitated by a supply of chemicals from collaborating industrial colleagues that have the potential to provide PPN selective nematicides that act by impairing the parasite's ability to find its host plant. In this way the project will address the threat to farming posed by the lack of effective, environmentally safe nematicides.
Technical Summary
Understanding of C. elegans neurobiology will be leveraged to provide insight into the neural mechanisms underpinning host location by plant parasitic nematodes (PPN). We will develop new assays for measuring cue-dependent behaviour in two species of PPN. Preliminary assays indicate PPNs exhibit a similar repertoire of locomotory behaviours as C. elegans comprising reversals, turns, speed of motility, direction of motility, and in a similar fashion to C. elegans, these behaviours are modified by chemosensory cues. Thus we will adapt video-based analysis designed for C. elegans to a discrete analysis of PPN behaviour and parameterise sub-components of locomotion that together enable the worm to localise its host. We will investigate the role of key signalling molecules, i.e. neurotransmitters and receptors, in mediating these behaviours. The work will be facilitated by maturing genome sequencing projects for PPNs permitting identification of PPN orthologues of key molecular components e.g. neurotransmitter receptors, involved in PPN navigation towards its host. These will be targeted by RNAi and the impact of their reduced expression on PPN plant cue-dependent responses will thus delineate potential nematicide targets. In addition, by testing the effects of compounds, encompassing known nematicides, anthelmintics and novel neuroactive chemicals we will quantify potential efficacy against PPN host location behaviour. Subsequent heterologous expression of the PPN receptors will build on the organism-based approaches and allow a more direct comparison of chemical action on the C. elegans and PPN targets. As this derives from a comparative approach it can contribute to the design of PPN selective compounds. This effort will be facilitated by an ongoing industrial collaboration in the field of crop protection that will provide access to compound libraries representing modifications of established nematicide chemistry or compounds with unknown mode of action.
Planned Impact
A: Beneficiaries from this research
A1: Commercial private sector
Crop protection industry: There is a need for basic research that will inform development of the next generation of crop protection products with the required specificity and lack of non-target effects. This is currently hampered by a relative lack of knowledge on the physiology and pharmacology of plant parasitic nematodes.
UK potato growers: The British Potato Council (BPC) estimates the UK potato production, processing and retail market has an annual value of c. £3 billion. This research will, in the long term, support potato producers who need approaches to control potato cyst nematode, particularly the cyst nematode species Globodera pallida. The pesticides used to control this nematode are the largest variable cost of the growers who use them. This represents 23% of the UK potato acreage being treated each year. The proposed project will demonstrate that fundamental research can support their agronomic needs.
International growers: Nematodes are responsible for worldwide crop losses of c. $ 125 billion per annum. This research will investigate a key aspect of plant-nematode interactions in two of the most economically important genera of plant parasitic nematodes. The information gained is likely to be relevant to a wide range of growers in both intensive and subsistence agriculture.
Supermarkets: Some of the major supermarkets see value in removing even the theoretical risk of pesticide residues from the potatoes they sell. The outputs of this project may in the longer term support that policy.
A2: Policy-makers
DEFRA and The Scottish Government (SG) must implement the EU's amendment Directive 91/414/EEC that seeks to reduce use of hazardous crop protection chemicals in EU agriculture. The Directive involves the abrupt or gradual withdrawal of nematicides from the UK market. This is a challenge for UK potato production as it receives more crop protection treatments than other broad acre crops. DEFRA and SG need evidence of effective alternatives for potato cyst nematode control as they must also support an EU Directive specifically aimed at potato cyst nematodes (2007/33/EC) that came into force in July 2010. The research addresses basic aspects of nematode behaviour that could culminate in improved pathogen management in the longer term.
A3: General Public
Most of the UK population consumes potatoes and there is a need to maintain potatoes as a nutritious and inexpensive staple food. This work will support that need in the long term.
B: Nature of benefits from this research
B1: Benefits for UK economic competitiveness
The prevalence of G. pallida contributed to a decline in the UK potato crop of 11.9% between 1999 and 2003. This is a larger fall than that of other major EU producers that lack this pest. This work would build a platform to address the problem of PCN control that faces many UK producers and is one cause of their move away from this crop.
B2: Increasing the effectiveness of public services and policy
It is relevant for those who seek to implement change in policies such as an amendment to Directive 91/414/EEC and implementation of 2007/33/EC to be aware that the UK science base supports its agricultural sector and is working to develop measures to address new legislation.
B3: Enhancing cultural enrichment, quality of life and health?
Reducing reliance on currently used hazardous pesticides carries a benefit for UK biodiversity and sustainability of food production.
A recent report from the Royal Society identified the need for training in agricultural sciences and related topics. The Postdoctoral scientist will therefore be trained in an area of considerable importance and recent neglect.
Impact activities will raise awareness in the general public of some of the problems associated with food production and the role science can play in addressing these issues.
A1: Commercial private sector
Crop protection industry: There is a need for basic research that will inform development of the next generation of crop protection products with the required specificity and lack of non-target effects. This is currently hampered by a relative lack of knowledge on the physiology and pharmacology of plant parasitic nematodes.
UK potato growers: The British Potato Council (BPC) estimates the UK potato production, processing and retail market has an annual value of c. £3 billion. This research will, in the long term, support potato producers who need approaches to control potato cyst nematode, particularly the cyst nematode species Globodera pallida. The pesticides used to control this nematode are the largest variable cost of the growers who use them. This represents 23% of the UK potato acreage being treated each year. The proposed project will demonstrate that fundamental research can support their agronomic needs.
International growers: Nematodes are responsible for worldwide crop losses of c. $ 125 billion per annum. This research will investigate a key aspect of plant-nematode interactions in two of the most economically important genera of plant parasitic nematodes. The information gained is likely to be relevant to a wide range of growers in both intensive and subsistence agriculture.
Supermarkets: Some of the major supermarkets see value in removing even the theoretical risk of pesticide residues from the potatoes they sell. The outputs of this project may in the longer term support that policy.
A2: Policy-makers
DEFRA and The Scottish Government (SG) must implement the EU's amendment Directive 91/414/EEC that seeks to reduce use of hazardous crop protection chemicals in EU agriculture. The Directive involves the abrupt or gradual withdrawal of nematicides from the UK market. This is a challenge for UK potato production as it receives more crop protection treatments than other broad acre crops. DEFRA and SG need evidence of effective alternatives for potato cyst nematode control as they must also support an EU Directive specifically aimed at potato cyst nematodes (2007/33/EC) that came into force in July 2010. The research addresses basic aspects of nematode behaviour that could culminate in improved pathogen management in the longer term.
A3: General Public
Most of the UK population consumes potatoes and there is a need to maintain potatoes as a nutritious and inexpensive staple food. This work will support that need in the long term.
B: Nature of benefits from this research
B1: Benefits for UK economic competitiveness
The prevalence of G. pallida contributed to a decline in the UK potato crop of 11.9% between 1999 and 2003. This is a larger fall than that of other major EU producers that lack this pest. This work would build a platform to address the problem of PCN control that faces many UK producers and is one cause of their move away from this crop.
B2: Increasing the effectiveness of public services and policy
It is relevant for those who seek to implement change in policies such as an amendment to Directive 91/414/EEC and implementation of 2007/33/EC to be aware that the UK science base supports its agricultural sector and is working to develop measures to address new legislation.
B3: Enhancing cultural enrichment, quality of life and health?
Reducing reliance on currently used hazardous pesticides carries a benefit for UK biodiversity and sustainability of food production.
A recent report from the Royal Society identified the need for training in agricultural sciences and related topics. The Postdoctoral scientist will therefore be trained in an area of considerable importance and recent neglect.
Impact activities will raise awareness in the general public of some of the problems associated with food production and the role science can play in addressing these issues.
Publications
Courtot E
(2015)
Functional Characterization of a Novel Class of Morantel-Sensitive Acetylcholine Receptors in Nematodes
in PLOS Pathogens
Crisford A
(2015)
The effect of double-stranded RNA on styley behaviour in Globodera pallida
in Aspects of Applied Biology
Crisford A.
(2014)
SEROTONERGIC SIGNALLING IN
GLOBODERA PALLIDA
in JOURNAL OF NEMATOLOGY
Crisford Anna
(2013)
LEVERAGING
C.
ELEGANS CUE-DEPENDENT BEHAVIOR TO UNDERSTAND THE HOST/PARASITE INTERACTION FOR PLANT PARASITIC NEMATODES
in JOURNAL OF NEMATOLOGY
Crisford, Anna
(2013)
Leveraging C. elegans cue-dependent behaviour to understand the host/parasite interaction for plant parasitic nematodes.
in International Worm Meeting Conference Proceedings
Holden-Dye L.
(2014)
LABEL-FREE COHERENT RAMAN SCATTERING (CRS) IMAGING FOR METABOLIC PROFILING OF NEMATODES.
in JOURNAL OF NEMATOLOGY
Hu C
(2014)
StyletChip: a microfluidic device for recording host invasion behaviour and feeding of plant parasitic nematodes.
in Lab on a chip
Kearn J
(2014)
Fluensulfone is a nematicide with a mode of action distinct from anticholinesterases and macrocyclic lactones.
in Pesticide biochemistry and physiology
Description | Plant parasitic nematodes are microscopic worms that infect the roots of their host plants. Mounting concerns over the ecotoxicity of currently used chemical control agents, nematicides, and their subsequent regulation means that these pests present an increasing threat to food security. This project has brought together a group in Leeds with expertise in plant parasitic nematodes with neuroscientists based at the University of Southampton to tackle this problem from a new angle. The rationale is that a deeper understanding of the neural mechanisms in the nematode that enable it to recognise and invade its host plant will provide a better informed route to new approaches for chemical control. The Southampton group brought expertise in understanding the neural mechanisms of cue-dependent behaviour in the model genetic organism C. elegans to the project whilst the Leeds group brought expertise in the biology of plant parasitic nematodes and a very timely knowledge of the genome of the potato cyst nematode G. pallida through their key involvement in the just completed sequencing project. We conducted a bioinformatics screen in G. pallida to identify orthologues of components of signalling pathways known to regulate cue-dependent behaviour in C. elegans. We identified more than 30 candidates for investigation and selected those most likely to impact on host plant invasion behaviour for further analysis including nicotinic acetylcholine receptor subunits and components of the serotonergic signalling pathways. We established the function of the G. pallida genes by showing that their expression in a C. elegans knockout genetic background could fully rescue the C. elegans phenotype. These results have been presented as conference contributions and will form the basis for at least two full manuscripts. To assess the neural mechanisms underpinning behaviour of the infective J2 stage of the plant parasitic nematode Globodera pallida, a major economic burden on potato production in the UK, we developed new assays for quantifying motility and cue-dependent behaviours in response to host plant signals. These assays will be written up as a short publication. We attempted gene knockdown using RNAi for specific components of the serotonergic signalling pathway to delineate its functional role in the nematode's behaviour however we found that RNAi treatment resulted in a non-specific toxicity. This has been published as a short communication in the Annals of Applied Biology. As an alternative we adopted a chemical biology approach and have carried out an extensive pharmacological analysis of the role of serotonergic signalling in host plant invasion behaviour. This has yielded new insight into the fundamental importance of serotonin signalling in the parasitic life cycle of Globodera pallida and highlights a new route to pest control. In sum, we have characterised key receptor signalling pathways involved in the behaviour of the plant parasitic nematode Globodera pallida, a major pest of potatoes in the UK, and found new chemical approaches to preventing them from invading the host plant root. |
Exploitation Route | The project opens the way for a more targeted approach to preventing plant parasitic nematodes from invading their host plants. |
Sectors | Agriculture Food and Drink |
Description | The research has been used to support a number of public engagement activities including exhibits for Science Week (2013,14, 15; typically 3000 visitors per year) and practical research projects (up to 20 students per year) for a 6th form college, Peter Symonds, which have run every year for the last 4 years. Numerous one-off lectures have been delivered by the PIs for lay audiences including through Café Scientifique and Pint of Science. In addition, an exhibition was provided for the New Forest Show in July 2015. The project, and in particular the fruitful collaboration between the Leeds Group and Southampton, has facilitated interactions with industry for chemical testing and mode of action studies. This collaboration is ongoing through a fully funded PhD student with Adama Agricultural Solutions. We have a patent pending for the use of reserpine as a seed coating to protect against plant parasitic nematodes. This has just received pump priming funding of £30k to explore proof of concept through glass house and field trials (HEIF funding). The collaboration sponsored by this project between Leeds and Southampton was also instrumental in the development of a novel platform for testing the effect of chemical on host plant invasion behaviour, StyletChip, which has further contributed to the launch of an enterprise unit, Neurivo, based at Southampton with a goal of further translating advances in nematode neurobiology to an industrial setting. The project has provided leverage to add value in the form of two PhD studentships; a BBSRC CASE studentship with Bayer CropScience (Southampton) with the potential to deliver further impact in the arena of crop protection. |
First Year Of Impact | 2023 |
Sector | Agriculture, Food and Drink,Education |
Impact Types | Cultural Economic |
Description | Bayer Grants4Targets |
Amount | € 30,000 (EUR) |
Organisation | Bayer |
Department | Bayer CropScience Ltd |
Sector | Private |
Country | United Kingdom |
Start | 08/2016 |
End | 05/2017 |
Description | Characterisation of Globodera pallida stylet thrusting and mode of action of emodepside |
Organisation | Bayer |
Department | Bayer CropScience Ltd |
Country | United Kingdom |
Sector | Private |
PI Contribution | The collaboration supports a BBSRC CASE partnership |
Collaborator Contribution | Supply of reagents and industrial placement |
Impact | Paper in preparation |
Start Year | 2012 |
Description | Characterisation of H. contortus levamisole receptors |
Organisation | French National Institute of Agricultural Research |
Department | INRA Toulouse |
Country | France |
Sector | Public |
PI Contribution | We provided expertise for the characterisation of H. contortus receptors using C. elegans as a transgenic expression platform. |
Collaborator Contribution | INRA provided a visiting researcher to conduct the experiments for a period of 2 months and H. contortus clones |
Impact | Publication in PLoS Pathogens 2015, Courtot et al. |
Start Year | 2014 |
Description | Characterisation of plant parasitic nematode nicotinic acetylcholine receptors |
Organisation | French National Institute of Agricultural Research |
Department | INRA Toulouse |
Country | France |
Sector | Public |
PI Contribution | Our team has contributed cloned genes for potato cyst nematode acetylcholine receptors, data concerning their function and expertise, to facilitate a collaborative investigation of the function of plant parasitic nematode receptors using heterologous expression in a Xenopus oocyte system. |
Collaborator Contribution | Our collaborators have contributed vectors, cloned genes, expertise in oocyte expression and analysis and access to specialist equipment and facilities for undertaking the experiments. A member of our research team has been hosted by the collaborators at INRA to undertake experiments. |
Impact | Data has been obtained that will provide insights into the composition and function of nicotinic acetylcholine receptors of the potato cyst nematode Globodera pallida. These receptors are targets for common drugs and pesticides and the information will help us to understand the differing sensitivity of nematodes to such chemicals. A joint publication describing the collaborative work is planned. |
Start Year | 2014 |
Description | Nematicide mode of action study |
Organisation | DuPont |
Country | United States |
Sector | Private |
PI Contribution | Contract research |
Collaborator Contribution | Contract research |
Impact | Confidential report |
Start Year | 2015 |
Description | Raman Spectroscopy for metabolic profiling of parasitic nematodes |
Organisation | University of Southampton |
Country | United Kingdom |
Sector | Academic/University |
PI Contribution | We provided nematode samples for analysis |
Collaborator Contribution | Dr Sumeet Mahajan is an expert in CARS, coherent anti-stokes Raman spectroscopy, which provides a label free method for detecting and quantifying molecules e.g. lipids in living tissue. He applied this technique to plant parasitic nematodes for the first time permitting an analysis of the distribution and levels of lipid stores in the infective J2s. |
Impact | This work will be published as a short manuscript demonstrating the capability of CARS for profiling parasitic nematodes. |
Start Year | 2012 |
Title | The use of reserpine as a seed coating |
Description | The present invention relates to the use of reserpine as a seed coating, in particular to deter nematodes from damaging plants. The present invention further relates to a seed coating comprising reserpine. |
IP Reference | GB1710057.9 |
Protection | Patent application published |
Year Protection Granted | |
Licensed | No |
Impact | Pending |
Description | Science Week Exhibition |
Form Of Engagement Activity | Participation in an activity, workshop or similar |
Part Of Official Scheme? | Yes |
Geographic Reach | Local |
Primary Audience | Public/other audiences |
Results and Impact | Part of an award winning Science and Engineering Week activity- 2 exhibits on a rolling annual basis 'A journey through your beautiful brain' and 'Crops Critters and Climate Change' Press coverage in local media |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | Pre-2006,2006,2007,2008,2009,2010,2011,2012,2013,2014,2015,2016 |
Description | Yorkshire Show |
Form Of Engagement Activity | Participation in an activity, workshop or similar |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | Regional |
Primary Audience | Public/other audiences |
Results and Impact | Yorkshire Show; 2012; Regional; 101-500 people. Primary audience = general public All members of the research team at Leeds participated in preparation and delivery of an interactive display at The Great Yorkshire Show. The display explained the problem of plant parasitic nematodes in agriculture and introduced the research being done in our group to both the general public and members of the agricultural community. Members of the group engaged in numerous discussions about our research with a wide audience. |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2012 |