Turbulence and transport in the presence of electromagnetic fluctuations and supra-thermal particles in tokamaks.
Lead Research Organisation:
University of Oxford
Department Name: Oxford Physics
Abstract
Providing a long-term solution to the world energy problem and climate change is one of the most scientifically challenging endeavours that faces humanity on the global scale. Fusion energy is a particularly attractive solution and is poised to become a viable energy source in the coming decades by providing carbon-free, steady-state, high energy density in the absence of radioactive waste. However, confinement of the hot plasma is remarkably complicated to achieve in fusion conditions. Magnetic confinement fusion is championed by the tokamak concept, which uses strong magnetic fields in a donut-shaped device to produce the confinement. Despite the confining magnetic fields, experiments and theory have provided strong evidence that turbulent processes in the plasma produce a constant leakage of heat and particles out of the hot confining core, which impedes efficient generation of the fusion processes. This motivates understanding the plasma turbulent processes leading to heat and particle transport from a fundamental perspective, as well as its implications for real life tokamak experiments.
Recent numerical and theoretical studies have shown that fluctuations in the electromagnetic field can lead to enhanced transport losses in the spherical tokamak core at sufficiently high values of beta (ratio of plasma to magnetic pressure), leading to a paradigm shift between the traditional electrostatic description of the 'so-called' ion-scale turbulence (characteristic of the outer-core conventional tokamak) to a fully electromagnetic description and new transport processes. Electromagnetic, meso-scale instabilities (Alfvén eigenmodes) can also be driven by the presence of supra-thermal particles, and are capable of stabilising electrostatic ion-scale turbulence fluctuations. The stabilisation of ion-scale turbulence in the ST and the inner tokamak core leads to unexplored confinement regimes that are likely dominated by the electron heat losses. These are traditionally subdominant to ion heat losses in conventional core tokamak plasma scenarios. These regimes are critically relevant for future fusion reactors which are expected to have dominant electron heating and transport. The novelty of this research is to study these unexplored confinement regimes by combining experimental measurements of the electron fluctuations that are believed to be responsible for the electron heat transport (extremely scarce to date), direct numerical turbulence simulation (gyrokinetic simulation), synthetic diagnostics for the quantitative interpretation of the experimental measurements, and analytical theory to yield a fundamental understanding of the experimental and numerical findings.
Programmatically, the study of electromagnetic fluctuations and Alfvén eigenmodes driven by fast particles is important as they bridge the gap between current machine operation and future fusion reactors. The upcoming JET DT campaign (CCFE, UK), MAST-U (CCFE, UK) and NSTX-U experiments (Princeton, USA) are the missing link between present-day machines and fusion burning plasma experiments such as ITER, STEP (UK) and SPARC (US). Scientifically, this research will lead to ground-breaking discoveries such as new interaction mechanisms between supra-thermal particles and turbulence or the discovery of enhanced confinement regimes expected of future fusion reactors. This will have direct influences affecting the projections and design of the future STEP and ITER burning-plasma experiments, and will enable the UK to gain full in-house energy independence from magnetic fusion in the coming decades.
Recent numerical and theoretical studies have shown that fluctuations in the electromagnetic field can lead to enhanced transport losses in the spherical tokamak core at sufficiently high values of beta (ratio of plasma to magnetic pressure), leading to a paradigm shift between the traditional electrostatic description of the 'so-called' ion-scale turbulence (characteristic of the outer-core conventional tokamak) to a fully electromagnetic description and new transport processes. Electromagnetic, meso-scale instabilities (Alfvén eigenmodes) can also be driven by the presence of supra-thermal particles, and are capable of stabilising electrostatic ion-scale turbulence fluctuations. The stabilisation of ion-scale turbulence in the ST and the inner tokamak core leads to unexplored confinement regimes that are likely dominated by the electron heat losses. These are traditionally subdominant to ion heat losses in conventional core tokamak plasma scenarios. These regimes are critically relevant for future fusion reactors which are expected to have dominant electron heating and transport. The novelty of this research is to study these unexplored confinement regimes by combining experimental measurements of the electron fluctuations that are believed to be responsible for the electron heat transport (extremely scarce to date), direct numerical turbulence simulation (gyrokinetic simulation), synthetic diagnostics for the quantitative interpretation of the experimental measurements, and analytical theory to yield a fundamental understanding of the experimental and numerical findings.
Programmatically, the study of electromagnetic fluctuations and Alfvén eigenmodes driven by fast particles is important as they bridge the gap between current machine operation and future fusion reactors. The upcoming JET DT campaign (CCFE, UK), MAST-U (CCFE, UK) and NSTX-U experiments (Princeton, USA) are the missing link between present-day machines and fusion burning plasma experiments such as ITER, STEP (UK) and SPARC (US). Scientifically, this research will lead to ground-breaking discoveries such as new interaction mechanisms between supra-thermal particles and turbulence or the discovery of enhanced confinement regimes expected of future fusion reactors. This will have direct influences affecting the projections and design of the future STEP and ITER burning-plasma experiments, and will enable the UK to gain full in-house energy independence from magnetic fusion in the coming decades.
People |
ORCID iD |
Juan Ruiz Ruiz (Principal Investigator / Fellow) |
Publications
Garcia Jeronimo
(2023)
Stable Deuterium-Tritium burning plasmas with improved confinement in the presence of energetic-ion instabilities
in arXiv e-prints
Juan Ruiz Ruiz
(2024)
Airy behaviour near the turning point in Doppler Backscattering measurements
Nathan Belrhali
(2024)
Criteria for the limitation of the Gaussian beam tracing method near a turning point caustic
Patel B
(2024)
Pyrokinetics - A Python library to standardise gyrokinetic analysis
in Journal of Open Source Software
Ruiz Ruiz J
(2023)
https://www.aappsdpp.org/DPP2023/html/3contents/topical.html
Ruiz Ruiz J
(2024)
Beam focusing and consequences for Doppler Backscattering measurements
Ruiz Ruiz J
(2024)
Measurement of zonal flow activity due to Alfvénic modes in JET
Schneider P
(2023)
Isotope physics of heat and particle transport with tritium in JET-ILW type-I ELMy H-mode plasmas
in Nuclear Fusion
Description | Collaboration with Princeton Plasma Physics Laboratory (PPPL) |
Organisation | Princeton University |
Department | Princeton Plasma Physics Laboratory |
Country | United States |
Sector | Academic/University |
PI Contribution | This collaboration is mainly with Prof. Felix Parra, project partner in this fellowship, who currently works at the Princeton Plasma Physics Laboratory (PPPL). The main objective of the fellowship is to study the impact of supra-thermal particles on the turbulence in a magnetic fusion device called a tokamak. In this collaboration with Prof. Parra, we have developed a theory to interpret the measurement of turbulence in a plasma via a technique called Doppler Backscattering (DBS). This work provides new insight and interpretation behind the measurement of turbulence in plasmas via DBS, and has already enabled to understand the impact of external actuators such as supra-thermal particles on the plasma. This technique is currently being applied to understand turbulence measurements in the JET tokamak in the Culham Centre for Fusion Energy (CCFE). This collaboration has also enabled me to train two young researchers as part of their undergraduate and graduate curricula. One of those will imminently submit a journal publication entitled 'Criteria for the limitation of the Gaussian beam tracing method near a turning point caustic' (see below under list of outputs). The second student is currently working on submitting a journal publication in late 2024 or early 2025, tentatively entitled 'A beam tracing model for Radial Correlation Doppler Reflectometry'. |
Collaborator Contribution | The main contributions from the partners is the intellectual input and expertise, as well as the funding of two 4-week long trips to PPPL to work and collaborate in person. |
Impact | This research is expected to give rise to at least four journal publications, two of which are already fully written up and are under review by co-authors. The titles are 'Beam focusing and consequences for Doppler Backscattering measurements' and 'Criteria for the limitation of the Gaussian beam tracing method near a turning point caustic', both to be submitted imminently to the Journal of Plasma Physics (JPP). A third publication is currently under preparation to be submitted in 2024, with title 'Airy behaviour near the turning point in Doppler Backscattering measurements'. A fourth publication has 80% of the scientific results completed and is to be submitted in late 2024 or early 2025, with title 'A beam tracing model for Radial Correlation Doppler Reflectometry'. |
Start Year | 2023 |
Description | Collaboration with the National Institutes for Quantum and Radiological Science and Technology (QST, Naka, Japan) |
Organisation | National Institutes for Quantum and Radiological Science and Technology |
Country | Japan |
Sector | Public |
PI Contribution | This is a new collaboration kickstarted in late 2023. The objective of this collaboration is access experimental data from the next generation high-performance tokamak JT60-SA, which is currently being upgraded in Naka, Japan. The collaboration is with Dr. Jeronimo Garcia, project partner in this fellowship who is currently working in QST. JT60-SA is a superconducting tokamak that is the next step aftre the JET tokamak and before the completion of the ITER project. This collaboration has just very recently started and no concrete outcomes are issued from this. The collaboration started in November 2023 with an in-person visit to QST in Japan. This collaboration is expected to yield new avenues of research following my current focus on the measurements of turbulence in the presence of supra-thermal particles in JET. In JTSA-60, new plasma regimes will be achieved, and the next step of my research will be to study the effect of supra-thermal particles in JT60-SA. |
Collaborator Contribution | Dr. Jeronimo Garcia has enabled this collaboration and provided his intellectual expertise to frame the follow on continuation of the project in JT60-SA. |
Impact | This collaboration has just started and no direct outcomes have come out of it yet. It is expected to lead to high-impact publications in the coming year. |
Start Year | 2023 |
Description | Collaboration with the UK Atomic Energy Authority (UKAEA) |
Organisation | Culham Centre for Fusion Energy |
Country | United Kingdom |
Sector | Academic/University |
PI Contribution | The collaboration with UKAEA has enabled two main contributions. The first one is the development of a synthetic diagnostic to interpret the measurement of turbulence in a fusion plasma. This first collaboration is mainly with Dr. Bhavin Patel at UKAEA. A synthetic diagnostic is a numerical tool that mimics the process of the measurement of turbulence via a specific technique called Doppler Backscattering. This synthetic diagnostic is currently implemented and will soon be made publicly available, and has led to a primary contribution in a recent journal publication (see below under outcomes). The second contribution to this work is the access to experimental turbulence data in the JET tokamak, which is enabled by Dr. Jeronimo Garcia, project partner in this fellowship who currently works in QST (Naka, Japan) but enabled this collaboration while he was working at UKAEA until 2023. |
Collaborator Contribution | The contributions from Dr. Bhavin Patel is intellectual expertise in the software, computing and coding for the development of the numerical tools to implement a synthetic diagnostic into a common framework for turbulence analysis called pyrokinetics. The contributions from Dr. Jeronimo Garcia are intellectual expertise in the topics of turbulence simulations in the presence of supra-thermal particles, which is expected to lead to a high impact journal publication in 2024, and also allowing the access to experimental turbulence data from the JET tokamak at UKAEA. |
Impact | The outcome of the collaboration with Dr. Patel at UKAEA is a recent journal publication 'Pyrokinetics - A Python library to standardise gyrokinetic analysis'. A second journal publication is expected to be submitted in 2024. The outcome of the collaboration with Dr. Jeronimo Garcia will be a high impact publication in 2024, entitled 'Measurement of zonal flow induced by Alfvenic activity in the JET tokamak'. This publication is currently under preparation and expected to be submitted in 2024 to Physical Review Letters. This collaboration has also led to multiple presentations in international conference such as in the American Physical Society Annual Meeting on Plasma Physics (APS DPP 2023) and the Asia Pacific Annual Meeting on Plasma Physics (AAPPS DPP 2023). |
Start Year | 2023 |
Title | Pyrokinetics - A Python library to standardise gyrokinetic analysis |
Description | I continue to actively participate in the development and deployment of the software called 'Pyrokinetics' that is used by the magnetic confinement fusion energy research community. I have developed a synthetic diagnostic to quantitatively interpret the measurement of turbulence in a magnetic fusion plasma. This is a numerical tool that mimics the measurement and allows to obtain quantitative characteristics of the turbulence in a fusion plasma. This is highly valuable because it is can be used as a direct probe into the specific physical phenomena that are taking place in the plasma, that are impossible to obtain otherwise. |
Type Of Technology | Software |
Year Produced | 2024 |
Impact | The main outcome is a journal publication that was recently accepted in the Journal of Open Software. I led and continue to lead the deployment of the synthetic diagnostic into the framework 'Pyrokinetics', which will be available to the open public in the coming weeks. This tool is currently gaining a lot of traction in the fusion community to become a standard tool used by researchers to study turbulence from numerical turbulence codes. |
URL | https://joss.theoj.org/papers/10.21105/joss.05866 |