CAMPUS (Combining Autonomous observations and Models for Predicting and Understanding Shelf seas)
Lead Research Organisation:
Centre for Environment, Fisheries and Aquaculture Science
Department Name: CEFAS Lowestoft Laboratory
Abstract
Shelf seas are of major societal importance providing a diverse range of goods (e.g. fisheries, renewable energy, transport) and services (e.g. carbon and nutrient cycling and biodiversity). Managing UK seas to maintain clean, healthy, safe, productive and biologically diverse oceans and seas is a key governmental objective, as evidenced by the obligations to obtain Good Environmental Status (GES) under the UK Marine Strategy Framework, the Convention on Biological Diversity and ratification of the Oslo-Paris Convention (OSPAR) .. The delivery of these obligations requires comprehensive information about the state of our seas which in turn requires a combination of numerical models and observational programs.
Computer modelling of marine ecosystems allows us to explore the recent past and predict future states of physical, chemical and biological properties of the sea, and how they vary in 3D space and time. In an analogous manner to the weather forecast, the Met Office runs a marine operational forecast system providing both short term forecast and multi-decadal historical data products. The quality of these forecasts is improved by using data assimilation; the process of predicting the most accurate ocean state using observations to nudge model simulations, producing a combined observation and model product.
Marine autonomous vehicles (MAVs) are a rapidly maturing technology and are now routinely deployed both in support of research and as a component of an ocean observing system. When used in conjunction with fixed point observatories, ships of opportunity and satellite remote sensing, the strategic deployment of MAVs offers the prospect of substantial improvement in our observing network. Marine Gliders in particular have the capability to provide depth resolved data sets of high resolution from deployments that can endure several months and cover 100s kms, allowing the collection of sufficient information to be useful for assimilation into models.
We will improve the exchange of data between model systems and observational networks to inform an improved strategy for the deployment of the UK's high-cost marine observing capability. In particular we will utilise mathematical and statistical models to develop and test "smart" autonomy - autonomous systems that are enabled to selectively search and monitor explicit features within the marine system. By developing data assimilation techniques to utilise autonomous data, our model systems will be able to better characterise episodic events such as the spring bloom, harmful algal blooms and oxygen depletion, which are currently not well captured and are key to understanding ecosystem variability and therefore quantifying GES.
In doing so CAMPUS will provide a step change in the combined use of observation and modelling technologies, delivered through a combination of autonomous technologies (gliders), other observations and shelf-wide numerical models. This will provide improved analysis of key ocean variables, better predictions of episodic events, and 'smart' observing systems in order to improve the evidence base for compliance with European directives and support the UK industrial strategy.
Computer modelling of marine ecosystems allows us to explore the recent past and predict future states of physical, chemical and biological properties of the sea, and how they vary in 3D space and time. In an analogous manner to the weather forecast, the Met Office runs a marine operational forecast system providing both short term forecast and multi-decadal historical data products. The quality of these forecasts is improved by using data assimilation; the process of predicting the most accurate ocean state using observations to nudge model simulations, producing a combined observation and model product.
Marine autonomous vehicles (MAVs) are a rapidly maturing technology and are now routinely deployed both in support of research and as a component of an ocean observing system. When used in conjunction with fixed point observatories, ships of opportunity and satellite remote sensing, the strategic deployment of MAVs offers the prospect of substantial improvement in our observing network. Marine Gliders in particular have the capability to provide depth resolved data sets of high resolution from deployments that can endure several months and cover 100s kms, allowing the collection of sufficient information to be useful for assimilation into models.
We will improve the exchange of data between model systems and observational networks to inform an improved strategy for the deployment of the UK's high-cost marine observing capability. In particular we will utilise mathematical and statistical models to develop and test "smart" autonomy - autonomous systems that are enabled to selectively search and monitor explicit features within the marine system. By developing data assimilation techniques to utilise autonomous data, our model systems will be able to better characterise episodic events such as the spring bloom, harmful algal blooms and oxygen depletion, which are currently not well captured and are key to understanding ecosystem variability and therefore quantifying GES.
In doing so CAMPUS will provide a step change in the combined use of observation and modelling technologies, delivered through a combination of autonomous technologies (gliders), other observations and shelf-wide numerical models. This will provide improved analysis of key ocean variables, better predictions of episodic events, and 'smart' observing systems in order to improve the evidence base for compliance with European directives and support the UK industrial strategy.
Planned Impact
This project will be of interest and benefit to a wide community, ranging from policy makers to end users of operational forecasts, and industry, underpinning the development of strategies to achieve a healthy marine environment, rendering ecosystems more resilient to climate change and variability, and assisting sustainable exploitation of marine resources.
Policy and Marine Management: Defra, Marine Scotland and Agri-Food and Biosciences Institute AFBI are responsible for implementation of the Marine Strategy Framework Directive in the UK and the establishment of clear environmental targets and monitoring programmes. They will benefit from improved knowledge and predictive skill for key indicators of the state of the marine environment. We will inform the assessment of Good Environmental Status, through demonstrating that data assimilated model products can provide a complete and contiguous information resource. This work will also inform the OSPAR assessment and future advances in the indicators used. Other policy areas that will benefit are marine spatial planning, fisheries policy and environmental assessment for off-shore operations. We will also engage with relevant international actors, e.g. International Council for the Exploration of the Sea; and non-governmental organisations (e.g. WWF), who develop science and advice to support the sustainable use of the oceans. CAMPUS will seek to engage with policy makers, via briefing notes, POSTnotes, or via the Parliamentary & Scientific Committee.
Marine Monitoring strategies: Optimising the use of the UK's high-cost marine observing capability requires integrated network design and cost benefit analysis: CAMPUS will provide understanding of the scales and variability of the shelf sea system in the context of GES indicators and thus advise on the optimal observation network design for monitoring. This will assist the UK Integrated Marine Observing Network (UK-IMON); UK Marine Monitoring and Assessment Strategy (UKMMAS); the UK Marine Science Co-ordination Committee (MSCC). Key stakeholders include Defra, Marine Scotland, UKMO and AFBI.
Operational Ocean forecast: The Copernicus Marine Environment Monitoring Service (CMEMS) provides regular and systematic reference and monitoring information on the state of the oceans and regional seas, for both policy applications, such as MSFD, businesses and marine operators to exploit commercially. CAMPUS will integrate improved model-data systems into existing CMEMS operational oceanographic simulation and data delivery systems, further providing a template as to how this might be effected in other regions. Key stakeholders include MERCATOR and the UKMO
Industry: Dynamic sampling and truly autonomous vehicles open up the potential for a) new technology developments in the AV industry b) wider applications for monitoring in the energy / offshore industry and c) risk assessment for the aquaculture industry. Key stakeholders include DSTL, the MASSMO consortium and the Scottish aquaculture industry.
Data delivery: A key challenge for encouraging the use of model data products is the ability to make them easily accessible to the full range of stakeholders (e.g. policy, NGO, business, academics, general public). Model and data products will be made accessible via working with BODC, the Marine Environmental Data and Information Network (MEDIN) and international data infrastructures provided by ICES and EMODnet. A public facing web-based GIS data portal will allow users to browse and map data.
Overseas Development Assistance: CAMPUS will provide a template for closely aligning models and observations in the ODA context, for example using models to aid the design of monitoring effort and inform model system configuration. We will explore how this would work in practice in a short desk study, focusing on Living Marine resources in the Bay of Bengal. This project will contribute in particular to UN Sustainable Development Goals (UNSDG14)
Policy and Marine Management: Defra, Marine Scotland and Agri-Food and Biosciences Institute AFBI are responsible for implementation of the Marine Strategy Framework Directive in the UK and the establishment of clear environmental targets and monitoring programmes. They will benefit from improved knowledge and predictive skill for key indicators of the state of the marine environment. We will inform the assessment of Good Environmental Status, through demonstrating that data assimilated model products can provide a complete and contiguous information resource. This work will also inform the OSPAR assessment and future advances in the indicators used. Other policy areas that will benefit are marine spatial planning, fisheries policy and environmental assessment for off-shore operations. We will also engage with relevant international actors, e.g. International Council for the Exploration of the Sea; and non-governmental organisations (e.g. WWF), who develop science and advice to support the sustainable use of the oceans. CAMPUS will seek to engage with policy makers, via briefing notes, POSTnotes, or via the Parliamentary & Scientific Committee.
Marine Monitoring strategies: Optimising the use of the UK's high-cost marine observing capability requires integrated network design and cost benefit analysis: CAMPUS will provide understanding of the scales and variability of the shelf sea system in the context of GES indicators and thus advise on the optimal observation network design for monitoring. This will assist the UK Integrated Marine Observing Network (UK-IMON); UK Marine Monitoring and Assessment Strategy (UKMMAS); the UK Marine Science Co-ordination Committee (MSCC). Key stakeholders include Defra, Marine Scotland, UKMO and AFBI.
Operational Ocean forecast: The Copernicus Marine Environment Monitoring Service (CMEMS) provides regular and systematic reference and monitoring information on the state of the oceans and regional seas, for both policy applications, such as MSFD, businesses and marine operators to exploit commercially. CAMPUS will integrate improved model-data systems into existing CMEMS operational oceanographic simulation and data delivery systems, further providing a template as to how this might be effected in other regions. Key stakeholders include MERCATOR and the UKMO
Industry: Dynamic sampling and truly autonomous vehicles open up the potential for a) new technology developments in the AV industry b) wider applications for monitoring in the energy / offshore industry and c) risk assessment for the aquaculture industry. Key stakeholders include DSTL, the MASSMO consortium and the Scottish aquaculture industry.
Data delivery: A key challenge for encouraging the use of model data products is the ability to make them easily accessible to the full range of stakeholders (e.g. policy, NGO, business, academics, general public). Model and data products will be made accessible via working with BODC, the Marine Environmental Data and Information Network (MEDIN) and international data infrastructures provided by ICES and EMODnet. A public facing web-based GIS data portal will allow users to browse and map data.
Overseas Development Assistance: CAMPUS will provide a template for closely aligning models and observations in the ODA context, for example using models to aid the design of monitoring effort and inform model system configuration. We will explore how this would work in practice in a short desk study, focusing on Living Marine resources in the Bay of Bengal. This project will contribute in particular to UN Sustainable Development Goals (UNSDG14)
Publications
Piroddi C
(2021)
Effects of Nutrient Management Scenarios on Marine Food Webs: A Pan-European Assessment in Support of the Marine Strategy Framework Directive
in Frontiers in Marine Science
Description | CAMPUS explored how to enhance the use of autonomous instruments, using understanding from the Alter ECO project, combined with hydrodynamic /ecosystem models to provide a cost effective marine monitoring system for the UK. CAMPUS: i) developed realistic scenarios for a future UK network, integrating a variety of autonomous vehicles and instrumentation with in situ observations, ii) costed each scenario and then iii) demonstrated their effectiveness at accurately assessing the status of the UK Seas relating to the OSPAR - Eutrophication assessment. The existence of the network can provide data in real time to be used in model assimilation, these models can then forecast water quality status. |
Exploitation Route | Work is still ongoing in getting adoption of a Marine Network incorporating Autonomous instrumentation. |
Sectors | Environment Government Democracy and Justice |
Description | One of the key goals of CAMPUS is to deliver improved information for marine management. There is also increasing pressure on managers and policy-makers to make decisions based on such information including using predictions of ocean change, key to this is confidence that the information can be relied upon. Marine ecosystem models have not previously been used in UK policy and the uptake of models is poor in international fora as well. CAMPUS has contributed to the OSPAR (Oslo Paris Convention) Commission multi model ensemble application that has simulated historic scenarios of a pre eutrophication state (c 1900s) , and there by defined "high status" for European regional seas. The associated derived thresholds will be used in the next OSPAR Eutrophication assessment reporting round. This is the first time that marine models have been used as evidence, in this policy context. Furthermore, the above ensemble application supported by CAMPUS has opened the door to models being used as evidence in future marine environment state assessments. International agreements require multi country alignment on methods and outcomes: . |
First Year Of Impact | 2022 |
Sector | Environment,Government, Democracy and Justice |
Description | Advice to HBDSEG on new monitoring strategy |
Geographic Reach | National |
Policy Influence Type | Participation in a guidance/advisory committee |
Description | Conversation with Beth Stoker |
Geographic Reach | National |
Policy Influence Type | Influenced training of practitioners or researchers |
Description | Collaboration with OSPAR ICG -EMO |
Organisation | Deltares |
Country | Netherlands |
Sector | Private |
PI Contribution | Working with the OSPAR group Interssesional Group for ecological modelling to define the historical thresholds for defining the thresholds for the waters of the OSPAR regions. I.e. North West European shelf. The 8 model ensemble simulates the conditions of the 1900s before the industrial process of nitrogen manufacturer occurred. These models are then used to define the best conditions that should be attainable. |
Collaborator Contribution | Cefas as part of this Campus consortium and having links to UK government has a dual role. There has been provision of marine ecosystem model outputs simulating the North West European shelf. There is also substantial work in helping set the direction of how the model outputs are used and accepted internationally. Its the aim of Campus that models are accepted as evidence at international level and used in assessments. This work is a fundamental step in that direction and a significant output of the Campus project. |
Impact | The outputs are still confidential at present as need agreement with Heads of Delegation they will be avialable after easter from the OSPAR web site. |
Start Year | 2021 |
Description | Collaboration with OSPAR ICG -EMO |
Organisation | European Commission |
Department | Joint Research Centre (JRC) |
Country | European Union (EU) |
Sector | Public |
PI Contribution | Working with the OSPAR group Interssesional Group for ecological modelling to define the historical thresholds for defining the thresholds for the waters of the OSPAR regions. I.e. North West European shelf. The 8 model ensemble simulates the conditions of the 1900s before the industrial process of nitrogen manufacturer occurred. These models are then used to define the best conditions that should be attainable. |
Collaborator Contribution | Cefas as part of this Campus consortium and having links to UK government has a dual role. There has been provision of marine ecosystem model outputs simulating the North West European shelf. There is also substantial work in helping set the direction of how the model outputs are used and accepted internationally. Its the aim of Campus that models are accepted as evidence at international level and used in assessments. This work is a fundamental step in that direction and a significant output of the Campus project. |
Impact | The outputs are still confidential at present as need agreement with Heads of Delegation they will be avialable after easter from the OSPAR web site. |
Start Year | 2021 |
Description | Collaboration with OSPAR ICG -EMO |
Organisation | French Research Institute for the Exploitation of the Sea |
Country | France |
Sector | Public |
PI Contribution | Working with the OSPAR group Interssesional Group for ecological modelling to define the historical thresholds for defining the thresholds for the waters of the OSPAR regions. I.e. North West European shelf. The 8 model ensemble simulates the conditions of the 1900s before the industrial process of nitrogen manufacturer occurred. These models are then used to define the best conditions that should be attainable. |
Collaborator Contribution | Cefas as part of this Campus consortium and having links to UK government has a dual role. There has been provision of marine ecosystem model outputs simulating the North West European shelf. There is also substantial work in helping set the direction of how the model outputs are used and accepted internationally. Its the aim of Campus that models are accepted as evidence at international level and used in assessments. This work is a fundamental step in that direction and a significant output of the Campus project. |
Impact | The outputs are still confidential at present as need agreement with Heads of Delegation they will be avialable after easter from the OSPAR web site. |
Start Year | 2021 |
Description | Collaboration with OSPAR ICG -EMO |
Organisation | University of Hamburg |
Country | Germany |
Sector | Academic/University |
PI Contribution | Working with the OSPAR group Interssesional Group for ecological modelling to define the historical thresholds for defining the thresholds for the waters of the OSPAR regions. I.e. North West European shelf. The 8 model ensemble simulates the conditions of the 1900s before the industrial process of nitrogen manufacturer occurred. These models are then used to define the best conditions that should be attainable. |
Collaborator Contribution | Cefas as part of this Campus consortium and having links to UK government has a dual role. There has been provision of marine ecosystem model outputs simulating the North West European shelf. There is also substantial work in helping set the direction of how the model outputs are used and accepted internationally. Its the aim of Campus that models are accepted as evidence at international level and used in assessments. This work is a fundamental step in that direction and a significant output of the Campus project. |
Impact | The outputs are still confidential at present as need agreement with Heads of Delegation they will be avialable after easter from the OSPAR web site. |
Start Year | 2021 |
Description | ICG_EMO |
Form Of Engagement Activity | A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | International |
Primary Audience | Professional Practitioners |
Results and Impact | ICG EMO is the modelling group of OSPAR . Involvement in this group is a key part of what CAMPUS is about in that it is getting models used and accepted in marine policy. The modelling group is running scenarios of historic nutrient levels and is using this to determine the threshold values for future assessments. This is a significant achievement, with mutli model ensembles being used to generate the threshold values. This is the first time models have been used in the marine environment to set thresholds. The challenge of how to combine models and observations with corrections for model and observation bias is a difficult one. The progress made in this project is therefore important. |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2020,2021 |
URL | https://www.ospar.org/meetings/archive/technical-group-for-the-common-procedure-3 |
Description | Improving links between research science and Defra Marine evidence requirements: Shelf Seas Biogeochemistry Legacy Workshop |
Form Of Engagement Activity | Participation in an activity, workshop or similar |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | National |
Primary Audience | Policymakers/politicians |
Results and Impact | This workshop was spefically aimed at improving links between research science and Defra Marine evidence requirements: and used the recently completed Shelf Seas Biogeochemistry program as base for discussion. Many of the outcomes and recommendations are relevant to Campuss. |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2019 |
Description | National Partnership for Ocean Prediction - bio geochemsity meeting. |
Form Of Engagement Activity | A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | National |
Primary Audience | Industry/Business |
Results and Impact | This is a specialist group looking at the future of bio geochemistry modelling. |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2020 |
Description | OPEG |
Form Of Engagement Activity | A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | National |
Primary Audience | Professional Practitioners |
Results and Impact | Stephen Dye, CEFAS - as part of the Campus program attended the OPEG (Ocean and Physical evidence) group as chair. He made OPEG group aware of the aim of campus and how the results could be useful. |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2018 |
Description | OSPAR - Task Group for OSPAR Comprehensive Procedure (TG COMP) and ICG -EMO (OSPAR Intercessional Group for Modelling) f |
Form Of Engagement Activity | A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | International |
Primary Audience | Professional Practitioners |
Results and Impact | OSPAR is responsible for assessing the formal state of the European Seas. Specifically this group in the Eutrophication assesment group, and is developing and implementing better methods to assess the Eutrophication status of the NWES (North West European Shelf). At present the formal assessment doesnot include modelling. Alongside this group is the ICG_EMO group which undertakes ecosystem/ water quality modelling and is a route to get models used in formal assessments. |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2019 |
URL | https://www.ospar.org/meetings/archive/intersessional-correspondence-group-on-eutrophication-modelli... |
Description | OSPAR ICG_IMO_Historic Scenario |
Form Of Engagement Activity | A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | International |
Primary Audience | Professional Practitioners |
Results and Impact | Attendance at regular meetings of ICG_EMO Historic Nutrients Scenarios . Defining, agreeing and setting a nutrient scenario (1900) for use in modelling so that it can be used to set base line conditions. |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2020 |
Description | Pacific Ocean Alliance Meeting monitoring and assessment for Small Island States |
Form Of Engagement Activity | Participation in an activity, workshop or similar |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | International |
Primary Audience | Professional Practitioners |
Results and Impact | The workshop had approximately 100 people for the Pacific Ocean Alliance Meeting - discussing UK research in context of Pacific Ocean, particularly the application of Sustainable Development Goals and the role of monitoring and assessment. It was held in Suva, Fiji October 2019. The specific role of Campus is that there is the intention of developing monitoring programes and combinations for the UK which could then be applied in the broader international context. |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2019 |
Description | The fourth workshop of the 'Network of Experts for ReDeveloping Models of the European Marine Environment' |
Form Of Engagement Activity | A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | International |
Primary Audience | Professional Practitioners |
Results and Impact | The work shop was the fourth by the Network of Experts for ReDeveloping Models of the European Marine Environment. One aspect of the project is getting uptake of models into the wider European community to be accepted as evidence. |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2019 |
URL | https://ec.europa.eu/jrc |