GLOW-Energy nested bio system flows:from the home to the hub

Lead Research Organisation: University of Strathclyde
Department Name: Architecture

Abstract

The aim of this project is to provide an innovative dynamic approach to transform how people manage energy in homes inspired by bees' social organization and communication. A new computational system is developed to identify and communicate inefficiencies found between individual household energy use and community energy demand. Bees have evolved an efficient mechanism to communicate collective needs at an individual level in responsive and targeted ways that humans have not. The new system draws on behavioural patterns found in bees as a way to communicate an optimised approach to managing energy behaviour in homes in a responsive, targeted and effective way.

Currently, energy in homes is managed through technologies that are designed to alert users to reduce their use when passing a designed threshold. These thresholds are derived mostly from technical data rather than evidence that takes into account the social values and approaches to community, ways of living and home character. It is well established that despite being alerted to change how they use energy, most users do not alter their behaviour in the longer term. This lack of responsiveness is seen to occur mainly through not taking into account users' values, their homes' social and spatial character and ways of living. Energy demand in housing is growing and diversifying with predicted carbon emissions from homes significantly impacting on health and wellbeing of society as a whole. Without a significant step change in the status quo, the long-term impacts of managing energy demand unsustainably in housing are critical.

Working closely with three housing communities and industry partners, the research will use mixed methods to study how energy is used in homes and how this varies between different communities. The existing behavioural patterns across the three housing communities will be studied and identified inefficiencies will be computationally optimised using learning found in bees' communication protocols. The developed computational system prototype will be tested initially through a web-based app, through which potential users could engage in a selection of behaviour change scenarios based on their inputs related to their self-identified behavioural patterns. Engagement and responses from the app will be studied and presented at two separate citizen juries in order to develop a holistic understanding into potential prototype service applications across a range of communities and sectors.

The project extends current work in EPSRC Energy and Digital Economy themes and provides multiple benefits not just through the developed prototype but also in evidencing use of innovative mixed methods that may be applied in future technology innovation studies in a range of sectors including energy. Findings will benefit a range of stakeholders including residents, housing developers, energy policymakers, energy technology developers, architects and housing associations. The project will benefit residents through enabling a user-focused and evidence-based approach to managing energy in homes, whilst housing developers can gain a better holistic understanding of how energy is used in homes and how its spatial and social configuration supports net-zero carbon design and development. Energy policymakers will benefit from gaining new insights and an evidence base that offer social and spatial knowledge, household behavioural patterns, and social responses that will better inform future sustainable energy demand management.

Building on a growing interest in sustainable energy transitions and energy democracy, this project offers an accelerated approach for both communities and individuals to forge a new relationship with energy. Though the focus is on the energy sector and housing, findings from this project have wider implications and potential benefits in the food supply chain for instance where collective needs necessitate an optimised individual response.
 
Description Call for input - the Future of Distributed Flexibility (Ofgem)
Geographic Reach National 
Policy Influence Type Contribution to a national consultation/review
URL https://blogs.bath.ac.uk/iprblog/2023/06/08/unlocking-the-potential-of-distributed-flexibility-for-a...
 
Description Delivering a smart and secure electricity system - Consultation on interoperability and cyber security of energy smart appliances and remote load control
Geographic Reach National 
Policy Influence Type Contribution to a national consultation/review
URL https://glow.arch.strath.ac.uk/project-outputs/
 
Description Submission to Draft Energy Strategy and Just Transition Plan consultation, Scottish Government
Geographic Reach Local/Municipal/Regional 
Policy Influence Type Contribution to a national consultation/review
URL https://www.bristol.ac.uk/policybristol/academic-consultation-responses/energy-just-transition/
 
Description EPSRC EDI+ Research and Innovation Network 
Organisation Durham University
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Through the insights gained from her involvement in the GLOW project, Dr. Chatzimichali has been appointed as an EDI Fellow by EPSRC EDI+ Research and Innovation Network+ for Equality, Diversity and Inclusion in the Energy Research Community. She also became an active contributor to the EPSRC IGNITE Network Plus, engaging in discussions, initiatives and a research project funded by the network aimed at promoting inclusivity and innovation in energy research.
Collaborator Contribution access to training, expertise and networks
Impact none yet
Start Year 2023
 
Description Engagement focused website 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact Development of website structure and content (both text based and graphical) with key focus on inclusive engagement channels- developing structure for news sharing and announcements to reach wide audience base.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://glow.arch.strath.ac.uk/
 
Description Feel The Heat: Glasgow 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Policymakers/politicians
Results and Impact The "Feel The Heat: Glasgow" event was organised and hosted by the University of Strathclyde with the objective to facilitate knowledge exchange and discussion around the ongoing developments in the Glasgow area concerning sustainable heat and power networks for local use. The GLOW team delivered an informative presentation introducing the aim, objectives, and initial insights from the GLOW research project to a diverse group of energy professionals. The attendees included representatives from various organisations, such as the Scottish Government, Scottish Water Horizons, Clyde Gateway, Star Renewable, Enervate, Vattenfall, BE-ST, and Fortum, as well as other academic institutions.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
 
Description Green Heat Hubs - Stakeholder engagement workshop 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Policymakers/politicians
Results and Impact This event was a workshop for Scottish Green Heat Hub, focussed on enabling novel discussions with academia, industry, and third sectors. Discussions focussed on the many challenges associated with Scotland meeting climate change and decarbonized heat targets, including those related to smart energy and residential heat pump deployment. Also, participants noted that these challenges could only be met through the cooperation of different technology sectors, industry/third sectors, coordinated policy development, academic research, and consumer feedback. The outcome of the workshop was development of framework that would identify the key challenges facing heat pump deployment as part of wider smart energy transitions in Scotland. The team participated in the workshop and contributed by sharing insights gained from the GLOW project thereby strengthening the outcomes through provision of new empirical evidence.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
 
Description Socially Intelligent Home Energy Networks?? views from Glasgow residents 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Policymakers/politicians
Results and Impact The activity was an expert workshop held at the University of Strathclyde, Glasgow on 4th May 2023 entitled 'Socially Intelligent Home Energy Networks - views from Glasgow residents. The purpose of the workshop was to share insights and exchange knowledge gained from the project and co-develop pathways to impact. The workshop included 7 invited expert participants from the Scottish Communities Climate Action Network, the Centre for Energy Policy at the University of Strathclyde, The Eildon Group (housing association), the PNDC at the University of Strathclyde, and the University of St. Andrews. Key insights discussed in the workshop emphasised the importance of considering collective capabilities in a socially intelligent energy approach at various scales, from the neighbourhood to the national level (neighbourhood, city, country). By understanding the social dynamics, cultural norms, and economic conditions, tailored sustainable energy solutions could be developed to meet the specific needs of local communities. At the city level, socially intelligent energy systems could ensure the sustainable fulfilment of urban energy needs through data analytics and energy management systems. Nationally, policies and regulations could promote sustainable energy practices and technologies. By incorporating collective capabilities in a socially intelligent energy approach, a more sustainable and equitable energy system could be created, benefiting all members of society. The discussion conveyed below key points:

Fuel poverty and energy crisis:
• Participants raised the importance of fuel poverty and how the project involved participants who may be in fuel poverty - in Scotland this may present 40% of the population. For instance, fuel poverty can result in households struggling to afford adequate heating and energy services. This can have a significant impact on their health and well-being, particularly during cold winters. It was recommended that greater consideration needs to be given in the project to whether participants involved were in fuel poverty and how the project could consider fuel poverty in the approach developed.
• Participants observed that the data collected may convey a very particular point in time at the start of the energy crisis and the end of Covid-19. It was suggested that future consideration needs to be given to the fact that data collection took place at a time when many were adapting to sudden increases in energy costs.

Community and emergency crisis:
• Participants questioned whether the project considered insights from community responses to Covid and what could be learnt from those studies.

Scale and community:
• The discussion touched upon questions of the scale of the potential impact of the system proposed. Participants considered how residents may be acting not only within the context of their neighbourhoods but also beyond - at the scale of a city or even country. The project may consider the implications of the proposed approach at various scales.
Participants highlighted the effectiveness of communities in addressing and managing crisis, particularly in the context of energy-related activities. They emphasized the importance of better understanding social factors such as poverty, gender, housing, and community dynamics in shaping energy practices. As discussed, communities were seen to play a crucial role in influencing individual households through the spread of energy-saving practices or energy-intensive behaviours within the community. Moreover, they noted that collective action and community engagement are seen as key drivers of sustainable energy use in Scotland, with communities collaborating to implement renewable energy technologies and initiatives. In addition, participants emphasised the advocacy role of communities in promoting policy changes for sustainable energy use, influencing the broader energy system towards a more sustainable future.

Participants recognised the significance of gender as an important factor to consider in energy-related discussions. They discussed the variations in energy consumption and management practices between men and women. Additionally, they discussed how the number of appliances within households can impact energy usage and influence energy-related activities and routines. The discussions held emphasized the influence of housing conditions and social factors, including income, education, and data, on energy-related activities.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
 
Description What can energy and housing stakeholders learn from bees 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact Purpose - The GLOW HIVE Workshop was held in spring 2022 (online), with the primary aim of engaging with a wide audience including representatives from architecture, energy, engineering, housing and community sectors, in order to understand how diverse participants viewed the use of energy in homes and what this might mean in the context of a community/neighbourhood. The Workshop was organised into 4 groups named HIVES - each made up of 56 participants within a representative sector with discussion drawing on either a social, spatial, digital and/or technical lens.
Outcomes - In summary, it was concluded that greater interdisciplinary and multidimensional knowledge was required to better understand how communities and neighbourhoods manifested-what were the physical, social, and digital boundaries and behaviours, and how residents perceive and associate with their neighbourhood; their home and community energy needs and their potential role within a community energy system.
Impact - The participants reported increased understanding and interest in social energy demand practices in various types of homes and neighbourhoods. The implications of the workshop are twofold - a recognition and expressed involvement in the project from both the energy and housing sectors to better communicate and plan for how a neighbourhood energy management system could operate equitably and efficiently. To date, community energy has mainly been considered in the context of neighbourhoods that could generate their own energy - rather than more generally.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022