Improving early detection and diagnosis of breast cancer among multi-ethnic rural communities in Malaysia - implementation of the CENP
Lead Research Organisation:
Queen's University Belfast
Department Name: Centre for Public Health
Abstract
Breast cancer (BC) is the commonest cancer in Malaysia. Women in rural areas present with advanced cancer and experience poor survival due to low awareness about symptoms and low participation in BC screening. This project aims to harness the lessons from our previous successful study in Malaysia and the methods of implementation science to develop and evaluate a community education and navigation programme (CENP) that will improve the early detection and diagnosis of BC among rural women. The study will be conducted in Segamat district, Johor State in consultation with local stakeholders and with the support of the South East Asia Community Observatory (SEACO), an established Health & Demographic Surveillance Site. The immediate beneficiaries will be women and families in local rural communities in Malaysia. Our project will benefit rural communities by increasing public awareness about warning signs and symptoms and, more specifically, by navigating women to breast cancer screening. The CENP will identify and counter emotional barriers, dispel misbeliefs and prompt help-seeking behaviour thereby enhancing cancer prevention and leading, where appropriate, to early diagnosis and
treatment. Our project via improved prevention and earlier diagnosis will reduce the burden including the personal, financial and psychosocial burden that is experienced by many women and their families as well as the resource burden to the health care system and the wider societal economic consequences for Malaysia. In addition, our project will collaborate with primary care physicians in order to improve their understanding further about the community in which they serve, embed patient navigation in community and primary care services and expedite referral of suspected cases. Furthermore, the project will capacity build' to the benefit of rural communities, NGOs, public health researchers and academics by enhancing knowledge and educational materials and related skills regarding cancer.
treatment. Our project via improved prevention and earlier diagnosis will reduce the burden including the personal, financial and psychosocial burden that is experienced by many women and their families as well as the resource burden to the health care system and the wider societal economic consequences for Malaysia. In addition, our project will collaborate with primary care physicians in order to improve their understanding further about the community in which they serve, embed patient navigation in community and primary care services and expedite referral of suspected cases. Furthermore, the project will capacity build' to the benefit of rural communities, NGOs, public health researchers and academics by enhancing knowledge and educational materials and related skills regarding cancer.
Technical Summary
Phase 1 will involve conducting an evidence synthesis of studies about community navigation programmes. The views of community advocates and stakeholder groups will be elicited via focus groups with women from different socioeconomic backgrounds and ethnic groups in rural areas of Segamat and individual interviews with key informants. Phase 2 will involve co-designing a culturally sensitive CENP, the selection of navigators and the development of training modules and health education materials. Phase 3 will test the appropriateness and acceptability of the new programme via FGs. Phase 4 will conduct a comparative evaluation in Segamat district which has 11 sub-districts, 5 of which provide data for the SEACO platform. The 5 sub-districts are approximately similar in terms of socio-demographic profile and health service profile. One intervention sub-district and two comparator sub-districts will be chosen randomly from the 5 rural sub-districts. SEACO completes an annual enumeration and multiple population-wide health surveys in these sub-districts. A sample of 466 at the 'intervention sub-district' and 466 at each 'comparator sub-district' will be drawn randomly from SEACO data to participate in the evaluation. A sample size of 1400 will allow 80% power to detect, as statistically significant at the 5% level, an increase of 8% or more in the proportion
aware of a breast cancer symptom in the CENP site compared with comparator sites after the intervention (based upon baseline awareness of a breast lump as a cancer symptom of 65% from our previous Newton-funded study). The sample size of 1400 will also allow 80% power to detect an absolute increase in the proportion of women who visit a doctor in the 6 months following CENP of 8% in the CENP site compared with comparator sites. Phase 5 activities will involve dissemination and writing joined-up policy and practice briefs for the Ministry of Rural Development and the Ministry of Health.
aware of a breast cancer symptom in the CENP site compared with comparator sites after the intervention (based upon baseline awareness of a breast lump as a cancer symptom of 65% from our previous Newton-funded study). The sample size of 1400 will also allow 80% power to detect an absolute increase in the proportion of women who visit a doctor in the 6 months following CENP of 8% in the CENP site compared with comparator sites. Phase 5 activities will involve dissemination and writing joined-up policy and practice briefs for the Ministry of Rural Development and the Ministry of Health.
Publications
Mila Nu Nu Htay
(2021)
Breast Cancer Screening in Malaysia: A Policy Review
Htay MNN
(2022)
Changing Health Beliefs about Breast Cancer Screening among Women in Multi-Ethnic Malaysia.
in International journal of environmental research and public health
Su T
(2022)
Improving breast and colorectal cancer screening uptake in Malaysia
in European Journal of Cancer Care
Htay MNN
(2022)
Women's health beliefs and uptake of breast cancer screening in Malaysia.
in European journal of cancer care
Schliemann D
(2022)
mHealth Interventions to Improve Cancer Screening and Early Detection: Scoping Review of Reviews
in Journal of Medical Internet Research
| Description | The development and evaluation of a mHealth, community education and navigation intervention to improve clinical breast examination uptake in Segamat Malaysia Breast cancer (BC) screening uptake in Malaysia is low and a high number of cases present at a late stage. Community navigation and mobile health (mHealth) may increase screening attendance, particularly by women from rural communities. This randomized controlled study evaluated an intervention that used mHealth and community health workers to educate women about BC screening and navigate them to clinical breast examination (CBE) services in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic. Women aged 40-74 years, from Segamat, Malaysia, with a mobile phone number, who participated in the South East Asian Community Observatory health survey, (2018) were randomized to an intervention (IG) or comparison group (CG). The IG received a multi-component mHealth intervention, i.e. information about BC was provided through a website, and telephone calls and text messages from community health workers (CHWs) were used to raise BC awareness and navigate women to CBE services. The CG received no intervention other than the usual option to access opportunistic screening. Regression analyses were conducted to investigate between-group differences over time in uptake of screening and variable influences on CBE screening participation. We recruited 483 women in total; 122/225 from the IG and 144/258 from the CG completed the baseline and follow-up survey. Uptake of CBE by the IG was 45.8% (103/225) whilst 3.5% (5/144) of women from the CG who completed the follow-up survey reported that they attended a CBE during the study period (adjusted OR 37.21, 95% CI 14.13; 98.00, p<0.001). All IG women with a positive CBE attended a follow-up mammogram (11/11). Attendance by IG women was lower among women with a household income =RM 4,850 (adjusted OR 0.48, 95% CI 0.20; 0.95, p=0.038) compared to participants with a household income |
| Exploitation Route | Several papers have been published and the final outcomes paper is under review. Overall, and bearing in mind the study limitations, the results of this study suggest that the use of a multicomponent community education and navigation intervention or programme has considerable potential to elicit positive health protective intentions and improve clinical breast examination uptake in Segamat Malaysia even in the highly challenging circumstances of the COVID-19 pandemic. The results point to ways in which the intervention might be improved as well as the need for further research to test how well the intervention works in a non-pandemic context and how its generalisability might be addressed and extended. |
| Sectors | Communities and Social Services/Policy Healthcare |
| Description | A study of the implementation of population-based bowel cancer screening in Malaysia |
| Amount | £202,396 (GBP) |
| Funding ID | MR/S014349/1 |
| Organisation | Medical Research Council (MRC) |
| Sector | Public |
| Country | United Kingdom |
| Start | 11/2018 |
| End | 11/2022 |
| Description | The PACED Initiative in Malaysia |
| Organisation | Ministry of Health Malaysia |
| Country | Malaysia |
| Sector | Public |
| PI Contribution | Early on in the project, the study team, comprising researchers from the University of Malaya and Queen's University Belfast, developed collaborative working relationships with the National Cancer Society Malaysia and the Ministry of Health Malaysia and the NI Public Health Agency. |
| Collaborator Contribution | The UM-QUB team met with the personnel from the Northern Ireland (NI) Government Department of Health's Public Health Agency (PHA) who are responsible for the Be Cancer Aware Programme (BeCAP) in NI. We have developed good working relationships with the PHA BeCAP staff and Dr Schliemann provides regular updates to the PHA about the PACED Project. In particular, the PHA shared all BeCAP media materials and content with the PACED team as well as reports, evaluation tools and experiences about running the mass media campaign in Northern Ireland. The National Cancer Society and the Ministry of Health worked collaboratively with the UM-QUB team on all aspects of the design and delivery of the public health cancer campaign. |
| Impact | The public health cancer awareness campaign comprised: ? Television (TV3, TV9 and 8TV) - these channels were chosen as they are channels with a large viewership and target two major ethnic groups (Malay and Chinese). A 15-30-second TV commercial will be produced including three cancer survivors (1 female Malay, 1 male Chinese, 1 male Indian). ? Radio (Raaga and Lite FM) - These stations were chosen as they are stations with large listenership. Raaga is a Tamil station that has been chosen to reach the Indian population. Lite FM is an English station, targeted at people aged 40 years and older. Therefore, Lite FM reaches people from all ethnicities. A 30-second radio advert was produced in Tamil and English. ? Print advertisement - Based on evaluation results from BeCAP, placement of posters in doctor's clinics was the second most common medium which people noticed (after TV). Therefore, we distributed posters throughout public and private clinics in the study area. Local doctors distributed our posters as well as brochures in their clinics. In addition, posters were distributed in Mosques and local shops. Buntings were distributed throughout the study area. Furthermore, advertisements were placed throughout the University of Malaya Campus (bunting and LED screens) to promote awareness amongst University staff and students. The PACED team decided against newspaper advertisement due to budget constraints and feedback from the focus group discussions, which highlighted that few people read newspapers and magazines. ? Internet - The website domain becanceralert.com was purchased and set up by the PACED team. The website was used to provide further information about colorectal and breast cancer. Social media experts were hired to create professional content and analyse feedback on social media, mainly Facebook. The National Cancer Society Facebook account was used to post all campaign related materials, so that we were able to reach a larger number of people through social media than if we were to set up a new account. The Colorectal Cancer (CRC) campaign took place in April. The campaign ran from the 2nd of April until the 6th of May 2018 (5 weeks) and the campaign launch was held on the 5th of April. The Breast Cancer (BC) Campaign was run during Breast Cancer Awareness month from 24th September until 28th October (5 weeks). |
| Start Year | 2017 |
| Description | The PACED Initiative in Malaysia |
| Organisation | National Cancer Registry (Malaysia) |
| Country | Malaysia |
| Sector | Hospitals |
| PI Contribution | Early on in the project, the study team, comprising researchers from the University of Malaya and Queen's University Belfast, developed collaborative working relationships with the National Cancer Society Malaysia and the Ministry of Health Malaysia and the NI Public Health Agency. |
| Collaborator Contribution | The UM-QUB team met with the personnel from the Northern Ireland (NI) Government Department of Health's Public Health Agency (PHA) who are responsible for the Be Cancer Aware Programme (BeCAP) in NI. We have developed good working relationships with the PHA BeCAP staff and Dr Schliemann provides regular updates to the PHA about the PACED Project. In particular, the PHA shared all BeCAP media materials and content with the PACED team as well as reports, evaluation tools and experiences about running the mass media campaign in Northern Ireland. The National Cancer Society and the Ministry of Health worked collaboratively with the UM-QUB team on all aspects of the design and delivery of the public health cancer campaign. |
| Impact | The public health cancer awareness campaign comprised: ? Television (TV3, TV9 and 8TV) - these channels were chosen as they are channels with a large viewership and target two major ethnic groups (Malay and Chinese). A 15-30-second TV commercial will be produced including three cancer survivors (1 female Malay, 1 male Chinese, 1 male Indian). ? Radio (Raaga and Lite FM) - These stations were chosen as they are stations with large listenership. Raaga is a Tamil station that has been chosen to reach the Indian population. Lite FM is an English station, targeted at people aged 40 years and older. Therefore, Lite FM reaches people from all ethnicities. A 30-second radio advert was produced in Tamil and English. ? Print advertisement - Based on evaluation results from BeCAP, placement of posters in doctor's clinics was the second most common medium which people noticed (after TV). Therefore, we distributed posters throughout public and private clinics in the study area. Local doctors distributed our posters as well as brochures in their clinics. In addition, posters were distributed in Mosques and local shops. Buntings were distributed throughout the study area. Furthermore, advertisements were placed throughout the University of Malaya Campus (bunting and LED screens) to promote awareness amongst University staff and students. The PACED team decided against newspaper advertisement due to budget constraints and feedback from the focus group discussions, which highlighted that few people read newspapers and magazines. ? Internet - The website domain becanceralert.com was purchased and set up by the PACED team. The website was used to provide further information about colorectal and breast cancer. Social media experts were hired to create professional content and analyse feedback on social media, mainly Facebook. The National Cancer Society Facebook account was used to post all campaign related materials, so that we were able to reach a larger number of people through social media than if we were to set up a new account. The Colorectal Cancer (CRC) campaign took place in April. The campaign ran from the 2nd of April until the 6th of May 2018 (5 weeks) and the campaign launch was held on the 5th of April. The Breast Cancer (BC) Campaign was run during Breast Cancer Awareness month from 24th September until 28th October (5 weeks). |
| Start Year | 2017 |
| Description | The PACED Initiative in Malaysia |
| Organisation | Public Health Agency (PHA) |
| Country | United Kingdom |
| Sector | Public |
| PI Contribution | Early on in the project, the study team, comprising researchers from the University of Malaya and Queen's University Belfast, developed collaborative working relationships with the National Cancer Society Malaysia and the Ministry of Health Malaysia and the NI Public Health Agency. |
| Collaborator Contribution | The UM-QUB team met with the personnel from the Northern Ireland (NI) Government Department of Health's Public Health Agency (PHA) who are responsible for the Be Cancer Aware Programme (BeCAP) in NI. We have developed good working relationships with the PHA BeCAP staff and Dr Schliemann provides regular updates to the PHA about the PACED Project. In particular, the PHA shared all BeCAP media materials and content with the PACED team as well as reports, evaluation tools and experiences about running the mass media campaign in Northern Ireland. The National Cancer Society and the Ministry of Health worked collaboratively with the UM-QUB team on all aspects of the design and delivery of the public health cancer campaign. |
| Impact | The public health cancer awareness campaign comprised: ? Television (TV3, TV9 and 8TV) - these channels were chosen as they are channels with a large viewership and target two major ethnic groups (Malay and Chinese). A 15-30-second TV commercial will be produced including three cancer survivors (1 female Malay, 1 male Chinese, 1 male Indian). ? Radio (Raaga and Lite FM) - These stations were chosen as they are stations with large listenership. Raaga is a Tamil station that has been chosen to reach the Indian population. Lite FM is an English station, targeted at people aged 40 years and older. Therefore, Lite FM reaches people from all ethnicities. A 30-second radio advert was produced in Tamil and English. ? Print advertisement - Based on evaluation results from BeCAP, placement of posters in doctor's clinics was the second most common medium which people noticed (after TV). Therefore, we distributed posters throughout public and private clinics in the study area. Local doctors distributed our posters as well as brochures in their clinics. In addition, posters were distributed in Mosques and local shops. Buntings were distributed throughout the study area. Furthermore, advertisements were placed throughout the University of Malaya Campus (bunting and LED screens) to promote awareness amongst University staff and students. The PACED team decided against newspaper advertisement due to budget constraints and feedback from the focus group discussions, which highlighted that few people read newspapers and magazines. ? Internet - The website domain becanceralert.com was purchased and set up by the PACED team. The website was used to provide further information about colorectal and breast cancer. Social media experts were hired to create professional content and analyse feedback on social media, mainly Facebook. The National Cancer Society Facebook account was used to post all campaign related materials, so that we were able to reach a larger number of people through social media than if we were to set up a new account. The Colorectal Cancer (CRC) campaign took place in April. The campaign ran from the 2nd of April until the 6th of May 2018 (5 weeks) and the campaign launch was held on the 5th of April. The Breast Cancer (BC) Campaign was run during Breast Cancer Awareness month from 24th September until 28th October (5 weeks). |
| Start Year | 2017 |
| Description | Tripartite Collaboration - Malaysia |
| Organisation | Melaka Manipal Medical College |
| Country | Malaysia |
| Sector | Academic/University |
| PI Contribution | Collaborative design of rapid review and pilot studies. |
| Collaborator Contribution | Collaborative supervision of research assistant to conduct pump-riming research and writing up of protocol and papers. |
| Impact | It is very early days to report outcomes. However, a protocol for a rapid review was registered with PROSPERO: https://www.crd.york.ac.uk/prospero/display_record.php?RecordID=391832 |
| Start Year | 2022 |
| Description | Tripartite Collaboration - Malaysia |
| Organisation | Monash University Malaysia |
| Country | Malaysia |
| Sector | Academic/University |
| PI Contribution | Collaborative design of rapid review and pilot studies. |
| Collaborator Contribution | Collaborative supervision of research assistant to conduct pump-riming research and writing up of protocol and papers. |
| Impact | It is very early days to report outcomes. However, a protocol for a rapid review was registered with PROSPERO: https://www.crd.york.ac.uk/prospero/display_record.php?RecordID=391832 |
| Start Year | 2022 |
