EPSRC-SFI: Blockchain transactions in the electricity industry: beyond tokenised energy
Lead Research Organisation:
University of Edinburgh
Department Name: Sch of Engineering
Abstract
Cryptocurrencies such as Bitcoin are underpinned by a computer technology called blockchain, which has existed for around ten years. There are now proposals to use blockchain technologies to allow consumers to buy electricity directly from generators, in the form of tokenised energy.
This project will investigate the new opportunities that could arise if the trading of tokenised electricity gains broader adoption. In particular, the project will examine the role another new blockchain technology, known as smart contracts, can play in such a business landscape. Smart contracts allow financial and business arrangements to be codified directly into the blockchain itself, where they execute in a way that cannot be interfered with. This project will explore the potential for deploying smart contracts in various new roles connected with tokenised energy trading, for instance:
- to allow trading of other useful electricity services, such as targeting and rewarding reductions of consumption at times of high system stress;
- to coordinate the generation and consumption of electricity within local energy communities so they do not burden the physical utility network;
- to provide financial functions such as price guarantees for consumers or revenue-sharing schemes for community-owned energy resources.
A particular focus of the project will be on renewable energy: can these blockchain technologies speed up the decarbonisation of electricity grids?; and can empowering communities, consumers and renewable generators with new financial tools create a cleaner and more collaborative electricity system?
Overall, this project is a forward-looking piece of research which will guide how system operators adapt to blockchain technologies. The goal is give a well-rounded perspective on the full potential value that can be captured, rather than narrowly focusing on just the trading of tokenised energy itself. The project will show how positive interaction effects can arise, so that a vibrant blockchain sector can emerge across the electricity value chain, with each new piece of smart contract functionality complementing and adding value to the entire ecosystem.
This project will investigate the new opportunities that could arise if the trading of tokenised electricity gains broader adoption. In particular, the project will examine the role another new blockchain technology, known as smart contracts, can play in such a business landscape. Smart contracts allow financial and business arrangements to be codified directly into the blockchain itself, where they execute in a way that cannot be interfered with. This project will explore the potential for deploying smart contracts in various new roles connected with tokenised energy trading, for instance:
- to allow trading of other useful electricity services, such as targeting and rewarding reductions of consumption at times of high system stress;
- to coordinate the generation and consumption of electricity within local energy communities so they do not burden the physical utility network;
- to provide financial functions such as price guarantees for consumers or revenue-sharing schemes for community-owned energy resources.
A particular focus of the project will be on renewable energy: can these blockchain technologies speed up the decarbonisation of electricity grids?; and can empowering communities, consumers and renewable generators with new financial tools create a cleaner and more collaborative electricity system?
Overall, this project is a forward-looking piece of research which will guide how system operators adapt to blockchain technologies. The goal is give a well-rounded perspective on the full potential value that can be captured, rather than narrowly focusing on just the trading of tokenised energy itself. The project will show how positive interaction effects can arise, so that a vibrant blockchain sector can emerge across the electricity value chain, with each new piece of smart contract functionality complementing and adding value to the entire ecosystem.
Planned Impact
This project aims to demonstrate how blockchain smart contracts can create a participatory financial ecosystem that offers value across the electricity sector.
Prosumers (consumers who own and proactively manage distributed energy resources) will benefit from new smart contracts that increase the utilisation of their energy resources, and de-risk their ownership. Smart contracts will be designed that facilitate the formation of cooperative federations between groups of prosumers, allowing them to enter into larger and longer-term energy and flexibility contracts. Hedging and risk-sharing arrangements built into the smart contracts will help address electricity price uncertainty, variable renewable generation and penalties for flexibility service non-delivery.
Blockchain-enabled peer-to-peer trading offers value for prosumers, and if properly managed, for the system as a whole. Matching local renewable generation with flexible demand can reduce upstream power flows and losses, alleviate the need for renewable curtailment and help defer costly distribution, transmission and generation infrastructure upgrades. However, a major unresolved challenge is how network constraints can be managed, without re-introducing a distribution system operator as a central authority. The project will address this by developing a novel methodology for calculating peer-to-peer network incentives, in the form of fees and subsidies, which help steer blockchain markets away from outcomes which would violate network constraints.
System operators will be able to make use of smart contracts to procure flexibility services from prosumers. Since, smart contracts are decentralised and directly negotiated, they are particularly suited for establishing transparent and competitive markets. Integrating owners of smaller scale flexible resources (e.g. electric vehicles, heat pumps) into flexibility markets would help increase liquidity and allow constraints to be managed on a more granular level. This is expected to become increasingly important, given government policies supporting the rapid electrification of heat and transport.
Overall, the aim of the project is to go beyond how blockchain smart contracts can benefit particular electricity market participants, by articulating how they can create value across the sector. Ultimately, the successful translation of the technologies developed during the project would be reflected in lower energy bills for consumers, even as the UK and the Republic of Ireland pursue ambitious decarbonisation objectives.
Prosumers (consumers who own and proactively manage distributed energy resources) will benefit from new smart contracts that increase the utilisation of their energy resources, and de-risk their ownership. Smart contracts will be designed that facilitate the formation of cooperative federations between groups of prosumers, allowing them to enter into larger and longer-term energy and flexibility contracts. Hedging and risk-sharing arrangements built into the smart contracts will help address electricity price uncertainty, variable renewable generation and penalties for flexibility service non-delivery.
Blockchain-enabled peer-to-peer trading offers value for prosumers, and if properly managed, for the system as a whole. Matching local renewable generation with flexible demand can reduce upstream power flows and losses, alleviate the need for renewable curtailment and help defer costly distribution, transmission and generation infrastructure upgrades. However, a major unresolved challenge is how network constraints can be managed, without re-introducing a distribution system operator as a central authority. The project will address this by developing a novel methodology for calculating peer-to-peer network incentives, in the form of fees and subsidies, which help steer blockchain markets away from outcomes which would violate network constraints.
System operators will be able to make use of smart contracts to procure flexibility services from prosumers. Since, smart contracts are decentralised and directly negotiated, they are particularly suited for establishing transparent and competitive markets. Integrating owners of smaller scale flexible resources (e.g. electric vehicles, heat pumps) into flexibility markets would help increase liquidity and allow constraints to be managed on a more granular level. This is expected to become increasingly important, given government policies supporting the rapid electrification of heat and transport.
Overall, the aim of the project is to go beyond how blockchain smart contracts can benefit particular electricity market participants, by articulating how they can create value across the sector. Ultimately, the successful translation of the technologies developed during the project would be reflected in lower energy bills for consumers, even as the UK and the Republic of Ireland pursue ambitious decarbonisation objectives.
Publications


Billimoria F
(2022)
An insurance mechanism for electricity reliability differentiation under deep decarbonization
in Applied Energy




Charbonnier F
(2025)
Centralised rehearsal of decentralised cooperation: Multi-agent reinforcement learning for the scalable coordination of residential energy flexibility
in Applied Energy

Charbonnier F
(2022)
Scalable multi-agent reinforcement learning for distributed control of residential energy flexibility
in Applied Energy

Charbonnier F
(2022)
Coordination of resources at the edge of the electricity grid: Systematic review and taxonomy
in Applied Energy
Description | - An important output from the project is a blockchain-based market layer for on-demand flexibility procurement which has been designed so that it could be integrated into the existing electricity market architecture of Great Britain (GB). This presents the novel use of blockchain smart contracts for aggregation and disaggregation of grid-edge flexibility, with automatic handling of revenue sharing and under-delivery penalties. The key benefits of using blockchain smart contracts here are (i) transparency, (ii) trust without third parties, (iii) cryptographic security, (iv) resilience due to decentralisation, and (v) transaction cost savings. A proof-of-concept software prototype was developed and has been made available as open-source code. Simulation case studies for the GB Balancing Mechanism demonstrated that our proposed blockchain marketplace operating in January of 2021 and coordinating 100 MW of flexibility could have reduced balancing costs by over £4m. This work was published in Energy Economics. - For our work on national value assessment, we developed a high-fidelity 1900 node model of the GB transmission system linked with unit-level Elexon data for the Balancing Mechanism, GB's main market for supply demand balancing and constraint management. This model has also been made available as an open-source project, and was an important enabler of an EPSRC project (EP/W027321/1), "Data-driven exploration of the carbon emissions impact of grid energy storage deployment and dispatch". - Another novel application of blockchains we have developed with our partners in University College Dublin (UCD) is the use of Decentralised Autonomous Organisation (DAO) smart contracts to enable shared financing, governance and revenue dispersal for battery energy storage systems. This work has led to conference papers at the IEEE Global Emerging Technology Blockchain Forum and the IEEE PowerTech conference. This work has the potential to unlock crowdfunding as a new means of financing grid storage investment, which could simultaneous help accelerate the net-zero transition and share its financial benefits more widely. |
Exploitation Route | The new smart contract designs and open-source software could be used as the basis for new smart contract-based energy market businesses around unlocking grid flexibility and financing for investment. A potential barrier to commercialisation we identified in Europe is the exclusion of computer programs and methods of doing business from patent protection. Our work on detailed modelling of Great Britain's transmission system and balancing mechanism demonstrated that substantial value could be unlocked from distributed grid-edge flexibility. This motivates future implementation focused research and development. In addition, it can also provide evidence relevant for policymakers considering electricity market reforms, as well as National Grid ESO and GB distribution network operators which are working on mechanisms that would enable innovation in the area of digitalisation to incentivise and coordinate national and local flexibility from grid-edge devices. |
Sectors | Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software) Energy Financial Services and Management Consultancy |
URL | https://github.com/EsaLaboratory/public_folder/tree/main/Blockchain_flex_market |
Description | - Overall, the project has investigated and demonstrated applications for blockchain within energy systems which go beyond peer-to-peer transactions, and instead enable more complex financial arrangements which can unlock new sources of grid flexibility and empower communities to invest in renewable technologies. - The project has resulted in papers published in top-ranked power systems and economics journals conferences. - The project has established an ongoing collaboration between Dr Morstyn (now Associate Professor at Oxford University), Dr Savelli (now a Marie Curie Research Fellow at Bocconi University) and Dr Cuffe at University College Dublin. - Dr Morstyn was invited to present on panel sessions at the INFORMS Annual Meeting, the EnergyREV Summit event, and at a seminar organise by the Iran Local Energy Market Committee. These activities have helped disseminate the research to the UK and international energy systems research communities. - Dr Morstyn was invited to contribute to book chapters on "Active Players in Local Energy Markets " and "Local Energy Markets: From Concepts to Reality" for the book Trading in Local Energy Markets and Energy Communities: Concepts, Structures and Technologies. - Dr Morstyn was invited to be a guest editor for an IET Smart Grid journal special issue on "Blockchain technologies empowering peer-to-peer trading in multi-energy systems" - A software prototype for our blockchain flexibility marketplace developed with Vyper for the Ethereum Virtual Machine has been released as an open-source software project. - Our high-fidelity model for the Great Britain transmission system and Balancing Mechanism has been released as an open-source project. - The high-fidelity model developed for Great Britain's transmission system and balancing mechanism was a key enabler of the EPSRC project "Data-driven exploration of the carbon emissions impact of grid energy storage deployment and dispatch" (£1.0m) which I am a co-investigator, along with collaborators from the University of Oxford and Imperial College London. The research from the project on blockchain smart contracts for flexibility aggregation and shared financing, governance battery storage financing, governance and revenue dispersal is also relevant for distributed battery storage as one of the technologies we are now exploring. |
First Year Of Impact | 2022 |
Sector | Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software),Energy |
Impact Types | Economic Policy & public services |
Description | EPSRC IAA Accelerating Net Zero Edinburgh: Infrastructure & Place |
Amount | £77,359 (GBP) |
Funding ID | PV039 |
Organisation | Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) |
Sector | Public |
Country | United Kingdom |
Start | 01/2023 |
End | 12/2023 |
Title | Great Britain High-Fidelity Transmission Network and Balancing Mechanism Data |
Description | High-Fidelity data for the Great Britain transmission network and balancing mechanism. This combines unit-level market data from Elexon and detailed network data from the National Grid 10 Year Statement. It contains data for 1882 nodes, 2769 lines and 5002 balancing mechanism units. |
Type Of Material | Database/Collection of data |
Year Produced | 2022 |
Provided To Others? | Yes |
Impact | This model was used for analysis conducted for BEIS to investigate the value of locational enhancements to the UK's Contracts for Difference Auction scheme. A paper on this has been published: Savelli, I., Hardy, J., Hepburn, C., & Morstyn, T. (2022). Putting wind and solar in their place: Internalising congestion and other system-wide costs with enhanced contracts for difference in Great Britain. Energy Economics. |
URL | https://github.com/EsaLaboratory/EnhancedCfD |
Description | Energy Blockchain Collaboration with University College Dublin |
Organisation | University College Dublin |
Country | Ireland |
Sector | Academic/University |
PI Contribution | The project started in August 2021. We are holiding fortnightly meetings with Dr Cuffe and his research team. We have developed an initial design for a blockchain smart contract which would enable the flexible formation of federated power plants made up of small- and medium-scale distributed energy resource owners, enabling them to offer balancing services to National Grid ESO. |
Collaborator Contribution | The project started in August 2021. Dr Cuffe and his research team are participating in fortnightly meetings. Dr Cuffe and his team have an initial proposal for blockchain-based decentralised finanacing mechanisms to help facilitate community financing of renewable generation. |
Impact | Since our project started in August 2021, we expect to have collaborative outputs later this year. |
Start Year | 2021 |
Title | "On Request" smart contracts to help reduce balancing costs in the UK |
Description | This software is a proof-of-concept for a blockchain-based market layer for on-demand flexibility procurement that can be fully integrated into the existing electricity market architecture in Great Britain. |
Type Of Technology | Software |
Year Produced | 2023 |
Open Source License? | Yes |
Impact | A paper presenting the blockchain software and demonstrating its potential value for Great Britain's Balancing Mechanism was published in Savelli, Rao Bokkisam, Cuffe, Morstyn, "On-demand energy flexibility market via smart contracts to help reduce balancing costs in Great Britain", Energy Economics, 2023, doi: 10.1016/j.eneco.2023.106931 |
URL | https://github.com/EsaLaboratory/public_folder/tree/main/Blockchain_flex_market |
Description | EnergyREV Summit Panel Presentation on the Role of Energy Smart Places in Net-Zero and Multi-Scale Market Design |
Form Of Engagement Activity | A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | National |
Primary Audience | Industry/Business |
Results and Impact | Invited to present as part of a Panel on the Role of Energy Smart Places in Net-Zero at the EnergyREV Summit to around 70 attendees from industry, academia and government. My presentation was on multi-scale market design. |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2023 |
Description | INFORMS Annual Meeting 2021 - Chaired Panel Session on "Market Design for Smart Local Energy Systems" |
Form Of Engagement Activity | A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | International |
Primary Audience | Professional Practitioners |
Results and Impact | Invited to chair a panel session on "Market Design for Smart Local Energy Systems" at the INFORMS 2021 Annual Meeting (held virtually). The INFORMS Annual Meeting is the main gathering of the The Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences. The aim of the session was to bring together researchers working at the forefront of energy market design to discuss the state-of-the-art and identify impactful research directions. |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2021 |
URL | http://meetings.informs.org/wordpress/anaheim2021/schedule |
Description | INFORMS Annual Meeting 2022 - Panel Session on Market Design in Future Energy Systems |
Form Of Engagement Activity | A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | International |
Primary Audience | Professional Practitioners |
Results and Impact | Invited to present at a Panel Session on "Market design in future energy systems" at the INFORMS 2022 Annual Meeting. The INFORMS Annual Meeting is the main conference of The Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences. The talk had approximately 30 attendees, including academics from engineering, economics and computer science as well as policymakers and industry professionals. |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2022 |
URL | https://meetings.informs.org/wordpress/indianapolis2022/ |
Description | Seminar for the Iran Local Energy Market Committee |
Form Of Engagement Activity | A talk or presentation |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | International |
Primary Audience | Policymakers/politicians |
Results and Impact | Presentation of research to the Iran Local Energy Market Committee in collaboration with the Iran Future Energy Market Forum and Iran Energy Agency. 30+ attendees showed interest with lots of questions at end of presentation. Outcomes: - New acdemic collaboration established with Dr Mohsen Khorasany and Dr Amin Shokri Gzafroudi on the design of integrated markets for peer-to-peer energy trading and distribution system flexibility. - Asked to present a webinar for the second season of the Iran Local Energy Market Forum on tools, libraries, and softwares related to modelling local energy markets - Asked to contribute two book chapters for a new book being published by Springer, "Trading in Local Energy Markets and Energy Communities: Concepts, Structures and Technologies" |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2021 |
URL | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YVUJyd-CzaE |