The development of effective grain refiner for the production of high performance light metal castings

Lead Research Organisation: Brunel University London
Department Name: Ctr for Advanced Solidification Tech

Abstract

Aluminium-Silicon (Al-Si) alloys are important alloys as they are lightweight (2.7 g/cc), easily recycled, corrosion resistant, durable and environmentally friendly. In comparison with steel (7.8 g/cc), they have higher strength to weight ratio. 90% of aluminium shape castings are based on these Al-Si alloys and currently, ~ 5 million tonnes per annum are being used in automotive industry. The average car manufactured in 2006 contained between 110-145 kg of Aluminium, compared to ~1000 Kg of Steel. Life cycle analysis suggest that, a 100 kg weight reduction through substituting Steel with Aluminium parts would result in a saving of 900 litres of petrol during the car's life span (200,000 km) and 2,000Kg of CO2 savings (10 g/km). The big problem for the light metal industry in increasing the further use of these lightweight Al-Si alloys with respect to replacing steel in the transport sector is the lack of ductility and yield strength associated with the large grain structure, defects and large intermetallic particles. Since Al-Si alloys are difficult to grain refine, widespread adoption is currently constrained due to excessive casting defects and inadequate mechanical properties. Higher Si levels in these alloys results in large grains, which make casting difficult, thus resulting in very high rejection rates, up to 60% for high value critical components.

Ti based grain refiners used for non-cast (wrought) Al alloys are less effective in cast Al-Si alloys due to reaction between Si and Ti. Brunel has invented an effective grain refiner that can revolutionize the foundry casting process for these Al-Si casting alloys, significantly reducing the casting defects and producing superior mechanical properties that, despite (deliberately) limited publicity, is already generating significant market interest within the materials supply chain. The Brunel grain refiner (BGR) improves castability of a wide range of aluminium alloys; eliminates hot-tearing, a common problem in castings; it improves much needed tensile strength and ductility; improves homogeneity in mechanical properties across the component; it enables thin-wall cast structures; and it tolerates high impurity levels (aluminium scrap can now be manufactured with superior properties). Additionally, it is expected to enable the casting of large and complex shaped structures using sand moulds and reduce the high (up to 60%) rejection rate during manufacture of high value components.

The unique selling points of the Brunel Grain refiner are that it is highly effective for bulk castings and easily employable by the industry. Currently there exists no effective grain refiner for Al-Si castings and previously difficult to produce high performance bulk castings without defects can now be easily processed.

Delivering benefits to a wide range of casting techniques, it should enable the production of castings with superior properties, allowing aluminium to replace a growing proportion of steel parts in the automotive sector. This will put the UK in the forefront of metallurgical technological developments. Very substantial environmental benefits are foreseen due to light-weighting and concomitant reductions in energy consumed and CO2 emitted.

Planned Impact

Brunel has developed a novel grain refiner for aluminium-silicon alloys that refines both primary aluminium and silicon eutectic phases, which results in several advantages over current methods of grain refinement. The impact on casting technology would be significant. The Brunel Grain Refiner (BGR) provides fine grain structure at wide range of cooling rates, better fluidity during casting owing to the lack of large grains interfering with flow, less porosity with higher ductility, strength and toughness. The advantages in the casting operation would include; better process yield through reducing variation from melt to melt; less material used within runners and biscuits, meaning less internal recycling and dross loss; and less extremes in tooling temperature in die casting leading to higher tool life.

Weight savings through the use of high performance Aluminum-Silicon castings, fabricated with BGR technology, are expected to create new market opportunities in casting new automotive components that have never been cast before. The current market size for automotive Al castings in UK, EU and worldwide are 0.07 mt, 2.8 mt and 5.2 mt respectively. Market size for BGR technology is estimated to be up to £ 3 billion p.a.. Since adapting BGR would require no capital equipment investment for foundries, and little if any process changes, the market for casting is projected to be doubled in ten years. Volume car makers have identified that there is a huge potential for replacing steel parts, with Al provided the Al-Si castings are produced with higher strength and ductility, in an economical way. BGR has this potential due to the simple nature of the manufacturing process.

Current rejection rate during manufacturing process varies between 5% and 60% depending on nature of applications. This high rejection rate for high value castings should be much reduced. Considering that BGR offers, reduced porosity and macro-defects, the rejection rate during manufacturing would be minimal (<5%).

Impact on academic would be through academic publications, news letters, magazines focussed on light metals industry work, presentation and exhibitions at international Aluminium conferences.

By 2020, it is expected that there would be 1.2 billion cars worldwide. A 100 Kg weight reduction can result in 2.4 billion tons of CO2 savings (2 tonnes/car lifespan) by 2030, thus benefiting the planet's environment.

BGR allows direct recycling of aluminium alloy scrap that contains higher levels of impurities, so that post consumer Al alloy scrap as a valuable materials resource can be directly applicable for lightweight body & powertrain applications. This will make the UK less dependent on imports of expensive primary metal and contribute significantly to a lower environmental impact by re-balancing the flow of materials through the UK economy and reducing landfill and emissions.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description We have successfully developed a process to produce a novel master alloy that is highly effective in refining grain size of Al-Si alloys. The master alloys simplifies the way the inoculants (grain refining agents) are introduced into the Al-Si melt. Wide range of tests have been conducted and confirmed the grain refinement in Al-Si commercial alloys. The improvement in properties of Al-Si alloys produced through grain refinement is observed.
Exploitation Route TSB project has been successfully completed. The consortium members inculde automotive end-user, prototype Al-Si parts manufacturer, master alloy manufacturer and solidification simulation software developer.
Technology has been succssfully transferred to UK based master alloy manufacturer and the large batches of master alloy with compositions specified in patent application have been produced, applied in UK foundry and Jaguar and Land Rover used this to produce protype engine cylinder heads. The project won "Cast Metal Federation Innovation Award in 2015.
Five different direct collboration partnerships have been established to test the grain refiner in DC casting, Low Pressure die casting, Gravity casting and High pressure diecasting. These were conducted in industries located in Germany, Italy, Japan and China. It is an exciting ongoing research programme and currently this techinlogy is in TRL4, TRL5 levels depending on nature of Al-Si parts produced.
The way the master alloy is processed has been further refined by CBMM (Niobium manufacturer) and this refined version of master has been tested at UK foundry and now this is being developed as a commercial product. UK manufacturing industry has been licensed to produce large scale and further large batch (3 tonne batch) trails have been on going.
This product (near to commercial) has been tested by UK car manufacture and produced car engine cylinder heads and validating the technology and benefits that it provides.
Sectors Aerospace

Defence and Marine

Manufacturing

including Industrial Biotechology

Transport

URL https://player.vimeo.com/video/205944823
 
Description The grain refinement technology has been succssfully transferred to UK based master alloy manufacturer and the large batches of master alloy with compositions specified in patent application have been produced, applied in UK foundry and UK leading automotive end-user used this to produce protype engine cylinder heads. Five other direct collboration partnerships have been established to test the grain refiner in DC casting, Low Pressure die casting, Gravity casting and High pressure diecasting. These were conducted in industries located in Germany, Italy, Japan and China. It is an exciting ongoing research programme and currently this technology is in various technology ready levels (TRL4 and TRL5) depending on types of end products. Several knowledge transfer activities (Company names are not disclosed due to Non-Disclosure Agreements) • UK based manufacturer & supplier: Technology demonstrated and licensed. 10 tonnes of grain refiner produced. UK based Aluminium engine cylinder head manufacturer: Over 100 cylinder heads have been successfully produced. • Germany based radiator manufacturer: Technology demonstrated at foundry. 2nd large scale trial was successfully completed. Technology ready to be adopted in future products. • Italy based Tier 1 car parts manufacturer: Technology successfully demonstrated by producing large Mg part (300 parts) with improved performance. • Japan based world leading car manufacturer: Stage 1. Technology demonstrated on the material that they use to manufacture car engines. In Stage 2, Practical way of applying this technology is demonstrated. Stage 3. Japanese industry conducted industrial trail and collaboration work is on-going. • China based world leading Tier 1 manufacturer: Technology demonstration in their foundry and work in progress. • Brazil based metal producer: Knowledge transferred, new master alloy produced in the industry, successfully tested. Large batches (1 tonne) of master alloy produced at an UK industry and this is being now tested at worldwide foundry in particular in Aluminium wheels, Shock towers and Engine cylinder heads. Variety of automotive castings have been produced across the world by adopting the Al-Nb-B master alloy and recently a large aerospace casting (several of them) produced in UK.
First Year Of Impact 2013
Sector Aerospace, Defence and Marine,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology,Transport
Impact Types Societal

Economic

 
Description Application of master alloy to HPDC alloy
Amount £50,000 (GBP)
Funding ID R33469 
Organisation Renault 
Sector Private
Country France
Start 12/2016 
End 04/2017
 
Description Grain Refiner - Industry testing
Amount £40,000 (GBP)
Funding ID R33457 
Organisation CBMM Technology Suisse 
Sector Private
Country Switzerland
Start 04/2016 
End 08/2016
 
Description Grain refiner for high performance lightweight aluminium automotive castings
Amount £118,928 (GBP)
Funding ID 101177 
Organisation Innovate UK 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 11/2012 
End 10/2014
 
Description Industrial fund
Amount £12,000 (GBP)
Organisation Renault 
Sector Private
Country France
Start 12/2015 
End 12/2016
 
Description Industry direct funding
Amount £28,791 (GBP)
Funding ID R33457 
Organisation Brazilian Metallurgy and Mining Company 
Sector Private
Country Brazil
Start 12/2017 
End 06/2018
 
Description Industry funding
Amount £35,000 (GBP)
Funding ID It a consultancy work in relation to Al-Nb-B grain refiner developed in this project 
Organisation Beta Technology Ltd 
Sector Private
Country United Kingdom
Start 08/2017 
End 08/2018
 
Description Mechanical property testing on parts produced in foundry at industrial scale
Amount £35,000 (GBP)
Funding ID R33457 (additional funds) 
Organisation CBMM Technology Suisse 
Sector Private
Country Switzerland
Start 01/2017 
End 04/2017
 
Title METHOD OF REFINING METAL ALLOYS 
Description Method of refining metal alloys A method of refining the grain size of (i) an alloy comprising aluminium and at least 3% w/w silicon or (ii) an alloy comprising magnesium, comprisesthe steps of (a) adding sufficient niobium and boron to the alloy in orderto form niobium diboride or Al3Nb or both, or (b) adding niobium diboride to the alloy, or (c) adding Al3Nb to the alloy, or (d) any combination thereof. 
IP Reference WO2012110788 
Protection Patent granted
Year Protection Granted 2012
Licensed Yes
Impact The patent has generated significant interest from automotive and aero-spece sector and it enables to produce thin wall sections with superior mechanical properties so that lightweighting can be achived. Varierty of collbaoratvie partnerships have been established with industry to test and assess the performance of grain refiner.
 
Title Master alloy for grain refining 
Description A chemical grain refiner to refiner grain size of Al-Si cast alloys was successfully developed and a patent application has been submitted to protect the grain refining composition. The EPSRC follow-on grant enabled us to strengthen the patent and also led to another patent application. This new application is related to producing a master alloy for grain refining. This method is basically about producing a master alloy that contains higher concentration of grain refining composition in Al matrix. The foundry can simply add the required qunatity of this master alloy to the Al-Si melt. This has been successsully demonstrated in 6 tonne melt. 
IP Reference GB1214650.2 
Protection Patent application published
Year Protection Granted
Licensed No
Impact The grain refiner techonlogy has been successfully trasnferred to UK based master alloy manufacturer. The manufacturer successfully upscaled the process from 1Kg batch to 500 Kg batch. The mass produced master alloy has been applied by UK based foundry. The foundry succesffully introduced the grain refiner into their manufacturing process. Licence negotiations are on going.
 
Title Masterbatch for grain refiner 
Description A practical way of introducing grain refiner in liquid metal is to first produce a master batch (Al containing higher concentration of grain refining composition). The patent describes the method of making master batch. 
IP Reference ZL201380043494.5 
Protection Patent application published
Year Protection Granted 2016
Licensed Yes
Impact Knowledge in Masterbatch process has been transferred to two UK manufacturing industry and one Brazil (Niobium mining company). 1st UK manufacture developed the medium-scale process- The product has been tested successfully tested and produced automotive component (part of InnovateUK project). Brazilian company refined the process of producing master alloy with controlled chemical compositions and the product has been tested successfully at both lab and industrial scale. "Master batch process" has been licensed to 2nd UK manufacturer. This manufacturer in collaboration with Brunel and Brazilian company has developed a process for large batch (3 tonne). Master alloy produced in large batch has been successfully tested by an UK automotive manufacturer and produced engine cylinder heads with refined grain structure.
 
Description Charles Hatchett Seminar 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact 2016 Charles Hatchett Award Winners receiving their medals from The Institute of Materials, Minerals and Mining (IOM3). Pictured from left: Hari-Babu Nadendla, Magdalena Nowak, IOM3 President Mike Hicks, and Leandro Bolzoni.

The annual Award, now in its 38th year, is sponsored by Companhia Brasileira de Metalurgia e Mineração (CBMM). This is only the second occasion the award has been made for work on aluminium-based materials. Over the last 20 years significant progress has been made in vehicle light-weighting through the use of advanced high strength steels. This has allowed automotive manufacturers to meet increasingly stringent EU automobile emission targets. Further progress in this area will require the use of other light-weight materials, including aluminium alloys. To maximise the benefits available from the use of cast aluminium components it is important to optimise strength levels and minimise property variability. This can be achieved by refining the microstructure in the cast product.

The 2016 Charles Hatchett Award winning work focuses on the development of Nb-B based inoculants for use in the production of aluminium alloy castings. These inoculants were shown to be effective in widely-used commercial Al-Si casting alloys, especially when the Si content is higher than 5%. Above this level of Si, conventional Ti-B inoculants lose their effectiveness as a grain refiner. Significant refinement of the cast microstructure was obtained over a broad range of cooling rates, encompassing those found in common casting methods such as die- and sand-casting.

The award winners, from Brunel University London, UK were presented with their medals at the Institute of Materials, Minerals and Mining (IOM3) dinner held in London on the 12th July.

The following day, the lead author, Dr N. Hari Babu, presented the winning project at a seminar held at the Royal Society of Chemistry. The international seminar "Niobium for Aluminium Cast Parts in Automotive Components", sponsored by CBMM, was attended by experts from the automotive supply chain and academia. The presentation described the fundamental metallurgy behind the design of the novel Nb-B inoculants and demonstrated their effectiveness in producing microstructure refinement at the laboratory scale.

The seminar was chaired by Dr Naila Croft from Beta Technology, the UK based company which manages the annual award process on behalf of CBMM. As International Coordinator of the Award, Dr Croft commented "We were delighted to host over 40 delegates in London for our important technical seminar. The speakers have described the initial development of the novel Nb-B inoculants. However, by bringing together representatives from academia and the automotive supply chain, the route to full commercial implementation of this development has been demonstrated."

Marcos Stuart, CBMM's Director of Technology also noted "This international award is part of our activities to recognise excellence in research on niobium and its applications. There is no single solution to vehicle light-weighting, the important thing is to have the right material in the right place. There are technical and cost challenges to the adoption of large aluminium alloy castings, such as engine blocks, which include efficiently filling the moulds during the casting process. The Nb-B inoculant refines the grains, improving the fluidity of the material being cast, and therefore making it easier to completely fill the moulds, leading to a higher integrity product. It is now up to the supply chain to act to ensure the adoption of this exciting new technology."
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016
URL https://player.vimeo.com/video/205944823
 
Description International Conference on Processing of Materials, Minerals and Energy (PMME2016), 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact This keynote lecture has attracted several materials engineering students to pursue research in light metals. Students have contacted me to pursue summer internship programme under my supervision.

One of the participant has invited me to deliver a keynote lecture at another international conference to be held In 2017.

One of the participant has invited me join "Ministry of Human Resource & development Scheme on Global Initiative on Academic Network (GIAN). As a part of this I have agreed to deliver 6 different lectures at National Institute of Technology, India.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016
URL http://www.pmme.co.in/
 
Description Invited lecture at International Congress "Non-ferrous metals and minerals-2015, Russia, Sept'2015 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact Over 1000 participants working on non-ferrous metals have attended the seminar. Discussions were held in possibility of applying the Nb-grain refiner in Al-Si alloy ingots manufacturing stage. .
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2015
URL http://nfmsib.ru/index.php/en/
 
Description Keynote speaker at International Symposium on Aspects of Mechanical Engineering and Technology for Industry, India, NERIST, Itanagar, India, December 2014 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Over 500 international (but majority from India) have attended the conference.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2014
URL http://www.ameti2014.org/
 
Description Materials in Car Body Engineering, Automotive Circle International 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Invited Lecture is "Materials in Car Body Engineering" organised by automotive Circle International, Frankfurt, 21-23rd April 2015, Over 300 delegates from worldwide automotive OEMs (JLR, BMW, Audi, Ford, Honda, Toyota, Daimler, Hyundai, Fiat, Renault, Volvo etc) have attended this conference. New collaborative links with industry are being explored.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2015
URL http://www.automotive-circle.com/
 
Description The Charles Hatchett Award Lecture at Companhia Brasileira de Metalurgia e Mineração (CBMM), Brazil 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Undergraduate students
Results and Impact 2016 Charles Hatchett Award winners visit CBMM operations in Brazil

As part of their prize, as a winner of the 2016 Charles Hatchett Award, we have visited Brazil as guests of CBMM. The programme included a visit to the CBMM head office in São Paulo, a seminar on Nb in Aluminium cast parts and the niobium mine and processing facility in Araxá.

The state of the art research facilities at CBMM's Research and Development Centre were very impressive and the various tours provided us with an overview of niobium mining, extraction metallurgy of high purity niobium and niobium applications in a wide range of engineering applications. This visit was sponsored by CBMM and organised by Beta Technology. This visit strengthened the collaboration work between the PI and CBMM.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
URL http://www.charles-hatchett.com/news/2016-charles-hatchett-award-winners-visit-cbmm-operations-in-br...
 
Description Visit to Indian Institute of Technology (Kharaghpur & Bhubaneswar) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact Delivered lecture on grain refinement for high performance automotive Al-Si castings. Around 150 students, academics and local industry personnel have attended. It was an exciting interactive discussions with academics who have worked in Al-Ti-B grain refiner in the past.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016