📣 Help Shape the Future of UKRI's Gateway to Research (GtR)

We're improving UKRI's Gateway to Research and are seeking your input! If you would be interested in being interviewed about the improvements we're making and to have your say about how we can make GtR more user-friendly, impactful, and effective for the Research and Innovation community, please email gateway@ukri.org.

Captive Arts: Curating the curious symbiosis between the arts and imprisonment

Lead Research Organisation: University of Warwick
Department Name: Sociology

Abstract

This project seeks to conduct the first empirical investigation of artists in English prisons. Its main research question is: who are prisoner artists and how does the experience of imprisonment shape their identity, artistic outputs and their reception within and beyond prison walls? While imprisonment is a predominantly detrimental experience, actively curtailing fundamental freedoms and animating our cultural infatuation with harsh and long punishments in Western neoliberal societies, the arts - in their various manifestations from visual art, sculpture, music, theatre, poetry and creative writing, among others - are thriving inside prisons. The arts in prison play a fundamental role in enabling for prisoners an otherwise inaccessible opportunity for expression and act as a significant source of education, therapy, and communication with the outside world. The arts have also been increasingly mobilised by penal institutions as one of the main ways in which objectives such as rehabilitation and tackling recidivism can be addressed, a strategy that has a long, if somewhat turbulent, history.

This project seeks to understand this curious symbiosis between the arts and imprisonment, and how and why artistic identities emerge in penal settings. It will provide the first comprehensive examination of the role that the arts play in the lives and identities of serving and former prisoners and by deploying qualitative and arts-based methodologies it will enable a systematic engagement with prisoner arts, to advance our understandings of the emotions of punishment, the impacts of imprisonment, the experiences, coping and resistance strategies of prisoners and the political messages we can derive from prisoners' artworks. The study will curate a comprehensive account of prisoner arts as a distinct art genre.

It will unpack the potential of the arts in A) articulating the experience and effects of imprisonment; B) transforming the lives and trajectories of prisoners and former prisoners; C) acting as means of political expression in an otherwise repressed institution, connecting those inside with audiences outside. This latter aspect will also inform the public engagement activities of the project which seek to utilise the affective power of the arts to alter public perceptions on issues of crime and justice and showcase the impact that prisoner arts can have for individuals and communities alike.

The project seeks to make a substantive contribution to prison studies, criminology, socio-legal and community arts and outsider arts research by advancing a conceptual toolkit for studying the ambivalent relationship between contemporary punishment and creative expression. The project involves empirical fieldwork including interviews with prisoners, former prisoners, arts therapists working in prisons, and arts practitioners and educators in prisons. It also involves ethnographic observation of short arts-courses offered in prisons and analysis of artworks created by participants and of prisoner arts available in the public domain.

The project will include the organisation of a major, international workshop engaging a range of practitioners and stakeholders in policy-informed and research-led discussions on the future of prisoner arts. It will host the largest prisoner arts festival of its kind at Warwick Arts Centre, co-produced with former prisoners who are artists. It will also create the first digital archive of prisoner arts to be hosted at Warwick's Modern Records Centre to promote future research and wider engagement with prisoner arts. The project will also produce a website that will showcase prisoner artworks and findings from the project, and host podcasts and blogposts on carceral aesthetics and the experience of becoming an artist in captivity. Academic outputs will include a monograph, two peer-reviewed articles and media outputs at arts-based, prisoner-led and criminal justice platforms.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description The Captive Arts project sought the undertake one of the first and most comprehensive investigations into prisoner arts in England. The study looked into visual arts, music, poetry and other creative writing and theatre based work inside prisons . Over the past 2 years I have conducted fieldwork in a number of prison settings, arts-spaces and exhibitions and engaged with a number of research participants including: 1) a qualitative case study with arts-therapists who work in prisons, 2) another case study with a range of arts-practitioners working in prisons either as freelancers or as part of companies or charitable organisations. 3) The fieldwork also involved interviewers with former prisoners who are artists and 4) interviews with prisoners taking arts-based courses in prisons. The research also involved ethnographic observations a music and lyric writing programme at a prison as well as various other ethnographic observations across more than 6 prisons that involved engagement in the arts classes taking place in prisons, celebration events of arts programmes inside prisons and a series of observations of prisoner arts (of all formats) exhibited and shared in venues outside prisons. The research also involves aesthetic and sociological analysis of artistic outputs emerging from prisons - including poetry and creative writing publications by prisoner artists, music and visual arts by prisoner and former prisoner artists.

The project's breadth and depth has offered a range of important findings.
1. the project makes a considerable intervention into theoretical and sociological understandings of the relationship between art-making, expression and coping in prisons. It unveils the role of the arts in the experience of punishment and details the impacts of this relationship between being punished and being creative. It maps the healing and therapeutic aspects of arts as process and relates these to rehabilitative objectives in prisons.
2. methodologically the project provides a new, original methodology for the study of prisons and of prisoners. This is a 'moving methodology' that shows how the arts open us a space to study otherwise closed off setting like prisons in a more accessible and affective manner. This part of the research explores the importance for researchers to engage and embrace the travelling involved in following arts-making and production and considers the future of prisoners arts in a digital context.
3. in terms of empirical findings the project has several discoveries with regards to each of the different cohorts studied: one aspect of the project explores care aesthetics as a means of understanding the professional identities of practitioners and therapists working in prisons. Another aspect of the project tackles the challenges and complexities of ascribing and adopting the 'artist' identity among prisoners and former prisoners. Here questions of authorship, authenticity and prisoner art anonymity become quite critical. Another layer of the findings focuses on the arts outputs themselves and unveils how these detail the affective and embodied experience of punishment in the 21st century. The project's findings can be summarised in the following themes which inform the structure of a book I'll put together on the project:
Part 1: Towards a Sociology of Prisoner Arts
- Expressing Identity and Freedom
- Curating and Representing Prisoner Arts: The making of a genre and its unfulfilled promise
- Researching Prisoner Arts: Towards an arts-based critique of modern punishment and towards a moving methodology of prison

Part 2: The Curious Symbiosis between the Arts and Imprisonment
-Performing Remorse, Restoring Labels of Criminalisation, Narrating the Past
-Conveying Punishment, Enacting Survival
-Articulating Resistance and Communicating Politics

Part 3: The surreptitious function of the arts in prison
-Supporting prisoners, enabling escape: The third sector as arts provider, patron, and campaigner
-Performing penal rehabilitation: Beyond the benevolence of arts
-Consuming prison art: The audiences and reception of arts beyond prison walls.
Exploitation Route The project is still on going but has several future directions - both in terms of policy and practitioner impact and in terms of academic scholarship. At the moment I'm seeking to develop further analysis from this project into a new, broader project looking into the relationship between arts and justice. The focus of Captive Arts being on prisoner arts has enabled an excellent angle from which to begin to explore more broadly the relationship between marginalisation, expression and justice efforts. As such the project is now leading onto global conversations around the place of the arts in the experience, expression and maintenance of transformative and therapeutic justice efforts.

Please note the project is still ongoing and findings are still developing.
Sectors Education

Government

Democracy and Justice

Culture

Heritage

Museums and Collections

URL http://www.captivearts.co.uk
 
Description These activities draw on findings from the AHRC-funded project "Captive Arts". Objectives for impact included: A) increase HM Prison Service awareness of the effectiveness of arts-based interventions; B)embed evidence-based approaches to arts-practitioners' future prison programmes; C)develop policy recommendations on arts interventions; D)develop global opportunities for including the arts-from-prison in GLAM-sector initiatives. The following activities were achieved: 1. A website to become the main independent, digital prisoner arts resource with international appeal and links (www.captivearts.co.uk). 2. A multistakeholder symposium on globalising prisoner arts approaches at Warwick Arts Centre involving Prison Service stakeholders, criminal justice charities and NGOs, arts organisations, activists and former prisoner artists. The event led to a policy & arts-practitioner briefing with recommendations for English prisons and national GLAM organisations. Audiences: 100; speakers: 25. 3. a series of online implementation workshop meetings to further develop and disseminate these recommendations to Prison Service/MoJ and GLAM sector senior leads focusing on promoting evidence-led, effective delivery of arts programmes and initiatives in prison. 5 selected stakeholders per meeting. 4. the development of IJAN - an International Justice Arts Network which seeks to bring together over 160 arts practitioners, researchers and campaigners working in the fields of arts and criminal justice. Members include high profile organisations and individuals from South America, Australia, India, Europe and North America. The above are underpinned by the following project findings: Three key findings are central to this impact proposal: 1. some approaches/types of programmes have clearer rehabilitative value, particularly on different prison cohorts (e.g women, young people). Few practitioners and HMPPS professionals are currently familiar with the differences between arts interventions, and few understand the relevant evidence-base, meaning the tenders for programmes are arbitrary and miss opportunities for holistic rehabilitation. The activities above have actively sought to change this. 2. insufficient attention is paid to the perspectives of prisoners vis-à-vis arts engagement and resettlement opportunities, including prospective career spaces in the GLAM sector. Desistance initiatives need to take these into account to be effective. The symposium, website and following workshop as well as IJAN seek to address these gaps in knowledge and communication. 3. Arts interventions are largely siloed into individual arts organisations' initiatives and lack broader engagement. Connection with successful international models can enable opportunities for prisoner arts to enter a global movement for arts-based social change. IJAN serves this purpose where the network's members exchange ideas and are planning future collaborations. These findings highlight the value and timeliness of developing opportunities for exchange. These activities sought to elevate the promise of prisoner arts as rehabilitative solutions and raise their policy status both in the Prison Service and arts-industry. The above activities were funded by a separate/additional Evolving Impact fund from the ESRC IAA at Warwick.
First Year Of Impact 2024
Sector Communities and Social Services/Policy,Creative Economy,Education,Government, Democracy and Justice,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Cultural

Societal

Policy & public services

 
Description Collaboration with AHRC Centre for Law & Social Justice team University of Warwick 
Organisation Rideout
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution I co-led on a University wide consortium application for the AHRC Centre for Law and Social Justice. My Captive Arts project was instrumental in defining methodological agendas around arts-based activities, public engagement plans around questions of arts and criminal justice and offered also direct links to prison-based arts charities and NGOs who joined the bid as collaborators.
Collaborator Contribution We have formed a large- nationwide and international - consortium and despite of the outcome of the application the University is supporting us in developing future activities and events, particularly with partners at the University of Southampton and several prison-arts organisations. My partners offered critical feedback on the application and are key in developing future research and public engagement activities (e.g. with Ride Out Theatre company and User Voice).
Impact It resulted in submission of a AHRC Centre for Law and Social Justice funding application (around 4.5million).
Start Year 2023
 
Description Collaboration with AHRC Centre for Law & Social Justice team University of Warwick 
Organisation User Voice
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution I co-led on a University wide consortium application for the AHRC Centre for Law and Social Justice. My Captive Arts project was instrumental in defining methodological agendas around arts-based activities, public engagement plans around questions of arts and criminal justice and offered also direct links to prison-based arts charities and NGOs who joined the bid as collaborators.
Collaborator Contribution We have formed a large- nationwide and international - consortium and despite of the outcome of the application the University is supporting us in developing future activities and events, particularly with partners at the University of Southampton and several prison-arts organisations. My partners offered critical feedback on the application and are key in developing future research and public engagement activities (e.g. with Ride Out Theatre company and User Voice).
Impact It resulted in submission of a AHRC Centre for Law and Social Justice funding application (around 4.5million).
Start Year 2023
 
Description Marginalised People's Creative Responses to Justice Problems' project with Southampton Institute for Arts and Humanities (SIAH) 
Organisation University of Southampton
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution I worked with David Gurnham and Harris Psarras from the University of Southampton to produce a successful funding application with SIAH for a series of events focused on Marginalised People's Creative Responses to Justice Problems. This networking project will fund 2 Soton workshop events planned for 2024. The workshops both address the question of how co-produced creative arts can be used to engage public audiences on issues of marginalisation. The Spring 2024 (27th March) event will be a full day workshop involving academics and arts charities; the Summer 2024 (19th June) one will be slightly shorter (a half-day) and will include also some people with lived experience of justice problems from a place of marginalisation and of working with arts charities for purposes of creative self-expression, and who may be prepared to share/perform their work (e.g. poetry). The 27th March workshop will be at the Winchester School of Art (UoS's Winchester campus) The 19th June event will be at Soton's 'The Art House' (a small workshop/performance space).
Collaborator Contribution My partners at Southampton included me in this application after we started an ongoing exchange in Summer 2023 where I was invited to present on my Captive Arts project at their Law School. They will cover the costs of these events, which are directly linked to my research project, and offer in kind support with extending my research network in this area. They have also invited me to contribute an article for a special issue they are putting together for the Journal Law & Humanities.
Impact Chamberlen, A. (forthcoming) 'Art from prison: 'Breaking the glass' through creative expression and carceral aesthetics', Law & Humanities (invited contribution to special Issue on 'Marginalised People's Creative Responses to Justice Problems' edited by H. Psarras & D. Gurnham). Plus presentations/talks at the aforementioned workshops. We are also discussing a further funding application to form a wider, nation wide network. This collaboration is fully multi-disicplinary: it includes sociology, law, visual arts, history of arts, theatre studies, literature and musicology.
Start Year 2023
 
Description Partnership with Derry Play House and Bobby Smith UKRI application 
Organisation The Playhouse Derry
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution I am collaborating with Derry Play House and Dr. Bobby Smith from Warwick's Theatre studies to support a UKRI funding application on theatrical representations of justice problems. I provided feedback on the funding application and offered in principle support with the public engagement plans of the project.
Collaborator Contribution If successful, the project will likely have several public engagement outputs which link to broader themes covered by Captive Arts. The project will also enable expanding my research and impact network to Northern Ireland.
Impact this collaboration is multidisciplinary, bringing together expertise from sociology, criminology, law, arts and theatre studies. The planned activities will take place in the future.
Start Year 2023
 
Description Participation at Geese Theatre performance Wolverhampton 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact I was invited to participate at Geese Theatre's performance and Q&A session of 'Out of Darkness Cometh Light' which was performed by people with experiences of criminal justice - ie. directly linked to themes of the research project Captive Arts. The company's theatre director is engaging with the project closely and acted as research participant.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2024
URL https://twitter.com/GeeseTheatre/status/1754822491552321628
 
Description Prisoner Arts in Context: An International Symposium 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact We hosted a large, international symposium on Prisoner Arts involving various stakeholders and exhibiting prisoner arts at Warwick Arts Centre. There were around 100 participants from prison service, the arts industry, cultural sector, charitable organisations, general public, students and former prisoners.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2024
URL https://warwick.ac.uk/fac/soc/sociology/research/projects/isc/captivearts/blog/prison_arts_in
 
Description Project Website with blogs and gallery entries 
Form Of Engagement Activity A broadcast e.g. TV/radio/film/podcast (other than news/press)
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact The project has a dedicated website www.captivearts.co.uk which hosts various writings and press releases on the project's findings, collaborations, events, seminar series and its international symposium. It also hosts blogposts by artists and practitioners and a gallery space showcasing prisoner artworks.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2025
URL http://www.captivearts.co.uk
 
Description We Roar Celebration Events at UK prisons 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact I have been invited to participate in a series of arts programme celebration events at various UK prisons. The events are hosted by Faye Claridge as part of an Arts Council funded project titled We Roar for which I'm project partner.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023,2024
URL https://fayeclaridge.co.uk/weroar