Targeted waveform enhanced plasma microreactor: Engineering Chemistry at the Interface of Microbubbles

Lead Research Organisation: University of Sheffield
Department Name: Chemical & Biological Engineering

Abstract

One class of electrochemical reaction are reactions in the plasma state. The PI and his team have been pioneering plasma microreactors that feed directly into microbubbles for the last decade. With the output of the plasma reactor entering the microbubble directly, the maximum activation is retained in the bubble, which then mediates the formation of active species on the microbubble interface. Recently, this approach has been used to catalyse the esterification reaction of free fatty acids to form esters (particularly biodiesel).

More than the effectiveness of the plasma activated microbubble reaction, microbubble processing is not limited by surface area of "electrode" in quite the same way. The grand aim of this proposal is to create heterogeneous catalysis capability by tuning the plasma activated species on the gas-liquid interface of microbubbles. Conventional electrochemistry has severe issues around upscaling. Plasma microreactors, particularly those that feed into liquid media as injected microbubbles, are a class of electrochemical reactors that can potentially upscale readily. Microbubbles can have hectares of gas-liquid interface per cubic metre of liquid reactant volume, so if the (plasma)electrochemical reaction can be catalysed on the gas-liquid interface, high throughput reaction rates can be achieved in large volume, continuous flow reactors. Already achieved in pilot plant studies of anaerobic digestion is a bubble surface area flux of 0.15 hectares/sec! If even a fraction of this surface area flux is effective at mediating plasma chemical transformations, the rate of transformation processes should far exceed conventional heterogeneous reactions.

This project aims to optimise how the formation of plasma-activated species is coupled to the transient operation of the plasma electronics that create the excited species that eventually react at microbubble gas-liquid interfaces. Preliminary studies show that the composition of an excited air plasma, for instance, can dramatically change with the contacting time in the reactor and the electric field applied. They also suggest that how that electric field is applied in space and time dramatically affects the chemical composition of the plasma, and consequently what chemical reactions dominate the microbubble mediated gas-liquid chemistry. The purpose of this proposal is to characterise this coupling between the time-varying plasma electronics output, as implemented with tuneable electrical engineering design, and the induced chemistry of the plasma and microbubble mediated reaction. The characterisation will be captured in computer models that permit inversion; from the desired chemical outputs, the optimum plasma electronics design, control and operating mode ("the waveform") will be predicted.

In the UK plasma chemistry research is vibrant but the work is mainly centred on nuclear science, capactively coupled plasmas with applications to surface treatment (i.e. EP/K018388/1) and medical applications. Globally, several research groups are investigating tailored waveform plasmas more generally but not with specific application to chemical generation on an industrial scale. The proposed closed-loop control of tailored waveform plasma microbubble reactors offers new possibilities to increase efficiency, throughput and scale-up. This, therefore, complements the contributions from these research groups (both national and international) and so will stimulate new research and commercial opportunities. By bringing together experts from the interface of chemical engineering, electrical engineering and mathematics who, together with some eight project partners providing £160k of support, can drive a blue-skies approach to targeted waveform control of plasma reactions (using novel chemical modelling and waveform generator design) while blazing a trail for industrial adaptation to a game-changing approach to chemical production.

Planned Impact

We start from two premises that a sustainable future for bio/processing for food, fuel and commodity chemicals requires (i) inventive problem solving and innovation for much more efficient and effective transformations than conventional technology; (ii) *scalable* electrochemical processing in some guise will be essential to provide at least the Gibbs free energy of reaction for endergonic reactions, replacing fossil fuels, and potentially for the *activation energy* or catalysis organising principle that reduces activation energy.

With limited proof of concept already achieved with *untuned* plasma sources, we expect that the near term impact will result from three classes of applications:
1. Chemical processing industries where novel and innovative heterogeneous catalysis, potentially with electricity providing the Gibbs free energy of reaction, as well as catalytic impetus and in situ product removal, are needed for disruptive change in processing.
2. Bio/chemical producers in industrial biotech, where in situ disinfection in fermenters (potentially preferential in attacking targeted contamination) and pretreatment of feedstocks for breakdown, say lignocellulosic or wet food waste, as simultaneous disinfection are needed for sustainable processing.
3. Integrated water purification or wastewater treatment, potentially for novel cleaning devices, and distributed (end of tap?) or municipal water purification systems.

Our impact strategy includes the following activities and features to set in motion:

1. Maintain regular briefings with at least twelve companies that have expressed an interest in untuned plasma-activated microbubbles for the general targets above.
2. Incubate more interactions from the agricultural and sustainable biomass utilisation sectors through the Anaerobic Digester and Biogas Association (named finalist with another microbubble intensification process for "project of the year", one of 3 from 200 nominees) and the trade conference on bioethanol/ethanol and biofuels (biannually) organised by FO Licht where the PI's InnovateUK/EPSRC "flagship" project on intensification of bioethanol processing is commissioning a pilot plant.
3. Disseminate bio/processing related innovations through the appropriate NIBBs when awarded - PI is Co-I of one such shortlisted NIBB proposal on waste gas utilisation. Disseminate chemical applications through c1net and CDUK where the PI is a founder member.
4. Hold a "mid-term" consortium building exercise - a workshop aimed at potential end users, development partners, supply chain members and academics - which will serve a "pathfinding" role for the potential different impact directions. The last such invited consortium building exercise held by the PI resulted in InnovateUK (£2.2m, bioethanol) and ERA-IB (EUR2.3m, biobutanol) consortium grants in 2016.
5. From expressions of interest and follow up planning discussions with participants of the mid-term consortium building exercise, agree two "Business Interaction Vouchers" of ~£10k each for small feasibility studies which require similar levels of partner input.
6. Engage in dissemination activities with a variety of target audiences - general public, academic conferences and journal articles, and trade conferences and journal articles. The PI has a standing offer from the editor of The Chemical Engineer (premier trade journal) for feature articles (used once in 2012) on microbubble advances and had an invited article for the International Journal of Sugar (2011).

Publications

10 25 50

publication icon
Ansari S (2022) Fully-Integrated Solid Shunt Planar Transformer for LLC Resonant Converters in IEEE Open Journal of Power Electronics

publication icon
Calverley J (2020) Hot Microbubble Air Stripping of Dilute Ethanol-Water Mixtures in Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research

 
Description Developed a graph theory for plasma chemical reaction pathway networks. Graphs can be traced for predictions of products and byproducts and their distribution / selectivity. This is a new intellectual tool for analysing complex plasma - microbubble interface catalyzed reactions.

A purpose-built experimental apparata and integrated electronics was design, fabricated, assembled, commissioned and trialed for microbubble mediated, plasma activated interfacial reactions. The electronics developed and exploited enabled the creation of a finely time resolved, but continuous, imposition of voltage difference across the electrodes of the DBD reactor. These electrodes were coated with various formulations of bespoke nanoceramic coatings, explored for their durability and capability of transferring charge effectively to the plasma. The control system allowed feedback from downstream sensing to regulate the product distribution.

This system was trialled three ways for exemplar chemical reactions:
1. Ammonia destruction in black, opaque and toxic landfill leachate as a pretreatment that resulted in yellow, translucent liquid which was then non-toxic to microalgae, and rapidly treated by the extremophile strain isolated from the landfill leachate site. The strain was ammonia-tolerant to survive, but in the low ammonia level treated leachate, grew far more rapidly than conventional strains, removing all the nutrients and creating a wastewater that could be used as grey water, with no sewerage issues.
2. Production of ozone / ozone-rich microbubbles. Achieved with high conversion, in line with the new graph theory of plasma catalysed reactions developed in the grant.
3. Plasma activated microbubble mediated methanol and organic acid reactions, aimed at esterification. The samples are awaiting analysis but indicate that the stoichiometric ratio of reactants were completely consumed, for what is conventionally an equilibrium reaction that does not go to completion. The team conducted several control experiments, with microbubbles that were not plasma activated and catalysed other ways. It is certainly the case that this reaction is free radical catalysed, as there are no other catalytic agents present. We expect that the product distribution must include nearly all esters, but it may include polyesters from visual observation. A doctoral student who was seconded to the project in its final year is conducting the analysis, expecting to explore more widely the applicability of the system than these three exemplars.

The research conducted by Electronic and Electrical Engineering focused on developing novel power supply technologies to improve power density for the integrated system and apparata described above. The studies focused on resonant power conversion since this offers enhanced efficiency, voltage gain magnification and reduced electromagnetic interference.

Integrated magnetic transformer design
This research focused on developing transformer designs where the magnetising and leakage inductance values are accurately determined by the transformer topologies and so can be used with external capacitors to create resonant circuits that both shape voltage and current waveforms and provide voltage gain magnification. In this work magnetic shunts were inserted within the transformer to provide a method to program the leakage and magnetising inductances. Several integrated magnetic structures were developed from which a set of design equations were obtained. Comparisons between results from finite element analysis and experimental measurements correlate well with estimates made using the equivalent circuit models.

Piezoelectric transformer and piezoelectric resonator power supplies
Electrically a piezoelectric device behaves like a highly tuned resonant circuit and owing to their construction they can offer Q-factors an order of magnitude greater than is often possible using discrete inductors and capacitors. In this project power supplies and their support circuits were researched using both types of piezoelectric devices in an effort to find a cheaper alternative to magnetic transformer based power supplies.
Exploitation Route Please see narrative impact statement about the impact that the landfill leachate pretreatment approach has led to.
Sectors Agriculture

Food and Drink

Chemicals

Energy

Environment

 
Description Farag et al. (2023) showed that plasma activated microbubble pre-treatment of landfill leachate destroys ammonia to a level that is no longer toxic, and with an extremophile strain of microalgae isolated and characterized genomically, results in high metabolic uptake of the remaining nutrients in the landfill leachate. These two features were instrumental in partner company Perlemax (which provided the purpose-designed, ammonia-resistant Desai-Zimmerman fluidic oscillator for the microbubble generation) and their partners Reepel (vertical farming including microalgae growth) and CCm Technologies, to propose grants for carbon capture and utilisation to InnovateUK (physicochemical capture of CO2 via ammonia stripped from ammonia-rich wastewaters) and DESNZ (biological capture of CO2 exploiting fertilizer from the other grant). Both were both awarded and started in 2023 for pilot scale operations. Clearly, ammonia recovery is preferrable to destruction if the recovery can be achieved efficiently and economically. That was separately shown by Desai et al. (2022), but the result of Farag et al. (2023) shows that the reduced ammonia content landfill leachate is a viable source of nutrients, valorizing what has been otherwise an intractable wastewater for which the waste management sector have adopted the "non-solution" of storage until an economically viable technology emerges. Farag AT, Holmes TD, Gilmour DJ, Zimmerman WB. An integrated novel plasma-microalgae approach for landfill leachate treatment using a high-ammonia tolerant strain of Chlorella vulgaris. Algal Research 103345, 2023. DOI: 10.1016/j.algal.2023.103345 Desai PD, Turley M, Robinson R, Zimmerman WB, Hot microbubble injection in thin liquid film layers for ammonia separation from ammonia rich-wastewater, Chemical Engineering and Processing - Process Intensification, doi.org/10.1016/j.cep.2021.108693, 2022.
First Year Of Impact 2023
Sector Agriculture, Food and Drink,Chemicals,Energy
Impact Types Societal

Economic

Policy & public services

 
Description Pitch to Health Secretary Matt Hancock for microbubble decontamination prototype for intensive sterilization of microbes and viruses
Geographic Reach National 
Policy Influence Type Contribution to a national consultation/review
 
Company Name Reepel 
Description Reepel develops gas transfer technology that aims to accelerate the growth of plants, algae and other organism. 
Year Established 2020 
Impact The company has won, as part of a consortium of partner companies, an InnovateUK and a BEIS grant (confidential at the moment), for UK-based R&D on the technology. It already has a demonstration in Dubai and is short-listed for facilities implementation in some Middle East sustainable cities projects.
Website https://www.reepel.co.uk/
 
Description Led the Shortlisted EPSRC grant proposal for the Centre for Doctoral Training in Modelling of Cleaning and Decontamination 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact The group of ten co-investigators engaged with more than 25 partner organisations as well as potential partner organisations to donate staff time and resources for training doctoral students in cleaning and decontamination best practise, as well as regulatory bodies concerning the principles of the regulatory framework, case studies and research targets. Eleven initial co-sponsorships of projects, with cash and in-kind support of more than £1m from non-academic partners and more than £1m of academic institution resources were pledged to the activity.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
URL http://www.modcad.org
 
Description Participation in Industry / Academia / Government Workshop on Modelling of Cleaning and Decontamination (ModCaD) leading to a roadmap report 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact Please see www.modcad.org

The intended purpose was to quantify the need across practically all sectors of the economy for quantitative modelling of cleaning and decontamination to inform best practise in this highly multidisciplinary sector, underpin innovation (particularly with scientific and engineering based design), and address new challenges such as sustainability, risk, diversity, networking, training, sensors and supporting sciences. From that quantification, the workshop developed a roadmap to tackle strateic investment in communication, community, training and features of the sceince base.
From the point of view of nbic and my feasibility study, my contribution to the roadmap was to highlight the innovations explored with biofilm removal, the need for further development work under conditions appropriate for endusers, and engineering science based modelling for design and understanding of fundamental mechanisms. A similar effort was extended to plasma activated microbubbles to underscore its potential and needs for development.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL http://www.modcad.org