The Effects of Coupled Wave Power and Plasma Properties on Radiation Belt Dynamics

Lead Research Organisation: British Antarctic Survey
Department Name: Science Programmes

Abstract

The Earth's radiation belts consist of energetic charged particles which surround the Earth like a ring doughnut. They were first discovered over 60 years ago, at the beginning of the space age, but many questions remain regarding the relative importance of the physical processes controlling their behaviour. The inner radiation belt, which typically lies at altitudes between 600 and 6,000 km in the magnetic equatorial plane, is relatively stable, but the outer radiation belt, which typically lies at altitudes between 12,000 and 45,000 km, is highly dynamic. Here the number of relativistic electrons can vary by orders of magnitude on timescales ranging from minutes to days. Understanding, modelling and ultimately predicting the behaviour of these so called "killer" electrons is critical because enhanced fluxes of these particles can damage satellites and pose a risk to humans in space.

A variety of plasma waves co-exist with the energetic charged particles in the Earth's radiation belts. They can interact strongly with the relativistic electrons and play a fundamental role in the dynamics of the belts, although their precise roles are yet to be determined. Two very important wave modes are whistler mode chorus and plasmaspheric hiss. Whistler mode chorus, so-called because it often resembles the twittering of birds in the dawn chorus when converted to sound, plays a dual role, contributing to both the acceleration and loss of energetic electrons. In contrast, plasmaspheric hiss, so-named because it resembles audible hiss when played back as sound, is primarily a loss mechanism. Our proposed project will assess the role of both wave modes to understand the basic physics and to improve radiation belt models and forecasts.

Current models for the interaction of plasma waves with electrons use models of the plasma waves based on spatial location and geomagnetic activity. The local plasma conditions in each location, which are also important for modelling the dynamics of the radiation belts, are modelled independently. However, recent studies have shown that it is important to incorporate co-located measurements of the local environment and wave spectra in radiation belt modelling. These new results mandate the development of new wave models binned not only by satellite location and geomagnetic activity, but also by the characteristics of the local environment.

The roles of chorus and plasmaspheric hiss using this new method are currently being investigated in a limited region of the radiation belts as part of the NERC-funded Space Weather Instrumentation Measurement Modelling and Risk (SWIMMR) project Sat-Risk. This study is mostly restricted to the region inside 28,000 km (in the magnetic equatorial plane) and absolute magnetic latitudes less than 21 degrees, excluding the important geostationary orbit region and beyond.

In this project we will use data from four additional satellites, THEMIS-A, -D, -E and Arase, to study how chorus and plasmaspheric hiss influence the behaviour of energetic electrons throughout the Earth's radiation belts. This will improve our understanding of the physics of the processes governing the behaviour of the belts and is essential for the accurate modelling and forecasting of space weather. Specifically, we will establish the importance of chorus at altitudes greater than 28,000 km on the acceleration and loss of energetic electrons in the Earth's outer radiation belt. We will also establish the importance of mid-latitude (21 < |MLAT| < 42 degrees) chorus and plasmaspheric hiss on radiation belt dynamics. Furthermore, we will run simulations with the outer radial boundary at the last closed drift shell to examine the roles of radial diffusion and chorus in the generation of MeV electrons throughout the outer radiation belt. The results will also be used to improve our radiation belt models and forecasts and, as such, will be of great value to satellite engineers, operators and insurers.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Title In Aurora's Garden 
Description In Aurora's garden is the fourth album of the art-science collaboration "Sounds of Space Project". Here we experience the solar storm of 17th June 2012. A few days prior to this, on the 13th and 14th June, two large explosions on the surface of the Sun released bursts of charged particles and magnetic field which travelled outwards and towards the Earth. The material reached the Earth on the 17th June, the day chosen for our album, tearing open the Earth's magnetic field, leading to a geomagnetic storm. Particles were injected into near Earth space giving rise to radio emissions including chorus and plasmaspheric hiss. At lower altitudes electrons rained down on the Earth's upper atmosphere leading to some beautiful and stunning displays of the aurora. We hear the crackles and pops of lightning spherics, the descending tones of whistlers, the rising and falling tones of chorus and the steady hum of plasmaspheric hiss. The musical response is wide and varied and includes gongs, wood blocks, bells, vibraphones, glockenspiels, the piano, a synthesis rig, the Japanese shakuhachi and the tabla. We also hear soprano Heather Lee, in Kim Cunio's setting of a traditional Chinese text, as well as a new version of the Joni Mitchell classic Both Sides Now. Artwork produced by multimedia artist Diana Scarborough, inspired by Antarctica, the space weather data and the music, adds a rich visual element to the album. The Sounds of Space Project are myself (science lead), multimedia artist Diana Scarborough and Australian composer and musician Kim Cunio. 
Type Of Art Composition/Score 
Year Produced 2023 
Impact The album was released on bandcamp in December 2023. Tracks from teh album have been played on The Dark Train on Warminster Community Radio, the Phantom Circuit on Beachy Head Radio and the Institute of Spectra-Sonic Sound on KEPW 97.3 FM. Tracks from the album have been played 772 times on bandcamp. 
URL https://soundsofspaceproject.bandcamp.com/album/in-auroras-garden
 
Title Sunconscious 
Description A 1 hour radio session featuring music from our album "Sunconscious" released in 2022. Timed to coincide with the launch of NASA's heliophysics big year the session included music inspired by and including the 'sounds' of the Sun. I created the session and provided commentary throughout. 
Type Of Art Artistic/Creative Exhibition 
Year Produced 2023 
Impact The session was aired on the Dark Train on Warminster Community Radio on 16th October 2023. It was later uploaded to Mixcloud where it received 69 listens. The show was rated 1st in the Avant-Garde chart, 6th in the Experimental Ambient Chart and 59th in the Electronica chart. 
URL https://www.mixcloud.com/katebosworth/wcr-dark-train-ma84-dr-nigel-merediths-sunconscious-session-16...
 
Title New Chorus Diffusion Coefficients for Radiation Belt Modelling 
Description Whistler mode chorus is an important magnetospheric wave emission playing a major role in radiation belt dynamics, where it contributes to both the acceleration and loss of relativistic electrons. In this study we compute bounce and drift averaged chorus diffusion coefficients for 3.0 < L* < 6.0, using the TS04 external magnetic field model, taking into account co-located near-equatorial measurements of the wave intensity and fpe/fce, by combining the Van Allen probes measurements with data from a multi-satellite VLF wave database. The variation of chorus wave normal angle with spatial location and fpe/fce is also taken into account. We find that chorus propagating at small wave normal angles has the dominant contribution to the diffusion rates in most MLT sectors. However, in the region 4 <= MLT < 11 high wave normal angles dominate at intermediate pitch angles. In the region 3 < L* < 4, the bounce and drift averaged pitch angle and energy diffusion rates during active conditions are primarily larger than those in our earlier models by up to a factor of 10 depending on energy and pitch angle. Further out, the results are similar. We find that the bounce and drift averaged energy and pitch angle diffusion rates can be significantly larger than the new model in regions of low fpe/fce,eq, where the differences can be up to a factor of 10 depending on energy and pitch angle. Funding was provided by the Natural Environment Research Council (NERC) Highlight Topic grant NE/P01738X/1 (Rad-Sat) and the NERC grants NE/V00249X/1 (Sat-Risk), NE/R016038/1 and NE/X000389/1. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2023 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact This dataset provides new chorus diffusion coefficients for radiation belt modellers. 
URL https://data.bas.ac.uk/full-record.php?id=GB/NERC/BAS/PDC/01782
 
Description "Sounds of Space" article for Antarktikos Magazine by Nigel Meredith, Diana Scarborough and Kim Cunio 
Form Of Engagement Activity A magazine, newsletter or online publication
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact This article described the 'sounds' of space and how I have used them in a muti-disciplinary art-science collaboration to produce three albums, 'Aurora Musicalis', 'Celestial Incantations' and 'Sunconscious'. All three albums are available on bandcamp. Antarktikos is a bi-annual print magazine that combines artistic and scientific exploration within the awe-inspiring and thought-provoking context of Antarctica. This article has thus enabled me to share my work and art-science collaboration with a wider audience.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
URL https://www.antarktikos.com
 
Description Nigel Meredith spoke to Dr Alfredo Carpineti of IFLScience about space weather and how it affects us all in Series 3 of the "The Big Questions" podcasts, released on 18th August 
Form Of Engagement Activity A broadcast e.g. TV/radio/film/podcast (other than news/press)
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact In this podcast I talked about space weather and how it affects us all. I also described some of the exciting ongoing research being conducted in the Space Weather and Atmosphere Team at BAS. I concluded by talking about and introducing some of the amazing 'sounds' of space weather as recorded by the VLF Receiver at Halley VI Research Station.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
URL https://www.iflscience.com/iflscience-the-big-questions-what-is-space-weather-and-how-does-it-affect...