The New Nuclear Imperialism: Science, Diplomacy and Power in the British Empire
Lead Research Organisation:
University of South Wales
Department Name: Faculty of Creative Industries
Abstract
Responding in 1960 to the prospect of French nuclear tests in the Algerian Sahara, the leader of postcolonial Ghana, Kwame Nkrumah, forewarned of a 'new nuclear imperialism' (Allman, 2008; Hill, 2018). The exploitation of foreign lands for uranium mining and the legacies of nuclear testing has ensured the ongoing relevance of Nkrumah's words, both in contemporary charges of 'nuclear neo-colonialism' and in the mobilisation of a worldwide movement towards a nuclear ban treaty (Broinowski, 2015). This research explores how the pursuit of nuclear power by Britain was enmeshed in empire, as well as how this history can be used to engage with current debates about the nuclear order. In doing so, the research is concerned not only with the structural connection between empire and nuclear power - the resources and sites that the British used to procure uranium or test weapons. It is also concerned with imperialism as a knowledge system by which the British nuclear programme was operationalised. In a period regarded as the high point of 'scientific imperialism', this research seeks to show how imperial knowledge informed key decisions and perspectives on where to mine and test, who to affect and involve in these processes and how these could be harnessed and legitimised in international politics (Bennet and Hodge, 2011). The British nuclear programme thus provides a window into imperial thinking about diplomacy, ecology and race at the end of empire.
In order to grasp the role of late imperialism in nuclear history and politics, this project considers nuclear technologies from their production to their potential effects, from the mining of uranium to compensation cases relating to the testing of weapons. In order to grasp imperialism as a distinctive mode of thinking about and acting in the world, the project also invokes methodologies that go beyond state archives and the papers of physicists. The retrieval of myths and folklore, for example, will help to comprehend the relationship between indigenous groups and their land, as well as how mining and testing on that land can be understood as having 'humanitarian impacts'. The project is grounded in five areas, starting with a theorisation of what 'nuclear imperialism' means - and what forms it took - in the context of British and French decolonisation and American internationalism. It goes on to focus on slavery and the global uranium trade in Namibia; diplomatic manoeuvrings around French tests in Algeria and their repercussions for nuclear and non-nuclear alliances; and the significance of non-scientific, non-western perceptions of the nuclear age for rights movements among indigenous groups such as the I-Kiribati in the Pacific. The final part of the project focuses on compensation claims against the British Ministry of Defence by veterans and 'victims' of tests. It uses these to engage more widely with issues of historical injustice, particularly as they have emerged in imperial historiography and the turn towards 'reparatory' histories of colonialism.
These historical links between late imperialism and nuclearity also help to explain challenges to the nuclear order today. To this end, the project will raise awareness and shed light on histories of nuclear imperialism with NGOs that are part of the 'humanitarian initiative' - a movement for the abolition of nuclear weapons among state and non-state actors in the UN. The project will consider the role of these histories in policy debates during the Non-Proliferation Treaty Review Conference (or RevCon), which takes place at the UN in 2020. It will do so in tandem with archivists, campaigners, legal and medical specialists and nuclear veterans.
In order to grasp the role of late imperialism in nuclear history and politics, this project considers nuclear technologies from their production to their potential effects, from the mining of uranium to compensation cases relating to the testing of weapons. In order to grasp imperialism as a distinctive mode of thinking about and acting in the world, the project also invokes methodologies that go beyond state archives and the papers of physicists. The retrieval of myths and folklore, for example, will help to comprehend the relationship between indigenous groups and their land, as well as how mining and testing on that land can be understood as having 'humanitarian impacts'. The project is grounded in five areas, starting with a theorisation of what 'nuclear imperialism' means - and what forms it took - in the context of British and French decolonisation and American internationalism. It goes on to focus on slavery and the global uranium trade in Namibia; diplomatic manoeuvrings around French tests in Algeria and their repercussions for nuclear and non-nuclear alliances; and the significance of non-scientific, non-western perceptions of the nuclear age for rights movements among indigenous groups such as the I-Kiribati in the Pacific. The final part of the project focuses on compensation claims against the British Ministry of Defence by veterans and 'victims' of tests. It uses these to engage more widely with issues of historical injustice, particularly as they have emerged in imperial historiography and the turn towards 'reparatory' histories of colonialism.
These historical links between late imperialism and nuclearity also help to explain challenges to the nuclear order today. To this end, the project will raise awareness and shed light on histories of nuclear imperialism with NGOs that are part of the 'humanitarian initiative' - a movement for the abolition of nuclear weapons among state and non-state actors in the UN. The project will consider the role of these histories in policy debates during the Non-Proliferation Treaty Review Conference (or RevCon), which takes place at the UN in 2020. It will do so in tandem with archivists, campaigners, legal and medical specialists and nuclear veterans.
Planned Impact
The events and outputs of the project are designed to engage - and have an impact on - three communities, all of which have a key stake in the humanitarian initiative against nuclear weapons. These include nuclear veterans in the UK and overseas, campaigners for the abolition of nuclear weapons and citizens in the destinations of the research trips: Accra in Ghana, Suva in Fiji and Windhoek in Namibia. In each of these communities, the project seeks to foster critical reflection on how nuclear and imperial histories have shaped understandings of 'the humanitarian impact of nuclear weapons', a phrase often used in contemporary policy debates.
What 'humanitarian impact' means and the political possibilities it opens up are contingent on the experience and framing of the distinctive histories of these communities. In this project, these span across ex-soldiers who carried out nuclear tests, campaigners who draw on traditions of anti-nuclear protest, and the peoples and workers in the margins - those whose livelihoods depend on the remote regions in which mining and testing have taken place.
In order to maximise the potential for impact, the events and one of the major outputs - the open-access project platform and edited volume - will be linked in to one another, thus empowering collaborators to act as co-producers of the research. This will ensure that collaborators are actively invested in the research, an approach that will support not only the diversity and quality of the edited volume, but also its potential to reach target audiences. The events, which includes three workshops and a conference, will feature interactive sessions in which collaborators can donate multimedia content to the open-access project platform hosted by Manifold with University of Minnesota Press (UMP). The multimedia content can then be embedded into the text of the proposed edited volume, which will emerge out of the project platform and the papers of selected speakers at the conference (Nuclear Histories, Humanitarian Impacts). The production of the edited volume will therefore mark the culmination of an open, iterative, process; one in which collaborators can shape, witness and feedback into the evolution of an academic book. This process will conclude when the multimedia texts of the project platform are codified into an open-access work entitled 'Fallout from the Past', which will also be available in print edition.
Project events are designed to resonate not only with the open-access platform and production of the edited volume, but also with the current context of nuclear disarmament in global politics. In particular, the project platform will be launched only months after the NPT Review Conference in May 2020. This global news event will serve as a springboard for the project, primarily through the publication of a series of blogs on the project website about the role of nuclear and imperial histories in policy debates at the conference. Similarly, the project will also create connections and open up flows between the research trips and the workshops, with the latter exploring issues around archives, ethnography and cultural representation in nuclear research. The workshops will tap into materials gathered during the research trips, and collaborators from overseas will be able to shape the agenda of the workshops by pre-circulating items and questions for discussion. A multimedia blog will also be drafted and published on the project website after each research trip, this time focusing on hidden histories of nuclear imperialism. The final event of the project, the conference, will thus bring together a nexus of critical activities and connections. It will provide a space in which researchers and community representatives can debate and historicise the humanitarian impacts of nuclear weapons, ultimately leading to the production of a live digital work that stands to make an impact across the field.
What 'humanitarian impact' means and the political possibilities it opens up are contingent on the experience and framing of the distinctive histories of these communities. In this project, these span across ex-soldiers who carried out nuclear tests, campaigners who draw on traditions of anti-nuclear protest, and the peoples and workers in the margins - those whose livelihoods depend on the remote regions in which mining and testing have taken place.
In order to maximise the potential for impact, the events and one of the major outputs - the open-access project platform and edited volume - will be linked in to one another, thus empowering collaborators to act as co-producers of the research. This will ensure that collaborators are actively invested in the research, an approach that will support not only the diversity and quality of the edited volume, but also its potential to reach target audiences. The events, which includes three workshops and a conference, will feature interactive sessions in which collaborators can donate multimedia content to the open-access project platform hosted by Manifold with University of Minnesota Press (UMP). The multimedia content can then be embedded into the text of the proposed edited volume, which will emerge out of the project platform and the papers of selected speakers at the conference (Nuclear Histories, Humanitarian Impacts). The production of the edited volume will therefore mark the culmination of an open, iterative, process; one in which collaborators can shape, witness and feedback into the evolution of an academic book. This process will conclude when the multimedia texts of the project platform are codified into an open-access work entitled 'Fallout from the Past', which will also be available in print edition.
Project events are designed to resonate not only with the open-access platform and production of the edited volume, but also with the current context of nuclear disarmament in global politics. In particular, the project platform will be launched only months after the NPT Review Conference in May 2020. This global news event will serve as a springboard for the project, primarily through the publication of a series of blogs on the project website about the role of nuclear and imperial histories in policy debates at the conference. Similarly, the project will also create connections and open up flows between the research trips and the workshops, with the latter exploring issues around archives, ethnography and cultural representation in nuclear research. The workshops will tap into materials gathered during the research trips, and collaborators from overseas will be able to shape the agenda of the workshops by pre-circulating items and questions for discussion. A multimedia blog will also be drafted and published on the project website after each research trip, this time focusing on hidden histories of nuclear imperialism. The final event of the project, the conference, will thus bring together a nexus of critical activities and connections. It will provide a space in which researchers and community representatives can debate and historicise the humanitarian impacts of nuclear weapons, ultimately leading to the production of a live digital work that stands to make an impact across the field.
Publications
Hill C.R.
(2024)
'Follow the Yellowcake Road': Historical Geographies of Namibian Uranium from the Rössing Mine
in Historical Social Research
Hill C.R.
(2024)
'Stealing fire from heaven': Odette du Puigaudeau and French nuclear colonialism in the Algerian Sahara
in International Review of Environmental History
Description | The research deepens understandings of the environmental, imperial and racial dynamics of nuclear energy and weapons projects, specifically in a British context. For the most part, this work has focused on uranium extraction and supply: the 'front-end' of the nuclear cycle. So far, the key findings are as follows: - The global uranium trade was articulated around imperial infrastructures and networks of science, including in chemical industries such as phosphates, in copper and gold mining and in scientific missions to 'remote' regions of the world such as the Antarctic - The global uranium trade offered a window of opportunity for the British multinational, Rio Tinto, to restructure its worldwide operations around Commonwealth states with pre-existing mining expertise and mineral resources: Australia, Canada and South Africa in particular - The rise of the dollar and decline of the pound in the post-war period accelerated rather than diminished British attempts to source uranium from colonies in 'soft currency' areas, though these efforts were rarely successful, except in the case of Namibia (under illegal South African occupation) - The development of uranium mines in former colonies was often predicated on a history of dispossession and violence. - In Namibia, the British-run Rössing mine was central to the strategic creation of a postcolonial identity in the SWAPO-led state - Rio Tinto investment in environmental research led to far more sophisticated understandings of desert ecologies in Namibia - For material and techno-political reasons, Namibian uranium was an invaluable resource for British nuclear energy and weapons in the late twentieth century These findings will be available to consult in a host of forthcoming publications: a peer-reviewed article with Dr Saima Ashipala entitled 'Follow the Yellowcake Road' (Historical Social Research, 2023)), a book chapter in a forthcoming volumed edited by the artist, Sascha Mikloweit (We Build Our Language Out of Rocks, Kerber Verlag, 2024) and a monograph entitled 'Radiant Empire: Africa's Last Colony and the Making of Nuclear Britain' (2024-25). In addition to this work, a second, supporting strand of the project has focused on the perspectives and voices of 'nuclear' groups: nuclear survivors, test veterans and uranium miners in particular. This part of the project has been global in scope and will lead to an edited volume with 20 contributions (Fallout Reframed: Rethinking Nuclearity from Below, contracted to Liverpool University Press and co-edited with Dr Jon Hogg and Professor Raminder Kaur). The findings from this strand of the project are still emerging, but revolve around the ways in which social groups challenge and contest technopolitical regimes of 'nuclearity' in their struggles for justice. |
Exploitation Route | The object of study in this research project - 'nuclear imperialism' - is developing into a large, international field of scholarship. The best work on this topic has tended to emerge out of the disciplines of ecocriticism and postcolonial literature. Whilst these disciplines have yielded key insights into social and cultural responses to nuclear imperialism, they have been less successful in historicising nuclear imperialism or defining exactly what it was or is. The research conducted in this project can now be used to develop a more authoritative historical interpretation of nuclear imperialism. I plan to develop a major article on this subject with Jessica Urwin, who recently completed her doctorate on a similar subject at Australia National University. It is also clear that a comparative, international perspective is needed on nuclear imperialism. To this end, I have become a key member of an international network led by Professor Renaud Meltz, who is leading a research project on the history and legacies of French nuclear weapons tests in Polynesia. |
Sectors | Education Energy Environment Healthcare Government Democracy and Justice Culture Heritage Museums and Collections Security and Diplomacy |
Description | The project has shed light on the need for an official recognition programme to support and remember British nuclear test veterans. My engagement with nuclear test veteran organisations precedes the project. During the project, I therefore invited nuclear test veterans and their descendants to contribute to project workshops, most notably in the first workshop on 'nuclear history and the archive'. For this workshop, I ran a dedicated session on the role of the archive among British nuclear test veterans. This proved to be surprisingly controversial - claims and counterclaims were made about which organisations and individuals had rights to archival materials. A recording of the workshop was even used as evidence during a legal hearing about archival materials. Despite these difficulties, the workshop also helped to put historical recognition on the radar of policymakers who specialise in veterans' welfare: the Office for Veteran Affairs (OVA) in particular. I was subsequently invited to attend a meeting with the OVA by the then CEO of the British Nuclear Test Veterans Association. I was personally invited to develop (a now successful) grant application to lead an OVA-funded project on the oral history of British nuclear test veterans. I was also invited as a dignitary to a high-profile commemorative event, where Rishi Sunak announced that nuclear test veterans would be awarded a medal for their service. The announcement of the medal precipitated another potentially impactful event linked to a forthcoming project research trip to Fiji. Dr Brian Jones, British High Commissioner for Fiji, has proposed that we co-organise an event for Fijian nuclear test veterans whilst I am in Suva in May 2023. According to Dr Jones, the legacy of British nuclear testing in the Pacific continues to have diplomatic implications for the UK in the wider region. Dr Jones would also like to see medallic recognition for Fijian nuclear test veterans. During the trip in May 2023, I also visited Kiritimati, the main base and test site for British hydrogen bomb trials in the Pacific. I have formed partnerships with a local Association focusing on nuclear justice for islanders, as well as with one of the two high schools on Kiritimati, St Francis. I am about to publish a news article about my research on Kiritimati for The Conversation. I have also been invited to publish a chapter about nuclear legacies on Kiritimati in an edited volume led by a team of leading researchers in the field. This is all leading to new impact opportunities around education and heritage. I am developing a project with a renowned British artist, the Office for Veterans Affairs and the Fijian High Commissioner on this topic. I may seek to apply for follow-on funding in order to pursue this project. |
First Year Of Impact | 2022 |
Sector | Communities and Social Services/Policy,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections,Security and Diplomacy |
Impact Types | Cultural Societal Policy & public services |
Description | An Oral History of British Nuclear Test Veterans |
Amount | £311,000 (GBP) |
Organisation | Cabinet Office |
Sector | Public |
Country | United Kingdom |
Start | 03/2023 |
End | 03/2025 |
Description | Annual Conference of the British Nuclear Test Veterans Association |
Form Of Engagement Activity | A talk or presentation |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | National |
Primary Audience | Study participants or study members |
Results and Impact | I gave a talk to British nuclear veterans about the research project. I invited key members to participate in future project events. |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2021 |
Description | Expert contributor to Forces News documentary |
Form Of Engagement Activity | A broadcast e.g. TV/radio/film/podcast (other than news/press) |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | International |
Primary Audience | Public/other audiences |
Results and Impact | Hannah King, a Producer for Forces News, invited me to appear as an historical expert on a documentary she is filming about British nuclear test veterans. The documentary will be broadcast on Youtube, where Forces News has over 600,000 subscribers. |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2023 |
Description | Talk at exhibition launch event |
Form Of Engagement Activity | A talk or presentation |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | National |
Primary Audience | Third sector organisations |
Results and Impact | I was invited to give a talk at the launch of 'Plym to Pamlico', an exhibition held at the Royal Engineers Museum in Kent. The talk was aimed at nuclear test veterans, civil servants from the Office of Veteran Affairs and journalists. |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2022 |
URL | https://www.re-museum.co.uk/plym-to-pamlico/#:~:text='Plym%20to%20Pamlico'%20is%20an,October%20to%20... |
Description | Workshop 1: Nuclear History and the Archive |
Form Of Engagement Activity | Participation in an activity, workshop or similar |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | International |
Primary Audience | Study participants or study members |
Results and Impact | This was the first in a series of three proposed workshops on methodological approaches to nuclear history in the arts and humanities. The workshop sought to connect academics and with members of what we called 'nuclear communities' - that is to say, members of communities who have been affected, usually adversely, by nuclear infrastructures and operations in the past. The workshop was particularly well-represented among leading members of the British nuclear veterans community. The connections made in the workshop will feed through to contributions for an open access edited volume contracted to Liverpool University Press. |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2021 |
Description | Workshop 2: Ethics and Ethnography in Nuclear History |
Form Of Engagement Activity | Participation in an activity, workshop or similar |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | International |
Primary Audience | Study participants or study members |
Results and Impact | This was the second in a series of three proposed workshops on methodological approaches to nuclear history in the arts and humanities. The workshop sought to connect academics and with members of what we called 'nuclear communities' - that is to say, members of communities who have been affected, usually adversely, by nuclear infrastructures and operations in the past. The workshop featured a keynote from a leading figure in the International Campaign for the Abolition of Nuclear Weapons (ICAN), as well as a roundtable among participants in the McClelland Royal Commission into British nuclear tests in Australia. The connections made in the workshop will feed through to contributions for an open access edited volume contracted to Liverpool University Press. |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2022 |